+1
Forum > Suggestions > Repetitive plays: More it's run, more likely the defensive is to stop it.
NVJumper
offline
offline
I don't like this idea, and I didn't have time to read anything other than the first page because I have to go to work soon.
However, if a team is running the same play over and over again, then you should know about it from previous scouting.
If they choose to run a play over and over against YOU while not against other teams (no matter how much you scout it won't matter) then maybe you should take that as a clear-cut sign to either change your own personal tactics or get some help.
If a team scouts well enough to exploit defenses, kudos to them. I understand the logic behind the suggestion, but at the same time it is an entity in and of itself, and not real life.
Lastly, if it isn't scouting by the team that allows them to exploit defenses... maybe their lone weapon is a super PB? Let them use him, and the defense, via scouting, should be able to recognize this and gear up accordingly.
However, if a team is running the same play over and over again, then you should know about it from previous scouting.
If they choose to run a play over and over against YOU while not against other teams (no matter how much you scout it won't matter) then maybe you should take that as a clear-cut sign to either change your own personal tactics or get some help.
If a team scouts well enough to exploit defenses, kudos to them. I understand the logic behind the suggestion, but at the same time it is an entity in and of itself, and not real life.
Lastly, if it isn't scouting by the team that allows them to exploit defenses... maybe their lone weapon is a super PB? Let them use him, and the defense, via scouting, should be able to recognize this and gear up accordingly.
Deathblade
offline
offline
Originally posted by NVJumper
However, if a team is running the same play over and over again, then you should know about it from previous scouting
This is more meant to address instances where there is an overpowered play, and we all know that they have existed ever since the offensive AI was released. Even the perfect defense against them can't stop them. This suggestion would prevent a team from using it 100%.
It also prevents situations where one team will see a minor hole in a defense, and try running that play 100% of the time with the defense not adjusting at all.
I mean, you could say the same for the offense...but the offense controls the defense, the defense doesn't control the offense.
However, if a team is running the same play over and over again, then you should know about it from previous scouting
This is more meant to address instances where there is an overpowered play, and we all know that they have existed ever since the offensive AI was released. Even the perfect defense against them can't stop them. This suggestion would prevent a team from using it 100%.
It also prevents situations where one team will see a minor hole in a defense, and try running that play 100% of the time with the defense not adjusting at all.
I mean, you could say the same for the offense...but the offense controls the defense, the defense doesn't control the offense.
NVJumper
offline
offline
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by NVJumper
However, if a team is running the same play over and over again, then you should know about it from previous scouting
This is more meant to address instances where there is an overpowered play, and we all know that they have existed ever since the offensive AI was released. Even the perfect defense against them can't stop them. This suggestion would prevent a team from using it 100%.
It also prevents situations where one team will see a minor hole in a defense, and try running that play 100% of the time with the defense not adjusting at all.
I mean, you could say the same for the offense...but the offense controls the defense, the defense doesn't control the offense.
A good defense can control an offense... but that's not the point.
I didn't realize the thread was about "bugged' plays - shouldn't this be in a different thread? :-P
Originally posted by NVJumper
However, if a team is running the same play over and over again, then you should know about it from previous scouting
This is more meant to address instances where there is an overpowered play, and we all know that they have existed ever since the offensive AI was released. Even the perfect defense against them can't stop them. This suggestion would prevent a team from using it 100%.
It also prevents situations where one team will see a minor hole in a defense, and try running that play 100% of the time with the defense not adjusting at all.
I mean, you could say the same for the offense...but the offense controls the defense, the defense doesn't control the offense.
A good defense can control an offense... but that's not the point.
I didn't realize the thread was about "bugged' plays - shouldn't this be in a different thread? :-P
Deathblade
offline
offline
Originally posted by NVJumper
A good defense can control an offense... but that's not the point.
I didn't realize the thread was about "bugged' plays - shouldn't this be in a different thread? :-P
Well no, it is one of the only ways to prevent an overpowered play from being abused when one crops up. It is a preemptive fix, rather than having to wait a season before it can be fixed, and the entire season being made void because of one play being ridiculously strong.
And no, a good defense cannot control an offense. An offense chooses which formation and which down...and this can be changed between games. The only thing the defense can do is take a wild guess at what they might run, and hope that the defense they use counters it. If the offense decides to switch it up, the defense is more or less screwed.
A good defense can control an offense... but that's not the point.
I didn't realize the thread was about "bugged' plays - shouldn't this be in a different thread? :-P
Well no, it is one of the only ways to prevent an overpowered play from being abused when one crops up. It is a preemptive fix, rather than having to wait a season before it can be fixed, and the entire season being made void because of one play being ridiculously strong.
And no, a good defense cannot control an offense. An offense chooses which formation and which down...and this can be changed between games. The only thing the defense can do is take a wild guess at what they might run, and hope that the defense they use counters it. If the offense decides to switch it up, the defense is more or less screwed.
Last edited Mar 15, 2009 09:17:25
NVJumper
offline
offline
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by NVJumper
A good defense can control an offense... but that's not the point.
I didn't realize the thread was about "bugged' plays - shouldn't this be in a different thread? :-P
Well no, it is one of the only ways to prevent an overpowered play from being abused when one crops it. It is a preemptive fix, rather than having to wait a season before it can be fixed, and the entire season being made void because of one play being ridiculously strong.
And no, a good defense cannot control an offense. An offense chooses which formation and which down...and this can be changed between games. The only thing the defense can do is take a wild guess at what they might run, and hope that the defense they use counters it. If the offense decides to switch it up, the defense is more or less screwed.
I was more referring to real life, my mistake, in terms of the Steelers, Ravens, etc. I have yet to see a GLB focus primarily on the defensive side of the ball with GOOD builds (not just speed is king builds, either, as those have obvious weaknesses). I believe that a well-made defensive team could do well.
But again, I digress...
I don't really understand what you mean by "cropping" a play. I don't do offensive or defensive play calling for either of my teams, so maybe that's my problem, but I just don't see how a defense can't gear up to stop a certain play
Originally posted by NVJumper
A good defense can control an offense... but that's not the point.
I didn't realize the thread was about "bugged' plays - shouldn't this be in a different thread? :-P
Well no, it is one of the only ways to prevent an overpowered play from being abused when one crops it. It is a preemptive fix, rather than having to wait a season before it can be fixed, and the entire season being made void because of one play being ridiculously strong.
And no, a good defense cannot control an offense. An offense chooses which formation and which down...and this can be changed between games. The only thing the defense can do is take a wild guess at what they might run, and hope that the defense they use counters it. If the offense decides to switch it up, the defense is more or less screwed.
I was more referring to real life, my mistake, in terms of the Steelers, Ravens, etc. I have yet to see a GLB focus primarily on the defensive side of the ball with GOOD builds (not just speed is king builds, either, as those have obvious weaknesses). I believe that a well-made defensive team could do well.
But again, I digress...
I don't really understand what you mean by "cropping" a play. I don't do offensive or defensive play calling for either of my teams, so maybe that's my problem, but I just don't see how a defense can't gear up to stop a certain play
Deathblade
offline
offline
Originally posted by NVJumper
I don't really understand what you mean by "cropping" a play. I don't do offensive or defensive play calling for either of my teams, so maybe that's my problem, but I just don't see how a defense can't gear up to stop a certain play
Meant to say "crop up"...had a typo.
Edit:
A defense CAN gear up to stop a certain play, but with some plays, that doesn't even help. I mean, Strong-I with a strong side run this season is unstoppable unless the defense outlevels the offense. Even if you gameplan against it, it is nearly unstoppable. So teams are running it nearly 100% and winning with relative ease.
I don't really understand what you mean by "cropping" a play. I don't do offensive or defensive play calling for either of my teams, so maybe that's my problem, but I just don't see how a defense can't gear up to stop a certain play
Meant to say "crop up"...had a typo.
Edit:
A defense CAN gear up to stop a certain play, but with some plays, that doesn't even help. I mean, Strong-I with a strong side run this season is unstoppable unless the defense outlevels the offense. Even if you gameplan against it, it is nearly unstoppable. So teams are running it nearly 100% and winning with relative ease.
Last edited Mar 15, 2009 09:19:33
unicorn99
offline
offline
sounds good would help to ballance things off and would increase the feel of real football
seeing a play over and over just mean a smaller chance of it working,
even its just called every so often play but if a play is used more than like 1 in 5
i would recognize it in the first milisecond of the play (still do watching the nfl and i never played on any significant level) so these guys definatly should be able to punish offenses for repeatedlycalling the same or even similar plays
seeing a play over and over just mean a smaller chance of it working,
even its just called every so often play but if a play is used more than like 1 in 5
i would recognize it in the first milisecond of the play (still do watching the nfl and i never played on any significant level) so these guys definatly should be able to punish offenses for repeatedlycalling the same or even similar plays
Last edited Mar 15, 2009 14:06:26
Ronnie Brown 23
offline
offline
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by NVJumper
I don't really understand what you mean by "cropping" a play. I don't do offensive or defensive play calling for either of my teams, so maybe that's my problem, but I just don't see how a defense can't gear up to stop a certain play
Meant to say "crop up"...had a typo.
Edit:
A defense CAN gear up to stop a certain play, but with some plays, that doesn't even help. I mean, Strong-I with a strong side run this season is unstoppable unless the defense outlevels the offense. Even if you gameplan against it, it is nearly unstoppable. So teams are running it nearly 100% and winning with relative ease.
Could someone test to see if my suggestion for giving defenders vision (and someone else suggested SAs, such as First Step) would work? I'm slightly against giving defenders better attributes or better rolls but if giving defenders maximum vision doesn't fix the issue, then I guess you'd have to give them some kind of attribute or roll bonus.
Originally posted by NVJumper
I don't really understand what you mean by "cropping" a play. I don't do offensive or defensive play calling for either of my teams, so maybe that's my problem, but I just don't see how a defense can't gear up to stop a certain play
Meant to say "crop up"...had a typo.
Edit:
A defense CAN gear up to stop a certain play, but with some plays, that doesn't even help. I mean, Strong-I with a strong side run this season is unstoppable unless the defense outlevels the offense. Even if you gameplan against it, it is nearly unstoppable. So teams are running it nearly 100% and winning with relative ease.
Could someone test to see if my suggestion for giving defenders vision (and someone else suggested SAs, such as First Step) would work? I'm slightly against giving defenders better attributes or better rolls but if giving defenders maximum vision doesn't fix the issue, then I guess you'd have to give them some kind of attribute or roll bonus.
elfuego51
offline
offline
Originally posted by pinonium
Does this mean that if the Offense runs the same play 9 times, and then a different play the 10th time, they could fool the defense?
That would be a rare occurrence given that we have no control over the play-calling once the game starts. The chances of a play being run 9 times in a row, then having the 10th come from the same formation is highly unlikely.
Does this mean that if the Offense runs the same play 9 times, and then a different play the 10th time, they could fool the defense?
That would be a rare occurrence given that we have no control over the play-calling once the game starts. The chances of a play being run 9 times in a row, then having the 10th come from the same formation is highly unlikely.
Sabataged
offline
offline
I think Vision should be tied in when teams are constantly trying to run the same play over and over. Kind of like in madden when your playing on All-Madden, if you keep trying to run the same ol play action pass, or the same run they will eat it up after the 3rd time or so. I think GLB should be the same way. If these teams are going to run their powerback off tackle 50 times a game, I think after atleast 5 they should start to see a drop off, especially if it is 5 in row they should be getting hit with a loss. Defenses with High vision should be able to sniff out the play if they seen it ran a million times
Iversen
offline
offline
Originally posted by Sabataged
I think Vision should be tied in when teams are constantly trying to run the same play over and over. Kind of like in madden when your playing on All-Madden, if you keep trying to run the same ol play action pass, or the same run they will eat it up after the 3rd time or so. I think GLB should be the same way. If these teams are going to run their powerback off tackle 50 times a game, I think after atleast 5 they should start to see a drop off, especially if it is 5 in row they should be getting hit with a loss. Defenses with High vision should be able to sniff out the play if they seen it ran a million times
But if you have high vision you can't have high enough strength/tackling to actually stop the powerback anyway? (Nevermind, different issue)
I like this idea.
I think Vision should be tied in when teams are constantly trying to run the same play over and over. Kind of like in madden when your playing on All-Madden, if you keep trying to run the same ol play action pass, or the same run they will eat it up after the 3rd time or so. I think GLB should be the same way. If these teams are going to run their powerback off tackle 50 times a game, I think after atleast 5 they should start to see a drop off, especially if it is 5 in row they should be getting hit with a loss. Defenses with High vision should be able to sniff out the play if they seen it ran a million times
But if you have high vision you can't have high enough strength/tackling to actually stop the powerback anyway? (Nevermind, different issue)
I like this idea.
jdbolick
offline
offline
Originally posted by aliuking
I don't like the idea much at all because it isn't like we have a lot to choose from when it comes to offensive plays
That is just nonsense. If people run the same crap over and over, it's because they choose to. Most of my offensive AI has 8+ inputs per situation, meaning I don't even know what our offense is going to run. There are plenty of plays to choose from, some are just more commonly used than others.
I don't like the idea much at all because it isn't like we have a lot to choose from when it comes to offensive plays
That is just nonsense. If people run the same crap over and over, it's because they choose to. Most of my offensive AI has 8+ inputs per situation, meaning I don't even know what our offense is going to run. There are plenty of plays to choose from, some are just more commonly used than others.
catcher_0_3
offline
offline
After losing today to a team who ran the ball 71 times, with one guy, 99% Singleback Ace Right, I endorse this.
Last edited Mar 17, 2009 15:51:16
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























