User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Please don't nerf the CB!
Page:
 
Phantom_Opera
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Billy Corman
3 teams have dropped out of a League I am heavily involved in [Africa AA#2]. Teams are quitting the SE Asia Pro Leagues. Many of the Pro Leagues across the board started the year with CPU's.

I guess they all quit because their QB's had issues with the long bomb ...


Sounds Like the Lions and Cowboys IRL.
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
ttt
 
PP
offline
Link
 
I didn't read all this. So, sorry if it has been brought up.

The solution isn't to nerf CBs. They are actually playing about how they should. The solution is to FIX THE DAMN QB PASSING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! If a QB actually lead his WRs and WRs didn't stop on their routes and stand there (often before the route is finished), the sim would be improved for the better. On the flip side, every nerf, without fail, has made the game worse and only ends up getting reversed a ssn or 2 later anyway. Fix the sim itself and leave the players alone already!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! pls
 
Luzod
offline
Link
 
For me there are only 2 things to be done to bring back some competition to this game:

You either nerf Powerbacks (and yes, I was against it before, but I changed my mind last game week, rather because you can run the same HB almost 70 times a game and he'll keep breaking tackles and making good runs, which is unacceptable) or you make passing game a lot better.

This way, you either have defense back to the game or you give everyone offensive power, even for teams who doesn't have their own personal super power back to run the whole game.

I'd rather see this thing happening: Few routes looks amazingly bad atm, I'd rather have them slightly better and power backs really less POWER. You could also make stamina count hell a lot for power backs, because it can't be easy to run over 60~ defenders with 60-100 strength.
 
Luzod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PP
I didn't read all this. So, sorry if it has been brought up.

The solution isn't to nerf CBs. They are actually playing about how they should. The solution is to FIX THE DAMN QB PASSING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! If a QB actually lead his WRs and WRs didn't stop on their routes and stand there (often before the route is finished), the sim would be improved for the better. On the flip side, every nerf, without fail, has made the game worse and only ends up getting reversed a ssn or 2 later anyway. Fix the sim itself and leave the players alone already!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! pls


Agreed on this post too.
 
nightstar289
offline
Link
 
BORT WHY DO YOU HATE DEFENSES!?!?!?!?!

Pass D is fine this season. If you don't want so many PDs, make QB accuracy worse and increase the pressure felt when hurried (also create different degrees of pressure). NERFING THE DEFENSE IS NOT THE ANSWER!!!
 
yoshi_yoshi
offline
Link
 
If you think about the end point of this game, defenders are going to eventually have to get the nerf of not reacting instantaneously to a thrown ball.

It's something that has to happen eventually and ok for Bort to mention, but don't just do it as a solo fix or else it will upset the balance.
 
PP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Luzod
For me there are only 2 things to be done to bring back some competition to this game:

You either nerf Powerbacks (and yes, I was against it before, but I changed my mind last game week, rather because you can run the same HB almost 70 times a game and he'll keep breaking tackles and making good runs, which is unacceptable) or you make passing game a lot better.

This way, you either have defense back to the game or you give everyone offensive power, even for teams who doesn't have their own personal super power back to run the whole game.

I'd rather see this thing happening: Few routes looks amazingly bad atm, I'd rather have them slightly better and power backs really less POWER. You could also make stamina count hell a lot for power backs, because it can't be easy to run over 60~ defenders with 60-100 strength.


I'd argue that nerfing any player is bad. It always ends up turning into a hideous abortion every time Bort does. As an added bonus, it screws his customers that invested their time and $ into making a stud player, only to have Bort waste him with a wave of his hand. For the pitifully little it's worth, I'd be massively against nerfing power backs.

Making energy more important would make sense though. No back can run 50-70 times a game. Hell, 30 carries are considered to be really pushing it in real FB. It is flat out ridiculous that any back is even close to as effective after 30 carries as they were in their 1st 30. Bort had sold us on how important energy was supposed to be many ssns ago. Turns out that stamina is near meaningless. If you want proof of that, just look at all the slow build teams that have jaw dropping glamor skills and are able to dominate an entire game with 20, 15, even 10 in stamina. Frankly, it's sickening.
 
Darkstrand
offline
Link
 
why would bort nerf the CB? pass % numbers are finally falling into a reasonable area although still 5% or so too high
 
PP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by yoshi_yoshi
If you think about the end point of this game, defenders are going to eventually have to get the nerf of not reacting instantaneously to a thrown ball.

It's something that has to happen eventually and ok for Bort to mention, but don't just do it as a solo fix or else it will upset the balance.


If WRs weren't leveling and getting better, I'd agree...But the fact that WRs are also improving totally blows that, IMO. Fakes (both pumps and WR head fakes & Jukes) keep getting higher, as well as the speed and agility they need to get open, QB vision, strength, throwing, SAs and so on keep improving. If they were constant and CBs were the only ones to keep getting better, I'd agree, but that's not how the game is setup. Because the other side keeps getting better too is also why Bort's nerfs are a constant fuck up to the game
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkstrand
why would bort nerf the CB? pass % numbers are finally falling into a reasonable area although still 5% or so too high


check out the OP darkstrand
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Eventually people will just stop making D players and everyone will only make O players, so they'll be facing CPU defenses. Everyone will get their stats though! Isn't that what everyone wants?

I'm actually only partly kidding too. With the way the defensive side of the game is continually getting shafted it's bound to happen one day. Good luck then!
Last edited Mar 7, 2009 14:51:07
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PP
Originally posted by Luzod

For me there are only 2 things to be done to bring back some competition to this game:

You either nerf Powerbacks (and yes, I was against it before, but I changed my mind last game week, rather because you can run the same HB almost 70 times a game and he'll keep breaking tackles and making good runs, which is unacceptable) or you make passing game a lot better.

This way, you either have defense back to the game or you give everyone offensive power, even for teams who doesn't have their own personal super power back to run the whole game.

I'd rather see this thing happening: Few routes looks amazingly bad atm, I'd rather have them slightly better and power backs really less POWER. You could also make stamina count hell a lot for power backs, because it can't be easy to run over 60~ defenders with 60-100 strength.


I'd argue that nerfing any player is bad. It always ends up turning into a hideous abortion every time Bort does. As an added bonus, it screws his customers that invested their time and $ into making a stud player, only to have Bort waste him with a wave of his hand. For the pitifully little it's worth, I'd be massively against nerfing power backs.

Making energy more important would make sense though. No back can run 50-70 times a game. Hell, 30 carries are considered to be really pushing it in real FB. It is flat out ridiculous that any back is even close to as effective after 30 carries as they were in their 1st 30. Bort had sold us on how important energy was supposed to be many ssns ago. Turns out that stamina is near meaningless. If you want proof of that, just look at all the slow build teams that have jaw dropping glamor skills and are able to dominate an entire game with 20, 15, even 10 in stamina. Frankly, it's sickening.


i also agree that powerbacks shouldn't be nerfed. but i'll add to your idea above.

powerbacks should need more carrying and confidence than elusive backs. why? as hard hits make a guy lose more stamina, his effectiveness decreases. and as it decreases, he needs the high confidence to maintain composure. same with carrying, powerbacks should fumble more than an elusive back (if their carrying attribute is the same).

case in point, brandon jacobs. he fumbles more than LT. he also needs 2 backups. and his backups play more than LT's backup
 
Link
 
God damnit. I knew I should've just made a powerback. This is ridiculous. My entire TEAM has fewer interceptions than a decent CB would have after 5-6 games. Fix interceptions if you're gonna fuck up CB coverage.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Breaking Tackles is one of the most tiring things to do in football. There aren't many things in life that require the physical exertion that shrugging off a tackle from a 220, 240, 260, 300 pound guy requires.

That's where this game is partly ass backwards. You lose more stamina for running down field than for running through people and carrying them on your back. Its stupidity.

Not to mention fixing that piece of the game would make it possible to field a special teams unit without gassing every player on your team. The fact that we need a VA to limit energy expenditure on special teams plays is ludicrous, running down field to make a play is not as tiring as playing in the trenches or running over people with the ball. Fix it, don't give a BS VA to help it.

If powerbacks got tired like they should, they would be nerfed without being nerfed. They would still be effective at breaking tackles, they just wouldn't be able to have 40-50 rushes per game. They'd top out at 20-35. And to get to that upper level towards 35 or above it, they'd have to sacrifice SPs to build Stamina and Confidence, which would be realistic from a gaming perspective.
Last edited Mar 7, 2009 15:12:32
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.