Agree with OP.
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Why "nerfs" and "berfs" are a bad idea (this is long, if you have ADD don't read it)
gameface25
offline
offline
Considering an avg powerback just broke 46 tackles in one game, against a 4-0 1st place team today in a AA league I am in, I think that powerbacks need looked at, no?
UMBF
offline
offline
The nerfs are a result of HORRIBLE game balance and design...which is something that should have been taken care of long before GLB ever went pay for play. Developers don't let people pay for their game before it is a finished product. Even in MMOs, they don't ask you to pay for the beta. I can completely understand the need for money to expand GLB to the level where it is at now...but players are paying for an unfinished product that has massive fundamental flaws in the game design.
rj414
offline
offline
Originally posted by gameface25
Considering an avg powerback just broke 46 tackles in one game, against a 4-0 1st place team today in a AA league I am in, I think that powerbacks need looked at, no?
Once again - I refer specifically to the passing game in this post, but mostly because I think it is the clearest illustration of the fundamental problem with nerfs and buffs. I am by no means saying that powerbacks are fine - they and the offensive line do need to be looked at.
Considering an avg powerback just broke 46 tackles in one game, against a 4-0 1st place team today in a AA league I am in, I think that powerbacks need looked at, no?
Once again - I refer specifically to the passing game in this post, but mostly because I think it is the clearest illustration of the fundamental problem with nerfs and buffs. I am by no means saying that powerbacks are fine - they and the offensive line do need to be looked at.
gameface25
offline
offline
Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by gameface25
Considering an avg powerback just broke 46 tackles in one game, against a 4-0 1st place team today in a AA league I am in, I think that powerbacks need looked at, no?
Once again - I refer specifically to the passing game in this post, but mostly because I think it is the clearest illustration of the fundamental problem with nerfs and buffs. I am by no means saying that powerbacks are fine - they and the offensive line do need to be looked at.
I wasnt addressing you...... at all...... dont take every post in this thread as some kind of "attack the OP" post... I agree with you 100%
Just adding further evidence as to the sim being borked
Originally posted by gameface25
Considering an avg powerback just broke 46 tackles in one game, against a 4-0 1st place team today in a AA league I am in, I think that powerbacks need looked at, no?
Once again - I refer specifically to the passing game in this post, but mostly because I think it is the clearest illustration of the fundamental problem with nerfs and buffs. I am by no means saying that powerbacks are fine - they and the offensive line do need to be looked at.
I wasnt addressing you...... at all...... dont take every post in this thread as some kind of "attack the OP" post... I agree with you 100%
Just adding further evidence as to the sim being borked
teamriots
offline
offline
Originally posted by UMBF
The nerfs are a result of HORRIBLE game balance and design...which is something that should have been taken care of long before GLB ever went pay for play. Developers don't let people pay for their game before it is a finished product. Even in MMOs, they don't ask you to pay for the beta. I can completely understand the need for money to expand GLB to the level where it is at now...but players are paying for an unfinished product that has massive fundamental flaws in the game design.
The nerfs are a result of HORRIBLE game balance and design...which is something that should have been taken care of long before GLB ever went pay for play. Developers don't let people pay for their game before it is a finished product. Even in MMOs, they don't ask you to pay for the beta. I can completely understand the need for money to expand GLB to the level where it is at now...but players are paying for an unfinished product that has massive fundamental flaws in the game design.
rj414
offline
offline
Gameface, I didn't mean to imply you were attacking me in this case, but was more trying to clarify the OP - I edited it to make that more clear.
Last edited Mar 5, 2009 12:37:40
is the defense too late to react?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2220514
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2215665
bort has commented that he is looking at "lower completion rates" for season 8. nerf next?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2220514
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2215665
bort has commented that he is looking at "lower completion rates" for season 8. nerf next?
Bukowski
offline
offline
Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by gameface25
Considering an avg powerback just broke 46 tackles in one game, against a 4-0 1st place team today in a AA league I am in, I think that powerbacks need looked at, no?
Once again - I refer specifically to the passing game in this post, but mostly because I think it is the clearest illustration of the fundamental problem with nerfs and buffs. I am by no means saying that powerbacks are fine - they and the offensive line do need to be looked at.
Also, their is no balance with LBs and RBs.
LBs need EVERYTHING to even have a chance to be successful, while power backs only need Strength/Carrying/SAs and decent Speed/Agility. LBs need 3rd capped Speed/Agility, double capped Tackling/Strength/Vision, along with a ton of Confidence/Stamina. It doesn't balance out, which is the main problem with power backs, basically because LBs need to build to stop both Elusive and Power RBs.
Originally posted by gameface25
Considering an avg powerback just broke 46 tackles in one game, against a 4-0 1st place team today in a AA league I am in, I think that powerbacks need looked at, no?
Once again - I refer specifically to the passing game in this post, but mostly because I think it is the clearest illustration of the fundamental problem with nerfs and buffs. I am by no means saying that powerbacks are fine - they and the offensive line do need to be looked at.
Also, their is no balance with LBs and RBs.
LBs need EVERYTHING to even have a chance to be successful, while power backs only need Strength/Carrying/SAs and decent Speed/Agility. LBs need 3rd capped Speed/Agility, double capped Tackling/Strength/Vision, along with a ton of Confidence/Stamina. It doesn't balance out, which is the main problem with power backs, basically because LBs need to build to stop both Elusive and Power RBs.
kr0n
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by gameface25
Considering an avg powerback just broke 46 tackles in one game, against a 4-0 1st place team today in a AA league I am in, I think that powerbacks need looked at, no?
Once again - I refer specifically to the passing game in this post, but mostly because I think it is the clearest illustration of the fundamental problem with nerfs and buffs. I am by no means saying that powerbacks are fine - they and the offensive line do need to be looked at.
Also, their is no balance with LBs and RBs.
LBs need EVERYTHING to even have a chance to be successful, while power backs only need Strength/Carrying/SAs and decent Speed/Agility. LBs need 3rd capped Speed/Agility, double capped Tackling/Strength/Vision, along with a ton of Confidence/Stamina. It doesn't balance out, which is the main problem with power backs, basically because LBs need to build to stop both Elusive and Power RBs.
most LBs can't match up with the great passing TE's anyway, no matter how you look at it. so i would rather focus on what they were meant to do, tackle HBs and not have speed at 100
Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by gameface25
Considering an avg powerback just broke 46 tackles in one game, against a 4-0 1st place team today in a AA league I am in, I think that powerbacks need looked at, no?
Once again - I refer specifically to the passing game in this post, but mostly because I think it is the clearest illustration of the fundamental problem with nerfs and buffs. I am by no means saying that powerbacks are fine - they and the offensive line do need to be looked at.
Also, their is no balance with LBs and RBs.
LBs need EVERYTHING to even have a chance to be successful, while power backs only need Strength/Carrying/SAs and decent Speed/Agility. LBs need 3rd capped Speed/Agility, double capped Tackling/Strength/Vision, along with a ton of Confidence/Stamina. It doesn't balance out, which is the main problem with power backs, basically because LBs need to build to stop both Elusive and Power RBs.
most LBs can't match up with the great passing TE's anyway, no matter how you look at it. so i would rather focus on what they were meant to do, tackle HBs and not have speed at 100
rj414
offline
offline
Originally posted by kr0n
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by gameface25
Considering an avg powerback just broke 46 tackles in one game, against a 4-0 1st place team today in a AA league I am in, I think that powerbacks need looked at, no?
Once again - I refer specifically to the passing game in this post, but mostly because I think it is the clearest illustration of the fundamental problem with nerfs and buffs. I am by no means saying that powerbacks are fine - they and the offensive line do need to be looked at.
Also, their is no balance with LBs and RBs.
LBs need EVERYTHING to even have a chance to be successful, while power backs only need Strength/Carrying/SAs and decent Speed/Agility. LBs need 3rd capped Speed/Agility, double capped Tackling/Strength/Vision, along with a ton of Confidence/Stamina. It doesn't balance out, which is the main problem with power backs, basically because LBs need to build to stop both Elusive and Power RBs.
most LBs can't match up with the great passing TE's anyway, no matter how you look at it. so i would rather focus on what they were meant to do, tackle HBs and not have speed at 100
But kr0n, that's another result of the problem with nerfing and berfing as opposed to tweaking the sim. Look at your first line - they can't cover TEs anyway - that's BECAUSE of the sim , so your second response is what a smart player would do - focus on what he CAN stop by exploiting the sim the other way. If Bort had TE coverage by LBs working properly, you would NOT consider just giving the TEs what they can get so casually
That's exactly the kind of thing Bort keeps nerfing stuff to avoid, but he's just playing pin the nerf on the donkey because smart players will continue to find ways to adapt and exploit the sim because every time he closes a hole or ignores one another is created.
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by gameface25
Considering an avg powerback just broke 46 tackles in one game, against a 4-0 1st place team today in a AA league I am in, I think that powerbacks need looked at, no?
Once again - I refer specifically to the passing game in this post, but mostly because I think it is the clearest illustration of the fundamental problem with nerfs and buffs. I am by no means saying that powerbacks are fine - they and the offensive line do need to be looked at.
Also, their is no balance with LBs and RBs.
LBs need EVERYTHING to even have a chance to be successful, while power backs only need Strength/Carrying/SAs and decent Speed/Agility. LBs need 3rd capped Speed/Agility, double capped Tackling/Strength/Vision, along with a ton of Confidence/Stamina. It doesn't balance out, which is the main problem with power backs, basically because LBs need to build to stop both Elusive and Power RBs.
most LBs can't match up with the great passing TE's anyway, no matter how you look at it. so i would rather focus on what they were meant to do, tackle HBs and not have speed at 100
But kr0n, that's another result of the problem with nerfing and berfing as opposed to tweaking the sim. Look at your first line - they can't cover TEs anyway - that's BECAUSE of the sim , so your second response is what a smart player would do - focus on what he CAN stop by exploiting the sim the other way. If Bort had TE coverage by LBs working properly, you would NOT consider just giving the TEs what they can get so casually
That's exactly the kind of thing Bort keeps nerfing stuff to avoid, but he's just playing pin the nerf on the donkey because smart players will continue to find ways to adapt and exploit the sim because every time he closes a hole or ignores one another is created.
Last edited Mar 5, 2009 12:57:24
chazutx
offline
offline
Yeah I agree with rj here. This pin the nerf on the donkey crap that bort is doing is getting out of hand.
Koncorde
offline
offline
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2220514 - catch up.
Originally posted by rj414
Bort, the passing game is struggling this season, I agree. As an offensive coordinator, a passing game guru, and somebody who would very much benefit from the passing game being a little easier in this case because my team is built to throw the ball
I'd choose a new job title
Originally posted by rj414
Bort, the passing game is struggling this season, I agree. As an offensive coordinator, a passing game guru, and somebody who would very much benefit from the passing game being a little easier in this case because my team is built to throw the ball
I'd choose a new job title

whoshotjr
offline
offline
I agree that the end of S6 seemed to have the best line play in my opinion. I used to actually look forward to games against top DEs and DTs to see how my OL guys would do against them, and it seemed very possible to hold a top DL guy to a sack and a few hurries. Now I don't even bother to look at anything but sacks.
If that had been left as-is and then the O-line was given a pancake boost, I think we would have had a pretty interesting sim.
If that had been left as-is and then the O-line was given a pancake boost, I think we would have had a pretty interesting sim.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























