User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Oceania AAA Leagues > Oceania AAA #2 > Oceania AA MVP/Pro Bowl Race Season 2
Page:
 
Polished Rock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wrkarl
Thank you for including Karls Myth in your Pro bowl listings


As an observer of CB's Karls Myth is having a fantastic season.
 
vetsgt02
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sxewesley
I totally agree with you. Sorry if I didn't make myself clear. I was trying to say that good offensive production from players on lower ranked teams should be given special consideration, because it is much harder for them with less plays.


Ya Jimmy Rawson is one of the top players almost every game but we have yet to win a game.
 
vetsgt02
offline
Link
 
check out his stats. He has over 1000 all purpose yrds. 800+ on KR and he has a 30 yrd average on returns. The fumbles were at the begging of the season when he was a level 4. I have fixed that problem and brought his carrying up.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=154470
Last edited May 15, 2008 09:56:01
 
Polished Rock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vetsgt02
check out his stats. He has over 1000 all purpose yrds. 800+ on KR and he has a 30 yrd average on returns. The fumbles were at the begging of the season when he was a level 4. I have fixed that problem and brought his carrying up.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=154470


858.5 yard on 29 returns for a 29.6 avg. Likewise your CB has 16 KR for only 29.9 avg. Having a lot of Returns doesn't mean you excel at them. It just means you are being scored on much and therefore are being kicked off to a lot. At this point in the season, there are 15 guys in the league with at least 10 KR's that avg at least 30.7 yards a return.

The point being made accurately by some is, quality of play should be recognized, not quantity. There are teams in the league that have played 200 fewer defensive snaps than LA after 9 games this year. Those better teams are going to have fewer opportunity for tackles, interceptions, sacks, pass deflections, etc. And because they are better and have have higher quality back-ups, the starters may not even play as much. So the starters on teams that are struggling get many more defensive plays. When they might be 3rd or 4th on the depth chart of one of the better teams.

So, it's more than just mere stats that indicate an all-star. Every "environment" a player is in should be measured with the actual production of the player.
Yes, CB's can have more passes thrown their way if they are susceptible to giving up a play, or less if they are better than the WR. Less passes thrown at means less tackles, pass deflections, interceptions. Of course a CB can always make tackles in the running game.

And vetsgt02, it is always much more satisfying to have a peer recognize your player and nominate him rather than pushing your own player(s) yourself.
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
Just looking over the Avengers real Quick, the player that jumps out at me is SS Denis Tevs.

He is getting more work then I am sure the team would like, but he seems to be making the most of it.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=41886
 
jrogers79
offline
Link
 
how about the wilds return guy 2 tds 34.3 avg
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=133744
 
Polished Rock
offline
Link
 
Has anyone mentioned Kickers and punters?
 
TheKingOfVa
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Polished Rock
Has anyone mentioned Kickers and punters?


I will update the list after next game and add fb's, kickers, and punters plus kick/punt returners
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrogers79
how about the wilds return guy 2 tds 34.3 avg
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=133744


Yeah, good point. They also have 3 ST TDs as a team. Wicked.
 
bluepike
offline
Link
 
Kevin Oldberry, WR, Launceston Llamas
72 rec., 851 yds., 6 TD's, 11.8 avg.
#3 in receptions, #2 in yds.
Stats on an offense that didn't see a lot of PT during some of the games this season against overpowering opponents. Can't deny those stats are deserving.

Dan Gagnon, CB, Llamas
71 tackles, 16 PDs, 4 INTs, 1 missed tackle along with 35.3 KR avg on 8 KRs
#5(T) in tackles, #12(T) INTs
Excellent in coverage and on run support. I'm not sure if he's given up more than a TD or two all season. He didn't start until the third or fourth game of the season either and still has compiled those stats.
Last edited May 16, 2008 13:26:47
 
Leksington
offline
Link
 
First I would like to thank you recognizing my CB Leks Gambit. He hasn't given up any touchdowns and I think the Brisbane Heat have been the only team to even get double digit yards on him. His tackles have been predominantly in run support, and he has started getting pass defelections on guys that aren't even his coverage assignment.

But what I am here to post about is that I think DT Barry Mobster of the Sydney Pelicans deserves some consideration.

He is on one of the top Defensive units so his stats aren't padded.
Through 10 games:
-23 Tackles
-7 Hurries
-3 Sacks (for 17 yards)
-10 TFLs
-4 Forced Fumbles
and
-1 INT where he broke a tackle and rumbled 35 yards down the field for the TD (you just have to love those big man TDs)
 
lcisneiros
offline
Link
 
Hey thanks for indicating Lucas Cisneiros for FS!
Last edited May 16, 2008 15:55:22
 
Intricate08
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Leksington

But what I am here to post about is that I think DT Barry Mobster of the Sydney Pelicans deserves some consideration.

He is on one of the top Defensive units so his stats aren't padded.
Through 10 games:
-23 Tackles
-7 Hurries
-3 Sacks (for 17 yards)
-10 TFLs
-4 Forced Fumbles
and
-1 INT where he broke a tackle and rumbled 35 yards down the field for the TD (you just have to love those big man TDs)


Seconded.

 
mzsleeper02
offline
Link
 
It's probably better to approach something like this by getting each coach to nominate a "skill player" (QB/RB), a receiver, a member of his O-line, a member of his D-line, a linebacker, and a member of the secondary. With each nomination, the coach could give a few highlights from that player to build some context from their stats. From that list, a committee could determine the members of a Pro Bowl team.

In any case, it's absolutely idiotic to determine the team based on stats alone. For example, offensive linemen: pancakes are nothing but an indicator of how bad you outlevel your opponent. While fun to look at, they rarely tell the whole story of how well a lineman picks up a blitz, hits the second level of defense, etc.
 
PlayinHarder
offline
Link
 
Coming from a non GM player.

Theoretically every GM scouts the other team, plans, coordinates, and computes a strategy against other teams. In doing so they look at more stats then the average player, or at least they should be, they should then vote for there player of the week MVP, from a another team, so to speak. And in doing so the player with the most MVP votes in any position should be the pro bowl players. to be decided either by an all player vote (cant vote for players from your own team). Man this sounds like such drunk talk, but so far is making sense in my own head. Hopefully someone will somewhat understand this and clean it up some.

Make sense.

**** notice .... I have been drinking heavily tonight so all of this can be null and void *******
Last edited May 17, 2008 00:06:09
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.