First of all, let me say that the Aces are probably underrepresented here, but I wanted to give players from other teams a chance--specifically, I looked at teams who might be underperforming but might have some really good players on their rosters. Even so, I obviously can't deny the Aces their due, so I've included a number of their players to reflect that.
WESTERN Conference
1x QB = Joe Magician, Galaxy Aces -- There are a number of solid QBs in this conference, but this decision is a no-brainer. 24 TDs, 8 INTs, and over 170 yards per game. He has to be doing something right.
1x RB = Bo Jackson #34, Carolina Juice -- I like Jackson because he's the RB of a top team who doesn't have an equally dazzling partner in the backfield. His numbers might not match some of his peers in his conference, but he gets the job done with grit.
1x FB = Jessie McPenis, Minnesota Shockers -- What do you want out of a FB? One word: power. McPenis (how I hate that name) has demonstrated an ability to shed tackles when carrying the rock and lay down the law on defenders when running a lead block. With the Shockers in the midst of a heated battle for playoff seeding, McPenis has the skills to give their ground game an edge.
2x WR = Plotz LePuke, Galaxy Aces and Jaison Williams, Portland Ducks -- Both of these players have shown they can consistently gain yardage and minimize drops. LePuke has the best QB in the conference throwing to him, but Dennis Dixon of the Ducks isn't exactly lighting the world on fire which makes Williams's performance even more impressive.
1x TE = JD Kruger, Denver Wildcats -- The Wildcats aren't exactly a powerhouse, but if their passing game has any spark at all, it's because of this guy. As a TE, he gets nearly twice as many looks as any of the WRs, and he in turn accounts for nearly half of their passing production. The Wildcats are 3-8; without Kruger, they'd be even worse.
1x C = Max Unger, Portland Ducks -- In looking at different conference stats, I noticed something rather amazing: Portland QB Dennis Dixon hasn't been hurried or sacked this season. At all. They've played some good defenses too, so I have no idea how to explain this, but something tells me Max Unger might have something to do with it.
2x OG = Hank Thickneck, Los Angeles Riots and Matt Birk, Minnesota Shockers -- These two players are fantastic additions to any line. I'll admit I took Thickneck based on nothing other than his Pancake stats, which leads the league. Birk, who is confusingly a backup C who starts at RG, blocks for a top-five conference rushing attack that doesn't have the luxury of a steamrolling passing offense. I'd wager that a good part of that is due to his skill at his position.
2x OT = Left Wally, Galaxy Aces and Big Unit, Billy Creech Gangstaz -- Left Wally protects the blind side of the best QB in the conference; his inclusion is pretty inarguable. Big Unit plays on the worst team in the league. I've selected him out of charity; maybe a trip to Hawaii will make him forget the meat grinder that season 2 has been. Plus, maybe it will provide a confidence boost to his team when they see one of their players has been voted into the Pro Bowl. Who knows, maybe they'll even win a game. Either way, it's my little bit of charity towards them.
Whew, that took a long time! I'll do Defense and Special Teams later.