Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Godzirra
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Godzirra
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Godzirra
Yeah, if scouting bars is only for starters then how come when I take my third string HB off of the depth chart my rushing bar goes down. And BTW in my opinion the only scouting bars that matter are blocking, which high is good. Rush defense, high means you are facing a stronger front 7 but they are probably going to be slower. High receiving bars is more than likely going to mean less drops but are open less often, at least at this level. Teams with a low rushing bar means they probably went more with power backs, who always have lower rushing bars.
Originally posted by -MITH-
Originally posted by aird88
My old team was 48 overall and we beat a 54.
And thats not the point of the thread. I know better than anyone that gameplanning is the key ingrediant of a great team. However, scouting bars directly reflect how well a team is built in starter positions. You take a team that has a great bunch of builds and add great gameplanning and you have a team that will make the playoffs for sure and possibly win it all. That is the entire point of this. NOT wow a 42 overall they cant loose ever.
My team won EEBBB#1 last season. It was the ebst league ive been part of by far and maybe the best ever expansion league ever in GLB. SABBB#1 has all the pieces to be even better this season. So i'll be watching them alot. We moved up to EEA of course and should be very competitive. We may even win it all who knows. Were out leveled but i believe our builds are much stronger. Why else would a team full of level 35+'s still only have a 48 scouting bar? they built bad.
I tend to agree. A lot of people say scouting bars mean nothing. Usually they are ones with low scouting bars from crappy builds themselves. Scouting bars DO mean something. It may not mean the team with a higher bar will win every time, but it does show how well they are built in comparison to another team.
If a EEBBB team had a 51 at end of season and a team already in EEA only has a 48 now, there is something not right.
A team 1 season older than the EEBBB team would not have the lower overall because they were "built better". Get real!
Cough cough you're wrong if you're trying to say that scouting report bars mean you are built better.
And you are wrong if you are saying that scouting bars mean you are built worse. Ya, the higher you are the worse you are. Higher bars automatically mean you are worse. That makes sense.
Lets put it this way... hypothetically speaking... if I were an owner that was NOT allowed to see builds and could ONLY go by scouting bars, I'm going to go with the higher, "better" bars.
And when I say this, I'm not necessarily saying the higher "overall" bar... but the higher bar that I think is more important for the particular position I am searching for.
My point I am making is that it's on a case by case basis, sometimes higher scouting report bars mean a better build, sometimes they don't. Just look at the Washington Wolfpack, great team, highest scouting report bars in the game and they still were not able to win USA AAA 2-3 seasons running. BTW they have some very good gameplanners so I don't think that was so much the problem...people undervalue certain things that don't go into bars such as SAs or eq. placement or a team being built to complement one another.(which is what makes teams like HHW so good)
Who says they have good gameplanners? You? No offense, but I don't think much of your opinion on many topics so far. And maybe they do have good bars, and good builds, and good gameplanners... but it's possible they either ran up against BETTER gameplanners... or the random bullshit sim that we've all encountered... or both.
So just because a higher scouting bar team lost, doesn't necessarily mean that higher bar team has bad builds.
One other thing to consider, is the scouting bars is for only starters. It's possible the backups are much lower in level. You have to consider the drop off in talent. One thing I do know is teams like CKT and CY that have a 51 for starters also have a 51 for backups. There is absolutely no drop off.
This is why player scouting bars mean more to me than team scouting bars. Less variables with a single player than a whole team.
No offense Godzirra, I don't think too much of your in game knowlledge and you are wrong about scouting report bars only being for starters. But you obviously, as normal missed my point. I said it's on a case by case basis but having the better scouting report bars =/= better team and/or builds.