Originally posted by SZA
Originally posted by Bugman_AZ
lol, good idea.
So if im reading this correctly, if you have 20 players on the bench with 1 point in MS then you would have a 100% chance of it firing. Statistically that is. And if you have a Punter with 15 in MS then you would have a 75% chance. Sounds like the ONLY logical conclusion is to have 1 for every player on the team and then it would fire basically on every play. This to me kinda defeats the whole "realistic" approach to having "ONE" guy on the team that is good at motivating his teammates. Im not complaining really, because this way makes it very easy to get the roll every play, but its basically a "legal" exploit. If this is the case then every GM should be requiring it for every player.
It has been years since I have taken statistics so I could be wrong, but I think the math is off here. Take a coin flip for instance. Probability of heads is 1/2. If you flip it again, the probability of the second is also 1/2, but the probability of getting 2 heads in a row is 1/2 * 1/2 = 1/4. It should work the same way with MS. With 1 point for 20 players, there would be a 5% chance for it working and therefore a 95% chance of it failing. If you look at it from the failure side, there is a .95^20 chance of everybody failing their roll and MS not kicking in. This equates to a .35 chance of complete failure of any player's MS roll succeeding. 1-.35=.65 chance of at least one of your players MS ability firing. So, if I remember stats correctly, 20 players with 1 in MS should result in it firing about 65% of the time.
You win. Your math teacher would be proud. 1 player with 15 points in MS does trump 20 players with one point. It is actually closer to 64% success rate with the 20 player hypothetical.
Originally posted by Bugman_AZ
lol, good idea.
So if im reading this correctly, if you have 20 players on the bench with 1 point in MS then you would have a 100% chance of it firing. Statistically that is. And if you have a Punter with 15 in MS then you would have a 75% chance. Sounds like the ONLY logical conclusion is to have 1 for every player on the team and then it would fire basically on every play. This to me kinda defeats the whole "realistic" approach to having "ONE" guy on the team that is good at motivating his teammates. Im not complaining really, because this way makes it very easy to get the roll every play, but its basically a "legal" exploit. If this is the case then every GM should be requiring it for every player.
It has been years since I have taken statistics so I could be wrong, but I think the math is off here. Take a coin flip for instance. Probability of heads is 1/2. If you flip it again, the probability of the second is also 1/2, but the probability of getting 2 heads in a row is 1/2 * 1/2 = 1/4. It should work the same way with MS. With 1 point for 20 players, there would be a 5% chance for it working and therefore a 95% chance of it failing. If you look at it from the failure side, there is a .95^20 chance of everybody failing their roll and MS not kicking in. This equates to a .35 chance of complete failure of any player's MS roll succeeding. 1-.35=.65 chance of at least one of your players MS ability firing. So, if I remember stats correctly, 20 players with 1 in MS should result in it firing about 65% of the time.
You win. Your math teacher would be proud. 1 player with 15 points in MS does trump 20 players with one point. It is actually closer to 64% success rate with the 20 player hypothetical.




Don't ever give anyone the benefit of the doubt on this game though. So good catch
























