User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Is a complete reset neccesary?
Page:
 
csull36
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cabrasher
Originally posted by F8n4tune

Originally posted by csull36


Otherwise, how do we know agents have not been abusing this bug for a long time?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1291083
(Will be retiring him shortly, but just pointing out how easy the bug is to exploit.)

Unless there is a way to track SP distribution historically (is there?) it looks like things could spiral out of control.

I really hope the admins can find a way to remedy this soon. It is a sad day for glb nonetheless


Save that an pm it to someone in authority and tell them how you did it. DO NOT TELL EVERYONE HERE......lmao

But yes it's time for a re-set.


I just figured it out as well, and sadly, it was way too easy. After seeing how easy it was, it would be stupid to think that there were not some people out there who have been doing this for seasons. Very, very sad day for GLB indeed.

I'll say this though regarding a possible solution. Although I don't know the server-side code obviously, there MIGHT be a way to determine who exploited this if Bort kept a historical log of each time a player assigned his/her points. It would be pretty obvious. But then again, the likelihood that there is such a log might be slim to none, as it would be huge Viewing backup databases wouldn't tell you either.


That is what I was thinking. Most databases keep at least some sort of audit table system where changes are tracked. Creating a quick procedure to run through historical audit tables and flag any skill point updates that were not small amounts (from training) and were not multiples of 5 would be the easiest solution. But it might be wishful thinking that these sort of audit tables or historical logs even exist...
 
addddddum
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
Originally posted by Asheme

What we need is a build reset (depending on how widespread the exploit is), not a total player wipe.


And what about training? How would you factor those into SPs?


Couldn't Bort just factor in the days the player has been created and x2? It would take forever to train, but seems the only way to get training SP back.
 
F8n4tune
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
And then we can wait over a year again to figure out how Season 10 decline will work!


Who cares man , anybody boosting a dead player was/is a fool anyway imho. That's throwing good money after bad , seasons IN MY MIND were never the decline point based on the leveling factors players were already in decline by lvl 40 or so in my mind , this game was/is based on having an excellent season in the first 5-6 seasons as proven by the stats of players.

Then the excuse was he plays in a better league(which sensible people knew to be a farce with 2-3 cpu teams a league) and against better competition and yeah some things were nerf edso that;'s why the stats went down. But that is your opinion and this is mine , neither of us knows who is right though i'd say.


 
hokegoalie
offline
Link
 
Howtosweepthisundertherug?

Erm, it's only been possible this offseason of course!!
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
What we need is a build reset (depending on how widespread the exploit is), not a total player wipe.


As much as I think Taha is an ass who needs to be gone, his suggestion would just be that, and I think it's the right call.

I don't think it will kill the game like some suggested, I think it will make it stronger in the long run, and you have to think Bort is in this for the long run.

As much as I am totally against respecs and the like, I don't see any other way, and having said that, I think Taha's idea is the way to go.

What I would love to see is Bort come on here later this afternoon with an announcement saying they had a company meeting about the issue, they fixed the problem and this (insert plan here) is what they are going to do, no bitching/whining/complaining, it is how it's gonna be, period.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by addddddum
Won't happen though. Obviously it would be in the best interest of the community to conduct a complete reset, but Bort will never allow that since it hits his pocket hard.


Not as hard as the alternative.
 
Hanz
offline
Link
 
If we used this suggestion

"I think we need a BUILD reset.. I would suggest the following.. keep the level of the player (DO NOT RESET LEVELS) reset the attributes and let us RE-roll our player ... take for example my lvl 37 center. I suggest I get to re roll my lvl 37 center like a new center that I am creating... but instead of getting 15 SP after finishing re-rolling. I get 15 SP + 5*36 SP to spend on the build..
For the training please (when resetting) Give 2 Training points * the amount of days the player has existed. as for the equipment I suggest that Equipment shouldn't get reset"


Bort would not lose any money. My center is still level 40...I still need to boost him to level 43 to be competetive. How would bort lose any money at all by implementing the above suggestion.

I would just add 1 cavet to the above suggestion......Every player get 100k for training costs

But the reset talked about above it totally doable logistics wise....not sure code wise
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
And what about training? How would you factor those into SPs?

We were discussing this in Dryden's GM forum, and a great point was brought up.

Figure out a static number of training SP per level (much like VP/VXP was done when that mechanic was rolled out), and apply it to everyone. It may not be exact, but it will be fair.
 
kr0n
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Seven17
Originally posted by Sarg01

Reset would kill the game.

... but I don't know how else you fix it.


how would a reset kill the game ? we would all start over like in season 1 with lv 1's woohoo
and buy teams and such , but most of all fix the exploits and bugs right this time


what about all the flex we have wasted boosting our players?
 
Underdawg08
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HATEMOBSTER
Even with a closed build you can still see scouting bars. You would think someone would've seen an awesome bar and posted it in the bugs forum had it happened earlier. I don't think this has been around for that long. I think greasemonkey should be banned from the game. Just too many ways to exploit shit. That's what initially ruined a different online game I had played.


Matter of fact for a long time people have been baffled. I have seen some posts that said HOW DOES THIS F.S. HAVE THIS SCOUTING BAR AT LEVEL 32 It was like 75 pass defense. AT the time I thought it was a great build. NOW NOT SO MUCH. that was like 3 fucking season ago.
 
carumba10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HATEMOBSTER
I think greasemonkey should be banned from the game. Just too many ways to exploit shit. That's what initially ruined a different online game I had played.


100% agree.

 
mattshwink
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HATEMOBSTER
Even with a closed build you can still see scouting bars. You would think someone would've seen an awesome bar and posted it in the bugs forum had it happened earlier. I don't think this has been around for that long. I think greasemonkey should be banned from the game. Just too many ways to exploit shit. That's what initially ruined a different online game I had played.


The problem (as far as I understand it) has nothing to do with Greasemonkey but rather older browsers and slow connections.
 
taz20075
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
Originally posted by Asheme

What we need is a build reset (depending on how widespread the exploit is), not a total player wipe.


And what about training? How would you factor those into SPs?


If you're using training for SPs then you're doing it wrong and deserve to lose those SPs.
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
the risk is the exploiters who didn't over do it -

how many freaking players were just taking 8 or 9 SP's per level instead of 5??


that won't be showing up very easily in the scouting bars...........



i would expect that bort will come on and say "no one ever used it...blah blah blah..."
 
csull36
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HATEMOBSTER
Even with a closed build you can still see scouting bars. You would think someone would've seen an awesome bar and posted it in the bugs forum had it happened earlier. I don't think this has been around for that long. I think greasemonkey should be banned from the game. Just too many ways to exploit shit. That's what initially ruined a different online game I had played.


There is still the potential of a crafty user using the bug to raise skills marginally on older players, where it would be harder to track the normal sp distribution, since many were not slow built...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.