User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Limit the number of GMs
Page:
 
Intimnasc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Welsh76
Originally posted by Intimnasc

I think changing it now without stripping all existing trophies is a waste of time.


I'm sure Bort could run a script and easily find the teams that offered all these trophies; just remove those.


So what your saying is Bort could run a script to find out what each GM did to participate in the teams functions? He may be smart but he ain't that smart. Basically a script to read everyones minds to see what was discussed in PM,s, Vent channels, phone calls, and e-mails?
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
GM trophies by their nature will always be up for debate. There is no way to validate anything related to a GM trophy. Why try and police something like that?
 
Skoll Wolfrun
offline
Link
 
This could just be reclassified as each GM has to be slotted: OC, DC, FA (financial advisor), SC (Scout), OW (Owner), (not sure what else...)
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
GM trophies by their nature will always be up for debate. There is no way to validate anything related to a GM trophy. Why try and police something like that?


then there's no reason for them at all? it would be nice when an OC brags that he lead his team to the title that s/he actually had a OC trophy from that team. I like the idea of OC, DC, ST, recruiting, finance, and scouting GM trophies and the rest being plaques.
 
Welsh76
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Intimnasc
Originally posted by Welsh76

Originally posted by Intimnasc


I think changing it now without stripping all existing trophies is a waste of time.


I'm sure Bort could run a script and easily find the teams that offered all these trophies; just remove those.


So what your saying is Bort could run a script to find out what each GM did to participate in the teams functions? He may be smart but he ain't that smart. Basically a script to read everyones minds to see what was discussed in PM,s, Vent channels, phone calls, and e-mails?


That's not what I'm saying, all he has to do is run a script to find out where 10+ GM trophies were awarded to a team and remove all those. Either that or check the date that the GM's were appointed and if they were a GM for less than half the season then remove the trophy.

There's plenty of ways to go about it, I'd be happy if he just removed them altogther and come up with a better system.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
Originally posted by wombat killer

GM trophies by their nature will always be up for debate. There is no way to validate anything related to a GM trophy. Why try and police something like that?


then there's no reason for them at all? it would be nice when an OC brags that he lead his team to the title that s/he actually had a OC trophy from that team. I like the idea of OC, DC, ST, recruiting, finance, and scouting GM trophies and the rest being plaques.


But there is no way to validate that person with the OC designation really did anything. Its also impossible to compare different OCs across teams.
 
Welsh76
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
But there is no way to validate that person with the OC designation really did anything. Its also impossible to compare different OCs across teams.


You're correct, which I why I'd prefer to see a sytem where you only appoint 1 OC, 1 DC etc.. if anyone wants to help out then they become assistants to them. At the moment some teams use the GM's as a list of friends and I'm sure Bort never intended for it to be like that.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Welsh76
Originally posted by wombat killer

But there is no way to validate that person with the OC designation really did anything. Its also impossible to compare different OCs across teams.


You're correct, which I why I'd prefer to see a sytem where you only appoint 1 OC, 1 DC etc.. if anyone wants to help out then they become assistants to them. At the moment some teams use the GM's as a list of friends and I'm sure Bort never intended for it to be like that.


I think you missed my point. There is no way to validate the one guy you have listed as OC did anything.
 
Welsh76
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by Welsh76

Originally posted by wombat killer


But there is no way to validate that person with the OC designation really did anything. Its also impossible to compare different OCs across teams.


You're correct, which I why I'd prefer to see a sytem where you only appoint 1 OC, 1 DC etc.. if anyone wants to help out then they become assistants to them. At the moment some teams use the GM's as a list of friends and I'm sure Bort never intended for it to be like that.


I think you missed my point. There is no way to validate the one guy you have listed as OC did anything.


Maybe not, but just giving out 1 trophy is much better than 300+
 
fortna29
offline
Link
 
i like the idea of giving the trophies to the owner of the Team... This owner gets say 10 trophies at the end of every season... gold and silver just like they are now to give out to 10 GM's on the team for what they did... make a list of what they could have done like a drop down list so that you just cant write something in then there could be a couple of OC's or DC's... you are limited to 1 trophy from a team. Gold to the league Champ and Silver to the Runner up... forget the Conference Trophy.... if you have a league Trophy we know you won your conference.

You shouldnt need more then 10 GM's to run a team but hey maybe ya do......

also i say just leave the trophies that are there alone... create a link to a page where those trophies are kept or better yet... move them to the bottom of the page below all the players.... Then with the new system put them where the ones are now or put the Trophy in the box where the team is.... then with a scroll over of the mouse you are able to see what the agent did to get this trophy.

if you leave a team your trophy gets moved to the TOP of the page next to the Agents name where the ones are kept now but instead of having the text below the trophy change it to a Scroll over feature were a text box pops up with what they did and who they Gm'ed for and what league they won or came in second
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Maybe you could make it cost money like Super Bowl rings?
 
Kutzy
Child Support
offline
Link
 
I disagree with this 100%. What is the limit? How do you know a person isnt helping the team out?
 
Gus38
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kutzy
I disagree with this 100%. What is the limit? How do you know a person isnt helping the team out?


Read up...
 
firemonster
offline
Link
 
Ya for me i feel that gm is not going what i hired them for then there FIRED
 
Kutzy
Child Support
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gus38
Originally posted by Kutzy

I disagree with this 100%. What is the limit? How do you know a person isnt helping the team out?


Read up...


I read it, but it makes no sense. Why am I only getting 5, 7, 10 people? Maybe I had more help than that. Why are you ruining the chance of people who actually put work into my team from getting a trophy?

GLB has learned from its mistakes before with gutting collusion faults. Just because 1 person fudges with the system doesnt mean you need to completely revamp the system.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.