User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > CPU-owned teams should not be allowed to make the playoffs
Page:
 
Diamonddog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
no team should be handed a playoff spot that they did not earn. The big issue here is that a good team was allowed to go bellyup after the start of the season.


Yes, and the solution is to make it painful for owners to gut.
The fact that that owner will get all the flex points back, and be able to get another team for 1000 flex points, doesn't help this situation at all.
 
Fezmid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Outlaw Dogs
I would be embarrassed to make the playoffs solely based on a CPU not being able to make the playoffs.


You'd be embarrassed to make the playoffs over a team playing the first 12 games of the season (going 9-3) then quitting to lose the last 4 games and finish 9-7?
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Diamonddog
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc

no team should be handed a playoff spot that they did not earn. The big issue here is that a good team was allowed to go bellyup after the start of the season.


Yes, and the solution is to make it painful for owners to gut.
The fact that that owner will get all the flex points back, and be able to get another team for 1000 flex points, doesn't help this situation at all.


its such an easy solution too, dont let teams sell back. if I go to a restaurant and order a meal, i dont get to eat half the meal then ask for a refund on the remainder.

 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
So Guppy you'd rather have 500 teams with inactive owners rather than recycling them? That's worse than the gutting itself...
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnerhero
So Guppy you'd rather have 500 teams with inactive owners rather than recycling them? That's worse than the gutting itself...


an inactive team can still have GMs that are running the team, it can still have jobs for human players instead of CPUs. And nice exaggeration on the number of teams. As soon as you start throwing out BS like that, you already have lost the argument.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by turnerhero
So Guppy you'd rather have 500 teams with inactive owners rather than recycling them? That's worse than the gutting itself...


They can be bought in the offseason. I don't think you should be allowed to sell a team midseason.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
no team should be handed a playoff spot that they did not earn. The big issue here is that a good team was allowed to go bellyup after the start of the season.


This is the crux of the issue.

However it doesn't solve the issue that:

A - the Romantics previously gutted a AA USA team for the purpose of stacking the AA Western Europe team after it became obvious they would never be anything other than also-rans in the US. The USA team promptly had 2 seasons of max cash to fill build the stadium and save money. This is previously raised as a concern with Support.

B - the Romantics gut midseason on a whim. They've already had an influence on the direction of the Play-offs by being involved in 11 or 12 games....everyone else after that week gets a free win. This skews the Playoff standings as it's unknown if this team could have in fact defeated those 4 or so teams (including the 9th placed team).

C - when they gutted the Romantics, every single player (bar 5 or 6) signed with a BBB team (the original gutted team).

As far as I'm concerned, the players involved should get an XP wipe for the entire season.

There also needs to be a provision for teams going CPU (i.e. that they are inelligible for the playoffs). Harsh on the teams sans Owner but still with GM's, but otherwise you'll have gut jobs going on with 1 player left behind because it doesn't matter.

The Global Eagles, the team that will miss out, have been a competitive team in AAA for 4 or so seasons now. To suggest that they are worth less than CPU teams would be enough to drive some Owners just to quit the game.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dansingingfool
Originally posted by turnerhero

So Guppy you'd rather have 500 teams with inactive owners rather than recycling them? That's worse than the gutting itself...


They can be bought in the offseason. I don't think you should be allowed to sell a team midseason.


In 1.

You pay for the season, you get the season.

Requests to sell should be reviewed by Admins at the minimum. Not enough Admins? Hire more.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
Originally posted by Diamonddog

Originally posted by Guppy, Inc


no team should be handed a playoff spot that they did not earn. The big issue here is that a good team was allowed to go bellyup after the start of the season.


Yes, and the solution is to make it painful for owners to gut.
The fact that that owner will get all the flex points back, and be able to get another team for 1000 flex points, doesn't help this situation at all.


its such an easy solution too, dont let teams sell back. if I go to a restaurant and order a meal, i dont get to eat half the meal then ask for a refund on the remainder.



That's great...but how do you want to handle

-inactive owners
-disinterested owners
--active players on a team with one of the above

there are a lot of other issues that need to be considered
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Improve customer services?

Have an Admin responsible for each League Tree to review everything?

And again - if there aren't enough, then hire some.
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yukon Don
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc

Originally posted by Diamonddog


Originally posted by Guppy, Inc



no team should be handed a playoff spot that they did not earn. The big issue here is that a good team was allowed to go bellyup after the start of the season.


Yes, and the solution is to make it painful for owners to gut.
The fact that that owner will get all the flex points back, and be able to get another team for 1000 flex points, doesn't help this situation at all.


its such an easy solution too, dont let teams sell back. if I go to a restaurant and order a meal, i dont get to eat half the meal then ask for a refund on the remainder.



That's great...but how do you want to handle

-inactive owners
-disinterested owners
--active players on a team with one of the above

there are a lot of other issues that need to be considered


There is nothing that can be done about owners that lose interest if they arent winning, or are incompetent. the problem is that right now that those owners can up and quit with no real impact to themselves while leaving the team in the same shape. I've always thought that owners need to do some team related activity every day, and not just sign in to keep the 14 day clock resetting. If support gets a complaint right now that an owner isnt doing anything for the team, the response is always that nothing can be done. Seize the team if it isnt being managed. When people sign up for a team, its implied that they will make a good faith effort to run the team and when they do not, seize the team and appoint a temp GM to run it for the remainder of the season. I'm sure that if you opened a list of those willing to be temp GM that many would apply. I know a couple of people that have asked for my help learning the AIs and this would be the perfect training ground.
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
In this specific case, I think the admins should review the situation and give the 9th place team the playoff spot. I'll try to address various concerns raised throughout the thread.

1) Why do we have the current relegation system for sold/gutted teams? To increase parity in the leagues. Allowing this team to keep its playoff spot does nothing for league parity or competition. To the person who said it shouldn't happen because a team might get a cupcake game - that's exactly what this game is now - a cupcake game that will probably end 80+ to 3 or something.

2) In the spirit of competitiveness, the 9th place team will be better off to attack the new season. Even though it's marginal, they have some playoff money to expand the stadium, give equipment, buy players, etc. The CPU team will leave the league and go down. In my opinion, any time you have a chance to fairly increase the level of competition in a league, it should be allowed.

3) I agree that CPU teams with human GMs and players should be allowed to continue on. With something like this, you really have to make it a case by case basis. There is not one good solution that applies to everything.

For everyone trying to use NFL type comparisons, it really doesn't work. It's like if the Eagles players and coaches completely left and they were replaced by USC. It's far more fair and in the spirit of good competition to let the next team play.
 
Skoll Wolfrun
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bmedders
In this specific case, I think the admins should review the situation and give the 9th place team the playoff spot. I'll try to address various concerns raised throughout the thread.

1) Why do we have the current relegation system for sold/gutted teams? To increase parity in the leagues. Allowing this team to keep its playoff spot does nothing for league parity or competition. To the person who said it shouldn't happen because a team might get a cupcake game - that's exactly what this game is now - a cupcake game that will probably end 80+ to 3 or something.

2) In the spirit of competitiveness, the 9th place team will be better off to attack the new season. Even though it's marginal, they have some playoff money to expand the stadium, give equipment, buy players, etc. The CPU team will leave the league and go down. In my opinion, any time you have a chance to fairly increase the level of competition in a league, it should be allowed.

3) I agree that CPU teams with human GMs and players should be allowed to continue on. With something like this, you really have to make it a case by case basis. There is not one good solution that applies to everything.

For everyone trying to use NFL type comparisons, it really doesn't work. It's like if the Eagles players and coaches completely left and they were replaced by USC. It's far more fair and in the spirit of good competition to let the next team play.


1: tends to happen between 2 player owned teams anyway, so no real difference. 8th seed beating #1 (or 7th beating #2) is the super rare case.

2: CPU teams just get replaced; sometimes through relegation, more times by a Human agent buying a team.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
If the CPU team is better, it should make the playoffs.


 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

If the CPU team is better, it should make the playoffs.




The CPU team isn't better NOW. They WERE better with a completely different lineup and management, but they aren't now.

Maybe in order to settle this, you have a scrimmage between the CPU team and the ninth place team. If the ninth place team wins (which they will 99.9% of the time), they get the playoff spot.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.