User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > ITT: Necessary and indisputable fixes to GLB
Page:
 
presvedder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by DavidD458

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Sik Wit It



I can see the 2 point conversion being abused. With how easy it is to get 2 yds, I bet people would go for 2 after every TD and succeed with regularity.


I could see onside kicks being used in the same vein, if there was a decent chance of recovering them.

And no, not really all that easy to code. Bouncing footballs aren't exactly easy to model math-wise.


Understandable. Then don't show it (like FGs). It'd then be just rolling dice. And it can only be used in certain situations.


Hm, that's an idea. Then you get the "why can't I view the onside kick replays" problem, though.


I think the onside kick is a great idea, but I would rather have it implemented when we have a realistic chance to stop the pass between two equal teams.
 
nightstar289
offline
Link
 
For FGs, if we don't get replays anytime soon, could we at least have some feedback on how a FG was missed? So the options would be: FG (Good) or FG (Missed, Wide Right/Left/Short)
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nightstar289
For FGs, if we don't get replays anytime soon, could we at least have some feedback on how a FG was missed? So the options would be: FG (Good) or FG (Missed, Wide Right/Left/Short)
maybe that's because it doesn't exist in the sim. It's possible that, like Court Rivals, the sim just spits out "good" or "bad" based on the attributes, not "inaccurate" or "short" or "wide left" or "wide right"
 
Splat
offline
Link
 
Allow Fumble Forcers to not lie unconscious for 6 seconds and MAYBE have a chance at recovering the fumble they forced.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

I can see the 2 point conversion being abused. With how easy it is to get 2 yds, I bet people would go for 2 after every TD and succeed with regularity.


I could see onside kicks being used in the same vein, if there was a decent chance of recovering them.

And no, not really all that easy to code. Bouncing footballs aren't exactly easy to model math-wise.



I didn't read the whole thread, but it would just be easier to just to list the "result" like a FG attempt does.


Make the math non-existent (a constant):

chance of recovering an onside kick = 2%


If the % was fixed like that regardless of who was on the field, then I don't think it would be abused.

Maybe we could debate the % as to if it should be 1% or 3%, but I would just do something like that. It spices up the games and would be easy to do.




edit: oops. someone said the same thing.


also: no one really cares about not seeing FG's, and no one would care about not seeing the onside kick. They only care about the FG illustration so they know if they are missing short (need more strength) or missing to the side (vision?). If you set the onside kick as a constant, then no one care about a replay because there would be nothing to improve.

Last edited Jan 22, 2009 02:04:47
 
Link
 
Originally posted by nightstar289
For FGs, if we don't get replays anytime soon, could we at least have some feedback on how a FG was missed? So the options would be: FG (Good) or FG (Missed, Wide Right/Left/Short)


exactly.

 
Link
 
agree with everything davidD458 had to say except for qb kneel downs. they do happen now but they aren't perfect. my team knelt down in the last game and then punted. the other team got a play off, not that it mattered, but that's some bad coaching right there lol.
 
morbo
offline
Link
 
SI has the right idea, except it should be somewhere between 20-25%

2% wtf lol
 
Link
 
it shoudl be 2% , unless ur down by like 10 or less , and its within the last ___ (set by u guys) amount of minutes in the game
 
DavidD458
offline
Link
 
As I said, ~13% was the NFL average.
 
maz621
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DavidD458
As I said, ~13% was the NFL average.


the only problem with it being this high is this is GLB... there will be teams who take that 1 in 10 shot every single time the smaller the % the less its abused
 
morbo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DavidD458
As I said, ~13% was the NFL average.


Your google search was wrong. Wiki said that 2004 the average was 23%, but the source link (was to nfl.com) was broken due to a restructure. I went to nfl.com myself and counted the 2007 season onsides, they had a 25% success rate.
 
morbo
offline
Link
 
So what if there are teams that take the shot all the time, if they want to it should be their choice. I would more than welcome my opponent to onsides, and then laugh at him.

I think most coaches would get sick and tired of giving their opponents excellent field position all the time pretty quickly.
 
Blamo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by morbo
So what if there are teams that take the shot all the time, if they want to it should be their choice. I would more than welcome my opponent to onsides, and then laugh at him.

I think most coaches would get sick and tired of giving their opponents excellent field position all the time pretty quickly.


With the way the game is currently shifted towards offense right now, I think everyone would have to take that chance right now. GLB is basically Madden right now.
 
DavidD458
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by morbo
Originally posted by DavidD458

As I said, ~13% was the NFL average.


Your google search was wrong. Wiki said that 2004 the average was 23%, but the source link (was to nfl.com) was broken due to a restructure. I went to nfl.com myself and counted the 2007 season onsides, they had a 25% success rate.


Nah, it was right. It was a four year average. 13% was not considering "surprise" onside kicks, which are the most successful. I'd be assuming there are no "surprise" onside kicks since we just want another chance at the ball, not surprising another team. The unexpected onside kick had like over a 35% success rate or something.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.