User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Forced fumbles on RBs - a thing of the past?
Page:
 
DarkRogue
offline
Link
 
My HB has always been fumble prone until this season where he has not fumbled a single time with 41.58 Carrying and 52.4 Strength along with 2 in cover up, I went from a 6-7 fumble a season back to being on pace for no fumbles.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=139451
 
Jaxx
offline
Link
 
I have seen little difference in FF's this season had as a team 13 so far and would guess will end up with about 24 to 26. Team is in USA AAA#1 with no CPU teams may just be random factor coming into play with people.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
That's interesting - FF's should theoretically be up with the change I made to monster/big hit affecting tackle quality (which has to be decent to allow a FF check in the first place) on top of their +FF chance bonus. I guess I could experiment with increasing their bonus, or upping the base FF likelihood for next season.

Many RB owners tend to really freak the F out whenever they fumble more than a couple times a season though, even if they have 30 carrying and crap strength.

VA's like motivational speaker (though it's not very much of a morale bonus per play, I guess it could make a difference over the course of a game) and some of the avoid fumble type ones might have something to do with it as well - those are fairly popular choices after track star and quick.
Last edited Jan 19, 2009 06:00:08
 
Luzod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
That's interesting - FF's should theoretically be up with the change I made to monster/big hit affecting tackle quality (which has to be decent to allow a FF check in the first place) on top of their +FF chance bonus. I guess I could experiment with increasing their bonus, or upping the base FF likelihood for next season.

Many RB owners tend to really freak the F out whenever they fumble more than a couple times a season though, even if they have 30 carrying and crap strength.

VA's like motivational speaker (though it's not very much of a morale bonus per play, I guess it could make a difference over the course of a game) and some of the avoid fumble type ones might have something to do with it as well - those are fairly popular choices after track star and quick.


I think you should give a 'bonus' to avoid fumble for return specialists if you increase the chances of a fumble, because CBs just haven't anything to 'prevent it', so fumbles when returning are the 'most common' way to fumble, usually returned for a TD when it happens.
 
Crawly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Many RB owners tend to really freak the F out whenever they fumble more than a couple times a season though, even if they have 30 carrying and crap strength.

I'd feel a lot more sorry for them if I hadn't read the second half of that sentence.

Fumble-prone RBs fumble roughly every 30-40 rushing attempts against equal competition IRL. For example:
Player - carries - fumbles
Adrian Peterson - 363 - 9
Marion Barber - 238 - 7
Frank Gore - 240 - 6
Maurice Jones-Drew - 197 - 6
Larry Johnson - 193 - 5

This seems like a pretty reasonable rate to me, and works out to a fumble every 2-3 games for a feature back who doesn't have high carrying.

Of course, most NFL fumbles are by QBs, not by RBs - 14/15 leading fumblers in the NFL are QBs (or 19/21 if you keep going down the list). Increasing QB fumbles a bit would be nice.
Last edited Jan 19, 2009 06:10:51
 
WearyWarrior
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
That's interesting - FF's should theoretically be up with the change I made to monster/big hit affecting tackle quality (which has to be decent to allow a FF check in the first place) on top of their +FF chance bonus. I guess I could experiment with increasing their bonus, or upping the base FF likelihood for next season.

Many RB owners tend to really freak the F out whenever they fumble more than a couple times a season though, even if they have 30 carrying and crap strength.

VA's like motivational speaker (though it's not very much of a morale bonus per play, I guess it could make a difference over the course of a game) and some of the avoid fumble type ones might have something to do with it as well - those are fairly popular choices after track star and quick.


My 9 in Big Hit hasnt been picking me up many fumbles this season. My return on investment is certainly not working out. I suppose the hidden morale hit they take should be good too, but its intangible.
 
Spirer
offline
Link
 
If defenders need Speed, Agility, Strength, Tackling, Vision and more... it's probably fair to assume that RBs should need more than Strength, Speed and Agility, no?

For the game to be balanced between offense and defense it occurs to me that people should need/benefit from the same amount of attributes, otherwise you end up with the over-specialized, unrealistic players we have now, Powerbacks of 100+ STR probably being the most iconic.

As an example, if a RB has low vision? Then he should pick bad routes every now and again, or run into his blockers, be slow to start, drop the hand-off, etc. He should also have penalties to tackle avoidance and even to holding on to the ball, he is after all less aware of the tackles coming his way. What happens when someone doesn't see the tackle coming? It usually hurts.

I would expect a RB to have at least 60+ in Confidence and Carrying (Level 40+) if he wants to have few fumbles. After all they should be major stats for RBs, along with Strength and/or Agility and Speed. Vision should be at least 40 I think.

A lot of what I said is probably already in the game, maybe just needs to influence things a bit more.
 
Spirer
offline
Link
 
Just remembered another "trick" you could do with in game formulas. Bear in mind, I have no idea how they are right now, but if for example if they are additive it could be something like:

FF reduction = STR/2 + CAR/1.5 + Cover up*2 etc

If you make it like

FF reduction = (STR/2)*(CAR/1.5)*(Cover up*2 +1) etc

Moving from additive formulas to multiplicative ones would make extreme values less useful and the whole group of factors more relevant, which means "balanced" players would have some benefits.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Spirer
I would expect a RB to have at least 60+ in Confidence and Carrying (Level 40+) if he wants to have few fumbles. After all they should be major stats for RBs, along with Strength and/or Agility and Speed. Vision should be at least 40 I think.


I understand the point, but that will push players even more to becoming power backs rather than speed/elusive backs. The (realistic and worthwhile) changes to LB pathing made it much more difficult for a speed/elusive runner to have much success this season (especially if they don't have several of their elusive SAs maxed out), and if you require confidence over 60 and carrying over 60 as well, that means that they will be mostly useless carrying the ball (their fumbles actually will go down b/c I would bet they'd carry the ball much less often given the gimpiness of their builds). Power backs need many fewer SAs (and also lower total attribute points) to be effective, and so would be able to 60+ carrying/60+ confidence in a way that speed/elusive backs wouldn't. In other words, I can see why people would want a change, but this type of change will turn speed/elusive backs (in the higher leagues) from somewhat useless against good competition to completely useless. If carrying did more to aid speed/elusive backs in avoiding tackles, however, there might be a decent balance that could be struck.

One of the reason's fumbles may be down, in fact, is that many speed/elusive backs are getting fewer carries this season than last (b/c their less effective and b/c the passing game has been much more effective). In addition to skewing the counting stat aspect of fumbles, it also ought to mean that the in-game energy/morale of HBs when they do carry the ball is higher than it would be when they were carrying the ball more often.



Last edited Jan 19, 2009 07:38:55
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
By the way, I should have added that I'm not suggesting that 30 carrying should make a HB fumble proof (and it doesn't, 48 carrying doesn't either), just that 60 strikes me as too high to be considered the new average.
Last edited Jan 19, 2009 07:45:09
 
Spirer
offline
Link
 
Gyuri1: Thanks for the input, I do understand Elusive backs are having a bit of a hard time at the moment. The reason why I said 60+ in both those attributes, if because of how defensive players are built.

The defensive players that will more commonly "face" the HB are the Linebackers and Safeties, D-line is often tied up with the O-line and the Corners are usually away.

So if we say for example that a level 45 "common" LB has STR 60, SPD 80, AGI 60, TKL 60, STA 45, VSN 60, CNF 50, then we need to match that to a RB... let's say he has STR/AGI 90/50 (swap for elusive), SPD 80, STA 40, VSN 40, I think that leaves room for 60 CNF and CAR.
 
Arles
offline
Link
 
Check out an elusive RB. He will have 20 carries, maybe 3-4 broken tackles (many on juke - no contact) and sometimes he will score/go out of bounds. So, an elusive back with 20 carries will be hit 17-20 times (often not as cleanly). For power backs, they may have 15-20 broken tackles on 20 carries so they will be hit 35-40 times on those same carries.

So, if a change is made to increase fumbles on RBs, power backs should have nearly double the "fumbling opportunities" as a good elusive back.

Here's my issue:

1. Two marginal builds on the HB and tackler may end up with a RB fumble once every 200 carries (way too low).
2. A great tackler build and marginal HB builds seems to be more like once every 100 carries (also too low).
3. A great HB build immediately makes the defender build irrelevant as they will simply not fumble - ever.

So, if you setup a LB with 60 strength, 11 monster tackle, 60 tackling and additional morale-hitting SAs, you will never force a fumble on a back with 80+ strength, 40+ carrying and decent cover up.
 
Titus Pullo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
tackle quality (which has to be decent to allow a FF check in the first place)


That part right their may be the problem. I see FFs occur quite often in the NFL when the defender attacks the ball rather then the ball carrier. Thus the quality of the tackle is very low since the chance the defenders move of actually tackling the ball carrier is very low. However since he focued on slapping the ball out the ball comes loose and a fumble occurs.

Just watch some fumbling highlights and you will see what I am talking about. The ball carrier is running with the ball not hugged close (high carry skill) to his chest but out away from the body (low carry skill) and a defender who has little to no chance to making a tackle instead just dives at the exposed ball and knocks it lose (low strenght). Most QBs fumbles occur in this way as well since the ball is being held out in a throwing position and not secured very well. A pass rusher may miss the QB who side steps him, but he still is able to grab the arm or hit the ball as he flies by and cause a fumble. So the idea that tackle quality has to be high before a fumble can occur is incorrect. Eliminate that and you may see everything else work itself out.
 
expandingman
offline
Link
 
I have a level 14 HB and I have not given his carrying a single point (it's 14.3 right now)...he has never fumbled
 
csull36
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Arles
I've had some people PM me players with their builds temporary opened. There's one player that stuck out. He had 65 strength, 65 agility, 62 tackling, 11 monster hit and had forced numerous fumbles in prior seasons. This season, he's forced 0 in all 8 + 3 exhibition games. He even put points into "power tackling" as a vet ability. Now, guys like this have wasted 20-30 skill points and 10+ vet ability points on skills that seem to have no impact on forcing fumbles.

Something has gone haywire this season and the answer is in some of these vet abilities (like motivational speaker) completely negating the efforts of morale-dropping SAs/plays.


+++++
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.