User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
wbudwhite
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hockeyman14
Ok how about WR?


meis has a comfortable lead
 
OrangeAggie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pattybrhg

lol 500 yards and 8 TD's from getting to play Scottsdale twice doesn't hurt. Wait til you see the inflated stats he'll have after also playing the Rockhoppers and the Ni Knights twice as well. Getting 6 games against CPU or gutted teams won't say much about final stats on this guy.


Lol, I recall him having 13 receptions for 150 yards and 3 TD's against your team.
 
hockeyman14
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pattybrhg


lol 500 yards and 8 TD's from getting to play Scottsdale twice doesn't hurt. Wait til you see the inflated stats he'll have after also playing the Rockhoppers and the Ni Knights twice as well. Getting 6 games against CPU or gutted teams won't say much about final stats on this guy.


And the only team to keep me under a 100 yards was lima... 1 rec for 0 yards and a fumble... I am not looking forward to our next game...
 
pattybrhg
offline
Link
 
Hey man, I didn't put anyone else forward. All I said was there was going to be some definitive stat padding going on. You've had good stats, and you're obviously a good receiver. All I was pointing out was that it's not near as clear a lead as it was made out to be. The second game against Scottsdale netted you 305 yards and 6 TD, almost exactly the margin between you and the number two WR statistically right now.

I definitely screwed up on one point in that I thought you got FIRP twice, but you left Tears before they played them. Let's look at who you face instead of who you would have faced.
Remaining schedules (in pass defense ranking order instead of schedule order):

Tears pass defense rank ---------Cowboys pass defense rank
Bulldogs 1 --------------------------Rough Riders 9
Badgers 2 -------------------------- Blacc Diamonds 13
Fire Starters 8 ---------------------- Schisms 28
Cartel 16 --------------------------- Ni 30

Average rank replaced 6.75 ----------- Average rank remaining 20

The Rockhoppers and Death Monkeys were on both schedules for the first time, so I excluded them since they would be the same and cancel each other out anyway. If we give you the benefit of the doubt and also cancel out the 8 and 16 ranked pass defenses for the 9 and 13 ranked pass defenses, you're basically left with replacing the first and second ranking pass defenses with the 28th and 30th ranking pass defenses.

Missing out on the top two pass defenses and four teams all in the top half to replace them with two of the bottom five and no one in the top quarter of pass defenses is a bit of a change. If that doesn't bear out my point that you're going to have some inflated stats, I don't know what would. None of this was meant as a personal attack, and nowhere in any of my posts did I say a single negative thing about your WR. The All-League team was purely being evaluated by stats, and I was just showing that this is definitely a case where the stats won't tell the whole story. You're the only WR from our conference in the top 5. Number 6 and 7 are from our conference and also are yet to play the number 1 or 2 pass defenses. Number 9 has played both. Your accomplishments needless to say have been superior to those in your own conference. I just think the turn of events will have clouded the final results a bit.
Last edited Jan 25, 2009 01:59:26
 
rockqu
offline
Link
 

You are absolutely right stats don't tell the whole story. At least not the ones you quoted.

You missed a couple of important thing the Cowboys have been a rushing team. and are averaging 24 percent less pass attempts. And have more depth at receiver. So he may have less passes thrown his way, This is not really a stat but goes to the point that stat based awards are what they are and don't necessarily equate to the quality of the player. And also that he may have gotten more yards had he been able to play out the season with TFO. But with him on the team the Cowboys may be able to open up their passing game a little more.

Also you spent a lot of time researching this but your statistics are a little misleading.

The Bulldogs have yet to play the top passing teams. In fact the only team they played in the top half of passing teams was the #16 Cowboys. and that was before we got our starting receivers. and we put 200 yards on them.
While the Rough Riders have done just the opposite playing all of the Alpha teams in the top half of the standings except the #16 Cowboys.

The same goes for the Badgers but we hung 278 on them. And the only team they played in the top half of passing teams was also the #16 Cowboys. and that also was before we got our starting receivers. And the Blacc Diamonds, like the Rough Riders, have done just the opposite playing all of the Alpha teams in the top half of the standings except the #16 Cowboys.

Lets wait until the season ends and we really know how good the defenses are before you start whining about how it wasn't fair.
 
pattybrhg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rockqu

You are absolutely right stats don't tell the whole story. At least not the ones you quoted.
...
Lets wait until the season ends and we really know how good the defenses are before you start whining about how it wasn't fair.


Seriously man, I said not one bad thing about either your player or your team. I didn't even say the guy shouldn't be #1. I'm not whining for anything to change, just trying to inject a human element into some raw data. I think it's an interesting discussion point regarding a pretty rare event with a player moving intraconference in one season. If I had a WR in the top 3 or so, sure I'd probably be a little bothered. This is a game with a ton of down time. People are going to over analyze things. If you want a place where people are seriously calling people out, here: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1920038. I've been quite civil here so far, though admittedly neurotic.

Sure stats are misleading both ways, but could you honestly say that you think trading games with the Bulldogs and Badgers for the Ni Knights and Schisms is not a big trade? Of course not. Even if the Bulldogs and Badgers dropped to the middle of the pack from where they are now, you're still looking at a trade of close to 15 spots per game for two games.

For the Bulldogs to even drop to around the 16th slot they're going to have to average giving up 255 yards/game for the season. To get to that average, they're going to have to give up 473 yards per game through the air. Do you really think they're that terrible in pass defense? To put that in context, they haven't even giving up 300 in a game thus far. For the Badgers to drop that far they're going to have to give up 389 yards per game passing.
Originally posted by rockqu

And the only team they played in the top half of passing teams was also the #16 Cowboys.

This is wrong. Those #6 Ducks are a pretty solid passing team as well.
Last edited Jan 25, 2009 05:13:48
 
WoLF2001
offline
Link
 
If Floripas MLB- AJ Hawk isn't in the discussion then this pro bowl is a farce...
 
wbudwhite
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WoLF2001
If Floripas MLB- AJ Hawk isn't in the discussion then this pro bowl is a farce...


He would proably make it as a back-up to this guy.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=604763

Very similar stats but I thin the int TD is the difference. There is still time to catch him.

I might take away a couple points just because he plays for the Monkeys .....that LB puts up great numbers every year.

John
Last edited Jan 25, 2009 07:45:59
 
WoLF2001
offline
Link
 


I hate you..




kidding
 
rockqu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pattybrhg


Seriously man, I said not one bad thing about either your player or your team. I didn't even say the guy shouldn't be #1.


Hey Sorry if I misinterpreted that. But with your wide receiver in the running and the amount of effort you spent it came off that way. I just had to defend my team mate.

Also I get a little touchy about Stats. My primary players are a Center ,a DT and a Cornerback that teams don't throw against. None of those can be truly evaluated by stats. Especially the Center I don't know how many times I've seen a guy with lots of pancakes that I wouldn't have on my team.


Originally posted by pattybrhg

This is wrong. Those #6 Ducks are a pretty solid passing team as well.


My Apologies to you and the Ducks I was pretty tired by the time I finished that and just didn't check the cross conference games.
 
pattybrhg
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I was extra careful to try to not include myself in this one. I even called myself the 6th place receiver instead of interjecting myself there. To be clear I was absolutely not trying to interject myself into the conversation. My yardage is pretty good, but my scoring is lagging well behind contention. I guess this is the only position nomination that I said anything about because it is obviously a position I look at more because I have a same position player but also because of the peculiar circumstances.

I totally agree with not getting wrapped up with stats. Stat whores drive me nuts. Most of my players have been CB's and DT's as well. I totally understand the pain.
 
Phantom_Opera
offline
Link
 
So where is the list of leaders?
 
wbudwhite
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Phantom_Opera
So where is the list of leaders?


If you have a specific position I will look it up. I just do not want to look up the whole team just to have to do it again here in a few days.

John
 
zbenson
offline
Link
 
John, Can we get WR and DE lists, seems to be the 2 hot topics! Thanks
-ZB
 
wbudwhite
offline
Link
 
Zeta WR 1st http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=463336

This guy has the starter job pretty much locked up. I will proably take 3 WR and there is a log jam for the 2nd and 3rd.

Here are a few of the guys that would be in the running tomake either the 2nd or 3rd WR.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=229403
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=185616
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=563540
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=315355
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=89595

Zeta DE 1st http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=168781 This guy is first but he can be caught.

Here are a few that might either take over at #1 or at least make it as a #2...probably only going to take 2 DE

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=92759

Big drop off after those 2 guys
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=502188
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=531510

That is Zeta....Anybody else need to know where they stand?

Damn zbenson if you have all those good players why are you 7-5 in the little leauge conference????



Last edited Jan 25, 2009 19:49:32
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.