Originally posted by rockqu
You are absolutely right stats don't tell the whole story. At least not the ones you quoted.
...
Lets wait until the season ends and we really know how good the defenses are before you start whining about how it wasn't fair. Seriously man, I said not one bad thing about either your player or your team. I didn't even say the guy shouldn't be #1. I'm not whining for anything to change, just trying to inject a human element into some raw data. I think it's an interesting discussion point regarding a pretty rare event with a player moving intraconference in one season. If I had a WR in the top 3 or so, sure I'd probably be a little bothered. This is a game with a ton of down time. People are going to over analyze things. If you want a place where people are seriously calling people out, here:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1920038. I've been quite civil here so far, though admittedly neurotic.
Sure stats are misleading both ways, but could you honestly say that you think trading games with the Bulldogs and Badgers for the Ni Knights and Schisms is not a big trade? Of course not. Even if the Bulldogs and Badgers dropped to the middle of the pack from where they are now, you're still looking at a trade of close to 15 spots per game for two games.
For the Bulldogs to even drop to around the 16th slot they're going to have to average giving up 255 yards/game for the season. To get to that average, they're going to have to give up 473 yards per game through the air. Do you really think they're that terrible in pass defense? To put that in context, they haven't even giving up 300 in a game thus far. For the Badgers to drop that far they're going to have to give up 389 yards per game passing.
Originally posted by rockqu
And the only team they played in the top half of passing teams was also the #16 Cowboys. This is wrong. Those #6 Ducks are a pretty solid passing team as well.