User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Not enough fumbling?
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by fallingmercury


Reality. Balance. Fun.

Because this isn't high school boys basketball?

Fumbles seem fine to me, considering the vast majority of players are set to wrap-up, where they are choosing to force fewer fumbles.

So, if you build a hard hitting SS with a lot invested in the HH SA tree, you shouldn't be able to consistently force fumbles, which would be around 7-10 a season (adjusted upwards for loldots)?


No way, that's way too many.

What does a SS get, about 80 tackles per year? What you're suggesting is that the player would force a fumble a whopping 10% or more of his tackles. That would be insane, especially if there were multiple fumble-forcers on the same team.

IMO, you want GLB to be like basketball.
Last edited Jan 11, 2009 22:14:41
 
BBVD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sully

* Why is the number of fumbles so low?
* What can be done to make the occurrence of fumbles more likely?

Start up the discussion and let's see what comes up!



you might want to have robbie mac promote into the league...
 
BBVD
offline
Link
 
lower leveled (or low chemistry) C's and QB's need to fumble the snap exchange every now and then, there need to be bad snaps like over the head of the punter or a mishandled shotgun snap
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
I think FFs are incredibly random atm. Less so than in the past, but that's mainly because they've been down across the board. I mean, it's obviously build-related somehow, but the fact that no one really knows (like, at all) how to consistently force fumbles, is a bit troubling for me.


Bort said that the tackling attribute is key to landing a "good hit" on the ball carrier. Try making players with plenty of tackling and you'' see more fumbles forced. Most defenders don't have much of it...
 
zroeder
offline
Link
 
who cares. i mean really is this really what we are complaining about now. as long as there are turnovers what does it matter if its INT's or fumbles
 
Link
 
fumbles are probably down because the run game is neutered. everyone's passing (almost everyone, of course). cb's are still wimps. we see the pendulum swing back to HB's, and we'll see fumbles increase.
 
Link
 
Oh no my fake ego for my fake football player will be deflated if I don't get 15 FF a game. All the other fake football player owners will see my stats and make fun of me.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Rusty Trombone
fumbles are probably down because the run game is neutered. everyone's passing (almost everyone, of course). cb's are still wimps. we see the pendulum swing back to HB's, and we'll see fumbles increase.


Yeah this too. I keep seeing games where teams run like 8 times and throw 50.
 
Vykor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Second Goalie
Oh no my fake ego for my fake football player will be deflated if I don't get 15 FF a game. All the other fake football player owners will see my stats and make fun of me.


Stupid argument or whatever you're trying to accomplish by that post.

People that make LBs that should force fumbles do it to help the team by causing a turnover; your argument can be applied for for any position/player because according to that, people make HBs fast to pump up their ego, QBs accurate to pump up their ego, etc.

Quit trying to be an internet wise-guy; nobody likes them.
Last edited Jan 11, 2009 22:33:09
 
Link
 
Yes because all the complaining about not getting inflated stats is due to wanting to help the team. Win or lose the crying commences about not getting enough stats. Get real.
 
ripper12
offline
Link
 
blind side sack should be 33% fumble chance imo
 
Link
 
Originally posted by ripper12
blind side sack should be 33% fumble chance imo


We still have DEs (and some DTs) on track for ~60 sacks. That's already extraordinarily powerful. Do you really want them to get 20+ forced fumbles on top of that?
Last edited Jan 11, 2009 22:58:11
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
No way, that's way too many.

What does a SS get, about 80 tackles per year? What you're suggesting is that the player would force a fumble a whopping 10% or more of his tackles. That would be insane, especially if there were multiple fumble-forcers on the same team.

IMO, you want GLB to be like basketball.

The number is unimportant tbh. The point is consistency, some type of repeatable outcome (however many times it gets repeated is up to "realism").
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Bort said that the tackling attribute is key to landing a "good hit" on the ball carrier. Try making players with plenty of tackling and you'' see more fumbles forced. Most defenders don't have much of it...

Except that just isn't true (how it plays out). Momentum ends up being much more important. I've seen more fumbles forced on ST by offensive players and by speedy CBs hitting power backs than any other way.

Hell, my LB has forced 11 fumbles in his career (on 340 tackles), and his tackling is well below 40.
 
Vykor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by ripper12

blind side sack should be 33% fumble chance imo


We still have DEs (and some DTs) on track for ~60 sacks. That's already extraordinarily powerful. Do you really want them to get 20+ forced fumbles on top of that?


Yeah that's the problem... Players' find ways to (what I would call-) "exploit" certain things in the game & use it. (DEs getting that insane of a number of sacks... Hard to do other things for Bort; like calculate a better FF formula.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.