User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Suggestion to slow down gutting and killing teams
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Viscount
jackriley, punishing every person who sells a team is not a solution to the problem of gutting teams.


You're right, but that doesn't change the fact that what I posted, is something (some variation, not necessarily EXACTLY what i posted) needs to happen.

You can't disallow people that haven't even had the chance to own teams yet, to get them because people want the easy way out and want new teams, or they can't hack it as owners, sorry but its true sometimes, and they lose there team.

You also can't punish half the people and not the rest. But you can make different punishments based on the circumstances.

Furthermore, by losing your team, YOU SHOULD get punished because with all due respect, if you lose your team, you have no one to blame but yourself.

If you sell your team, like someone stated "what is a mod going to do fly to their house and see if they're telling the truth", you can't really determine whether the person selling the team is doing it justifiably or beacuse they're sick of losing in higher leagues so they want to take the easy way out.

So your only option, is to treat everyone in this situation equally. Make them wait a single season to get a new team, and limit people to 3 times that they can sell and repurchase a team (having to wait a season in between each time).

Owners that lose their teams, should get ONE second chance. But have to wait 2 seasons to get it. If they screw up that time, they shouldn't be allowed to get another team.

 
Viscount
offline
Link
 
I agree with what you say about people who lose their team, but I still don't think people should have to wait a season to get a new team.

I'm not sure if you realise this, but if everyone who previously owned a team had to wait another season to get a team, I very much doubt that Bort would release new teams and leagues each season as there would not be enough owners for them. Only gutted teams would probably be re-sold and they are far more likely to go CPU mid season due to the difficulty of recruiting high level players. There's also the fact that many players out of the D-leagues won't have anywhere to go due to being to low a level for most leagues.

Finally, there's the money issue. I don't think Bort would want less people getting a team each season, as that would lead to less Flex Points being bought so people can buy teams.
 
Diamonddog
offline
Link
 
funny thing is...I posted this, and I play for some of the greatest owners in the game,
offset, meauex jeaux, sarge and Bamafan. (listed by level...no favorites)
my top 4 players play for the best owners in the game, so this was for you...not for me...

I posted this for the very people that are arguing against it.

maybe i will learn my lesson.

as a DC and agent, I m doing quite fine.

This was for the guys that are arguing against it. so maybe we should all let their stupid asses suffer?



 
tdm13
offline
Link
 
I think it's a good idea..there are always exceptions to a rule, but in this case this should be implemented.
 
Diamonddog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tdm13
I think it's a good idea..there are always exceptions to a rule, but in this case this should be implemented.


I am ok with exceptions...

a few here and there.

My beef is with the guys that keep "re rolling" teams.
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Diamonddog
I think you shouldn't be able to own a team for a full season, after you abandon a team in the previous season.

Too many owners run teams that do quite well, and then get promoted, and then are not headed for another 13-3 season, so they give up the team 3 or 4 games in, and start a new one the following season.

Maybe if they had to sit out the next season as an owner, they might not be so eager to just throw the team on the trash heap.

(can't wait to see what kind of trolls this brings out of the woodwork)


Actually, it's been recommended that team's wishing to 'start over' with new low players to slow build should do exactly that. Sell the uncapped, and buy a capped expansion team.

It's far preferred vs. starting over with level one's on an uncapped team.

Last edited Jan 11, 2009 04:47:53
 
jfreaky3d
offline
Link
 
Great idea DD. I already been said, but I think they should sit out two seasons.
 
bamafan35016
offline
Link
 
I think if you give up a team you shouldn't be allowed to have one back at all.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Viscount
I agree with what you say about people who lose their team, but I still don't think people should have to wait a season to get a new team.

I'm not sure if you realise this, but if everyone who previously owned a team had to wait another season to get a team, I very much doubt that Bort would release new teams and leagues each season as there would not be enough owners for them. Only gutted teams would probably be re-sold and they are far more likely to go CPU mid season due to the difficulty of recruiting high level players. There's also the fact that many players out of the D-leagues won't have anywhere to go due to being to low a level for most leagues.

Finally, there's the money issue. I don't think Bort would want less people getting a team each season, as that would lead to less Flex Points being bought so people can buy teams.


Personally, I don't think less people WOULD be getting a team, hell there's already TOO MANY people that want one. The other thing too is.. Realistically, if this were done in conjunction with some of the other ideas suggested, like getting rid of LONG-TERM inactive players, and things of that nature, imo, it may open up a BIG GAP in the system for players who currently are having trouble finding teams.

Though, with that issue, it's more to the fact, more often than not, that they've improperly built their player and no one wants them.
 
LionsLover
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Diamonddog
I think you shouldn't be able to own a team for a full season, after you abandon a team in the previous season.

Too many owners run teams that do quite well, and then get promoted, and then are not headed for another 13-3 season, so they give up the team 3 or 4 games in, and start a new one the following season.

Maybe if they had to sit out the next season as an owner, they might not be so eager to just throw the team on the trash heap.

(can't wait to see what kind of trolls this brings out of the woodwork)


Been suggested before. I think there should be more than 1 season layoff, possibly 3. 5 months off gives you plenty to think about.
 
ryan_grant-25
offline
Link
 
what about teams that cant pay for people financially? people that mess up the stadium and the team wants EQ? they cant afford it so they gut the team and rebuild. its a good strategy, and if its a slow build team, it pays off in the long run


-1
 
Link
 
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25
what about teams that cant pay for people financially? people that mess up the stadium and the team wants EQ? they cant afford it so they gut the team and rebuild. its a good strategy, and if its a slow build team, it pays off in the long run


-1


It's not a good thing. Take the time, as an owner, to learn how to properly manage building a stadium, and manage finances before you even get a team. You have so much time before actually receiving a team to do this that, honestly, what you just said, is nothing more than an excuse.

Honestly, it seems like the people who actively DO THIS are the only ones who disagree with being penalized for it.
 
seorang
offline
Link
 
-1

Good intentions, but extreme and unecessary.

Most of the new teams are capped low-level teams. Such teams that gut can't come together again because most players will be over the new team's cap.

And besides, for the main problem stated in the OP (gutting and building a new team again), even if this solution were implemented, there's the obvious loophole of the owner becoming a GM and the GM becoming the new owner.

This will do nothing to slow down gutting.

Bad finances, the team's gotta sell players anyway.
Inactive management, players will leave anyway once team becomes CPU.
Selling because the owner cannot build a championship team, well, those sort of owners don't really come back after failing the first time, do they?
Incompetent ownership, they're not much competition, and the road will get tougher and tougher for them, and eventually they will quit and gut anyway.

Most owners who quit, don't come back. Those who do come back know what their mistakes are, and have fixed it, or will be supported by a network.
Last edited Jan 11, 2009 10:15:23
 
Outlaw Dogs
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Plus teams should cost more to start with. More expensive + no refund would probably go a long way to helping.


This is the best way to get better initial owners.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by seorang
-1

Good intentions, but extreme and unecessary.

Most of the new teams are capped low-level teams. Such teams that gut can't come together again because most players will be over the new team's cap.

And besides, for the main problem stated in the OP (gutting and building a new team again), even if this solution were implemented, there's the obvious loophole of the owner becoming a GM and the GM becoming the new owner.

This will do nothing to slow down gutting.

Bad finances, the team's gotta sell players anyway.
Inactive management, players will leave anyway once team becomes CPU.
Selling because the owner cannot build a championship team, well, those sort of owners don't really come back after failing the first time, do they?
Incompetent ownership, they're not much competition, and the road will get tougher and tougher for them, and eventually they will quit and gut anyway.

Most owners who quit, don't come back. Those who do come back know what their mistakes are, and have fixed it, or will be supported by a network.


These are the exact problems that we're talking about. The exact type of people that make penalties needed.

The notion that "most owners that quit don't come back" believe me, is a very untrue one.
Last edited Jan 11, 2009 10:25:14
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.