User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Canadian AA Leagues > Canada AA #2 > best RB in the league?
Page:
 
FUPA
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jiddy78
Originally posted by FUPA

I'm not sure who the "Best" RB is in the league but look at the stats from the Toronto vs. Yaks game. http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=302862. And you make the decision


This is a good player. I hope he doesn't take offense that I refer to him as Pierogi Ciesielszyk.


That is fine by me sir, pierogi's are a common polish dish, which i enjoy. But on the same topic may i call your RB "The Most Hyped MMA Fighter Ever" to fall flat on his face. (simply bc of your avatar of course)
 
dan rules
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by J Bo
Originally posted by Valdemar Widesen

Originally posted by dan rules


Simple question, would you guys rather your RB average 9.6 YPC, or 7.9?



Ofcourse 9.6... but the question is whether the 9.6 is based on 5 carries per game making it easier to get a higher average since the D is most likely sitting on the pass..
or whether you are averaging 7.9 on 30 carries per game, where the defense knows he's coming, but still can't stop him.

I would rather have the back with the 7.9 average in that described situation.. anyday!


Well stated Valdemar!

Honestly, its like the Gordonites have chosen the one stat category he happens to be leading in and totally disregard all others. Under the same logic we can say Englebert Smith is the best LB in the league cause he has the most forced fumbles.

Simple question, would you guys rather your LB have 3 forced fumbles or 1?


That is the worst analogy I have ever heard. So you are saying that YPC is to RB as FF is to LB? YPC is a VERY important stat for RB's, I would say it has to be the most important, while FF is obviously pretty far behind tackles and missed tackles for LBs.


Do you think Ty Marshall is a better back than Bombay BC Ty gets 20 more carries? Bombay can't be penalized because we are a more well rounded team.

 
Jiddy78
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dan rules
Originally posted by J Bo

Originally posted by Valdemar Widesen


Originally posted by dan rules



Simple question, would you guys rather your RB average 9.6 YPC, or 7.9?



Ofcourse 9.6... but the question is whether the 9.6 is based on 5 carries per game making it easier to get a higher average since the D is most likely sitting on the pass..
or whether you are averaging 7.9 on 30 carries per game, where the defense knows he's coming, but still can't stop him.

I would rather have the back with the 7.9 average in that described situation.. anyday!


Well stated Valdemar!

Honestly, its like the Gordonites have chosen the one stat category he happens to be leading in and totally disregard all others. Under the same logic we can say Englebert Smith is the best LB in the league cause he has the most forced fumbles.

Simple question, would you guys rather your LB have 3 forced fumbles or 1?


That is the worst analogy I have ever heard. So you are saying that YPC is to RB as FF is to LB? YPC is a VERY important stat for RB's, I would say it has to be the most important, while FF is obviously pretty far behind tackles and missed tackles for LBs.


Do you think Ty Marshall is a better back than Bombay BC Ty gets 20 more carries? Bombay can't be penalized because we are a more well rounded team.



Fine...Ya got us...We concede...J Bo is really a peewee leaguer without this guy in front of him: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=642490

 
J Bo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dan rules


That is the worst analogy I have ever heard. So you are saying that YPC is to RB as FF is to LB? YPC is a VERY important stat for RB's, I would say it has to be the most important, while FF is obviously pretty far behind tackles and missed tackles for LBs.


Do you think Ty Marshall is a better back than Bombay BC Ty gets 20 more carries? Bombay can't be penalized because we are a more well rounded team.



It's meant to be a terrible analogy. Its only slightly worse than proclaiming Bombay #1.

I just find it humorous that you have found one stat that Gordon happens to do well in and that is your entire argument. What about TD's, broken tackles, tackles for loss, total yards, fumbles, etc?

At only 12.6 carries a game your team would hardly miss you if you went elsewhere. The #1 back in the league is not even an impact player on his team?
Last edited Jan 10, 2009 23:12:30
 
nferg18
offline
Link
 
so 12 out of the teams 22 touchdowns is hardly an impact on the offense? I guess over 50% of the points scored is nothing...

how about you look at gains over 20 yards.... or pretty much anything that isnt a bulk stat.

really dude, any half way decent RB would put up monster stats which 50 carries a game
 
Roctronic
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by domenick2x
Originally posted by Roctronic

Originally posted by domenick2x


Originally posted by Roctronic



Originally posted by domenick2x




Originally posted by Roctronic





Originally posted by Jiddy78






Oh come on guys...It's not like they were trying in that game...


Eh, you can say what you want but the outcome of that game makes any single player stat on the yaks look crap.

Lose 42-41 or 100-0, its still a loss.


Whoooo-eeee. Who pissed in your cornflakes this morning?

We're talking about individual achievement here. That is not exactly impacted by W/L record, unless and until a team is blatantly trying to pump stats at the expense of winning games.


I don't eat cheerios and isn't the entire point of playing a sport to win? (Granted this is virtual, same idea should apply)

If not, your selfish imho.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1820096


Game, set, match.

Hurle must be selfish.... imagine winning the passing title 2 years in a row, yet not doing what is necessary for his team to advance. Selfish... or incompetent.



How?

We are talking about individual efforts when a team loses. He is saying that he is going to do as good as he did last year to lead this team to its second straight championship, nothing to do with I am the best and I don't care if my team wins or not.

If you can call losing a game a good one because of your stats, thats selfish.

I really can't be much clearer.



That you are a jackass? Agreed.

Originally posted by

nothing to do with I am the best and I don't care if my team wins or not.


Show me where ANYONE on the Yaks said anything remotely close to that regarding J Bo.



Show me ANYONE on the Marauders that have said that.
 
domenick2x
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Roctronic
Originally posted by domenick2x

Originally posted by Roctronic


Originally posted by domenick2x



Originally posted by Roctronic




Originally posted by domenick2x





Originally posted by Roctronic






Originally posted by Jiddy78







Oh come on guys...It's not like they were trying in that game...


Eh, you can say what you want but the outcome of that game makes any single player stat on the yaks look crap.

Lose 42-41 or 100-0, its still a loss.


Whoooo-eeee. Who pissed in your cornflakes this morning?

We're talking about individual achievement here. That is not exactly impacted by W/L record, unless and until a team is blatantly trying to pump stats at the expense of winning games.


I don't eat cheerios and isn't the entire point of playing a sport to win? (Granted this is virtual, same idea should apply)

If not, your selfish imho.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1820096


Game, set, match.

Hurle must be selfish.... imagine winning the passing title 2 years in a row, yet not doing what is necessary for his team to advance. Selfish... or incompetent.



How?

We are talking about individual efforts when a team loses. He is saying that he is going to do as good as he did last year to lead this team to its second straight championship, nothing to do with I am the best and I don't care if my team wins or not.

If you can call losing a game a good one because of your stats, thats selfish.

I really can't be much clearer.



That you are a jackass? Agreed.

Originally posted by


nothing to do with I am the best and I don't care if my team wins or not.


Show me where ANYONE on the Yaks said anything remotely close to that regarding J Bo.



Show me ANYONE on the Marauders that have said that.


Originally posted by
If you can call losing a game a good one because of your stats, thats selfish.



Let's go to the play by play, shall we?

Originally posted by
Marauders can stop him.


Originally posted by
lol no you cant.... http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=287848 (you can outscore him though )


Originally posted by
Eh, you can say what you want but the outcome of that game makes any single player stat on the yaks look crap.

Lose 42-41 or 100-0, its still a loss.




To translate: "We beat you, nyaah nyaah nyaah... thpbbpt! That means your RB isn't as good as you think he is!"

You are almost as classy as Saintsfan. Maybe you two should form a club.

 
Roctronic
offline
Link
 
So your defense to losing is to relate me to saintsfan?

Wow, you must really hate him.
 
domenick2x
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Roctronic
So your defense to losing is to relate me to saintsfan?

Wow, you must really hate him.


Meh, pity is more like it.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
I miss Spear Sai.
 
Saintsfan83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by domenick2x
Originally posted by Roctronic

So your defense to losing is to relate me to saintsfan?

Wow, you must really hate him.


Meh, pity is more like it.


I pity most people here that own teams and about 20+ players

before you go pitying me just to let you know I'm not short of anything that I would need your pity for

you might wanna think about what you say before you say it
Last edited Jan 13, 2009 08:34:20
 
domenick2x
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saintsfan83
Originally posted by domenick2x

Originally posted by Roctronic


So your defense to losing is to relate me to saintsfan?

Wow, you must really hate him.


Meh, pity is more like it.


O pity most people here that own teams and about 20+ players

before you go pitying me just to let you know I'm not short of anything that I would need your pity for

you might wanna think about what you say before you say it


O Bo and his brother J simply dominate them.



I always know what I'm saying. My comments stand.
 
FUPA
offline
Link
 
Why do people turn every forum that asks legitimate questions gay, just talk about this game and the question asked, that simple.
 
Jiddy78
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FUPA
Why do people turn every forum that asks legitimate questions gay, just talk about this game and the question asked, that simple.


Look it now...You put me down in the dump...lings...with this post.

Get it?

Pierogi!?!?

Dumplings?!?

HA! I KILL ME!

*slaps knee*
 
Mrstickball
offline
Link
 
Looks like my RB was able to hang with J Bo pretty decently.

J Bo
Lumberjack City HB
35 Rush, 226yds; 0 Rec, 0yds; 2 TD

Charles "Deathwish" Bronson
Newfoundland HB
30 Rush, 190yds; 1 Rec, 14yds; 2 TD

Not bad :-)
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.