User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Um, isn't it against the rules to gut a team?
Page:
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PYLrulz
Originally posted by JVinci

OP, why do you lurk teams so much? like every other thread you make is about whistle blowing some activity that MIGHT be against the rules.

is this just a hobby of yours?


If I was in his position, I would do the same thing.

I like it when there are people out there looking at the stuff that might be fishy, screwy, and downright outrageous. At least it helps try and keep some things on the up and up.


Originally posted by jkocurek
The more watchdogs we have, the better, imo.


Exactly. There's 3 Admins and I think around 8-10 Mods. It's not like we can be everywhere at once, so one of the best things that can happen is a community policing itself like this.

That said, I have no idea if this is a case where something fishy actually happened. From the looks of some of the posts, it may be nothing, but it's something at least worth looking into by the Admins. I'll point them towards this thread, one of them will look into it, and if there's anything fishy, action will be taken from there.

Just don't keep PM'ing us asking for updates, that's just annoying and if you see no action was taken, there's probably no real update.
 
Icespyder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Awesomus_Prime
couldn't find a GM or a Coordinator? Hmm, I've seen a few people make posts looking for one or the other, and they get a ton of "I will do it" posts.


Ask any former member of the Highlanders, I brought in 5 guys. Not one of them did what a coordinator is suppose to do.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LiveWire
Originally posted by wombat killer

At least you aren't biased.


Good thing you aren't either. I don't see why we have an angry mob with torches a pitchforks. This is no frankenstein! The guy didn't wanna be an d-bag to the people on his payroll, he gave them the options. Heck, it benefits the rest of the league with an easy win. Wombat as far as I can tell this doesn't even directly effect you. WHY ARE YOU HERE? Go outside! Hear the birds chirp, get a sun tan! Find a girl, make love to that girl! Live your life, and let everyone else live his. (I believe thats the correct grammar for that last phrase, if not, let me know and Ill go read more books and poems.)


Let's break this down.

"Good thing you aren't either" - that would imply you actually think I am biased.
"as far as I can tell this doesn't even directly effect you" - kind of implies I wouldn't be biased.

"I don't see why we have an angry mob" - so everyone involved in this sees no problem but people not involved seem to have a problem. I wonder which group would tend to be unbiased?

"Heck, it benefits the rest of the league with an easy win" - except the teams that already played them. Would you be happy if all the teams in your league did this and you can claim to be champions of the crapfest league?

"The rest of your babble" - the classic internet comeback of why do you spend so much time on the internet, but please ignore how much time I spend on the internet.


 
LiveWire
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Awesomus_Prime
couldn't find a GM or a Coordinator? Hmm, I've seen a few people make posts looking for one or the other, and they get a ton of "I will do it" posts.


He wanted to keep it in house, to people who knew the team, had been there from the start of the season. It's his choice who he wants in it, and if no one on the team cared enough to step up why should he care enough to keep it. I don't understand you people, a few weeks ago you wanted him dead. Now, he left and you want him... back? Which is it? Staying or going? You can't have your cake and eat it too!
 
Link
 
Originally posted by LiveWire
But he didnt reck the game, he just got up from the table and left.


Essentially that's exactly what he did--the rest of the players are no longer in the same balance they were in before he walked away.
 
Icespyder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sprocket
Its like playing Monopoly, and one player just kicks over the board. "Im not playing anymore".


If thats the way you feel, maybe you should suggest that they remove the option to sell a team back, I'm sure people would love it judging by the reaction in this thread.
Last edited May 7, 2008 14:07:16
 
Link
 
Originally posted by LiveWire
Originally posted by Awesomus_Prime

couldn't find a GM or a Coordinator? Hmm, I've seen a few people make posts looking for one or the other, and they get a ton of "I will do it" posts.


He wanted to keep it in house, to people who knew the team, had been there from the start of the season. It's his choice who he wants in it, and if no one on the team cared enough to step up why should he care enough to keep it. I don't understand you people, a few weeks ago you wanted him dead. Now, he left and you want him... back? Which is it? Staying or going? You can't have your cake and eat it too!




Speaking for myself, I'd like players to honor contracts, owners to honor commitments, and all involved to settle their disputes OUTSIDE of any current season. That's the only way for it to be fair for all involved.
Last edited May 7, 2008 14:08:05
 
LiveWire
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by LiveWire

Originally posted by wombat killer


At least you aren't biased.


Good thing you aren't either. I don't see why we have an angry mob with torches a pitchforks. This is no frankenstein! The guy didn't wanna be an d-bag to the people on his payroll, he gave them the options. Heck, it benefits the rest of the league with an easy win. Wombat as far as I can tell this doesn't even directly effect you. WHY ARE YOU HERE? Go outside! Hear the birds chirp, get a sun tan! Find a girl, make love to that girl! Live your life, and let everyone else live his. (I believe thats the correct grammar for that last phrase, if not, let me know and Ill go read more books and poems.)


Let's break this down.

"Good thing you aren't either" - that would imply you actually think I am biased.
"as far as I can tell this doesn't even directly effect you" - kind of implies I wouldn't be biased.

"I don't see why we have an angry mob" - so everyone involved in this sees no problem but people not involved seem to have a problem. I wonder which group would tend to be unbiased?

"Heck, it benefits the rest of the league with an easy win" - except the teams that already played them. Would you be happy if all the teams in your league did this and you can claim to be champions of the crapfest league?

"The rest of your babble" - the classic internet comeback of why do you spend so much time on the internet, but please ignore how much time I spend on the internet.




HAh, Ill ignore the rest of your crap and retorte on the insult, ask Icespyder and Tunda how much time I spend on the internet. Not much. They always yell at me for not being on. Just cuz I happen to have this afternoon off to post here means nothing. Womby, mind if I call you Womby? I have nothing against you, you're probably a good fellow. Go in peace, my son, go in peace.
 
FBGProfessor
offline
Link
 
This is creative gutting. If he didn't have time he shouldn't have bought the team or he should have sold it. Instead he gutted it to help his and your other teams. Originally posted by TundaKlap
Originally posted by flames54

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=718

Might be time to see if the old players all went to one place you know, like http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=1405

Second time this particular team has been involved in a gutting / mass player movement. (they got their players last season via a team getting gutted and sent to them).


Neither team was gutted last season, they both went deep into the playoffs. So do some research on that.

As someone already mentioned, the owner did have time to run the team anymore and didn't want it. The owner and I are good friends and both had a good amount of characters on the team, so we released them and spread them around. Other guys wanted their release, which isn't unreasonable.

Edit: If you're going to be a watch-dog, do some investigation while you're at it.


 
LiveWire
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by LiveWire

Originally posted by Awesomus_Prime


couldn't find a GM or a Coordinator? Hmm, I've seen a few people make posts looking for one or the other, and they get a ton of "I will do it" posts.


He wanted to keep it in house, to people who knew the team, had been there from the start of the season. It's his choice who he wants in it, and if no one on the team cared enough to step up why should he care enough to keep it. I don't understand you people, a few weeks ago you wanted him dead. Now, he left and you want him... back? Which is it? Staying or going? You can't have your cake and eat it too!




Speaking for myself, I'd like players to honor contracts, owner to honor commitments, and all involved to settle their disputes OUTSIDE of any current season. That's the only way for it to be fair for all involved.


If people WANT to be released, and on good terms, isn't that honoring the person? Situtations change, the players wanted release, let them go. Sometimes you have to let go of that which you love the most.
 
FBGProfessor
offline
Link
 
This is another example of why we need league Commish's elected by the owners in the league. Then when something like this starts to happen they could shut down the team and find a new owner.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by LiveWire
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Originally posted by LiveWire


Originally posted by Awesomus_Prime



couldn't find a GM or a Coordinator? Hmm, I've seen a few people make posts looking for one or the other, and they get a ton of "I will do it" posts.


He wanted to keep it in house, to people who knew the team, had been there from the start of the season. It's his choice who he wants in it, and if no one on the team cared enough to step up why should he care enough to keep it. I don't understand you people, a few weeks ago you wanted him dead. Now, he left and you want him... back? Which is it? Staying or going? You can't have your cake and eat it too!




Speaking for myself, I'd like players to honor contracts, owner to honor commitments, and all involved to settle their disputes OUTSIDE of any current season. That's the only way for it to be fair for all involved.


If people WANT to be released, and on good terms, isn't that honoring the person? Situtations change, the players wanted release, let them go. Sometimes you have to let go of that which you love the most.



Uh, no. The LEAGUE (and the leagues of those who got a fresh batch of players) were all adversely affected by the owner's abdication of his commitment. This isn't that hard--if you're not prepared to own a team for an entire season, DON'T START A NEW SEASON.

 
LiveWire
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FBGProfessor
This is creative gutting. If he didn't have time he shouldn't have bought the team or he should have sold it. Instead he gutted it to help his and your other teams. Originally posted by TundaKlap

Originally posted by flames54


http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=718

Might be time to see if the old players all went to one place you know, like http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=1405

Second time this particular team has been involved in a gutting / mass player movement. (they got their players last season via a team getting gutted and sent to them).


Neither team was gutted last season, they both went deep into the playoffs. So do some research on that.

As someone already mentioned, the owner did have time to run the team anymore and didn't want it. The owner and I are good friends and both had a good amount of characters on the team, so we released them and spread them around. Other guys wanted their release, which isn't unreasonable.

Edit: If you're going to be a watch-dog, do some investigation while you're at it.




People asked to be moved to the other team, he didn't force them. People like myself, I chose to go a different path. Im proud to say that my FS is now with the Thundertown Brawlers. My LB is currently in talks with several other teams. If it weren't for the Chitown Highlanders, I wouldn't be as good as I am. They do more good than bad but you people refuse to see that. You demand to remain ignorant but ignorance is no excuse when the truth shines brighter than a thousand stars into your dark corners. See the light brothers, set yourselves free from the bondage of ignorance!
 
Icespyder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by LiveWire

Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


Originally posted by LiveWire



Originally posted by Awesomus_Prime




couldn't find a GM or a Coordinator? Hmm, I've seen a few people make posts looking for one or the other, and they get a ton of "I will do it" posts.


He wanted to keep it in house, to people who knew the team, had been there from the start of the season. It's his choice who he wants in it, and if no one on the team cared enough to step up why should he care enough to keep it. I don't understand you people, a few weeks ago you wanted him dead. Now, he left and you want him... back? Which is it? Staying or going? You can't have your cake and eat it too!




Speaking for myself, I'd like players to honor contracts, owner to honor commitments, and all involved to settle their disputes OUTSIDE of any current season. That's the only way for it to be fair for all involved.


If people WANT to be released, and on good terms, isn't that honoring the person? Situtations change, the players wanted release, let them go. Sometimes you have to let go of that which you love the most.



Uh, no. The LEAGUE (and the leagues of those who got a fresh batch of players) were all adversely affected by the owner's abdication of his commitment. This isn't that hard--if you're not prepared to own a team for an entire season, DON'T START A NEW SEASON.



Life changes, I'm sure you are aware of that. The admins feel the same way, since they allow teams to be sold back.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sprocket
Its like playing Monopoly, and one player just kicks over the board. "Im not playing anymore".

It's worse than that. It's like playing Monopoly, having one player quit and give 95% of his assets to another of the players, and then have someone else take his spot and his "remaining assets".

One guy now owns half the properties and has a huge chunk of the money, and the guy that just jumped in has $14 and Baltic Avenue to his name. Everybody else is left with the "balance" of knowing that one player isn't going to be a threat the rest of the way because they have nothing to work with, and one player is going to annihilate them because of the advantage that was literally GIVEN to them.

Whether it's one owner, two owners, twenty owners, the amount doesn't matter: the team was intentionally gutted. Whether the players that left went to one team or to twenty different teams, whether they had a good reason or not, the team was left barren and that can't be disputed.

If he didn't have time for it, he should've sold the team back AS IS, not after he's picked the bones clean and left the new owner absolutely nothing to work with.

How would you feel if you spent FP to make a player, only to discover that instead of starting fresh like everyone else got to, you were being handed someone else's level 1 with all 15 starting points specced in Kicking when the player isn't a kicker?
Last edited May 7, 2008 14:16:09
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.