User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AAA Leagues > USA AAA #2 > Good Luck to Spicewood and any other Longhorn Fans
Page:
 
enoch101
offline
Link
 
from yahoo.com 1/9/09

* Bowl Subdivision Record
* Atlantic Coast 4-6
* Big 12 4-3
* Big East 4-2
* Big Ten 1-6
* Conference USA 4-2
* Independents (FBS) 1-1
* Mid-American 0-5
* Mountain West 3-2
* Pacific-10 5-0
* Southeastern 6-2
* Sun Belt 1-1
* Western Athletic 1-4

Last edited Jan 9, 2009 03:37:10
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Oklahoma in last 5 BCS games: 0 wins.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Oklahoma Bills is the best one I've heard so far.
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by tomcollins

If you honestly don't think margin of victory doesn't help decide which team would be favored over another, you are beyond hope.


So you agree that Utah is better than USC. You know, since Utah beat Oregon State and USC lost to them


LOL 1 datapointaments. I guess LSU is better than Florida since they beat Ole Miss!

Originally posted by tomcollins

If you can beat a team by 50, that data point says you are far far far better than your opponent. Replaying the game would lead to a victory of your opponent of maybe .001% of the time at best.


What's it like in make-believe stat land? I've always wanted to vacation there...

You were the one making up things that would never happen. In the case where a team wins one game by 50 and loses the next 10 by 1, I would still argue that the team that one a single game by 50 would be favored in game #12. Obviously you have no real argument or anything since you just talk out of your ass.

Originally posted by thunderdoozer

Wins are what is important, not margin of victory. MOV is next to irrelevant. These are kids out there on the field, 18 to 22 years old. Their lack of maturity can let otherwise evenly matched games get out of hand. Momentum is big in college sports for this reason. They can give up. A few fluke plays can put them way behind. Bad reffing. A million things.

You can't compare scores to determine who is better. It should be determined on the field. This is why the BCS fails miserably and will always fail miserably.


MOV is very relevant in determining who the "better" team is. Meaning who would be favored in a game tomorrow. Perhaps not in terms of who had the most successful season. There certainly is an argument there for Utah, although their big wins are not really that great IMO. They had less of a gauntlet to play. Switch the schedules with USC, Florida, etc..., and Utah would do much worse.

The sad thing is, your arguments pretty much prove my point. Say a bad call gives a team a win in a 1 point game. Would you honestly say that the team that lost is really proven to be that much worse than the team that beat them? I wouldn't. Teams that play close games are almost always close in skill level. Teams that get their asses handed to them usually aren't that good (at least compared to the team that put on the beating).

The BCS fails because there aren't enough data points to determine much. There are virtually no meaningful games between conferences. It is pretty easy (although not even always) to determine who the top teams are in each conference. Or at least who has had the best season in the conference (Texas vs. Oklahoma vs. Texas Tech was a rare case where its not as clear, but even IMO it was clear it was Oklahoma).

But look at GLB for example. Take a team that goes 16-0, wins every game by 50 points, then loses to an 8-8 team in the playoffs by 1 point. Are you going to honestly tell me that the 8-8 team has had a better season because they won a single playoff game? GMAFB.

But squares like you are the reason I can actually make money betting on games. You think wins and losses determine how strong a team is. Sharps know better than that.
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by baumusc


Both Utah and USC could run with Florida or Oklahoma. USC and Utah both dominated their bowl games against the #4 and #6 teams. In a head to head matchup though I think USC would pull it out because of their defense. SC was one tipped TD pass from being undefeated this season.


Lines that would likely to be seen in Vegas are:

USC -2.5 vs. Florida
USC -13 vs. Utah
USC -8 vs. Oklahoma
Florida -10 vs. Utah
Oklahoma -5 vs. Utah
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by enoch101
from yahoo.com 1/9/09

* Bowl Subdivision Record
* Atlantic Coast 4-6
* Big 12 4-3
* Big East 4-2
* Big Ten 1-6
* Conference USA 4-2
* Independents (FBS) 1-1
* Mid-American 0-5
* Mountain West 3-2
* Pacific-10 5-0
* Southeastern 6-2
* Sun Belt 1-1
* Western Athletic 1-4



The Big 10 faces an interesting dilemma. If you get two teams in the BCS, you get some real unfavorable matchups in bowl games. But you get a lot more money. Say Ohio State played in the Capital One bowl and everyone else shifted down 1 spot from the Big 10. You would likely have the Big 10 as 5-2 in bowl games.

USC over Penn State
Ohio State over Georgia (Cap One)
Michigan State over South Carolina (Outback)
Iowa over Missouri (Alamo)
FSU over Northwestern (Champs)
Wisconsin over Kansas (Insight)
Minnesota over Central Michigan (Motor City)

Big 10 isn't up to the level of the Pac 10, SEC, or Big 12, but its not a *huge* gap by any means.
 
paco12
offline
Link
 
2 things:

1) I'd vote Utah #1. Undefeated is hard to do, heck Florida has never done it. They beat 2 teams in the final top 7 of the AP poll. They beat 2 teams ranked in the final top 25. Their conference hammered the Pac Ten head to head this year. They beat Alabama by more than Florida did and they beat the team that beat USC. If they don't get a #1 vote for being the only undefeated team and playing a pretty reasonable schedule, you admit that only a few conferences are even playing for the national title at the start of the year and everybody else should drop down to another division.

2) aside from the Big Ten 2 teams in BCS thing which sometimes hurts the overall record, when looking at a conference's bowl record you have to look at matchups. The Big Ten has some tie-ins where they are the lower seed from their conference against a higher seed from another conference. Conversely, the Pac Ten has some nice tie ins where they are the higher seed against a lower seed from another conference (Holiday Bowl is Pac Ten #2 vs Big 12 #3 and Sun Bowl is Pac Ten #3 vs Big 12 #5).
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Utah - the only relevant team undefeated.

I'd have them ranked #2 at worst. I can get behind the Florida "we beat the last 2 #1 teams in a row" argument. However, the fact that Utah won't get their fair shot, and the fact they completely drilled Alabama a few days ago, exemplifies the utter failure of the BCS.

Problem is, it's Utah getting shafted, so no one will care outside of Utah.

The coaches final poll is a joke. The old boys club in action. Texas, barely beating overrated state university, finishes 3rd? Ahead of Utah? lol. ok.
Last edited Jan 9, 2009 10:07:53
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Utah - the only relevant team undefeated.

I'd have them ranked #2 at worst. I can get behind the Florida "we beat the last 2 #1 teams in a row" argument. However, the fact that Utah won't get their fair shot, and the fact they completely drilled Alabama a few days ago, exemplifies the utter failure of the BCS.

Problem is, it's Utah getting shafted, so no one will care outside of Utah.

The coaches final poll is a joke. The old boys club in action. Texas, barely beating overrated state university, finishes 3rd? Ahead of Utah? lol. ok.


Coaches poll is LOL funny. They could have picked names out of hat and had it more relevant. Georgia wins a close game against a shtity MSU team, and catapaults from #17 to #10? LOL. True hilarity IMO. Mizzou jumps to #16 after escaping an OT win against Northwestern?

 
canes30
offline
Link
 
i AGREE with tomcollins.

He knows his shit and backs it up. Everyone else is throwing out opinions and made up situations(what ifs)
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tomcollins
Originally posted by islander1

Utah - the only relevant team undefeated.

I'd have them ranked #2 at worst. I can get behind the Florida "we beat the last 2 #1 teams in a row" argument. However, the fact that Utah won't get their fair shot, and the fact they completely drilled Alabama a few days ago, exemplifies the utter failure of the BCS.

Problem is, it's Utah getting shafted, so no one will care outside of Utah.

The coaches final poll is a joke. The old boys club in action. Texas, barely beating overrated state university, finishes 3rd? Ahead of Utah? lol. ok.


Coaches poll is LOL funny. They could have picked names out of hat and had it more relevant. Georgia wins a close game against a shtity MSU team, and catapaults from #17 to #10? LOL. True hilarity IMO. Mizzou jumps to #16 after escaping an OT win against Northwestern?



funny the level of respect a win over a crappy big ten team will get you eh?
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
pretty much. I'm not saying OSU's defense is crappy though. That being said, Texas won by 3. Utah would have drilled them imo
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
pretty much. I'm not saying OSU's defense is crappy though. That being said, Texas won by 3. Utah would have drilled them imo


Drilled who? I would gladly take Ohio State -5 over Utah, and Texas -10 over them. Utah has only played 4 teams in the top 50 all season (and struggled against some of the other teams, ranked 50 or higher) as well.

For comparison, USC was 8-1 against the top 50, and Florida was 7-1.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tomcollins
Originally posted by islander1

pretty much. I'm not saying OSU's defense is crappy though. That being said, Texas won by 3. Utah would have drilled them imo


Drilled who? I would gladly take Ohio State -5 over Utah, and Texas -10 over them. Utah has only played 4 teams in the top 50 all season (and struggled against some of the other teams, ranked 50 or higher) as well.

For comparison, USC was 8-1 against the top 50, and Florida was 7-1.


Utah was undefeated against the top 50.

Utah deserved a chance at the championship. It couldn't possibly be more embarrassing than it was watching Ohio State in the last 2 championships.
Last edited Jan 9, 2009 16:52:43
 
Zable
offline
Link
 
yeah but Florida beat the #1 ranked team twice this year.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.