User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > The fix for powerbacks.... without taking away from their abilities
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Jan 03, 2009
- Increase to amount of balance lost when breaking a tackle, to help avoid super long strings of broken tackles in the middle of a 5 guy pile - should help improve gang tackling


go changelog!!!
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
glad to see that upgrade..... now give a bonus to making a tackle from behind and all is well.
Last edited Jan 4, 2009 13:55:32
 
ProfessionalKop
Gangstalicious
offline
Link
 
lots of good upgrades to the Defense. thanks bort
 
Speedcat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dkwon100
Man noobs like me will have to pray that they pick the right build and hit the higher levels at the right time so they have good seasons instead of bad ones and ending up as a free agent for life.


yeah well try keeping up with all the changes when your guy is above level 30... strength beasts borted, speed borted, then on to agility, borted, then to vision, then back on to strength.... you basicially get 20-25 SP a season including boosts to figure out how to adjust your build each season to what has been changed... and god help you if you boost right away and apply your points cause then your totally screwed all season
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley
glad to see that upgrade..... now give a bonus to making a tackle from behind and all is well.


Depending on how bad that penalty is, he may also need to crank up the chance to break a single tackle,with exponentially worse chances to break consecutive tackles.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley
The main issue is, when getting into the flats, you're usually facing one lb, and the rest of the players are cornerbacks and safeties. Yeah, strength and tackling would be nice for your secondary to have... Unfortunately, that would leave you completely unable to cover any WR or TE in the game.


Not true. Both of my higher level CBs have at least 35 strength and tackling....they've had little problem in coverage.
 
shakirus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
Originally posted by Pitch Black

Originally posted by imnotthatstupid


Originally posted by jktooley



http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=289337&pbp_id=1873575

Plays like this are just ridiculous, and completely unrealistic...

In my opinion, power backs should still be able to run people over. That's not the issue. That's their build, let them have success with it too. The thing is, they should enjoy the majority of their success during the actual playmaking phase of the run, not in the open field.

I've never seen a player in real life break 3 tackles from behind on one run without ever missing a step.

There should be a MAJOR boost to tackling when coming from behind. Outside of that, welcome to the season of isolating a power back in the flats and watching him run at full speed into the endzone.

That being said, to do it right though, you should still be able to drag out a few extra yards when being tackled from behind.


+1 all the way


what about LB's putting SP's into Strength and tackling... the problem is solved


No it's not - because to do that then you need to sacrifice the very skills necessary to bring down the Power Backs alter ego - the Speed Back.

Defenders need at least 1 (usually more) attributes to do their jobs than the guys they are forced to tackle need to do theirs - especially LB's.

The answer isn't as simple as put more points into X and Y - because to do that those points almost always have to come from A, B and C to do that. A LB not only has to be able to tackle a Power Back, he need to be able to catch a HB in the flat, drop back in coverage, blitz and a couple other things that require other skills at high levels than just Strength/Tackling.

In the end - a LB can NEVER win the "Match the guy you are tackling statistically" battle - he needs the entire kitchen sink just to be able to do his job - which means doing more than just stopping Power Backs.





Keep in mind too, that in RL, no LB can do all those things anyway. Most are specialized in one of a few things and may be decent at the rest, for instance one LB may be a great tackler but just so-so when they have to drop into coverage. That is what helps to add variety to this game. What you are asking it seems is for a player to be just an all around stud no matter what he is doing and as I said before, that is just not the case. That is why you build around what you have as a owner. If you have a good strong tackler for a LB, most times you place him at MLB, where as your more agile LB's you will probably place at OLB in order to be able to stop those HB's out in the flats.
 
Klydon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shakirus
Originally posted by greengoose

Originally posted by Pitch Black


Originally posted by imnotthatstupid



Originally posted by jktooley




http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=289337&pbp_id=1873575

Plays like this are just ridiculous, and completely unrealistic...

In my opinion, power backs should still be able to run people over. That's not the issue. That's their build, let them have success with it too. The thing is, they should enjoy the majority of their success during the actual playmaking phase of the run, not in the open field.

I've never seen a player in real life break 3 tackles from behind on one run without ever missing a step.

There should be a MAJOR boost to tackling when coming from behind. Outside of that, welcome to the season of isolating a power back in the flats and watching him run at full speed into the endzone.

That being said, to do it right though, you should still be able to drag out a few extra yards when being tackled from behind.


+1 all the way


what about LB's putting SP's into Strength and tackling... the problem is solved


No it's not - because to do that then you need to sacrifice the very skills necessary to bring down the Power Backs alter ego - the Speed Back.

Defenders need at least 1 (usually more) attributes to do their jobs than the guys they are forced to tackle need to do theirs - especially LB's.

The answer isn't as simple as put more points into X and Y - because to do that those points almost always have to come from A, B and C to do that. A LB not only has to be able to tackle a Power Back, he need to be able to catch a HB in the flat, drop back in coverage, blitz and a couple other things that require other skills at high levels than just Strength/Tackling.

In the end - a LB can NEVER win the "Match the guy you are tackling statistically" battle - he needs the entire kitchen sink just to be able to do his job - which means doing more than just stopping Power Backs.





Keep in mind too, that in RL, no LB can do all those things anyway. Most are specialized in one of a few things and may be decent at the rest, for instance one LB may be a great tackler but just so-so when they have to drop into coverage. That is what helps to add variety to this game. What you are asking it seems is for a player to be just an all around stud no matter what he is doing and as I said before, that is just not the case. That is why you build around what you have as a owner. If you have a good strong tackler for a LB, most times you place him at MLB, where as your more agile LB's you will probably place at OLB in order to be able to stop those HB's out in the flats.


Part of the issue is you can't sub specific players on defense based on what the offense trots out in terms of specific players. The custom slots give the offense far more control on who specifically will be on the field for a given play while the defense has no such tool that "if x player is on the field, then I have y player on the field". The offense is allowed to be far more specialized at several positions while defensive players are stuck trying to be able to deal with anything that comes their way.
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yukon Don
Originally posted by jktooley

The main issue is, when getting into the flats, you're usually facing one lb, and the rest of the players are cornerbacks and safeties. Yeah, strength and tackling would be nice for your secondary to have... Unfortunately, that would leave you completely unable to cover any WR or TE in the game.


Not true. Both of my higher level CBs have at least 35 strength and tackling....they've had little problem in coverage.


great.... now go try to tackle a real power back with him.... not gonna work. ever.
 
bamaplaya1
offline
Link
 
solution: stop ignoring strength with defenders
 
Link
 
wow thats BS... power backs are no fun
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley
Originally posted by Yukon Don

Originally posted by jktooley


The main issue is, when getting into the flats, you're usually facing one lb, and the rest of the players are cornerbacks and safeties. Yeah, strength and tackling would be nice for your secondary to have... Unfortunately, that would leave you completely unable to cover any WR or TE in the game.


Not true. Both of my higher level CBs have at least 35 strength and tackling....they've had little problem in coverage.


great.... now go try to tackle a real power back with him.... not gonna work. ever.


He shouldn't be able to tackle real power backs: He's a frigging CB! He's fine at tackling WR's, which is all he should have to be.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shakirus
Originally posted by greengoose

Originally posted by Pitch Black


Originally posted by imnotthatstupid



Originally posted by jktooley




http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=289337&pbp_id=1873575

Plays like this are just ridiculous, and completely unrealistic...

In my opinion, power backs should still be able to run people over. That's not the issue. That's their build, let them have success with it too. The thing is, they should enjoy the majority of their success during the actual playmaking phase of the run, not in the open field.

I've never seen a player in real life break 3 tackles from behind on one run without ever missing a step.

There should be a MAJOR boost to tackling when coming from behind. Outside of that, welcome to the season of isolating a power back in the flats and watching him run at full speed into the endzone.

That being said, to do it right though, you should still be able to drag out a few extra yards when being tackled from behind.


+1 all the way


what about LB's putting SP's into Strength and tackling... the problem is solved


No it's not - because to do that then you need to sacrifice the very skills necessary to bring down the Power Backs alter ego - the Speed Back.

Defenders need at least 1 (usually more) attributes to do their jobs than the guys they are forced to tackle need to do theirs - especially LB's.

The answer isn't as simple as put more points into X and Y - because to do that those points almost always have to come from A, B and C to do that. A LB not only has to be able to tackle a Power Back, he need to be able to catch a HB in the flat, drop back in coverage, blitz and a couple other things that require other skills at high levels than just Strength/Tackling.

In the end - a LB can NEVER win the "Match the guy you are tackling statistically" battle - he needs the entire kitchen sink just to be able to do his job - which means doing more than just stopping Power Backs.





Keep in mind too, that in RL, no LB can do all those things anyway. Most are specialized in one of a few things and may be decent at the rest, for instance one LB may be a great tackler but just so-so when they have to drop into coverage. That is what helps to add variety to this game. What you are asking it seems is for a player to be just an all around stud no matter what he is doing and as I said before, that is just not the case. That is why you build around what you have as a owner. If you have a good strong tackler for a LB, most times you place him at MLB, where as your more agile LB's you will probably place at OLB in order to be able to stop those HB's out in the flats.


Exactly. What people seem to want are LB's who are great at everything, and Bort should continue to say, "No, you can't have that." That also helps prevent cookie cutters, as each LB will have weaknesses, and if all on a team have the same weaknesses that's a problem for the team.
 
Kavadas
offline
Link
 
You can fix powerbacks by pumping STR and TKL. Powerbacks aren't just that good. With the buffing of STR and CAR this season it's only natural that all of those defensemen with builds predicated almost entirely on SPD/AGI would get eaten alive by the power backs.

Is 48 SPD enough for an elite WR? No, so why would 48 TKL be enough for an elite LB or Safety?

This is all just F'd up player perception who can't cope with the game leaving behind the pure dominance of SPD/AGI.
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kavadas
You can fix powerbacks by pumping STR and TKL. Powerbacks aren't just that good. With the buffing of STR and CAR this season it's only natural that all of those defensemen with builds predicated almost entirely on SPD/AGI would get eaten alive by the power backs.

Is 48 SPD enough for an elite WR? No, so why would 48 TKL be enough for an elite LB or Safety?

This is all just F'd up player perception who can't cope with the game leaving behind the pure dominance of SPD/AGI.


Except for the fact that you still have to have enough speed on a LB to catch the other 75% of the HB builds in this game... sure.

Once again, don't see why a bonus to tackling from behind is a bad thing, or really anything that would even severely alter the effectiveness of a powerback... It would just keep them from reeling off 80 yard runs with 18 broken tackles.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.