User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
MeauxJeaux
offline
Link
 
Oh lawd, you done opened up the toughest conference debate. That's like Pandora's box, close, it close it! lol

 
Ilok
offline
Link
 
it's an easy debate. Go by competitiveness within the conference? There hasn't been a back to back SEC champion in over 10 years and 6 teams out of 12 have won it in that span. Can any other conference say that? There hasn't been back to back east or west champions since 2000.

Lets compare BCS performances. Excluding this season because it's not finished, the SEC is 11-4 in the BCS and 4-0 in the NC game and had half it's teams represent the conference. What other BCS conference can claim that. The PAC 10 is the conference that has a higher winning percentage, but USC has 6 of it's 7 wins (that's counting this season). Big East is the only other BCS conference that has a .500 winning percentage in the BCS with a record of 6-5, but 3 of their wins are by Miami who aren't even in the conference anymore.

Year in and year out, the SEC is the toughest conference. The SEC might not have the best team in the nation year in and year out, but as a whole it is the toughest conference.
Last edited Jan 5, 2009 20:46:26
 
jloescher3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ilok
Why run up the score for style points in a bowl game? There is 1 huge reason preseason rankings.

Recruits don't really care if you win by 10 or 40, but voters sure as hell do. Preseason rankings mean everything. You know how impossible it would be for an unranked team to win a national championship or a even a team ranked between 25-20. 40 point beat down of a No. 14 ranked team has moved LSU about 5 places in the preseason polls, which means they will probably finish 5 places higher next season when bowl bids come around next season.

Lets say LSU finishes 9-3 next season. a 9-3 LSU team that started the season in the top 15 will finish the season in the top 15. a 9-3 LSU who started the season unranked would barely crack the top 25. Up until this game, everyone was talking about how bad LSU was and how over rated they were. Now they are talking about how good Jefferson is, how bright LSU's future is and about the dismantling LSU put on Georgia Tech in prime time. That's what a good coach does. Listen to sports talk radio or read a national college football column. Is anyone talking about Ol Miss upsetting Texas Tech or Arizona upsetting BYU? No they are talking about LSU destroying Tech and Utah destroying Alabama. A good coach knows how to get the national media on it's side and that's what Miles has done to salvage what can only be described as a piss poor season. Bob Stoops is the best coach in college football, not because he wins games or is a great strategist, because he can rally his boosters and fan base and get the media on his side. Stoops is the reason it's OU/Florida in the NC game and not Texas/Florida. He's done it multiple seasons. 2004 his style points made it a OU/USC NC game and not a USC/Auburn game. What reason would anyone stick any team over an undefeated team out of the unquestioned toughest conference in the NCAA in a NC game? It's called gamesmanship and you either have it or you don't.

Miles is proving he is a gamer. We should of known this last season when an 8-2 LSU team was picked to play in the NC game over a cubic buttload of qualified 8-2 teams. Yeah it's pretty piss poor college football is about politics and gaining style points, but that's the system in place and you either play the system or get played (Mack Brown)


ill concede you this (and god do i hate preseason rankings and how much they affect the postseason - see 1990), but you do agree w/ me that there is not a huge difference between 38-3 and 45-3.... it wouldnt gain you anything. run the ball and run out the damn clock so i can leave the stadium and still regard your team and coach w/ high respect. dont throw bombs the entire second half.
 
jloescher3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ilok
it's an easy debate. Go by competitiveness within the conference? There hasn't been a back to back SEC champion in over 10 years and 6 teams out of 12 have won it in that span. Can any other conference say that? There hasn't been back to back east or west champions since 2000.

Lets compare BCS performances. Excluding this season because it's not finished, the SEC is 11-4 in the BCS and 4-0 in the NC game and had half it's teams represent the conference. What other BCS conference can claim that. The PAC 10 is the conference that has a higher winning percentage, but USC has 6 of it's 7 wins (that's counting this season). Big East is the only other BCS conference that has a .500 winning percentage in the BCS with a record of 6-5, but 3 of their wins are by Miami who aren't even in the conference anymore.

Year in and year out, the SEC is the toughest conference. The SEC might not have the best team in the nation year in and year out, but as a whole it is the toughest conference.


and the ACC has the most bowl eligible teams ever.... one can say we meddle in mediocrity, but our worst team is the best worst team in college football ..... so we're the best conference (haha did i just say duke is the reason we're the best conference?) oh and pre-bowl season ACC vs SEC was 6-6 (and then a whole lot of ACC teams choked hardcore (see us, bc, clemson...))

actually whole different argument, but i bet if we play in any other stadium other than the Georgia Dome or Death Valley, LA we probably beat you guys this year. (yes i am including the superdome (for the opposite reason of why we played so poorly)) (of course i cant prove it for certain, but the GT team that showed up is not the same team that was playing in our last two games)

The two real reasons yall beat us: 1. hiring a temp. that specialized defending the TO back in the day. 2. our team was not motivated to play 2 miles from campus.
 
Ilok
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jloescher3
Originally posted by Ilok

it's an easy debate. Go by competitiveness within the conference? There hasn't been a back to back SEC champion in over 10 years and 6 teams out of 12 have won it in that span. Can any other conference say that? There hasn't been back to back east or west champions since 2000.

Lets compare BCS performances. Excluding this season because it's not finished, the SEC is 11-4 in the BCS and 4-0 in the NC game and had half it's teams represent the conference. What other BCS conference can claim that. The PAC 10 is the conference that has a higher winning percentage, but USC has 6 of it's 7 wins (that's counting this season). Big East is the only other BCS conference that has a .500 winning percentage in the BCS with a record of 6-5, but 3 of their wins are by Miami who aren't even in the conference anymore.

Year in and year out, the SEC is the toughest conference. The SEC might not have the best team in the nation year in and year out, but as a whole it is the toughest conference.


and the ACC has the most bowl eligible teams ever.... one can say we meddle in mediocrity, but our worst team is the best worst team in college football ..... so we're the best conference (haha did i just say duke is the reason we're the best conference?) oh and pre-bowl season ACC vs SEC was 6-6 (and then a whole lot of ACC teams choked hardcore (see us, bc, clemson...))

actually whole different argument, but i bet if we play in any other stadium other than the Georgia Dome or Death Valley, LA we probably beat you guys this year. (yes i am including the superdome (for the opposite reason of why we played so poorly)) (of course i cant prove it for certain, but the GT team that showed up is not the same team that was playing in our last two games)

The two real reasons yall beat us: 1. hiring a temp. that specialized defending the TO back in the day. 2. our team was not motivated to play 2 miles from campus.


you are seriously going to make the argument that Tech was not motivated to play in front of its home crowd?

How bout these being the reason:

Over confident
Tech only had a game and a half of film on the QB
Having a first year coach who hasn't had a lot of post season success
LSU Out Talented them
Scheme not matching up well (run heavy team going against one of the best run defense)
Throwing 24 times with a rushing QB and only completing 33% of the passes (he only had a 44% completion rating all season)

Tech just doesn't match up well with LSU. It's that simple
 
jloescher3
offline
Link
 
im laughing at your response.

it was, yet it wasnt a home crowd. when half of the bottom section is full of LSU fans, you cant here the rest of the stadium. that's how the GA dome is set up.

only overconfident because it was called a home game..... and the atmosphere wasnt like any home game they had ever experienced.

true only a game and a half of film on the QB, but he is a system QB and the system had been scouted for sure. if you dont think he ran the same plays the rest of your medley of QB's ran....well i dont know what to say.

1st year coach who hasnt had a lot of post season success.....(this is your worst point, BTW) at Navy he led his team to their first bowl games in a long time and we all can agree that is a huge accomplishment.... but thats not even his best postseason accomplishment...... 2 1-AA national championships at Ga. Southern. (if you dont think 1-AA national champs dont count i guess Tressel was an inexperienced coach when he won his d1-A champ.)

Out talented doesnt mean much (See Alabama vs Utah)

your run defense....ooh where to start...... yes you have some great DTs, but w/o the temp. D coord. the rest of your front 7 dont stand a chance - not disciplined enough...... same reason we ran over UGA and Miami....speed defenses tend to not be as disciplined. (im not going to argue this point) also your run D stats also had quite a bit to do w/ the fact that you had one of the worst pass D's in the country (in similar fashion but inverse, Colts almost set an nfl record this year for fewest Pass TDs allowed in a year)

that last point is truly your only good one and i was mad about it, but some of that had to do w/ playing from behind and some w/ your abysmal pass D this year (yes we did come out throwing.... but if we stuck to the run and yall didnt recover that onside kick much different ball game)

and when is the last time you saw a team play well in a "home" bowl game.... (w/in 10-15 miles of campus, outside of BCS games, cuz all teams are motivated to play in those) i cant think of any*.... its just not a reward to play in a "home" game - no travel, trapped in a hotel room in your own city that you're used to being able to roam about w/ ease, expect to have a "home crowd" cuz that's what its hyped as, but half of the lower deck is your opponent's fans so it doesnt look like a home crowd.

*im not counting Vandy cuz it was their firs bowl game in such a long time, yes they were motivated. (and BC has no fan support that travels outside of the NE - but thats another point altogether )

think it over im going to sleep ill reply to whatever you have in the morning - this is getting fun (sorry to everyone else for hijacking (although he might have started the hijacking ))
 
jloescher3
offline
Link
 


edit: oh and no need to quote.... i know you're responding to me

lol to anyonelse who saw this original post
Last edited Jan 5, 2009 22:10:41
 
MeauxJeaux
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MeauxJeaux


I rarely pull against the SEC in bowl games and it's a toughie for the championship game. I think Florida will win but I'm kinda pulling for OU. Got a couple of local kids playing for them, Chris Brown and Nic Harris, and i'd like to see them win it. If OU gets ahead or stays close i'll just have to mute the sound so I won't have to listen to that god awful boomer sooner song over and over and over again. They need a little more variety.


Damned good game so far!

 
Ilok
offline
Link
 
Florida is absolutely beating them self and another example why Refs need to crack down on horse collar more than face mask. How many careers are going to be ended before Refs start calling everyone including people that grab but not hold on to the back of the jersey.
 
jloescher3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ilok
Florida is absolutely beating them self and another example why Refs need to crack down on horse collar more than face mask. How many careers are going to be ended before Refs start calling everyone including people that grab but not hold on to the back of the jersey.


IMO there are two calls that need to be adjusted by college refs right now.

2. as you mentioned "horsecollar tackles" should become "attempted horsecollar penalties" you dont have to pull someone to the ground to injure a player. (it will be more severe of a injury if you take them all the way down, but regardless its dangerous)

1. Helmet to helmet penalties...... QBs and other runners who lead w/ their head should be allowed to hit HtH if the D player has already started his tackling motion. too many times this season did i see mobile QBs duck their heads right when they're about to get hit and get 15yds tacked onto their run because the D player is trying to make a solid tackle. this cost us our game against VT and it pissed me off to no end (and IIRC how VT also beat Nebraska and UNC....Tyrod ducks his head as hes about to get hit toward the end of the 4th Q and gets 15yds and a 1st)
 
DangerClose
offline
Link
 
not beating themselves right now,..
 
MeauxJeaux
offline
Link
 
One of the best championship games i've watched. Great game.
 
Ilok
offline
Link
 
Oklahoma let Florida stick around too long and Tebow made them pay. You got to jump on the Gators early and often and never stop.

Great game though.
 
DangerClose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ilok
Oklahoma let Florida stick around too long and Tebow made them pay. You got to jump on the Gators early and often and never stop.

Great game though.


yep, OU had their shot early, twice, or more, to get something done,...could have even settled for three at the end of the first half,..but NOoooo,..idiot throw into triple coverage by the next QB for the Lions,..is it just me, or did that guy look like he was just basically lost out there,..?,..kind of the look like the moment was a bit too big for him,..but not for the 'bow,..
 
MeauxJeaux
offline
Link
 
I wonder how many from each team go pro now? I'll help Mr. Tebow find the door, i'll be glad when he's gone.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.