User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Canadian AA Leagues > Canada AA #2 > Season 7 Power Rankings
Page:
 
Nectur
offline
Link
 
Okay, not to sound like I don't appreciate the work, cuz I do, but how does an 0-3 team (Saskatoon Fighting Gamecocks) rank above us a 2-1 team (Spitfires)?! All 3 of their losses have been by more than 30 points. Our 1 loss was by less than 10. Something just doesn't add up there. I know they have played "stronger" opponents... but their record and loss margin has to account for more than it apparently is.
 
ricksta1975
offline
Link
 
Thats intresting, the Marauders put up a great victory and drop down a place.

Nice work tho pal. Still cant believe Prince George Bulls are bottom still. lol
 
ricksta1975
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nectur
Okay, not to sound like I don't appreciate the work, cuz I do, but how does an 0-3 team (Saskatoon Fighting Gamecocks) rank above us a 2-1 team (Spitfires)?! All 3 of their losses have been by more than 30 points. Our 1 loss was by less than 10. Something just doesn't add up there. I know they have played "stronger" opponents... but their record and loss margin has to account for more than it apparently is.


Its an intresting one, considering how weak the Gamecocks Team looks, and how badly they have done so far too.
 
Link
 
seeing as the marauders stomped us last year and the fact that we have equal records right now, they should be above us.
 
UclaBob
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nectur
Okay, not to sound like I don't appreciate the work, cuz I do, but how does an 0-3 team (Saskatoon Fighting Gamecocks) rank above us a 2-1 team (Spitfires)?! All 3 of their losses have been by more than 30 points. Our 1 loss was by less than 10. Something just doesn't add up there. I know they have played "stronger" opponents... but their record and loss margin has to account for more than it apparently is.


To answer the question...in RPI, opponent's winning % counts more than your own winning %...which is why, they are above you; I wouldn't worry too much as things will correct themselves.

I'm going to add other factors eventually (such as margin of victory / bad losses / etc), but I wanted to see how pure RPI did at rating GLB teams first.

If it makes you better, my team (3-0 Alberta Wildcats) is ranked below many teams with losses; as the teams we have beaten currently have 1 win between them.

Originally posted by Valdemar Widesen
seeing as the marauders stomped us last year and the fact that we have equal records right now, they should be above us.


Given the variance that can happen between seasons...last season means nothing in terms of these rankings.
Last edited Jan 6, 2009 12:22:42
 
ill
offline
Link
 
so a team that has lost 3 games to teams with winning record is somehow getting rated higher because of who they LOST to?

The key word is lost.
Last edited Jan 6, 2009 12:45:30
 
BOTF
offline
Link
 
Think of it as the BcS of GLB. lol
 
ill
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BOTF
Think of it as the BcS of GLB. lol


now it makes sense.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by ill
Originally posted by BOTF

Think of it as the BcS of GLB. lol


now it makes sense.


Ok, feeling stupid now... what is this BcS thing??
 
ill
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Valdemar Widesen
Originally posted by ill

Originally posted by BOTF


Think of it as the BcS of GLB. lol


now it makes sense.


Ok, feeling stupid now... what is this BcS thing??


its a system used to rate college football teams that doesn't make any sense.
Last edited Jan 6, 2009 13:41:36
 
Stan Gable
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ill
Originally posted by Valdemar Widesen

Originally posted by ill


Originally posted by BOTF



Think of it as the BcS of GLB. lol


now it makes sense.


Ok, feeling stupid now... what is this BcS thing??


its a system used to rate college football teams that doesn't make any sense.

Oh yes it does. It makes sense to Mr. Greedy Monopolizing College and to Mr. Dollar Sign

 
Roctronic
offline
Link
 
wow, those rankings are really off.

This is why software doesn't work .

Someone should do rankings based on who they think is the best....Prince George is not 16th....not even close!
 
Link
 
Thanks for the explanations of the BcS thing
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Roctronic
wow, those rankings are really off.

This is why software doesn't work .

Someone should do rankings based on who they think is the best....Prince George is not 16th....not even close!


agreed, but the guy who made these already said its cause of the data utilized...

But yea, Prince George has either hit some seriously bad AI, unlucky games or wicked opponents, because they are a great team in my opinion and should be ranked above us (victoria) if you disregard the current records. I hope they are still in a slump when we meet them later on. Also hope that the Marauders hit a major slump later as well, so we have a chance at beating them.
 
Saintsfan83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Valdemar Widesen
Originally posted by Roctronic

wow, those rankings are really off.

This is why software doesn't work .

Someone should do rankings based on who they think is the best....Prince George is not 16th....not even close!


agreed, but the guy who made these already said its cause of the data utilized...

But yea, Prince George has either hit some seriously bad AI, unlucky games or wicked opponents, because they are a great team in my opinion and should be ranked above us (victoria) if you disregard the current records. I hope they are still in a slump when we meet them later on. Also hope that the Marauders hit a major slump later as well, so we have a chance at beating them.


I hope this doesn't mean the teams we play will be as tough
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.