User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AAA Leagues > USA AAA #2 > Even Bort knows Csonka breask some serious tackles
Page:
 
Ladyzman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by grooveskipinc
good tackling has a lot to do with vision, in my experience. taking the right angle, taking out legs or leading with your shoulder. you have to know where to tackle and know when to wrap up. should corners miss tackles on scatbacks and wide receivers? yes, they should. should they be unable to tackle a halfback? no. it also doesn't take 2 corners and a safety to bring down halfbacks, no matter how much creatine and hgh they've taken.


I think you are confusing tackling and vision here. All that you described is form tackling. I agree vision would play a part but know how to properly tackle a person would be basically tackling, am i right? Vision would be more of getting him in open field or avoiding a juke or lowered shoulder. And sorry to disagree but powerbacks look forward to corners. Of anyone on the Defense to go up against, i would say eating a corner or two would be his favorite meal.

Originally posted by grooveskipinc
my point is this - you cannot gimp your building of a secondary player (I'm including linebackers here as well) just in case you might play a team that is taking advantage of Bort's inability to find positional parity. A halfback that is 220 lbs and 5'10" that has 100 strength should be pretty dang strong, but they're really not stronger than the 6'5" 330 lb defensive tackle with 90 strength.


I agree. Secondary players have a lot more categories to cover to, if they want to be good. But i think you are confusing some things here also. First, i dont see the size and weight being that much calculated in Bort's scheme of things. I really feel if he meant it to play that much of a part, it would be able to be customized in some way and not just be some random build you were given in the beginning. Second, about the halfback versus the Lineman, i think you are forgeting that its not a Oklahoma drill. The D-line will be fighting with the O-lineman and most times at best get an arm or such on the Halfback. And yea, unless you get a great angle on a powerback, an arm isn't going to do much.

Originally posted by grooveskipinc
Bort should start encouraging players to build realistic players instead of making 1 attribute god-mode. Remember Flames' team of 100+ speed players? They killed people until Bort made agility worth something, and then suddenly receivers with 100 speed, 30 agility, 30 stamina, and 30 catching were total crap.

The fix for this and future issues like this (and there will be more if Bort just balances by nerfing) is to have a weighted player build in his calculations. A linebacker that is fast, strong, and agile is worthless if he can't see a hole to fill. Likewise a halfback that is outrageously strong, fast, and has good ball control skills shouldn't be as dominant as they are because they have neglected some of the critical skills of a full time back (vision, confidence, agility). In my opinion a halfback that isn't well rounded with these skills should be timid about getting hit, or not patient enough to see or even cognizant of the opening in the line, or be running into the back of the guard that just pulled for him.

In real football powerbacks are a big threat, but there is a reason they aren't on the field every play. They get pounded on, and they're short yardage backs.


I agree with most of what you said here. 1 attribute god-mode builds should be punished for the lack of other skills, or at best only be amazing at a few things. Like for example, a powerback that's only strength and carrying should not only run over his own players but the defense. With no vision i couldn't see them doing any complicated plays and i could only seem the specializing in like a Power-I formation. And on that, the reason many powerbacks are doing so amazing is because there seems to be only 1 build for LB's. Most Linebackers are spd/agi specialist, and thats great for coverage and such, but neglecting tackling, power or vision leads to the rampage of powerbacks. If we are going to try and look at this in a realistic view, there are alot more Brian Urlacher builds, rather than Ray lewis. And this is fine and dandy, but when you have a league with Brandon Jacobs, or Jamal Lewis or well i didnt want to say his name but Larry Csonka, you have to worry less about your spd/agi and switch to a tck/pwr. Oh and i named the first 2 because of your power back comment, cause yea, these 2 are pure powerbacks and they kickass for their team.

 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by grooveskipinc
good tackling has a lot to do with vision, in my experience. taking the right angle, taking out legs or leading with your shoulder. you have to know where to tackle and know when to wrap up. should corners miss tackles on scatbacks and wide receivers? yes, they should. should they be unable to tackle a halfback? no. it also doesn't take 2 corners and a safety to bring down halfbacks, no matter how much creatine and hgh they've taken.

my point is this - you cannot gimp your building of a secondary player (I'm including linebackers here as well) just in case you might play a team that is taking advantage of Bort's inability to find positional parity. A halfback that is 220 lbs and 5'10" that has 100 strength should be pretty dang strong, but they're really not stronger than the 6'5" 330 lb defensive tackle with 90 strength.

Bort should start encouraging players to build realistic players instead of making 1 attribute god-mode. Remember Flames' team of 100+ speed players? They killed people until Bort made agility worth something, and then suddenly receivers with 100 speed, 30 agility, 30 stamina, and 30 catching were total crap.

The fix for this and future issues like this (and there will be more if Bort just balances by nerfing) is to have a weighted player build in his calculations. A linebacker that is fast, strong, and agile is worthless if he can't see a hole to fill. Likewise a halfback that is outrageously strong, fast, and has good ball control skills shouldn't be as dominant as they are because they have neglected some of the critical skills of a full time back (vision, confidence, agility). In my opinion a halfback that isn't well rounded with these skills should be timid about getting hit, or not patient enough to see or even cognizant of the opening in the line, or be running into the back of the guard that just pulled for him.

In real football powerbacks are a big threat, but there is a reason they aren't on the field every play. They get pounded on, and they're short yardage backs.


A+ post, my favorite part bolded.
 
grooveskipinc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ladyzman


I think you are confusing tackling and vision here.



well, my meaning was that tackling shouldn't just be strength and tackling as it seems to currently be. a good tackling corner isn't the guy that knocks the ball out when he hits or the guy that leads with his shoulder, it's the guy that always gets the right line on the tackle and is athletic enough to drop the guy, no matter how strong he is, kind of like Champ. Is a great tackling corner going to miss? Yeah, they are, but they're not going to have 8 out of 10 tackles broken, I don't care how strong Earl Campbell is.

Mind you, I am not suggesting that cornerbacks and safeties have the advantage. I am only suggesting that our LOLDot secondaries not be PENALIZED for building a balanced player.
 
Spirer
offline
Link
 
I see several things that in my opinion have created this "problem" with powerbacks:

1 - There is no way to match a defensive player to an offensive threat. In a real football game you can do that easy and it prevents a lot of the problems we have in GLB, since even if you had 3 perfect LBs designed to stop powerbacks and 3 other perfectly designed to stop elusive backs, there is no way to field the right defense at the right time

2 - Because of 1, what agents have been doing regarding defensive players is making them all-rounders, which has problems when an offensive player can focus on say Strength and Carrying and another one can be focusing on Speed and Agility... since you just don't have enough SPs to be able to cater for all possible offensive players builds that you'll have to face.

3 - Offense just has to "break" the system. You can't decide to build a defensive team designed to stop powerbacks, because then you will be vulnerable to the pass and to elusive backs, so you have to cater for everything and be more balanced. Offense on the other side can perfectly well decide that they only want to do one thing and break the bank on it, since the odds of finding a specialized defense that will kill them are negligible (see http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=1509).

4 - The Veteran Abilities were added and Bruiser is just the icing on the cake for powerbacks. It makes them even more specialized and even more extreme.

To be honest the main problem in the game comes from the range of attributes you can have. In the field you could have someone with 10 STR and the next guy could have 110, which just doesn't work. In real life you don't have such big disparities and you can't have say 100 STR and 100 SPD, because it just doesn't work...
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
In real life, there is no such thing as a power back that averages even 4 yards per carry.

[/thread]
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
In real life, there is no such thing as a power back that averages even 4 yards per carry.

[/thread]

Guessing troll post, but:

Brandon Jacobs
http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/football/nfl/players/7286/
Rush 219
YDS 1089
AVG 5.0
TD 15

 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Good powerbacks get injured more often too. But hey wait! No injuries in GLB. 7 seasons in, and Bort cant seemt o code them - or relevant penalties, into a football 'sim'.

Comical.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Good powerbacks get injured more often too. But hey wait! No injuries in GLB. 7 seasons in, and Bort cant seemt o code them - or relevant penalties, into a football 'sim'.

Comical.


tbh, I don't think people really want injuries, and penalties are kinda... well, actually, fantastically boring.

Penalties are there to make sure people follow rules (alternatively, give people the chance to show their ability to tip-toe on the line but not cross over.) The sim enforces fair play, so penalties are really nothing but a way to force builds.

And, lets face it, who wants to pay for 900 flex of boosting to have a guy miss multiple games due to injuries.
Last edited Jan 6, 2009 10:50:31
 
icebergin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
And, lets face it, who wants to pay for 900 flex of boosting to have a guy miss multiple games due to injuries.


This.

But if there were some advantage of getting better through training while injured?
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by islander1

Good powerbacks get injured more often too. But hey wait! No injuries in GLB. 7 seasons in, and Bort cant seemt o code them - or relevant penalties, into a football 'sim'.

Comical.


tbh, I don't think people really want injuries, and penalties are kinda... well, actually, fantastically boring.

Penalties are there to make sure people follow rules (alternatively, give people the chance to show their ability to tip-toe on the line but not cross over.) The sim enforces fair play, so penalties are really nothing but a way to force builds.

And, lets face it, who wants to pay for 900 flex of boosting to have a guy miss multiple games due to injuries.


I would.

If you want realism in a sim, it's what you sacrifice. The scale of injuries can be on the mild side, but enough to actually make starting backups over starters actually practical occasionally. I see it as a winning scenario for everyone except the greedy starter worried about 'his numbers'.
There are tons of sims out there that utilize injuries. It is a part of sports, and it should be a part of this sim if it's going to call itself anything more then 'loldots' or 'rnddots'/

Penalties, how many times do you get angry when your football team gets screwed by the refs? That's football reality. GLB lacks it. I'm not saying every game should have 15 penalties in it...but if you are going to have anti-penalty SAs, then you as a developer of this game really shouldn't pussy out of implementing them, and making them relevant.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by icebergin
Originally posted by kurieg

And, lets face it, who wants to pay for 900 flex of boosting to have a guy miss multiple games due to injuries.


This.

But if there were some advantage of getting better through training while injured?


I'm also not suggesting you can't train while injured. Bort has commented in the past about implementing injuries in such a way that it doesn't force anyone not to play, but instead gives them an injury 'reduction' to their skills. So that player could still be a backup, and even get full experience.
Instead of being the starter who gets 40-50 plays you become, for a game or two, the backup who gets 20-25 plays.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
If penalties and injuries are implemented in such a way that they clearly and consistently are a function of build/team philosophy, then I think they might be interesting. For example, not having enough Strength on the line of scrimmage tends to result in trips to the hospital.

If it seems too much like a sparse, random data matrix, then they're shit and should never be used.

I agree that having SAs tied to penalties is retarded atm. I'm sure we can come up with something replace those SAs, though.

Last edited Jan 6, 2009 11:36:39
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
One easy fix would be to give LB's, CB's, and S's an extra .5 SP on each level up, as they have more attributes to focus on while building... Or , to give a .25 extra natural lvl-up bonus to strength/tackling to allow you to still focus on the speed/vision/agility/stamina/confidence aspects of the game.
 
whodey08
offline
Link
 
The biggest problem is not being able to choose which defenders are in the game based on what offensive players are in the game.

It wouldnt be hard to have a setting that says:

If opponents HB#1 is in than LB # ? is in.

If opponents HB#2 is in than LB # ? is in.

If WR #1 is in than CB# ? is in.

This could be done for each position and would dramatically help. No need to nerf builds if the defense could specifically choose who is on certain plays. At that point it would be up to the teams to find the right talent and sub them in accordingly.

PLEASE BORT....this can be done!!!!!
 
canes30
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley
One easy fix would be to give LB's, CB's, and S's an extra .5 SP on each level up, as they have more attributes to focus on while building... Or , to give a .25 extra natural lvl-up bonus to strength/tackling to allow you to still focus on the speed/vision/agility/stamina/confidence aspects of the game.


Probably the best suggestion. It's hard to to this in retrospect because a bunch of LB/S/CB are level 40 and missed out on what 20 extra SP's. If you gave my LB 20 SP right now, I'm pretty sure I wouldn't spend it all on Str/Tackling though so it's hard to actually do.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.