User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America A Leagues > South America A #5 > Valakar's First Attempt at Power Rankings
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by valakar
Ah man no love for my power rankings anymore?


lol, didnt i say you were fired?
 
Stonewall
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by valakar
Ah man no love for my power rankings anymore?


What are you talking about I love you power ranking. I just want to see if the mathmatical formulas support them
 
alladinsane
offline
Link
 
Lol...I am not feelin the love brotha. Anyways, now that my daughter is done; she had the comp till midnight finishing (or starting?) a project that was due today. She definitely follows her dads tendency for procrastination.

Okay...the Savor formula; There are 3 variations and I truly do not remember which one he devised and which ones I added as changes and adaptations. I have been using it for a long, long time and its fairly accurate in my opinion. The problem with it is that in the early season, the sample is just too small for accurate results. Being a statistical person, I only present these as an idea of early season trends. As the season progresses, it will paint a better picture imo.

Variation 1: When you beat a team, you receive points based on how many wins that team has (including the current game). If you lose to the team, you lose as many points equal to the number of losses that the team that beat you has. All of these things are scored as the team is at the time you beat them

Variation 2: Same as variation one except you have to update your score based on the *cumulative* win/loss record of the teams you have played. So if you beat a good team on week one, instead of getting zero (because it is week 1), you might get 15 points if they go undefeated the rest of the season.

Variation 3: (the one I am currently using) is the same as variation 2, except that you also get one point for each victory. Still its cumulative at +1 for your wins. Still take the same penalty when you lose.

You could change, adapt, or adopt any one of these as the season goes on. I like var3; though it and var 2 are a bit of work and may take up to 15-25 minutes each week. Anyways, here are the team standings now and remember that this small sample size really does not paint a good picture imo.
*************************************************
Alpha conference:

Boca Juniors0-2………………………0
Brazilian booty-snatcher2-0…………..2
Brazil Knights 1-1…………………….2
Buenos Aires Bullets 0-2……………..( -1 )
Caracas Vipers …………..2-0……….3
Cartagena Caribe Pirata ….2-0……….2
Cartago Fer-de-lance …….2-0………..2
Cuban Rebels…………….0-2………….0
Montevideo Orcs ………...1-1…………1
San Juan Slashes ……….2-0…….…..2
Sao Paulo ………………...1-1………...1
The Smiths………………..0-2…………0
Talsa Penguins …………...2-0…….…..2
Trinidad Braves ………….0-2…………0
Valencia Crocodiles………0-2………( -2 )
Zimbabwe Zebras ………...0-2………..( -1 )
--------------
Zeta conference

Angel Falls Demons………0-2……….( -1 )
Araraquara Anacondas……1-1……….1
Bogata Bandits…………...2-0………..4
Budapest Stars……………0-2……….0
Cochabamba Chachapoyas..0-2………0
Copacabana Titγs………..2-0…………2
Cordoba Hitmen …………0-2………..0
Cuzco Incan Warriors……0-2………..0
Ford CLiff Avalanche…….1-1………..1
Fortaleza Thugs…………..2-0………..3
Kamnik Wildcats…………2-0………..2
Mendoza Aquarius……….2-0……….2
Paraguay Piranhas………..2-0……….2
Peruvian Headstart……….1-1……….3
South Bend Sharks……….2-0………..3
Tallahassee Tomahawk's…0-2……….0
------------------
So combining these rankings with the previous poll, here is my poll vote, even though some of the saver rankings will be ties, I am numbering them just to cheese a few people off (including my own teammates).

1. Bogata Bandits...............2-0............4
2. Caracas vipers...............2-0............3
3. South Bend Sharks......2-0.............3
4. Forteleza Thugs...........2-0..............3
5. Peruvian Headstart.....2-0...............3
6. Brazilian snatchers....2-0................2
7. Cartago Fer-de-lance2-0................2
8. Talsa Penguins..........2-0................2
9. San Juan Slashers....2-0................2
10. Brazil knights ...........1-1............. ..2

Debate; argue; criticize; Whatever strikes your mood. I am doing it anyways and if you would like to see how it progresses through the season, I am fine with the c/p though I will only post my poll from this point on (unless a good debate starts). Its a very simple system that has worked well in college fb for quite some time and does a decent job (though I didn't do it this year) of predicting who will win in the nfl playoffs (because the sample size is large enough) also. enjoy as I load up on asbestos.

Be well

Edit: trying to clarify var 3
Last edited Jan 6, 2009 10:24:10
 
Stonewall
offline
Link
 
Humm, well I'm a biologist so I wouldn't be trusting of my own calculations. I understand that the data will be a little distorted at this point due to such a small sample size, but it is interesting to see that so many of the teams that will probably be fighting for 8th seeds made the combined list at this point and the Cartegena Caribe Pirata; probably the team to beat in Alpha this season failed to make the list. I can't wait to see how this changes after next game.
 
alladinsane
offline
Link
 
That was my mistake...caribe pirata should have been #6 with their two soft opening games (no criticism, my Sharks had two slow build cake walks also, though one was/is 1-1) and that would have knocked the knights off the list. This gets easier (in addition to more accurate) as the season progresses...I just missed it in all of my paper and pencil derangement.

As far as fighting for the 8th seed, thats a prediction I am not prepared to make. Some teams may have improved and some may have changed coordinators. Also supposedly, the slow build teams are going to eventually beat all of the teams who have a higher build lvl than them, I have yet to see that though. What I do wonder is, that with so many slow build teams who think they are going to stomp through the competition in a season or two, what are they going to do about the *other* slow build teams? It seems to me that the efforts to promote diverse building have actually created alot of homogeneity and right now its sub-par at that. Maybe it is a better way to build and we should grab our trophies now, (and I am fine with that!) since we...well, we can't get relegated from A5.

I think its awesome that you are a biologist; its a field that I have always had an interest in but was never dedicated enough to pursue it as a career. The supposedly fewer jobs in that field must be fiercely fought for, congrats on your success.

Be well
 
masheen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alladinsane
That was my mistake...caribe pirata should have been #6 with their two soft opening games (no criticism, my Sharks had two slow build cake walks also, though one was/is 1-1) and that would have knocked the knights off the list. This gets easier (in addition to more accurate) as the season progresses...I just missed it in all of my paper and pencil derangement.

As far as fighting for the 8th seed, thats a prediction I am not prepared to make. Some teams may have improved and some may have changed coordinators. Also supposedly, the slow build teams are going to eventually beat all of the teams who have a higher build lvl than them, I have yet to see that though. What I do wonder is, that with so many slow build teams who think they are going to stomp through the competition in a season or two, what are they going to do about the *other* slow build teams? It seems to me that the efforts to promote diverse building have actually created alot of homogeneity and right now its sub-par at that. Maybe it is a better way to build and we should grab our trophies now, (and I am fine with that!) since we...well, we can't get relegated from A5.

I think its awesome that you are a biologist; its a field that I have always had an interest in but was never dedicated enough to pursue it as a career. The supposedly fewer jobs in that field must be fiercely fought for, congrats on your success.

Be well


Don't worry about it. Those of us on the Pirata know where we'll be at the end. That's all that matters LOL. Looking forward to see how much these change as the season progresses.
 
Stonewall
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alladinsane
That was my mistake...caribe pirata should have been #6 with their two soft opening games (no criticism, my Sharks had two slow build cake walks also, though one was/is 1-1) and that would have knocked the knights off the list. This gets easier (in addition to more accurate) as the season progresses...I just missed it in all of my paper and pencil derangement.

As far as fighting for the 8th seed, thats a prediction I am not prepared to make. Some teams may have improved and some may have changed coordinators. Also supposedly, the slow build teams are going to eventually beat all of the teams who have a higher build lvl than them, I have yet to see that though. What I do wonder is, that with so many slow build teams who think they are going to stomp through the competition in a season or two, what are they going to do about the *other* slow build teams? It seems to me that the efforts to promote diverse building have actually created alot of homogeneity and right now its sub-par at that. Maybe it is a better way to build and we should grab our trophies now, (and I am fine with that!) since we...well, we can't get relegated from A5.

I think its awesome that you are a biologist; its a field that I have always had an interest in but was never dedicated enough to pursue it as a career. The supposedly fewer jobs in that field must be fiercely fought for, congrats on your success.

Be well


I'm part of a slow build team that got started 3 seasons ago so I can attest to it's effectiveness, but we where the only slow build team in that league. In a couple seasons ounce these slow builders get there builds really going this is going to be a very contested league.

Yeah Biology is a rough field to go into. I guess I'm really a herpatologist now, I work with topical pit vipers- kinda shows in our team name
 
alladinsane
offline
Link
 
I am sure there must be a 'topical' solution.

sorry...couldn't resist. I will resist the other wide open joke opportunity.

Be careful with those snakes...fer-de-lances are no joke iirc (deadly or just rattlesnake poisonous?). I presume you are involved with the making of anti-venoms or something like that? Just curious. I am a bit interested in some of the medicinal properties of venoms as I have heard that some could potentially be useful. I suffer from a relatively mild case of MS (I can still walk so far) and have been interested in the bee sting therapy experiments that are going on. Its something to keep an eye on at least. I have no false aspirations, I am just interested and you probably don't want to talk about your work on this forum where we want to talk football. Good luck with the Fer-de-lance and I hope we get to meet you in the playoffs, though now I am concerned that I am going to be facing somebody alot smarter than me (just a simple OC). Oh well, its good to be a contenda!

Be well
 
klocc1
offline
Link
 
Umm I'm not sure your ratings will work seeing as how we lost by a missed extra point to the team you have as #1 overall, and we aren't even in the top ten. I'm sure this will change drastically as the season progresses though, and I'm sure we'd all like to see your rankings every couple weeks. If your doing them anyway might as well put them up for all of us to see.
 
BloodTown
offline
Link
 
yo klocc1 dont let ur mouth open up again unless u want to see the handgun open up
 
masheen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BloodTown
yo klocc1 dont let ur mouth open up again unless u want to see the handgun open up


You're 17. The only handgun you own has Red Rider or "BB" stamped in the slide. And even if you have a REAL handgun. You probably can't use it any better than your HB can run against my defense
 
BloodTown
offline
Link
 
yea like i said give that message to ur defense wat i said to them ight
 
masheen
offline
Link
 
My defense is laughing at your pathetic attempts to inflate your ego. Don't go crying to mama when they pound your ass into the ground. I'd tell the whole defense, but you won't make it past the linemen and linebackers and I don't want my secondary feeling left out.
 
klocc1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BloodTown
yo klocc1 dont let ur mouth open up again unless u want to see the handgun open up


LMAO seriously now your just pathetic. Or to quote a rap song so your suburban(which you said you were) ass will understand. "your an internet gangsta an email thug"

found him in the dictionary even

http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Internet%20Gangsta
Last edited Jan 6, 2009 20:27:56
 
alladinsane
offline
Link
 
That is a flaw in the system klocc1, I agree. If you were trying to do something along the lines of a 'sagarin' rating where you could predict game scores based on the power ratings. This is definitely not that kind of system, its pretty much a 'who will probably win' type system and its based on pretty simple mathematical stuff (my daughter is the math wiz, I am most definitely not!).

I know how it stinks to lose by one point and if the anaconda's continue in their high lvl of play I have no doubt that they will climb onto the list soon enough. I am a bit sleepy now, but I think I remember that your loss was to a pretty darn good team as well. That will reflect in your power rankings as the sample size increases since the one team (besides when you play the SHARKS of course...sorry, had to throw some trash in there) you lost to will probably not take many power points from your overall total. In theory (and reality), if you lose to an undefeated team...your power ranking will not change since that team has zero losses. The opposite could be a bit skewing as well though if a scrub team somehow pulls off a miracle win over a team with a great record. Their power ranking might artificially jump, even though most of the other teams will see them as a 'bye week' team (that *can* have a good day though!). Its definitely a bell curve system that will jumble alot of teams in the mediocrity areas with the best and worst shaking out over a period of time and the sample size grows. Also, in reference to the sample size...I did post a disclaimer that the ratings as they are now are not necessarily indicative yet, too many slow build teams in this league for us to really hash it out until the better teams have faced off a bit.

Anyways...until someone starts posting something more scientific; its all we got for the moment. It might grow on you though, its simplicity has kept me coming back to it since you can figure a single team's rating in your head if you are looking at an updated schedule. Nice for those long plane rides etc.

Be well

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.