I know Bort would like to have us toss out a wide range of guesses, but I'm less concerned about a magic number than I am the tales that I keep reading where LBs and CBs have tackling and strength in the 30s and yet consistenly going a couple of games in a row without missing a tackle. That just doesn't ring right to me.
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Originally posted by RiverRat2
Originally posted by EastBayFunk
Originally posted by RiverRat2
Originally posted by EastBayFunk
Not much. NFL cornerbacks tackle running backs all the time.
nfl cornerbacks are pretty good at tackling IMO
My point is, you don't need to be some hulking monster to make a tackle.
True but a smaller guy needs a higher tackle skill to take down a powerback.
And this is a video game where you don't want to undervalue a stat so much that there's no point in having it. If 20 tackling can consistently take down my 100 STR 80 carrying guy, why would I bother getting 100 STR and 80 carrying?
Originally posted by EastBayFunk
Originally posted by RiverRat2
Originally posted by EastBayFunk
Not much. NFL cornerbacks tackle running backs all the time.
nfl cornerbacks are pretty good at tackling IMO
My point is, you don't need to be some hulking monster to make a tackle.
True but a smaller guy needs a higher tackle skill to take down a powerback.
And this is a video game where you don't want to undervalue a stat so much that there's no point in having it. If 20 tackling can consistently take down my 100 STR 80 carrying guy, why would I bother getting 100 STR and 80 carrying?
Dpride59
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by swoosh22
If we are going to have to make players have 70+ str and tackling that is going to give the offenses a huge advantage in this game which I already think they have.
How can a CB/SS/FS have that much in str and tackle when they need speed/agility/vision 70+ as well to cover WRs and not get faked by the QB.
Exactly.
Have you seen cb's trying to tackle All-day??? 9 outta 10 of them get stiff armed and slammed to the turf. If a power back is running and a corner or safety comes up one on one they get flatted. LAron landry vs Brandon jacobs anyone?
Originally posted by swoosh22
If we are going to have to make players have 70+ str and tackling that is going to give the offenses a huge advantage in this game which I already think they have.
How can a CB/SS/FS have that much in str and tackle when they need speed/agility/vision 70+ as well to cover WRs and not get faked by the QB.
Exactly.
Have you seen cb's trying to tackle All-day??? 9 outta 10 of them get stiff armed and slammed to the turf. If a power back is running and a corner or safety comes up one on one they get flatted. LAron landry vs Brandon jacobs anyone?
billthekill
offline
offline
Depends on the position.
For D=line I would say maybe 90 strength and 60 tackling should have a 90% chance of tackling him.
For a LB, you can't have 90 strength since a LB has so many other attributes that he needs to put point into. So maybe 70/50 for a 90% Chance of making the tackle.
Secondary: 50/40
For D=line I would say maybe 90 strength and 60 tackling should have a 90% chance of tackling him.
For a LB, you can't have 90 strength since a LB has so many other attributes that he needs to put point into. So maybe 70/50 for a 90% Chance of making the tackle.
Secondary: 50/40
NotRippedYet
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Let's say I have a power back with:
100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too
I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?
The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?
I've seen answers ranging from "soft cap str/tck should be enough" to "You should need 100 tackling skill and at least 70-80 strength."
I will keep my opinion to myself for the moment to keep from tainting anyone else's opinion.
I think looking at it from a purely numbers standpoint, around 70/70 STR/TKL, when coupled with good speed/agil/vision/confidence would be enough to put an end to that.
That said I think you need to put it in perspective. If an LB had to put their build at that, they would essentially nuke the entire rest of their build and would get gobbled up by the blockers, or never make it there due to angles/speed.
Let's say I have a power back with:
100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too
I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?
The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?
I've seen answers ranging from "soft cap str/tck should be enough" to "You should need 100 tackling skill and at least 70-80 strength."
I will keep my opinion to myself for the moment to keep from tainting anyone else's opinion.
I think looking at it from a purely numbers standpoint, around 70/70 STR/TKL, when coupled with good speed/agil/vision/confidence would be enough to put an end to that.
That said I think you need to put it in perspective. If an LB had to put their build at that, they would essentially nuke the entire rest of their build and would get gobbled up by the blockers, or never make it there due to angles/speed.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 19:03:14
Saris
offline
offline
As far as just making the tackle, I'd say a ponderate average of str/tackle/agi/vis should come into play. Otherwise the secondary could have major issues taking down power backs. BUT, a defenders strength and tackling should decide how many additional "dragging" yards a powerback can tack on after contact.
So a corner without exceptional str/tackle would still be able to bring down a powerback, although he'd probably get dragged for a couple yards and his odds of getting his tackle broken would be higher, just not game breakingly so.
So a corner without exceptional str/tackle would still be able to bring down a powerback, although he'd probably get dragged for a couple yards and his odds of getting his tackle broken would be higher, just not game breakingly so.
swoosh22
offline
offline
Another thing I would like to add is if you are going to make strength and tackle more of a priority to power backs, then you would have to nerf their speed.
Because in all honesty 50/60 speed/agility should be really slow... like in the 5.0-5.2 range.
Because in all honesty 50/60 speed/agility should be really slow... like in the 5.0-5.2 range.
iMan
offline
offline
Originally posted by Welsh76
I would guess it varies depending on the position of the player and the type of tackle he would adopt, my guess would be:
Defensive Line: 70 strength / 60 tackling
Linebackers: 60 strength / 50 tackling
Cornerbacks: 40 strength / 40 tackling
All set to 'Wrap-up' of course.
that makes absolutely no sense
it should be reversed.
its easier to stop the RB before he gets started (near the LOS) then after he gets started (secondary level)
I would guess it varies depending on the position of the player and the type of tackle he would adopt, my guess would be:
Defensive Line: 70 strength / 60 tackling
Linebackers: 60 strength / 50 tackling
Cornerbacks: 40 strength / 40 tackling
All set to 'Wrap-up' of course.
that makes absolutely no sense
it should be reversed.
its easier to stop the RB before he gets started (near the LOS) then after he gets started (secondary level)
boondocksaint
offline
offline
60/60 str/tak w/ some SA's should be good to take him down a good % of the time, imo. Granted, with that build for a powerback, I'd expect that he'd be tougher to take down without grinding out a few extra yards.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 19:03:11
Deathblade
offline
offline
I still think power tackling should be more effective against power rushers...
I mean, power rushers charge into people to break tackles. Power tackling misses more often because they get side-stepped. Missing tackles against powerbacks because of being on power tackling makes no sense...
I mean, power rushers charge into people to break tackles. Power tackling misses more often because they get side-stepped. Missing tackles against powerbacks because of being on power tackling makes no sense...
Dpride59
offline
offline
I think if cb's and safetys are consistently making tackles vs power backs we have a problem. Afterall if you have 100 + strength in a runningback, chances are your gettign caught from behind by lb's.
puppy
offline
offline
This is how I would have it worked out.
Strength - Stop the running back from moving forward/prevent him from falling forward.
Tackling - Wrapping him up and taking him to the ground.
So, with that, I'd say about 80 strength and 50 tackling or so....but most D Lineman have those stats and some LBs are close to that as well. There should be some kind of SA though for DBs like "Hit Low" or something to improve your chances of tackling a stronger running back.
Strength - Stop the running back from moving forward/prevent him from falling forward.
Tackling - Wrapping him up and taking him to the ground.
So, with that, I'd say about 80 strength and 50 tackling or so....but most D Lineman have those stats and some LBs are close to that as well. There should be some kind of SA though for DBs like "Hit Low" or something to improve your chances of tackling a stronger running back.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 19:04:08
Judan
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Firenze
Probably 80+ Str...70+ Tackling...
Depends on the formula for tackling a player...which only you know
I'm kinda asking: if you were determine how the formula worked, what would you think goes into it?
Opinions vary widely and I want to see where they are.
To consistently stop that, I would build this:
70+ strength
70+ tackling
60+speed
50+agility
40+confidence
40+vision
For SA:
Big hit/Monster: 8+ in each
Originally posted by Firenze
Probably 80+ Str...70+ Tackling...
Depends on the formula for tackling a player...which only you know

I'm kinda asking: if you were determine how the formula worked, what would you think goes into it?
Opinions vary widely and I want to see where they are.
To consistently stop that, I would build this:
70+ strength
70+ tackling
60+speed
50+agility
40+confidence
40+vision
For SA:
Big hit/Monster: 8+ in each
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 19:04:02
WestbrookFTW
offline
offline
Originally posted by swoosh22
If we are going to have to make players have 70+ str and tackling that is going to give the offenses a huge advantage in this game which I already think they have.
How can a CB/SS/FS have that much in str and tackle when they need speed/agility/vision 70+ as well to cover WRs and not get faked by the QB.
For a CB, you are tackling for the most part WRs. You should have around 48 tackling and 35 strength to bring them down. That isn't that hard...
Now, if WRs stopped going SPEED SPEED SPEED AGILITY, and went carrying/strength, you could have the dominate, possession WRs that are tough to bring down.
If we are going to have to make players have 70+ str and tackling that is going to give the offenses a huge advantage in this game which I already think they have.
How can a CB/SS/FS have that much in str and tackle when they need speed/agility/vision 70+ as well to cover WRs and not get faked by the QB.
For a CB, you are tackling for the most part WRs. You should have around 48 tackling and 35 strength to bring them down. That isn't that hard...
Now, if WRs stopped going SPEED SPEED SPEED AGILITY, and went carrying/strength, you could have the dominate, possession WRs that are tough to bring down.
Originally posted by dpride59
I think if cb's and safetys are consistently making tackles vs power backs we have a problem. Afterall if you have 100 + strength in a runningback, chances are your gettign caught from behind by lb's.
I think if cb's and safetys are consistently making tackles vs power backs we have a problem. Afterall if you have 100 + strength in a runningback, chances are your gettign caught from behind by lb's.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























