Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by Nike-Joe
I don't thin the AA incumbents should be considered above the teams moving up. Many of the A4 incumbents are teams that lost to A and BBB teams that moved up. We'll just have to let things sort themselves out. We'll know more soon enough.
Yeah but the A teams and BBB moveups that they lost to were annihilating the teams that just moved up for several seasons. In their time in A7 East, Alpine was virtually uncontested by any team that isn't now in AAA2, and Spicewood went 6-3 against Pro teams last year. Those are two examples of hideously good A level moveups, and I think now we've now reached a point where the moveups are on the same level or slightly lower than some of these incumbent teams. I also said playoff incumbents. Simply being in AA4 the earliest doesn't make a team better because some of these teams are season 1 teams - but AA4 incumbent playoff teams are very good - Crimson, Vermont, and NMR in particular. Those are teams that didn't get a free ride into AA for being around in season 1, but teams that moved up just like the teams that are here now. Also, the only A8 moveups from last season that advanced were the Woodys and the Waller Knights, both of whom were handed second round playoff exits - the Woodys by an AA4 incumbent, and the Knights by a former A7 team. The notion that a team like Crimson would miss playoffs in this years AA4 is hilarious, sorry :-\
First off, getting worked about this ranking in the preseason is what I'd call hilarious.
Again, I think time will tell and there is no reason to get worked up about a preseason ranking. Especially when the author freely admits it was just for yucks, and when he was nice enough to do it, no reason to call it moronic.
I'll also note that of the 3 teams you mentioned, Vermont, Crimson, and NMR, their preseason record against A teams that just moved up is 2-3.
Originally posted by Nike-Joe
I don't thin the AA incumbents should be considered above the teams moving up. Many of the A4 incumbents are teams that lost to A and BBB teams that moved up. We'll just have to let things sort themselves out. We'll know more soon enough.
Yeah but the A teams and BBB moveups that they lost to were annihilating the teams that just moved up for several seasons. In their time in A7 East, Alpine was virtually uncontested by any team that isn't now in AAA2, and Spicewood went 6-3 against Pro teams last year. Those are two examples of hideously good A level moveups, and I think now we've now reached a point where the moveups are on the same level or slightly lower than some of these incumbent teams. I also said playoff incumbents. Simply being in AA4 the earliest doesn't make a team better because some of these teams are season 1 teams - but AA4 incumbent playoff teams are very good - Crimson, Vermont, and NMR in particular. Those are teams that didn't get a free ride into AA for being around in season 1, but teams that moved up just like the teams that are here now. Also, the only A8 moveups from last season that advanced were the Woodys and the Waller Knights, both of whom were handed second round playoff exits - the Woodys by an AA4 incumbent, and the Knights by a former A7 team. The notion that a team like Crimson would miss playoffs in this years AA4 is hilarious, sorry :-\
First off, getting worked about this ranking in the preseason is what I'd call hilarious.
Again, I think time will tell and there is no reason to get worked up about a preseason ranking. Especially when the author freely admits it was just for yucks, and when he was nice enough to do it, no reason to call it moronic.
I'll also note that of the 3 teams you mentioned, Vermont, Crimson, and NMR, their preseason record against A teams that just moved up is 2-3.




I'm just kind of scratching my head, is all. 
























