User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Promotion/Demotion at the end of the off-season and the problems associated with it - need ideas
Page:
 
Link
 
I like the way it worked last off season, save the league swaps that had to happen, I think if you applied the same philosophies as last year with a little better planning and execution you wont really have any problems, and as jed stated you can't really please us all, so do what you think is in the best interest of the majority that play your game
 
Allarius
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
Why not just move the terrible team down to the lowest uncapped league.

I don't really enjoy seeing teams forced to disband because of promotion anyway.


Utterly sick of this THAT'S the essence of a real chemisty hit.
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, so I set up this up based on a suggestion last season:

Instead of processing all promotions/relegations at the start of day 41 and moving all the teams then and there, process it and "flag" the teams who will be moving, and keep doing so each day as teams get sold throughout the offseason. Teams flagged to move up out of the capped leagues get to sign players at their new league's cap. Then at the end of offseason, you move all the teams. Sounds simple enough, right?

I started thinking about it, though, and there are two potential problems with it:

1) Let's say a team a team expires. We flag it, and flag all the teams below to move up. The team owner contacts support and says "Ooops! I forgot to renew my team!" or "I wanted to transfer to my GM" or whatever. Now there is one less team flagged to move down, so one of the "fringe" capped teams is now un-flagged. Problem is: they've been able to recruit above the cap, and now they're not moving. Hrm.

2) Let's say the next season starts on the day after day 45. A team gets sold on day 45. Now somebody gets flagged to move up and literally has less than a day to recruit and prepare for their new league. That doesn't sound fun.

The only thing I've been able to come up with is to do promotion/relegation on day 42, to allow for dealing with people selling teams late or failing team renewals. Then have a roster freeze on day 41 so nobody gets an "unfair advantage" towards recruiting. Sounds like a waste of a day though.

Ideas? Thoughts?


If the team ownership expires on Day 40, why extend them the opportunity to extend ownership another day?

In a sense, it's kind of like bending the policy when you think about it. You're giving second chances to teams when they had 2 seasons to extend their ownership, yet they still need an extra day?

As long as they get alerts that their team is expiring, which I would send out today or tomorrow (give them a few days notice), I don't think their chances should be extended longer.
 
mpatt75
offline
Link
 
I agree with cwisler. Also, it really is a waste of time to sit and wait for them when they have had plenty of time to extend their teams.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
It's the holidays and a new year tho. So for the month of December/January I do think there should be leeway for people regarding team extensions etc etc.

Also, from what I can analyze, i see a roster freeze (ie, creating an off-season and a new pre-season period) as solving the problem. Only thing I would suggest tho is that the off-season is a little longer (the freeze) so you can sort out all the nonsense and delays and flagging and change of minds. Then a pre-season (unfreezing) can begin and so all market activity (recruiting of players) can start happening AFTER all teams have been promoted/relegated.

I.e., if the usual off-season period is 5 days. Create an off-season that lasts say 5 days, and create a new Pre-season period that's say 5 days. And this can stay in effect every season after.

Also, GLB is not gonna die as a business having an extra few days of "offseason+preseason". The extra time would also allow Bort more time to get new updates in and do a little more testing, than always being rushed to fit it all in.

No? Yes?
Last edited Dec 18, 2008 06:51:04
 
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
It's the holidays and a new year tho. So for the month of December/January I do think there should be leeway for people regarding team extensions etc etc.

Also, from what I can analyze, i see a roster freeze (ie, creating an off-season and a new pre-season period) as solving the problem. Only thing I would suggest tho is that the off-season is a little longer (the freeze) so you can sort out all the nonsense and delays and flagging and change of minds. Then a pre-season (unfreezing) can begin and so all market activity (recruiting of players) can start happening AFTER all teams have been promoted/relegated.

I.e., if the usual off-season period is 5 days. Create an off-season that lasts say 5 days, and create a new Pre-season period that's 1-2 days. And this can stay in effect every season after.

No? Yes?


Yes! This would work. I also really think Bort should only allow teams to be sold back at certain times. This way, someone can't look and think, "I'm selling my team anyway, might as well recoup any flex back now that I can". This would decrease teams being sold mid-season and turning up CPU to allow all the players to become FA's. This still causes problems within leagues, whether it be for stats, or for 1 team to say, "we had to play them with a full roster, you got to play them as a CPU team". That causes some problems in playoff seedings and in some cases making the playoffs.

So since teams are only going to be bought between certain days, teams should only be allowed to be sold on certain days. And have the days teams are allowed to be sold a few days before they're allowed to be bought. Yes? No?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I think a one day freeze would be plenty sufficient to address the problems; I don't think it would need to be 5 days.

Most people will contact us within a day of the team expiring, and most post-season sales happen on day 41. If people sell or want their teams back after that, oh well.

A 1 day freeze would make for some pissy owners I'm sure, though. "Why should I have to wait for the stupid slow people? I was ready to go on day 40!"
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I think a one day freeze would be plenty sufficient to address the problems; I don't think it would need to be 5 days.

Most people will contact us within a day of the team expiring, and most post-season sales happen on day 41. If people sell or want their teams back after that, oh well.

A 1 day freeze would make for some pissy owners I'm sure, though. "Why should I have to wait for the stupid slow people? I was ready to go on day 40!"


exactly what jed said, you can't please us all
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelCity Mafia
I also really think Bort should only allow teams to be sold back at certain times.


I don't see that as ever being practical. Many sold teams are sold by people who don't really want to play any more, and they just want to sell it to be nice and free the resources before taking off. If they can't sell it, the players on the team end up stranded when they go inactive.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
So are there any potential problems/flaws with a freeze? I cant see any. But maybe you or someone else can throw more scenarios out. But from what i can read of the OP dilemma, the solution is a freeze as you suggested. I only suggest a little extra time just because it's the Holiday season and maybe buy yourself extra time for updates or fitting in an extra update that otherwise might've been held back till the following season, or just for extra testing purposes of updates or whatever.

 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I think a one day freeze would be plenty sufficient to address the problems; I don't think it would need to be 5 days.

Most people will contact us within a day of the team expiring, and most post-season sales happen on day 41. If people sell or want their teams back after that, oh well.

A 1 day freeze would make for some pissy owners I'm sure, though. "Why should I have to wait for the stupid slow people? I was ready to go on day 40!"


So then have team ownerships expire on Day 41 instead of Day 40.

It will just lead to extending it another day eventually, and it will be an on-going cycle. If team ownerships expire on Day 40, it doesn't say you will have a second chance to extend ownership.

Owners start with 2 offseasons and 2 seasons worth of time to extend ownership (Over 80 days). So, if they get notice that their ownership is expiring, why should we continue to extend the second chance opportunity?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by SteelCity Mafia

I also really think Bort should only allow teams to be sold back at certain times.


I don't see that as ever being practical. Many sold teams are sold by people who don't really want to play any more, and they just want to sell it to be nice and free the resources before taking off. If they can't sell it, the players on the team end up stranded when they go inactive.


you should just limit midseason sellbacks, put in a term agreement for people when they buy a team stating a no-refund for midseason sellbacks or something, cuz if they are gonna go inactive there gonna do it regardless, not because you didn't let them sell there team back

edit: when are fame and veteran skills gonna be implemented?(off topic I know and I'm sorry but I couldn't resist since you're here posting)
Last edited Dec 18, 2008 07:00:50
 
imokdawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
if owners 'forget' and lose their team....even after receiving an alert; etc....then that sucks..but it is just too bad..


people in this game (forum mainly) don't seem to take much responsibility for their actions...that's not going to change until you and the mods make them accountable for their actions..


with the alerts that get sent out....there is no real reason for people to forget..

unless they have gone inactive; etc for some small period of time..maybe an alert should be sent out 40 days prior to team ownership expiring; 30 days prior; 20 days prior; 15 days prior; 10 days prior; and 5; 4; 3; 2; 1....then at least they'd have no excuse


I agree with this, once an owner lets a team go back, why would you give it back to them. Let them get back on the Waiting list.
 
keithj
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Jed

Basically, do whatever you think is going to work the best and figure no matter what, it's going to be unfair to someone and that person will unfortunately just have to deal with it.


Seems like last season's version worked well enough, minus the team swaps. The main problems were:

1) teams selling after day 40 - I'm less worried about that one because teams are sold all the time and there's not much we can do about it
2) "I forgot" expired teams that were moved to the bottom and then the owner comes back and wants his team back. Now he's stuck at the bottom of the ladder even if he was 16-0 in a pro league and won the title. We've given a bit more warning this season, though, with the alert on the team page, so maybe that won't be as much of an issue.

You forgot problem #3 with the team swaps:

A team gets promoted out of a capped league into an uncapped league, they sign a bunch of players and then find a team in a capped league to swap with. Now that team has players way over the cap in the league they just swapped into. That's definately not fair to the other teams in the capped league.
 
kmm227
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I think a one day freeze would be plenty sufficient to address the problems; I don't think it would need to be 5 days.

Most people will contact us within a day of the team expiring, and most post-season sales happen on day 41. If people sell or want their teams back after that, oh well.

A 1 day freeze would make for some pissy owners I'm sure, though. "Why should I have to wait for the stupid slow people? I was ready to go on day 40!"


I like the idea of a one day freeze because I think my team may be getting promoted and if they do not then I need to recruit different players as the ones I have recruited will be too high for my level 32 cap
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.