User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > I suggest a moderator whose sole job is to moderate FFA
Page:
 
MILTOWNFINEST
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

FFA should be modded no diffently than any other portion of the site.


Larry's got it right. Forum rules are supposed to be across the board.

We've been fairly lax on FFA because of the general attitude of "we should get to do what we want" there, and we know that a lot of it is in fun or jest. However, the purpose of FFA was to have a place to talk about off-topic stuff, not to spam or post the racist and rape stuff I've seen in there, etc. I was hoping private forums might help some of the people who want to do that stuff to find a place to do it where it doesn't end up offending new users (which happens all the time - we get complaints in support all the time about various posts).

Also, I would have not problem with an FFAer being a mod at all, IF they could take the job seriously and not try to apply special rules to that section of the forum only.


ME BIGM AND AD_MVP COULD BE LIKE THE 3 MUSKETEERS OF FFA MODS?
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

FFA should be modded no diffently than any other portion of the site.


Larry's got it right. Forum rules are supposed to be across the board.

We've been fairly lax on FFA because of the general attitude of "we should get to do what we want" there, and we know that a lot of it is in fun or jest. However, the purpose of FFA was to have a place to talk about off-topic stuff, not to spam or post the racist and rape stuff I've seen in there, etc. I was hoping private forums might help some of the people who want to do that stuff to find a place to do it where it doesn't end up offending new users (which happens all the time - we get complaints in support all the time about various posts).

Also, I would have not problem with an FFAer being a mod at all, IF they could take the job seriously and not try to apply special rules to that section of the forum only.



think you got your answer in regard to what Bort thinks/wants FFA to be.
 
GIEFF
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

FFA should be modded no diffently than any other portion of the site.


Larry's got it right. Forum rules are supposed to be across the board.

We've been fairly lax on FFA because of the general attitude of "we should get to do what we want" there, and we know that a lot of it is in fun or jest. However, the purpose of FFA was to have a place to talk about off-topic stuff, not to spam or post the racist and rape stuff I've seen in there, etc. I was hoping private forums might help some of the people who want to do that stuff to find a place to do it where it doesn't end up offending new users (which happens all the time - we get complaints in support all the time about various posts).

Also, I would have not problem with an FFAer being a mod at all, IF they could take the job seriously and not try to apply special rules to that section of the forum only.


I understand your intentions, but that isn't how the forum turned out. It's not always easy to control how thousands of posters will interact, and how a forum will evolve. Look at a forum like Canada Pro, and compare it to a forum like Africa Pro. They started exactly the same, but they are organic, and changed due to who was posting in them.

I agree 100% about the racism and rape stuff, and that's part of the reason why I think we need an FFA-only moderator - it still goes on, and needs to be stopped.

But do you see my point about it making little sense to apply no-spam rules to a forum in which off-content posts are the whole point of the forum? If you make silly, stupid threads in Suggestions or GLB, it hampers communication and the functioning of the forums, but that just isn't the case in FFA.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GIEFF
what would be "spam" in the Suggestions forum is NOT spam in FFA


Threads titled still like "ITT: IMO" filled with "tbh" and "wtf" are not spam? They serve no purpose in my eyes, other than to waste disk space, and make the forum run slower.

At least keep it to one thread if you want to post that kind of thing. I just hate seeing 50 threads in a row of nothing but that.
Last edited Dec 17, 2008 15:14:41
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by GIEFF

what would be "spam" in the Suggestions forum is NOT spam in FFA


Threads titled still like "ITT: IMO" filled with "tbh" and "wtf" are not spam? They serve no purpose in my eyes, other than to waste disk space, and make the forum run slower.


amen.
 
DM
offline
Link
 
Imo is not spam. Its something you add to the end to show that its not a fact, that it is just what you think. We sir have different views on spam.
 
MILTOWNFINEST
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by GIEFF

what would be "spam" in the Suggestions forum is NOT spam in FFA


Threads titled still like "ITT: IMO" filled with "tbh" and "wtf" are not spam? They serve no purpose in my eyes, other than to waste disk space, and make the forum run slower.


Originally posted by SEAN TAYLOR 21 36



ME BIGM AND AD_MVP COULD BE LIKE THE 3 MUSKETEERS OF FFA MODS?

 
Link
 
Originally posted by GIEFF
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


FFA should be modded no diffently than any other portion of the site.


Larry's got it right. Forum rules are supposed to be across the board.

We've been fairly lax on FFA because of the general attitude of "we should get to do what we want" there, and we know that a lot of it is in fun or jest. However, the purpose of FFA was to have a place to talk about off-topic stuff, not to spam or post the racist and rape stuff I've seen in there, etc. I was hoping private forums might help some of the people who want to do that stuff to find a place to do it where it doesn't end up offending new users (which happens all the time - we get complaints in support all the time about various posts).

Also, I would have not problem with an FFAer being a mod at all, IF they could take the job seriously and not try to apply special rules to that section of the forum only.


I understand your intentions, but that isn't how the forum turned out. It's not always easy to control how thousands of posters will interact, and how a forum will evolve. Look at a forum like Canada Pro, and compare it to a forum like Africa Pro. They started exactly the same, but they are organic, and changed due to who was posting in them.

I agree 100% about the racism and rape stuff, and that's part of the reason why I think we need an FFA-only moderator - it still goes on, and needs to be stopped.

But do you see my point about it making little sense to apply no-spam rules to a forum in which off-content posts are the whole point of the forum? If you make silly, stupid threads in Suggestions or GLB, it hampers communication and the functioning of the forums, but that just isn't the case in FFA.


Just so you know, if you would have started with this it would have save alot of people some time. This Fourm has gotten farther than all the others for sure.
 
trazer
offline
Link
 
just wow..I wish i had words for what is above me

eerr 2 above me
Last edited Dec 17, 2008 15:15:11
 
GIEFF
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by GIEFF

what would be "spam" in the Suggestions forum is NOT spam in FFA


Threads titled still like "ITT: IMO" filled with "tbh" and "wtf" are not spam? They serve no purpose in my eyes, other than to waste disk space, and make the forum run slower.


They are absolutely spam in other forums. But in FFA they are inside jokes, and attempts at humor. I understand completely why this rule was created; a thread in suggestions filled with tbh and imo is useless. But that is the whole point (organic point, not intended point) of FFA; to have fun and blow off steam.

If disk space is the issue, just have threads expire after a month, or give the FFA mod the ability to delete threads.
 
MILTOWNFINEST
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by trazer
just wow..I wish i had words for what is above me

eerr 2 above me


HUH?
 
kevbk6222
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SEAN TAYLOR 21 36
Originally posted by trazer

just wow..I wish i had words for what is above me

eerr 2 above me


HUH?


if you were a mod in any form the planet would combust
Last edited Dec 17, 2008 15:18:36
 
Link
 
Originally posted by kevbk6222
Originally posted by SEAN TAYLOR 21 36

Originally posted by trazer


just wow..I wish i had words for what is above me

eerr 2 above me


HUH?


if you were a mod in any for the planet would combust


+2
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
The spam is one thing, and I can handle it to a degree, because I know it's fun for some people.

Really, in the end, the main thing that concerns me about the content that frequently appears in FFA is this:

I don't want a law suit from some kid's angry parent. Threads about raping n*ggers, posting peoples' personal info, swearing just for the sake of swearing, etc do not paint a good picture of our site for new users, especially parents. Even some "thick skinned" people have sent in complaints about that stuff.
 
trazer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
However, the purpose of FFA was to have a place to talk about off-topic stuff



Not for inside jokes.

He meant it for actual conversation. Not for 3rd graders to be..."omg poopie!! TBH ROFLCOPTER IBL ITT: DIE IN A FIRE LOLCAKES!"

Actual discussion of things...

Seriously, even jokes are fine..but just acting like an idiot for no reason isnt.
Last edited Dec 17, 2008 15:20:13
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.