User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
bacchuspoet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aharden2
Responding to the "New people will not understand" statement:

College football players compete every year for the right to win the Heisman Trophy. Without Googling it, for whom is the Heisman named? Does being named the Thorpe award winner mean less to Aaron Ross, Michael Huff, or Malcolm Jenkins because they were not alive when Thorpe was in his prime? I will answer that with an emphatic and concise no. When paying tribute to those who came before you, part of the whole inspiration for doing so is to honor their legacy and educate later generations about them. Those who "do not understand" or are "new" to SA Pro will ask about the conference names. Then, our GLB community will explain the story of the great Satchmo and, in doing so, the legacy and the spirit of community will continue to grow. Naming the conferences in honor of arguably the best and most respectfed member of our SA Pro community is something that not only should happen, it must happen. Naming the conferences anything other than Satchmo and Dizzy would be a waste of a great opportunity to pay tribute to someone who meant so much to those of us in this game.

Real life trumps some arbitrarily decided upon conference names that are catchy because they have something to do with South America. Ask yourself what is the right thing to do. Would it be better to have conference names like "Cocaine Smuglers" and "Guerrilla Warfare" because they are childishly funny and amusingly stereotype South America? Does that feel like the right thing to do and forego the opportunity to have Satch's effect on the game be etched into this conference's future?


I never thought I would agree with harden about anything! But the above could not really have been better said. Thank you for making this statement so clearly. This is the perfect argument for the idea.
 
bacchuspoet
offline
Link
 
Oh, and as to viper's point... dude, no one is going to ban you. I sincerely hope that guy was just joking. That's just ridiculous.
I understand your argument for the cons, and appreciate the devil's advocate role you're playing. I just personally feel that it's a bit wrongheaded.
 
Iversen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aharden2
Responding to the "New people will not understand" statement:

College football players compete every year for the right to win the Heisman Trophy. Without Googling it, for whom is the Heisman named? Does being named the Thorpe award winner mean less to Aaron Ross, Michael Huff, or Malcolm Jenkins because they were not alive when Thorpe was in his prime? I will answer that with an emphatic and concise no. When paying tribute to those who came before you, part of the whole inspiration for doing so is to honor their legacy and educate later generations about them. Those who "do not understand" or are "new" to SA Pro will ask about the conference names. Then, our GLB community will explain the story of the great Satchmo and, in doing so, the legacy and the spirit of community will continue to grow. Naming the conferences in honor of arguably the best and most respectfed member of our SA Pro community is something that not only should happen, it must happen. Naming the conferences anything other than Satchmo and Dizzy would be a waste of a great opportunity to pay tribute to someone who meant so much to those of us in this game.

Real life trumps some arbitrarily decided upon conference names that are catchy because they have something to do with South America. Ask yourself what is the right thing to do. Would it be better to have conference names like "Cocaine Smuglers" and "Guerrilla Warfare" because they are childishly funny and amusingly stereotype South America? Does that feel like the right thing to do and forego the opportunity to have Satch's effect on the game be etched into this conference's future?


Great post, I agree.

But please are you new to SA or something?

Bullet points, bullet points, bullet points!!!
 
viperz2k5
offline
Link
 
Oh I know no ones gonna ban me but I'm just putting my point across in that matter. I just didn't like the way he rebutted against my statement the way that he did. I respect everyone's opinion and I'm sorry if I came out like an ass in here but I like to think about both sides, thats just how I am. Like I said if they do go with the changes I'll be more than happy to accept them. If they don't, well then I guess we have to accept that as well.
 
bacchuspoet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by viperz2k5
Oh I know no ones gonna ban me but I'm just putting my point across in that matter. I just didn't like the way he rebutted against my statement the way that he did. I respect everyone's opinion and I'm sorry if I came out like an ass in here but I like to think about both sides, thats just how I am. Like I said if they do go with the changes I'll be more than happy to accept them. If they don't, well then I guess we have to accept that as well.


I get what you're saying. But you had to know that if you said anything contrary to the majority in this conference that you were going to get blasted. Especially if it has to do with Satch. You've been around SA long enough to know that we're not really known for holding back.
 
aharden2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bacchuspoet

I never thought I would agree with harden about anything!


Welcome to the side of the good guys.
 
viperz2k5
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bacchuspoet
Originally posted by viperz2k5

Oh I know no ones gonna ban me but I'm just putting my point across in that matter. I just didn't like the way he rebutted against my statement the way that he did. I respect everyone's opinion and I'm sorry if I came out like an ass in here but I like to think about both sides, thats just how I am. Like I said if they do go with the changes I'll be more than happy to accept them. If they don't, well then I guess we have to accept that as well.


I get what you're saying. But you had to know that if you said anything contrary to the majority in this conference that you were going to get blasted. Especially if it has to do with Satch. You've been around SA long enough to know that we're not really known for holding back.


Oh I know that's why I knew I had it coming
 
rstiger11
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by viperz2k5
Originally posted by rstiger11

Originally posted by viperz2k5


I like this idea, but I also kinda agree with those that disagree with this idea. The conferences should be named after something relevant to South America rather than a person. I always admired Satchmo-n-Dizzy and I wish him a speedy recovery. But new people to the game won't understand what a Satchmo or Dizzy league would be. Naga and Garuda in SE Asia makes sense because it pertains to SE Asia. If we want to rename the conferences in this league we should rename it to something relevent and honor Satchmo-n-Dizzy in another way. Perhaps name the trophy after him or do an annual Battle of the Leagues or something. As for renaming SA, perhaps Taco and Burrito Conference?


This is an ignorant statement.....I know what we could do! Rename USA Pro's 2 conferences Hamburger and Hot dog!

The fact is that I haven't seen much of a dissenting opinion. Most all agree that this would be a great thing to honor satch. I have to agree completely. This is a game. The league is South America Pro, but in this game the biggest thing that represents South America is Satch, himself. Therefore it would be very fitting.

Now if you are wanting it to be more realistic, then maybe we should just call it the Continental and American conferences. To be honest most sports leagues are named based on where they are located or here in the US by National and American. Real creative. But Taco and Burrito??? Come on man!

Hud can we ban this guy???? Please????

Honestly most stadiums nowadays are named after corporations that forked over cash. Calling our conferences Satchmo and Dizzy would be going back to the old days when they used to name things after people who actually made a great impact on that particular organization, franchise, or city. My High School's football field is named after the guy that took care of it for decades and I am very proud to have it named that. Will everyone know who the guy is??? No, but that gives me the opportunity to tell them and how he made an impact on our school and football team. Same goes for these conferences. Satch's legacy will live on through this gesture.

These names would be going back to sport at it's purest form.

GREAT IDEA


Did I say I'm against it? I only looked at what the people who are against it might think. Instead of calling me ignorant and trying to get me banned, how about you reread my post. As for the taco and burrito conferences, I just said it hypothetically since SA Pro has their unprofound love for tacos. You really think I would be want the conferences named after food? It's called a joke man lighten up. There are other names we could think of but honestly just because I played the devil's advocate a bit I should be banned? Very cute man. As I said in my last post, I respect Satchmo-n-Dizzy for all he has done for GLB and I wouldn't be against this idea but seriously if people can't speak their mind in this game without being banned, then I don't know what to say then.


LOL, no man, I didn't really think you should get banned from GLB. Calm down, your players and teams are safe. Now that I have relieved you of your nervous constipation I'll enlighten you as to why you were targeted....and it's not because of a dissenting opinion.

I would have have probably disagreed with most anything stated against the idea, BUT would normally at least respect an opinion if it was intelligently put. The fact that you threw "taco and burrito conferences" into the mix was just plain ridiculous and you needed to be smacked down for it. Now I still blatantly disagree with what you said as stated in my previous post, but just know that I have a good relationship with Hud and I knew he would find it humorous with me being so dramatic and asking for a ban.....and that a ban would not ensue.

You have a right to your opinion (ignorance), and I have a right to be offended by ignorant comments....because all South Americans love to eat tacos and burritos and want to be identified for that love, right?
Last edited Dec 18, 2008 06:23:39
 
viperz2k5
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rstiger11
Originally posted by viperz2k5

Originally posted by rstiger11


Originally posted by viperz2k5



I like this idea, but I also kinda agree with those that disagree with this idea. The conferences should be named after something relevant to South America rather than a person. I always admired Satchmo-n-Dizzy and I wish him a speedy recovery. But new people to the game won't understand what a Satchmo or Dizzy league would be. Naga and Garuda in SE Asia makes sense because it pertains to SE Asia. If we want to rename the conferences in this league we should rename it to something relevent and honor Satchmo-n-Dizzy in another way. Perhaps name the trophy after him or do an annual Battle of the Leagues or something. As for renaming SA, perhaps Taco and Burrito Conference?


This is an ignorant statement.....I know what we could do! Rename USA Pro's 2 conferences Hamburger and Hot dog!

The fact is that I haven't seen much of a dissenting opinion. Most all agree that this would be a great thing to honor satch. I have to agree completely. This is a game. The league is South America Pro, but in this game the biggest thing that represents South America is Satch, himself. Therefore it would be very fitting.

Now if you are wanting it to be more realistic, then maybe we should just call it the Continental and American conferences. To be honest most sports leagues are named based on where they are located or here in the US by National and American. Real creative. But Taco and Burrito??? Come on man!

Hud can we ban this guy???? Please????

Honestly most stadiums nowadays are named after corporations that forked over cash. Calling our conferences Satchmo and Dizzy would be going back to the old days when they used to name things after people who actually made a great impact on that particular organization, franchise, or city. My High School's football field is named after the guy that took care of it for decades and I am very proud to have it named that. Will everyone know who the guy is??? No, but that gives me the opportunity to tell them and how he made an impact on our school and football team. Same goes for these conferences. Satch's legacy will live on through this gesture.

These names would be going back to sport at it's purest form.

GREAT IDEA


Did I say I'm against it? I only looked at what the people who are against it might think. Instead of calling me ignorant and trying to get me banned, how about you reread my post. As for the taco and burrito conferences, I just said it hypothetically since SA Pro has their unprofound love for tacos. You really think I would be want the conferences named after food? It's called a joke man lighten up. There are other names we could think of but honestly just because I played the devil's advocate a bit I should be banned? Very cute man. As I said in my last post, I respect Satchmo-n-Dizzy for all he has done for GLB and I wouldn't be against this idea but seriously if people can't speak their mind in this game without being banned, then I don't know what to say then.


LOL, no man, I didn't really think you should get banned from GLB. Calm down, your players and teams are safe. Now that I have relieved you of your nervous constipation I'll enlighten you as to why you were targeted....and it's not because of a dissenting opinion.

I would have have probably disagreed with most anything stated against the idea, BUT would normally at least respect an opinion if it was intelligently put. The fact that you threw "taco and burrito conferences" into the mix was just plain ridiculous and you needed to be smacked down for it. Now I still blatantly disagree with what you said as stated in my previous post, but just know that I have a good relationship with Hud and I knew he would find it humorous with me being so dramatic and asking for a ban.....and that a ban would not ensue.

You have a right to your opinion (ignorance), and I have a right to be offended by ignorant comments....because all South Americans love to eat tacos and burritos and want to be identified for that love, right?

Right!
 
Link
 
I don't want to be called Taco and Burrito...hope you were not serious. I do understand you point about being something relevant to SA.
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Something in Spanish would be fitting. May I suggest "East" and "West"?

But honestly, Alpha and Zeta work just fine...
 
viperz2k5
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
I don't want to be called Taco and Burrito...hope you were not serious. I do understand you point about being something relevant to SA.


It was meant to be a joke but I guess took it seriously lol.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
Something in Spanish would be fitting. May I suggest "East" and "West"?

But honestly, Alpha and Zeta work just fine...


Spain has an East and West? It looks round to me....
 
DWetzel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JuniorMcSpiffy
Originally posted by taurran

Something in Spanish would be fitting. May I suggest "East" and "West"?

But honestly, Alpha and Zeta work just fine...


Spain has an East and West? It looks round to me....


Diet Coke burns when spurted out my nose. I found this out thanks to this post. Thank you.

Now, on to the topic: this would be a very cool and fun way to honor him, and I have nothing but good things to say about it.

PS: Hockey was way funner when the Campbell Conference and the Prince of Wales conference got it on in the All-Star game. And I have no idea who either of those people are.
 
hud
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
I don't want to be called Taco and Burrito...hope you were not serious. I do understand you point about being something relevant to SA.


How about "Kai Lovers" and "Kai Haters"...

But really keep the comments coming, even if it is just - sounds good or I don't like it.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.