Originally posted by Tareton
Name me any other pass play if run 43 times in a game that will result in 43 completions, averaging 5.5+ yards a completion. Let me translate that all for the mathematically impaired. That will result in at worst 28 (assuming your kicker is worth a shit, but that is a whole other thread) points and quite honestly one or two of those will be broke for a TD, just nothing you can do to stop that occasionally happening.
Show me the other play. Any other play. It isn't in the game. This is the only play that teams need to have in their playbook and they WILL gain yards and score TD's as long as their team is in a competitive level range. No other play comes with that guarantee. Not the strong I Right, not the I form Left, not the single back slam, nothing.
As a matter of fact I am a big proponent of the diminishing returns rule being applied to certain plays. This being one of them. If you continuously run the same play over and over even the most obtuse defense will begin to see a pattern and react differently on the field. Just like the mouse and the cheese experiment. That little furry rodent doesn't have to be shocked 43 times to learn to use a different path. I am not talking about the second time you see a formation you will automatically shut it down. But the 30th time you see a play it should be well within your capability to recognize and react to it. I think that would placate both sides of this argument. It allows the play to remain in the game while limiting the abuse of the play by lazy owners/GM's that do use a cheap way out of having to plan for another team by calling the same play, with its yardage and TD guarantee, 43 times.
Word!
Name me any other pass play if run 43 times in a game that will result in 43 completions, averaging 5.5+ yards a completion. Let me translate that all for the mathematically impaired. That will result in at worst 28 (assuming your kicker is worth a shit, but that is a whole other thread) points and quite honestly one or two of those will be broke for a TD, just nothing you can do to stop that occasionally happening.
Show me the other play. Any other play. It isn't in the game. This is the only play that teams need to have in their playbook and they WILL gain yards and score TD's as long as their team is in a competitive level range. No other play comes with that guarantee. Not the strong I Right, not the I form Left, not the single back slam, nothing.
As a matter of fact I am a big proponent of the diminishing returns rule being applied to certain plays. This being one of them. If you continuously run the same play over and over even the most obtuse defense will begin to see a pattern and react differently on the field. Just like the mouse and the cheese experiment. That little furry rodent doesn't have to be shocked 43 times to learn to use a different path. I am not talking about the second time you see a formation you will automatically shut it down. But the 30th time you see a play it should be well within your capability to recognize and react to it. I think that would placate both sides of this argument. It allows the play to remain in the game while limiting the abuse of the play by lazy owners/GM's that do use a cheap way out of having to plan for another team by calling the same play, with its yardage and TD guarantee, 43 times.
Word!




haha
























