User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
GmanV2
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tareton
Name me any other pass play if run 43 times in a game that will result in 43 completions, averaging 5.5+ yards a completion. Let me translate that all for the mathematically impaired. That will result in at worst 28 (assuming your kicker is worth a shit, but that is a whole other thread) points and quite honestly one or two of those will be broke for a TD, just nothing you can do to stop that occasionally happening.

Show me the other play. Any other play. It isn't in the game. This is the only play that teams need to have in their playbook and they WILL gain yards and score TD's as long as their team is in a competitive level range. No other play comes with that guarantee. Not the strong I Right, not the I form Left, not the single back slam, nothing.

As a matter of fact I am a big proponent of the diminishing returns rule being applied to certain plays. This being one of them. If you continuously run the same play over and over even the most obtuse defense will begin to see a pattern and react differently on the field. Just like the mouse and the cheese experiment. That little furry rodent doesn't have to be shocked 43 times to learn to use a different path. I am not talking about the second time you see a formation you will automatically shut it down. But the 30th time you see a play it should be well within your capability to recognize and react to it. I think that would placate both sides of this argument. It allows the play to remain in the game while limiting the abuse of the play by lazy owners/GM's that do use a cheap way out of having to plan for another team by calling the same play, with its yardage and TD guarantee, 43 times.


Word!
 
mavdaddy22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chef17
Originally posted by mavdaddy22

here is my point exactly taken from a play run during the champ. game.. offense went with 3 WR (the WR screen "setup" alignment, lol) but south town chose to no go with a 3rd CB, the WR could block the CB but he was no match for the LB and the play was shut down to perfection... defensive AI 101... so now everybody stop going to nickel and dime against my team and just let us throw bombs all day haha

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=286795&pbp_id=12698948


Not taking any side in the WR screen argument, but that play just looks like the WR couldnt hold his block.


of course he could not hold his block on the LB, because he was blocking the CB... thats why the play works against weak CBs because if you have a strong WR, then he can block 2 cbs... (really he just blocks 1 and the other one gets stuck... its almost like a pick play into the flat rather than a screen) but a LB will make the play 9 out of 10 times.. to where a CB make it maybe 4 out of 10....

you can also have youre de's drop back into coverage and ive seen them spread out and make the play.
Last edited Dec 17, 2008 14:58:11
 
mavdaddy22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tareton
Name me any other pass play if run 43 times in a game that will result in 43 completions, averaging 5.5+ yards a completion. Let me translate that all for the mathematically impaired. That will result in at worst 28 (assuming your kicker is worth a shit, but that is a whole other thread) points and quite honestly one or two of those will be broke for a TD, just nothing you can do to stop that occasionally happening.

Show me the other play. Any other play. It isn't in the game. This is the only play that teams need to have in their playbook and they WILL gain yards and score TD's as long as their team is in a competitive level range. No other play comes with that guarantee. Not the strong I Right, not the I form Left, not the single back slam, nothing.

As a matter of fact I am a big proponent of the diminishing returns rule being applied to certain plays. This being one of them. If you continuously run the same play over and over even the most obtuse defense will begin to see a pattern and react differently on the field. Just like the mouse and the cheese experiment. That little furry rodent doesn't have to be shocked 43 times to learn to use a different path. I am not talking about the second time you see a formation you will automatically shut it down. But the 30th time you see a play it should be well within your capability to recognize and react to it. I think that would placate both sides of this argument. It allows the play to remain in the game while limiting the abuse of the play by lazy owners/GM's that do use a cheap way out of having to plan for another team by calling the same play, with its yardage and TD guarantee, 43 times.


now that IS a good idea... this should be inserted for ANY play.. but ive seen the screen get thrown to the inside, ive seen the WR drop the ball, it is rarely worth more than a five yard gain if its run to the short side.. and i think its a good play for the offense because it can keep the D for going nickel or dime every time you bring out 3 wrs.. but i preach that my WRs all have strength over 35, because if you think about how this game is set up.. if you get 2 CBs with 25 strength.. then mathmatically a WR with a 40 strength will be able to block one and hold the other for just as long as you need for that play to work... if you get your CB's strenth in the 40s then he simply wont be able to block him
 
Tareton
offline
Link
 
Very true Mav, high strength WR's I cna understand holding up a pile a bit more than the typical 15 strength 8 blocking WR that makes the play. I don't get as upset when teams insert a TE into the WR slot to make the block because that is just good game planning and taking advantage of your teams strengths. I also concede that you can slow down the screen with different approaches on defense and I have had both successes and failures this year on the several teams I DC for. I still hold firm to the statement it is the single most unbalanced play in the game and it is being abused.
 
missnlife
offline
Link
 
<---uses backup TE as WR3.

Against under-developed(Str-wise) CBs, he could probably legitimately hold his own against 2 CBs at a time. Clearly, ST knows that more goes into a CB than Spd/Agi....and at least 1 CB was able to get off the block most of the time.
 
chef17
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mavdaddy22
Originally posted by chef17

Originally posted by mavdaddy22


here is my point exactly taken from a play run during the champ. game.. offense went with 3 WR (the WR screen "setup" alignment, lol) but south town chose to no go with a 3rd CB, the WR could block the CB but he was no match for the LB and the play was shut down to perfection... defensive AI 101... so now everybody stop going to nickel and dime against my team and just let us throw bombs all day haha

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=286795&pbp_id=12698948


Not taking any side in the WR screen argument, but that play just looks like the WR couldnt hold his block.


of course he could not hold his block on the LB, because he was blocking the CB... thats why the play works against weak CBs because if you have a strong WR, then he can block 2 cbs... (really he just blocks 1 and the other one gets stuck... its almost like a pick play into the flat rather than a screen) but a LB will make the play 9 out of 10 times.. to where a CB make it maybe 4 out of 10....

you can also have youre de's drop back into coverage and ive seen them spread out and make the play.


My point was that we need more examples to see your point clearly. Showing one example where the LB makes the play does not mean that the wide receiver still wont block him most of the time.
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tareton
Name me any other pass play if run 43 times in a game that will result in 43 completions, averaging 5.5+ yards a completion. Let me translate that all for the mathematically impaired. That will result in at worst 28 (assuming your kicker is worth a shit, but that is a whole other thread) points and quite honestly one or two of those will be broke for a TD, just nothing you can do to stop that occasionally happening.

Show me the other play. Any other play. It isn't in the game. This is the only play that teams need to have in their playbook and they WILL gain yards and score TD's as long as their team is in a competitive level range. No other play comes with that guarantee. Not the strong I Right, not the I form Left, not the single back slam, nothing.

As a matter of fact I am a big proponent of the diminishing returns rule being applied to certain plays. This being one of them. If you continuously run the same play over and over even the most obtuse defense will begin to see a pattern and react differently on the field. Just like the mouse and the cheese experiment. That little furry rodent doesn't have to be shocked 43 times to learn to use a different path. I am not talking about the second time you see a formation you will automatically shut it down. But the 30th time you see a play it should be well within your capability to recognize and react to it. I think that would placate both sides of this argument. It allows the play to remain in the game while limiting the abuse of the play by lazy owners/GM's that do use a cheap way out of having to plan for another team by calling the same play, with its yardage and TD guarantee, 43 times.


Not to mention the exploit is not the play as much as the blocking that takes place. Anytime a WR can block 2 CBs and a FS or 3 CBs on one play that is a problem
 
mavdaddy22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tareton
Very true Mav, high strength WR's I cna understand holding up a pile a bit more than the typical 15 strength 8 blocking WR that makes the play. I don't get as upset when teams insert a TE into the WR slot to make the block because that is just good game planning and taking advantage of your teams strengths. I also concede that you can slow down the screen with different approaches on defense and I have had both successes and failures this year on the several teams I DC for. I still hold firm to the statement it is the single most unbalanced play in the game and it is being abused.


i think that the idea of a defense jumping on a play that has been run more than 2 or 3 times is a great idea.. but i also think that defensively strength is HIGHLY under valued.. especially at CB and LB... everyone wants the speedster that can get to the ball quick and they forget that STRENGTH is very important for speed, agility, tackling... and it also helps recover stamina quicker... i have a WR with 36 strength and he probably had 25-30 pancakes last year, and mite have had over 30 this year.. and thats with an 18 blocking... the best cbs that i see are ones with really high strength, it also gives them the ability to jump higher and be more aggressive in the coverage game..

i think the screenplay was put in for all the ppl that just dump all of their sp's into speed and agility and dont bother with the other vital stats that put together a solid football player.. one thing that i think needs to be fixed is all the DE's in the league with 70 speed 85 agility and 50 strenth.. they get 50-60 sacks a year with vision in the 30's, tackling in the low 40's and other stats like confidence untouched.. i think if anything they DE problem is a bigger joke than the wr screen... but for the guy that wanted to see the plays where the screen was stopped, i can go thru my games and pull out a bunch, but that would just be giving gameplanning away, lol..

i think the bottom line is that as much as we would love REAL football players out there making plays and doing their job.. the bottom line is that these games are simmed by a system that uses whatever mathmatical formula bort came up with to determine how games are won and lost and how players react to certain plays... but there are no REAL players and we have no REAL control over these "dots" that are running around... we can do our best to put them where we want but we cant make the play for them, i think everyone should just enjoy this game for what it is.. a MMORPG about football.... and realize that there will be glitches in the system NO MATTER WHAT WE do. if we fix the wr screen so it NEVER works, then we'll all just be talking about something else at this time next season..

there is no such thing as perfection (except for my girlfriend's rack ) and this game is a perfect example... someone will ALWAYS be unsatisfied.. no matter what
 
tackleb0x
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cruzi

If it's an exploit, then other teams would be beating us with it. They're not, and it's not because they refuse to use it.


Other teams have respect for others not to use the same play over and over just because the defensive AI doesnt cover it correctly and all get stuck trying to path thru the WR3.

 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
WR SCREEN SHENNANIGANS FTW!
 
missnlife
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superpunk
WR SCREEN SHENNANIGANS FTW!


FTL, actually.
 
mavdaddy22
offline
Link
 
i can post about 4 or 5 plays from a conf championship in canada AAA where i have a player and the WR screen got stopped every single time our team tried to run it.. ill post them..
 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by missnlife
Originally posted by superpunk

WR SCREEN SHENNANIGANS FTW!


FTL, actually.


Good point.

Circle gets the square.
 
mavdaddy22
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=286709&pbp_id=12745941

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=286709&pbp_id=12746433

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=234094&pbp_id=9602856

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=234094&pbp_id=9604735

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=234094&pbp_id=9608407


this was just two different games that i looked at, however in the case of my own team, which has wr's with very good speed there were way more positive plays from the screen then there were stops...
 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
From the exact same (1 game - Panama Reds vs. death knights) game...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=234094&pbp_id=9602822

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=234094&pbp_id=9603372

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=234094&pbp_id=9603708

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=234094&pbp_id=9603818

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=234094&pbp_id=9604451

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=234094&pbp_id=9604654

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=234094&pbp_id=9606121

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=234094&pbp_id=9606712

So um....lol
Last edited Dec 18, 2008 12:41:17
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.