Originally posted by gabrielrockman
Yeah, eventually the defense would realize "hey, we shouldn't be in a 3-4 and pass-rushing, we should be in a 4-3 focusing on the run .... our defensive coordinator is incompetent, let's fire him"
So I guess Bort needs to program something in that makes horribly bad coordinators, coaches, and GMs get fired, right?
Heck, even the Detroit Lions (who would not be able to stop a play, even if you ran it 71 times in a row against them) were eventually bright enough to fire Matt Millen.
This game is not realistic. If you do a bad job, you still get to keep your job.
Your last sentence is all-too-true.
However, I think you gravely understate Detroit. They are professionals, after all. Were they incapable of stopping the same play over and over again, Childress/Smith/McCarthy would run plays over and over. Sure, a team might run something like 60-70% of the time, but they do it using a wide variety of plays. An NFL player who sees the same thing over and over will read, react, and anticipate that play much quicker each successive time.
Part of the reason play-action passes work so well!
Yeah, eventually the defense would realize "hey, we shouldn't be in a 3-4 and pass-rushing, we should be in a 4-3 focusing on the run .... our defensive coordinator is incompetent, let's fire him"
So I guess Bort needs to program something in that makes horribly bad coordinators, coaches, and GMs get fired, right?
Heck, even the Detroit Lions (who would not be able to stop a play, even if you ran it 71 times in a row against them) were eventually bright enough to fire Matt Millen.
This game is not realistic. If you do a bad job, you still get to keep your job.
Your last sentence is all-too-true.
However, I think you gravely understate Detroit. They are professionals, after all. Were they incapable of stopping the same play over and over again, Childress/Smith/McCarthy would run plays over and over. Sure, a team might run something like 60-70% of the time, but they do it using a wide variety of plays. An NFL player who sees the same thing over and over will read, react, and anticipate that play much quicker each successive time.
Part of the reason play-action passes work so well!
Last edited Dec 4, 2008 23:55:39






























