User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > This is Garbage, Just About Quit Today, FIX IT!!!!
Page:
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gabrielrockman
Yeah, eventually the defense would realize "hey, we shouldn't be in a 3-4 and pass-rushing, we should be in a 4-3 focusing on the run .... our defensive coordinator is incompetent, let's fire him"

So I guess Bort needs to program something in that makes horribly bad coordinators, coaches, and GMs get fired, right?

Heck, even the Detroit Lions (who would not be able to stop a play, even if you ran it 71 times in a row against them) were eventually bright enough to fire Matt Millen.

This game is not realistic. If you do a bad job, you still get to keep your job.


Your last sentence is all-too-true.

However, I think you gravely understate Detroit. They are professionals, after all. Were they incapable of stopping the same play over and over again, Childress/Smith/McCarthy would run plays over and over. Sure, a team might run something like 60-70% of the time, but they do it using a wide variety of plays. An NFL player who sees the same thing over and over will read, react, and anticipate that play much quicker each successive time.

Part of the reason play-action passes work so well!
Last edited Dec 4, 2008 23:55:39
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins

I tend to agree with this, on the whole. GLB's all about connections.


Yep. Oh well. In the meantime, the OP is about teams running the same plays over and over. And it's not like Bort's gonna get paged directly because the OP demands his attention. But the complaint is legitimate (even if his defensive tactics contributed). And it's something that will only get heard (the suggestions about adding accruing %penalties against teams running the same plays, or other ideas to prevent it) when there's like tens of threads about it on the suggestions board and people are jamming the lines with complaints etc.

Plus, with Bort programming future implementations, then these kinds of suggestions probably wont be seen for another season or two. Not something I dont think Bort will tonight create a program for.
Last edited Dec 4, 2008 23:58:12
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by cdcollins


I tend to agree with this, on the whole. GLB's all about connections.


Yep. Oh well. In the meantime, the OP is about teams running the same plays over and over. And it's not like Bort's gonna get paged directly because the OP demands his attention. But the complaint is legitimate (even if his defensive tactics contributed). And it's something that will only get heard (the suggestions about adding accruing %penalties against teams running the same plays, or other ideas to prevent it) when there's like tens threads about it on the suggestions board and people are jamming the lines with complaints etc.

Plus, with Bort programming future implementations, then these kinds of suggestions probably wont be seen for another season or two. Not something I dont think Bort will tonight create a program for.


Totally agree. It's a shame, too, because these things are what would accelerate this game getting out of Beta. Sure, things like "Fame" and such are great, but I'd like to solidify the gameplay before working on the extra-curriculars. I'm sure Bort and I would disagree. And it leads to the result you just described.

And I apologize for steering this so far off-topic.
Last edited Dec 4, 2008 23:59:00
 
GoVikings16
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1570359
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gabrielrockman
Yeah, eventually the defense would realize "hey, we shouldn't be in a 3-4 and pass-rushing, we should be in a 4-3 focusing on the run .... our defensive coordinator is incompetent, let's fire him"

So I guess Bort needs to program something in that makes horribly bad coordinators, coaches, and GMs get fired, right?

Heck, even the Detroit Lions (who would not be able to stop a play, even if you ran it 71 times in a row against them) were eventually bright enough to fire Matt Millen.

This game is not realistic. If you do a bad job, you still get to keep your job.


Umm, the ONLY reason why Millen was fired was because a rift developed in the press between Ford Sr. and Jr.

When asked about the situation Ford Jr. said if I was running the team he's have been fired.

Millen wasn't fired out of incompetence - he was fired because Ford Sr. was called out by his own son.

Think about it - Millen was signed to a new 5 year extension a couple years prior to that coming off of a stellar 24% win record in his first 5 seasons. Incompetence was never the issue behind Millen's firing - it was the rift between Sr. and Jr. and family loyalties being greater than the loyalty of Millen that ended up with Millen getting the heave ho.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins

Totally agree. It's a shame, too, because these things are what would accelerate this game getting out of Beta. Sure, things like "Fame" and such are great, but I'd like to solidify the gameplay before working on the extra-curriculars. I'm sure Bort and I would disagree. And it leads to the result you just described.


I find that the most difficult thing to resolve in myself as a customer. Is that dilemma where it's Bort's game and he wants to do what he wants to do, what he wants this game to be, what things he wants to implement---because in his and DD's and Thorn's (etc) minds they believe/think that's what will make the game good. Meanwhile, you have plenty of customers who think/believe that there are other suggestions and ideas out there that NEED to be implemented as a priority, because they feel that's what will make the game better.

But that's the dilemma in yourself, as a suggestor, as a customer. Where, IF (keyword: if) you know you're right about something, about how some idea will help, or is better than another idea, you have no real power or influence even as a customer, and there's a point where you just have to sigh, give up suggesting, and just keep playing the game they decide they want it to be.

Im not talking about even big drastic changes. But things like how "fame" or other RPG elements might be taxi'd in quickly, while core problems holding the game back and are more urgent, get held back.

If Bort ever did hire a crew of programmers, then perhaps there would be a better process, and a better management of ideas and programming priorities. Where he could implement a whole bunch of them together by delegating tasks to different programmers etc.



 
TheNastiest
offline
Link
 
Everytime someone gets their ass kicked on here its the Games/Bort's fault and they threaten to quit.

You know what? Fuck it just QUIT!

OMG They ran the same running play over and over again and my team wasnt able to stop it! This is BS!

Stop bitching and do what the rest of us OC's & 'DC's do and go watch some film from multiple teams in all different leagues and find out what you did wrong and what others have done right. Cause a little hard work goes a long way on here.

Its incredible how much whining goes on here from people that clearly dont know what the hell they are doing when it comes to gameplanning. So when they get rocked its the sims fault.

Cause if im scouting your team and i keep seeing teams run a play against you and all season long you havent been able to stop it. Guess what? I'm going to whore that play to death and now its up to you to figure out how to stop that play or you lose.

And no that play isnt unstoppable, cause plenty of teams can shut that run down. You just dont know how to do it cause you havent put in the effort to find out how to stop that run. You figure that if you blitz a bunch of people that will work. And thats piss poor gameplanning.

There are no unstoppable plays in this game and thats been proving time and time again. People bitch early and then a few teams later on find out how to stop them and everyone follows.

To many lazy ass people on this game! Bort needs to start banning people for crying over stupid shit like this.



Last edited Dec 5, 2008 00:15:15
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by cdcollins


Totally agree. It's a shame, too, because these things are what would accelerate this game getting out of Beta. Sure, things like "Fame" and such are great, but I'd like to solidify the gameplay before working on the extra-curriculars. I'm sure Bort and I would disagree. And it leads to the result you just described.


I find that the most difficult thing to resolve in myself as a customer. Is that dilemma where it's Bort's game and he wants to do what he wants to do, what he wants this game to be, what things he wants to implement---because in his and DD's and Thorn's (etc) minds they believe/think that's what will make the game good. Meanwhile, you have plenty of customers who think/believe that there are other suggestions and ideas out there that NEED to be implemented as a priority, because they feel that's what will make the game better.

But that's the dilemma in yourself, as a suggestor, as a customer. Where, IF (keyword: if) you know you're right about something, about how some idea will help, or is better than another idea, you have no real power or influence even as a customer, and there's a point where you just have to sigh, give up suggesting, and just keep playing the game they decide they want it to be.

Im not talking about even big drastic changes. But things like how "fame" or other RPG elements might be taxi'd in quickly, while core problems holding the game back and are more urgent, get held back.

If Bort ever did hire a crew of programmers, then perhaps there would be a better process, and a better management of ideas and programming priorities. Where he could implement a whole bunch of them together by delegating tasks to different programmers etc.


I have my doubts on whether Bort would ever give thought to hiring a crew of programmers. He's made it fairly clear that this is his baby, and I have a certain amount of respect for that. But it does make the game lag a fair amount in the number of new implementations. In a way, it's fine for now, because we need to see how our players will react with the 10-season decline. But after we see how this works, perhaps not so much.

I enjoy the product, but I'm less apt to spend less and less money on it the longer the core problems go unchanged. I'll still boost my guys, but I may restrict the number of players I create.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
TheNastiest...

Much of what you say is true.
But the thing is, the whole point about suggestions/bugs is that this game is supposedly a beta and Bort/DD have asserted that due to the nature of the game, changes and tweaks WILL be an on-going thing. That we as customers are really testing the product for exploits and problems for them to correct so that they are no longer bugs or exploits.

 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins

I enjoy the product, but I'm less apt to spend less and less money on it the longer the core problems go unchanged. I'll still boost my guys, but I may restrict the number of players I create.


What you said there is perfectly stated in a nut-shell. Around season 2 I saw plenty of future problems that will occur in GLB and all my friends left the game seeing it too. But I held on just like you....holding out just in hopes that the game does evolve into the potential that is there. So 4 seasons later, im still hanging in there, but that's also 4 seasons worth of time where many of the core problems are still there and havent even been properly addressed. Or more focus has been spent on superficial things. Or, more time has been spent creating the Baseball game instead of fixing this game first. I've gone nuts creating players, but Im not sure how long I will be a booster. Or how many players I retain. Im still waiting it out to see the evolution of this game first before I commit.

 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheNastiest
Everytime someone gets their ass kicked on here its the Games/Bort's fault and they threaten to quit.

You know what? Fuck it just QUIT!

OMG They ran the same running play over and over again and my team wasnt able to stop it! This is BS!

Stop bitching and do what the rest of us OC's & 'DC's do and go watch some film from multiple teams in all different leagues and find out what you did wrong and what others have done right. Cause a little hard work goes a long way on here.

Its incredible how much whining goes on here from people that clearly dont know what the hell they are doing when it comes to gameplanning. So when they get rocked its the sims fault.

Cause if im scouting your team and i keep seeing teams run a play against you and all season long you havent been able to stop it. Guess what? I'm going to whore that play to death and now its up to you to figure out how to stop that play or you lose.

And no that play isnt unstoppable, cause plenty of teams can shut that run down. You just dont know how to do it cause you havent put in the effort to find out how to stop that run. You figure that if you blitz a bunch of people that will work. And thats piss poor gameplanning.


To many lazy ass people on this game! Bort needs to start banning people for crying over stupid shit like this.


Harvard graduate, IMO.

You might say this, but without the ability to make in-game adjustments, you're stuck with one gameplan, one pre-programmed set of inputs and outputs. Unless a defense is made up of the stupidest people alive, they're going to see a pattern developing in front of them: "Hmmm, every time they run Power-I, they run off the RT. Screw this, I'm just going to aim toward the RT when they line up in Power-I".

And before you claim that I'm whining, I've upset 2 teams with my own squad lately who thought they could run 60 times/game on us and have it work. Held one (who just upset the undefeated league leader, BTW) to its 3rd-lowest point total of the season. I know how to stop it. But if Bort wants to make this game anything like RL football, he needs to kill the exploits.
 
TheNastiest
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
TheNastiest...

Much of what you say is true.
But the thing is, the whole point about suggestions/bugs is that this game is supposedly a beta and Bort/DD have asserted that due to the nature of the game, changes and tweaks WILL be an on-going thing. That we as customers are really testing the product for exploits and problems for them to correct so that they are no longer bugs or exploits.



Running something over and over again isnt a exploit though. You see NFL teams do it plenty of times. Maybe not to the extreme that some teams do it on GLB, but if something is working teams will continue to use it and force you to either adjust or get dominated.

Its an exploit if no team in GLB can stop a play, but there is no play in this game that can't be stopped.

 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by cdcollins


I enjoy the product, but I'm less apt to spend less and less money on it the longer the core problems go unchanged. I'll still boost my guys, but I may restrict the number of players I create.


What you said there is perfectly stated in a nut-shell. Around season 2 I saw plenty of future problems that will occur in GLB and all my friends left the game seeing it too. But I held on just like you....holding out just in hopes that the game does evolve into the potential that is there. So 4 seasons later, im still hanging in there, but that's also 4 seasons worth of time where many of the core problems are still there and havent even been properly addressed. Or more focus has been spent on superficial things. Or, more time has been spent creating the Baseball game instead of fixing this game first. I've gone nuts creating players, but Im not sure how long I will be a booster. Or how many players I retain. Im still waiting it out to see the evolution of this game first before I commit.



There's certainly more out there like us, I believe.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheNastiest
Originally posted by GG

TheNastiest...

Much of what you say is true.
But the thing is, the whole point about suggestions/bugs is that this game is supposedly a beta and Bort/DD have asserted that due to the nature of the game, changes and tweaks WILL be an on-going thing. That we as customers are really testing the product for exploits and problems for them to correct so that they are no longer bugs or exploits.



Running something over and over again isnt a exploit though. You see NFL teams do it plenty of times. Maybe not to the extreme that some teams do it on GLB, but if something is working teams will continue to use it and force you to either adjust or get dominated.

Its an exploit if no team in GLB can stop a play, but there is no play in this game that can't be stopped.



That's the crux of dispute, bud.
Edit: And as I said above, we can't do in-game adjustments on GLB.

Last edited Dec 5, 2008 00:25:32
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Of course if you want to get heard, this is probably the wrong forum. I think admin ignores this forum until they see a thread that has over a certain number of posts.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.