User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Too many sacks - horrible blocking AI
Page:
 
CloudGT4
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lohengrin
What don't I get? Sacks are up this clearly up this year throughout every league - I don't think anybody can dispute that. OTs didn't all of a sudden suck in the transition from season 5 to season 6. I understand that DEs are forsaking certain skills to get Agility and Speed up to astronomical levels. what bothers me is that these DEs with low Strength and Tackling aren't getting turned into paste by high strength OTs, OGs, and FBs on running plays. There should be a downside to making such a one-dimensional player, and I don't see that to be the case


^ this
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Motiak
Originally posted by wikipedia

His strength and armspan allow him to be effective in both run- and pass-blocking, but perhaps his greatest asset is his athleticism - Pace's quickness of reflexes and speed are unmatched among NFL offensive linemen.



He ran a whopping 4.9 40 in his prime, so his speed was great for an OL but not great for an overall NFL player. Also, an agiile OT is different from an Agile CB or S. I would be willing to bet that if you had Orlando Pace perform agility and strength tests against some of the NFLs top CBs, HBs, LBs, and TEs, he would fair much more favorably in the strength tests.


 
Motiak
offline
Link
 
Oh, I know he's not fast in comparison with other positional players. I'm just trying to say that people who think you don't have to be fast or agile to be a lineman are wrong. As things work right now, I don't think it's very hard to build a solid OT, even if it isn't how you might think of an OT initially.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Motiak
61 or so.


Exactly. That is just stupid that you would need to build a high level OT with strength that low in order to have enough blocking and agility to block the DEs. OTs should be able to get by at around 85 strength, 70 blocking, 60 agility. Maybe giving up a sack here and there to the fast agile DEs with 50 - 60 strength, but also pancaking them regularly in the running game. Not a case where they get beaten on almost every single pass play then watching as those same DEs disengage from the block and make tackles on outside rushing plays.

 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Just swap out strength for blocking and you'll do fine. You don't need more than soft capped agility, just 90 blocking.
 
Motiak
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by Motiak

61 or so.


Exactly. That is just stupid that you would need to build a high level OT with strength that low in order to have enough blocking and agility to block the DEs. OTs should be able to get by at around 85 strength, 70 blocking, 60 agility. Maybe giving up a sack here and there to the fast agile DEs with 50 - 60 strength, but also pancaking them regularly in the running game. Not a case where they get beaten on almost every single pass play then watching as those same DEs disengage from the block and make tackles on outside rushing plays.



Well, I'm not going to argue against this in a suggestion thread. My main thing is that this is in bugs and I don't think it's a bug. There are builds to counter builds to counter builds, etc.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Motiak
Oh, I know he's not fast in comparison with other positional players. I'm just trying to say that people who think you don't have to be fast or agile to be a lineman are wrong. As things work right now, I don't think it's very hard to build a solid OT, even if it isn't how you might think of an OT initially.


I know it isn't that hard. But when I created an OT, I wanted to be able to build an OT. Not just a toon to counter other toons in the game. I can't do that the way the SIM works now. I have to have my OT with strength that is lower than 80% of the FBs in this game in order to have enough blocking and agility for competent pass protection.

 
mogs01gt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Motiak
Originally posted by mogs01gt

This isnt rock science people.

Geology?

LMAO good call! opps...

 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Just swap out strength for blocking and you'll do fine. You don't need more than soft capped agility, just 90 blocking.


Not if you are ROT and facing a very well built speed DE. I'm at 94 blocking and 57 agility on my ROT now so that he is effective for the time being. I'm going to take agility up to at least 61, however, because the DEs are only going to be adding more agility, speed, first step, shed block, and tunnel vision and I can't use protect SA.
 
mogs01gt
offline
Link
 
The only reason to keep raising strength and ignoring agility is to pad your Pancake stats. The Pancake SA needs to be on both Pass and Run blocking or removed from the game. If you want to keep pancakes, then there needs to be a stat that shows the number of sacks allowed by an offensive linemen

60 agility is pathetic for a RT. The tackles on the team I am on, both have strength above 80 and no pass blocking SAs. They have been giving up 5+ sacks a game.
Last edited Dec 5, 2008 12:48:42
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by Mat McBriar

Just swap out strength for blocking and you'll do fine. You don't need more than soft capped agility, just 90 blocking.


Not if you are ROT and facing a very well built speed DE. I'm at 94 blocking and 57 agility on my ROT now so that he is effective for the time being. I'm going to take agility up to at least 61, however, because the DEs are only going to be adding more agility, speed, first step, shed block, and tunnel vision and I can't use protect SA.


There are other SAs that will help you. My OT is a ROT as well, and he's only given up a few sacks all year (due to the TE bump bug)
 
MikieSoSmooth
offline
Link
 
I am afraid all the snot and tears produced by these threads are gonna short out the servers.
 
Lohengrin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mogs01gt
The only reason to keep raising strength and ignoring agility is to pad your Pancake stats. The Pancake SA needs to be on both Pass and Run blocking or removed from the game. If you want to keep pancakes, then there needs to be a stat that shows the number of sacks allowed by an offensive linemen

60 agility is pathetic for a RT. The tackles on the team I am on, both have strength above 80 and no pass blocking SAs. They have been giving up 5+ sacks a game.


This is a straw-man argument that has no bearing on this issue, and I don't understand why people keep bringing it up. Most people who are building pass-blocking OTs could care less about pancakes; stop projecting your own obsession with statistics on others
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mogs01gt
The only reason to keep raising strength and ignoring agility is to pad your Pancake stats. The Pancake SA needs to be on both Pass and Run blocking or removed from the game. If you want to keep pancakes, then there needs to be a stat that shows the number of sacks allowed by an offensive linemen

60 agility is pathetic for a RT. The tackles on the team I am on, both have strength above 80 and no pass blocking SAs. They have been giving up 5+ sacks a game.


The only reason to have strength above 80 is to have an OT built like a real OT!!!

OTs are typically some of the strongest players in the NFL. I gaurantee they do much better in the 225 bench rep test compared to peers than the cone drills or short shuttle drills.

 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar


There are other SAs that will help you. My OT is a ROT as well, and he's only given up a few sacks all year (due to the TE bump bug)


Have your owner schedule a friendly against a team like the Alpine Golfers and match your OT up on julius dee or the playboy players club and match him up on valandil saralonde 1 on 1.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.