User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America AAA Leagues > South America AAA #1 > NFC South = Best Division in the NFL?
Page:
 
masqu3rade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dook1e
Originally posted by masqu3rade



Food for thought, and a little strange:
NFC South is dominating the comparable teams match up(i.e., Panthers beat Arizona, Saint Louis, and Chicago all teams that the NFC East has lost to this year). Surprisingly, the teams that the NFC East seems to be losing to the NFC South is beating consistently.

NFC South also has the better overall and conference records.

However, the few teams the NFC South has lost to have been in the NFC East, albeit in very close games:
Falcons lost to the Eagles
Bucs lost to the Cowboys
Saints lost to the Redskins
Panthers play the Giants at the end of the year


NFC East will boast of head-to-head, NFC South the better consistency; Continue discussing.



How do you figure the NFC South is dominating the NFC East's comparable matchups? Please be a little more clear on that one....

Your second thing in bold..
Falcons got their ass handed to them by Philly
Bucs lost to a Romo-less Cowboys (HATE the Cowboys)
Redskins beat the Saints
Carolina won't get it done on the road in NY


A 13 point loss is not "getting your ass handed to you" in the first place; furthermore (HATE the Falcons), but you OBVIOUSLY didn't watch that game. The score was 20-14 when ATL turned the ball over with a little over 2 minutes left, and without any timeouts they couldn't challenge the debatable muffing the punt call.

Romo or no Romo, claiming to be without a player is a weak argument. The Panthers won two in a row without Steve Smith then lost the next one with him back. If the Cowboys have a terrible backup it's no one's fault but their own, Brady has been out all season but the Patriots are still making a playoff push.

No excuse for the Redskins not blowing out the 'obviously inferior NFC South Saints', but having to win it on their last drive?

I don't think the Panthers and Giants will be a real matchup; Giants should have locked up the #1 seed probably won't play their starters all of the last two games...
 
Pepperz90
offline
Link
 
I like masgu3rade's argument because I can not make one as good as his(or anywhere near) on my own.

Originally posted by stnaigkroywen
Originally posted by Pepperz90

Originally posted by dook1e



Carolina won't get it done on the road in NY



Any given sunday.


The Giants learned their lesson against the Browns this season, they will overlook no one from now on. Carolina will put up a fight, but the Gmen have too much power for the Panthers to keep up with.


btw, NFCE is still the best.



LOL. But those eagles can teach them a lesson instead huh? And now that Jacobs is out for who knows how long. There goes all their power. Jacobs and Bareass out. That limits their offense by... Half?
 
stnaigkroywen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pepperz90
I like masgu3rade's argument because I can not make one as good as his(or anywhere near) on my own.

Originally posted by stnaigkroywen

Originally posted by Pepperz90


Originally posted by dook1e




Carolina won't get it done on the road in NY



Any given sunday.


The Giants learned their lesson against the Browns this season, they will overlook no one from now on. Carolina will put up a fight, but the Gmen have too much power for the Panthers to keep up with.


btw, NFCE is still the best.



LOL. But those eagles can teach them a lesson instead huh? And now that Jacobs is out for who knows how long. There goes all their power. Jacobs and Bareass out. That limits their offense by... Half?


Browns also tought us a lesson in week 4, how many games did we win after that?

and we'll be fine, I'm not worried, you shouldnt be either . We'll beat teams just like we have 11 times before.
 
BigMark
offline
Link
 
Check out ESPN's power rankings ( http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/powerranking?season=2008&week=15&lpos=spotlight&lid=tab3pos1 )

NFC East Teams are 2 (NYG), 8 (DAL), 14 (PHI) and 18 (WAS) - avg postition 10.5
NFC South teams are 4 (CAR), 6 (TB), 11 (ATL) and 17 (NO) - avg postion 9.5

 
stnaigkroywen
offline
Link
 
The only way this can be settled is after the superbowl, then we'll know what div. had the best teams.
 
BigMark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stnaigkroywen
The only way this can be settled is after the superbowl, then we'll know what div. had the best teams.


no, that will just determine which division has the best team (singular).
 
Pepperz90
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stnaigkroywen
The only way this can be settled is after the superbowl, then we'll know what div. had the best teams.


Yeah, That means nothing. That was as bad as my Preseason post.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Pepperz90
Originally posted by stnaigkroywen

The only way this can be settled is after the superbowl, then we'll know what div. had the best teams.


Yeah, That means nothing. That was as bad as my Preseason post.


AFC North anyone?
 
Pepperz90
offline
Link
 
3rd, maybe 4th.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Pepperz90
3rd, maybe 4th.


1st come superbowl time though
 
masqu3rade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell
Originally posted by Pepperz90

3rd, maybe 4th.


1st come superbowl time though


I'd vote for the AFC North... If they had anyone other than the Bengals and the Browns...

Well, I take that back, if they had the Lions, Raiders, Chiefs, Seahawks, or Rams I still wouldn't vote for the AFC North.
 
stnaigkroywen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pepperz90
Originally posted by stnaigkroywen

The only way this can be settled is after the superbowl, then we'll know what div. had the best teams.


Yeah, That means nothing. That was as bad as my Preseason post.


bullshit, ya gotta figure that some NFCE and NFCS matchups are gonna happen in the playoffs, these are obviously the best 2 divisions, so I expect them to have the top teams in the playoffs. Whichever divisions play off teams do better, will prove what division is better.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by stnaigkroywen
Originally posted by Pepperz90

Originally posted by stnaigkroywen


The only way this can be settled is after the superbowl, then we'll know what div. had the best teams.


Yeah, That means nothing. That was as bad as my Preseason post.


bullshit, ya gotta figure that some NFCE and NFCS matchups are gonna happen in the playoffs, these are obviously the best 2 divisions, so I expect them to have the top teams in the playoffs. Whichever divisions play off teams do better, will prove what division is better.


Take a look how it stands now

1. Giants
2. Panthers
3. Vikings
4. Cardinals
5. Bucs
6. Cowboys

Vikings vs. Cowboys
Cardinals vs. Bucs

If the Bucs win they would play the giants unless the Cowgirls win then they would rematch for a 3rd time vs. the Bucs.
 
masqu3rade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stnaigkroywen
Originally posted by Pepperz90

Originally posted by stnaigkroywen


The only way this can be settled is after the superbowl, then we'll know what div. had the best teams.


Yeah, That means nothing. That was as bad as my Preseason post.


bullshit, ya gotta figure that some NFCE and NFCS matchups are gonna happen in the playoffs, these are obviously the best 2 divisions, so I expect them to have the top teams in the playoffs. Whichever divisions play off teams do better, will prove what division is better.


So then you meant to say, that it will be decided after the NFC Championship game; which I don't completely agree with, but your argument does have some merit. By saying Superbowl it just sounded like you meant the Giants would win and therefore NFC East would be the best. Which we have discussed before, hence, pepperz comment.

Ron also makes a good point though, unless the 5 and 6 seeds swap (or the 1 and 2) we couldn't have a Giants vs Bucs and Panthers vs Cowboys NFC semi. The only NFCE vs NFCS match up would be Giants vs Panthers. Which really only proves that either one of those teams dominates the other or they split the pair. Well could also be a Bucs vs Giants. But again that would only prove that either the Giants are really good or they aren't, nothing really about NFCE vs NFCS. Personal Opinion: This will never be decided, either you are for the NFCE or the NFCS, either way you aren't changing; barring a total melt down from all the teams in one of the conferences.
 
stnaigkroywen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by masqu3rade
Originally posted by stnaigkroywen

Originally posted by Pepperz90


Originally posted by stnaigkroywen



The only way this can be settled is after the superbowl, then we'll know what div. had the best teams.


Yeah, That means nothing. That was as bad as my Preseason post.


bullshit, ya gotta figure that some NFCE and NFCS matchups are gonna happen in the playoffs, these are obviously the best 2 divisions, so I expect them to have the top teams in the playoffs. Whichever divisions play off teams do better, will prove what division is better.


So then you meant to say, that it will be decided after the NFC Championship game; which I don't completely agree with, but your argument does have some merit. By saying Superbowl it just sounded like you meant the Giants would win and therefore NFC East would be the best. Which we have discussed before, hence, pepperz comment.

Ron also makes a good point though, unless the 5 and 6 seeds swap (or the 1 and 2) we couldn't have a Giants vs Bucs and Panthers vs Cowboys NFC semi. The only NFCE vs NFCS match up would be Giants vs Panthers. Which really only proves that either one of those teams dominates the other or they split the pair. Well could also be a Bucs vs Giants. But again that would only prove that either the Giants are really good or they aren't, nothing really about NFCE vs NFCS. Personal Opinion: This will never be decided, either you are for the NFCE or the NFCS, either way you aren't changing; barring a total melt down from all the teams in one of the conferences.


agree to disagree I guess
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.