User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
I issued a similar challenge a while back with the Strong I and I will do it here.

if you think you can dominate my team with the WR screen, BRING IT!
 
sgtjgarner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sgtjgarner
sorry maybe this is a better example, teams a lot closer (all the same game, there are more examples in game but thought those was good enough)

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=224377&pbp_id=7625781
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=224377&pbp_id=7625567
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=224377&pbp_id=7626039
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=224377&pbp_id=7626496
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=224377&pbp_id=7625781



in this game the other team ran the screen 10 times for a total of about 21 yards and a 0% td rate
 
msupoke
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bashman
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=2063

This team is currently #1 in EE AAA #2. They basically only use 4 plays.
1. Single Back HB Smash
2. Single Back WR Screen
3. Strong I OT
4. Strong I Medium Pass WR

In a few games they pretty much only used the first 2 plays. It's tough to adjust to that. I put my 2 best CBs on that side, had the FS in a Cover 2 look to help from over the top and tried bringing over the ROLB to stop the WR screen, but that opens up the HB Smash, and even bringing over the ROLB didn't help a lot. You stop the play once for a loss, but on the next play the WR goes off for 20+ plus yds. The WR Screen is definately too powerfull (especially in combination with the Single Back HB Smash). I probably used the wrong defenses too, but if the whole league fails to stop this play (with all kinds of defenses), then something is wrong.



It sounds as though they have the best team and a good OC. This is typical strategy. Find out the things you run well and run them. The best way to stop this is to have better players on the other side of the ball.
 
HANDSaLIVE
offline
Link
 
All I'm sayin is there needs to be a way for the defense to adjust to it once they have seen it more than a few times. The answer shouldn't be run this formation against this one play. That in itself shows theres a problem with the play. The quickest fix would be to have a tactics option where you can tell the CB to "watch for screens". That way he's atleast in some sort of position.
 
Link
 
The OP never answered my question: Please list all the defenses you tried to stop this play.


And for the guys who say that the defense doesn't have a way to adjust (like real life), let me make 2 points:

1.) The OFFENSE doesn't really have a way to adjust either. If they call screen pass 100% and you have a defense in there that stops it, then they are screwed for the entire game and have no chance to win. That is the danger of calling a play so much. In real life, if an offense called a play that wasn't working, they would't keep calling it over and over again anyways. The lack of perfect control is on BOTH sides of the ball, not just the offense. Ask anyone who went 100% off tackle run from the strong I against a team that could stop it when that play was thought to be unstoppable.

2.) The offense and defense DO have a way to adjust. There are actually a couple ways, but the easiest is to turn CPU assist on. It will scroll through offenses and defenses til it finds one that works and call it more often. Everyone knows of this way to ADJUST, but no one uses it.

Last edited Dec 2, 2008 11:31:45
 
sgtjgarner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HANDSaLIVE
All I'm sayin is there needs to be a way for the defense to adjust to it once they have seen it more than a few times. The answer shouldn't be run this formation against this one play. That in itself shows theres a problem with the play. The quickest fix would be to have a tactics option where you can tell the CB to "watch for screens". That way he's atleast in some sort of position.


ok that makes a little more since, its not really a bug just need more to defensive AI, which i can agree
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HANDSaLIVE
All I'm sayin is there needs to be a way for the defense to adjust to it once they have seen it more than a few times. The answer shouldn't be run this formation against this one play. That in itself shows theres a problem with the play. The quickest fix would be to have a tactics option where you can tell the CB to "watch for screens". That way he's atleast in some sort of position.


there is, it is called AUTO ADJUST. That is what it is there for, to ADJUST to the game being played. o_O
 
AD_SoDope
offline
Link
 
no its not...
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AD_MVP
no its not...


yes it is
 
HANDSaLIVE
offline
Link
 
The problem with auto adjust is that it adjusts EVERYTHING. It's not like it only fixes the problems and keeps doin what works. All autoadjust is is a free reign for the AI to shit on your gameplan.

Steelersindsider gimme a sec.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
^again I disagree but looks like we always will.
 
HANDSaLIVE
offline
Link
 
Also autoadjust is STILL not separate for offense and defense. I don't want my whole gameplan to change because of one thing.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by HANDSaLIVE
The problem with auto adjust is that it adjusts EVERYTHING. It's not like it only fixes the problems and keeps doin what works. All autoadjust is is a free reign for the AI to shit on your gameplan.

Steelersindsider gimme a sec.



If your defense is giving up TD after TD, then what is the harm?

Maybe you only need to use it for 1 game til you find a fix, then you have that fix from then on by calling it directly?

Or keep doing what what the OP did on offense. Just call WR screen 100% until someone stops it, then copy that defense. That is another option.
Last edited Dec 2, 2008 11:39:09
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HANDSaLIVE
Also autoadjust is STILL not separate for offense and defense. I don't want my whole gameplan to change because of one thing.


check it,

http://goallineblitz.com/game/compare_teams.pl?team1=5327&team2=5744

the owner is away right now but should be back any day now. send a challenge and throw a ton of WR-Screens my way and let's see if it is unstoppable.

maybe i will throw a ton also so you can hone your defense a bit.

try something different in each quarter
 
HANDSaLIVE
offline
Link
 
Sent the challenge.

Steelersinsider: Without getting into specifics from we basically run a bit of everything. I know in the game that it was ran repeatedly on us we used alot of cover 2, and then cover zero in goaline situations. Had a lot of 4and5 DB sets between the 20's. Mid and close coverages.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.