User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Have "Superstars" and "All-Pros"
Page:
 
Link
 
There already are superstars in GLB. This just gives every person who stinks at building but is good at paying a chance to buy their way into stardom.

What should happen IMO is mentioned in this thread - a new system to differentiate older players. I think new special abilities would be decent. If a player takes 10 seasons to start declining, he shouldn't stagnate after 4 seasons.
 
satandole666
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
This seems like a game breaker to me. We need more SA's, or advanced SA's tied each position that open up around level 30 to diversify the game.

Maybe even different attributes that also open around level 30 so everyone isn't just feeding their primaries and secondaries until each player looks exactly the same.

Superstars and All-Pros would turn this game into clown mode.


I'm not a big fan of the OP but I think this post has more merit.

A common theme in RPGs is new abilities or options opening up as you level. This might not be the best way to do it, but say level 1-7 you can only train the first two SAs in each tree. Level 8-15 the 2nd two. Level 16-23 the 3rd of both. Level 24-31 the 4th of both. Level 32+ you can train the last ability of both trees. Change the levels to your liking.

Also, for this to offer any differentiation a lot of the SAs will need a huge boost in effectiveness (to generate incentive to spend SPs in them). Choosing between which abilities to train or which tree to take should be a tough choice because both are equally good and very effective for what they are designed for. Unlike now where half of the SAs are a guessing game as to their effectiveness.

This might require a massive retooling the order of SAs, their effectiveness, and maybe even their base cost. Stats should be the base of every character, but how you invest in SAs in the long run should be how you set yourself apart IMO.
 
Link
 
I disagree with your idea about opening each of the 5. I think it would lead to less differentiation in the builds because it would limit players' options from the start.

Roll out a new set of SAs for higher level players who don't gain SP so fast and watch them try to figure out how to spend their SPs.
 
justafish2002
offline
Link
 
I think it would be better to just randomize the superstars in normal players and it's up to the agents to build them the right way.

These superstars will simply have a +10% play performance and +5% training.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve


we desperately need a way to make players more differentiated in the 30+ levels; this would be one idea that could work...



How would this make players more differentiated? All this would do is make some builds a little further advanced than others, but the same stats would still be getting pumped. This would not promote more varied builds in the slightest.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
This seems like a game breaker to me. We need more SA's, or advanced SA's tied each position that open up around level 30 to diversify the game.

Maybe even different attributes that also open around level 30 so everyone isn't just feeding their primaries and secondaries until each player looks exactly the same.

Superstars and All-Pros would turn this game into clown mode.


This would help promote more varied builds and make leveling past 30 a little bit better IMO.
 
satandole666
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by quantofsol2008
I disagree with your idea about opening each of the 5. I think it would lead to less differentiation in the builds because it would limit players' options from the start.

Roll out a new set of SAs for higher level players who don't gain SP so fast and watch them try to figure out how to spend their SPs.


From the start? I didn't think people recommending getting SAs until after level 24 or so? I said it might not be the best way.

I'd rather see the SAs unavailable until a later level anyway. Don't open then until level 20. This would prevent a ton of new players from recking builds early on as well.

So:
20-24 1st
25-29 2nd
30-34 3rd
35-39 4th
40+ 5th

Everyone can have comparable base stats. With new/improved effectiveness, SAs that are unlocked at later levels can really help a lot of players see improvement/differentiation. This is dependent on the SAs being effective and balanced though, which might be a bit much to ask.
 
Colin Mochrie
offline
Link
 
If this does get implemented, I am officially out. Since I only have about 2 players and would immediately become uncompetitive to those with the extra FP's to superstar boost.
 
flames54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Originally posted by TxSteve



we desperately need a way to make players more differentiated in the 30+ levels; this would be one idea that could work...



How would this make players more differentiated? All this would do is make some builds a little further advanced than others, but the same stats would still be getting pumped. This would not promote more varied builds in the slightest.



It would, because it would be a part of a complete game overhaul and only one of a number of solid additions.
 
Maddencoach
offline
Link
 
I'll tag him with the superstar just for the bonus and never boost him and just use him as one of my regular player
 
Capaneus
offline
Link
 
My only concern with this suggestion is that it would widen the disparity between the haves and the have nots. In the past, when asked about using FP to further upgrade Custom EQ, Bort said he was happy with the amount of flex needed to boost players and he didn't want to get greedy. I like the concept, but I'd never spend the money on it.
 
Unspoken
offline
Link
 
Offensive Line ftw.
 
GOLee
offline
Link
 
Wow. Flames' post hits epic status on the same day?

Does he just get to post directly in the Epic Suggestions board?
 
GOLee
offline
Link
 
Question.

Would you suggest that current players have the choice of being grand-fathered in at a prorated cost per level?

...otherwise there'd be a hell of a lot of retiring going on...
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Imo it's a good concept that needs cleaning up.
Look at it this way everyone...

Whether you have limited funds or not to buy FPs, if you wanted to create a QB today you have to spend 900 FPs compared to if you wanted to create a Guard which would cost you 300 FPs. That kind of scale of payment = scale of player existed from day 1 of GLB. And in principle is exactly the same as this Superstar tiered structure.

I dont see the reasoning behind statements like "this would ruin the boosting/player-market", or "if this gets implemented and my limited FP funds, i wouldnt play again"...etc, comments, considering that kind of "class system" exists already with all existing positions a person might want to create.

You'd just have included in that list "Superstar", how much extra it would cost to create, and that line saying how much is in demand...and it wouldnt look out of place, it wouldnt seem any different.

BUT...i do agree with people saying it shouldnt be too high a cost. Even 2x is too much. I dunno the right number, but I would think maybe if QB/RB/WR cost 900, then make superstar cost 1200. If it's a FB, then it would be 900. If it's a Guard it would be 600. In that sliding scale of 300 FPs that already exists. Ie, a superstar Guard is as costly as a normal FB. A superstar FB is as costly as a normal RB. That kind of thinking. Maybe???

And this would be evident also in other expenses of developing that player. Boosting, buying Custom EQT, and could incorporate AdvEQT and daily training costing more in salary etc.

Last edited Nov 28, 2008 18:17:00
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.