User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > A real fix to speed
Page:
 
johnny_bravo
offline
Link
 
Bort -- hoping you are still watching this thread.

Your comment on the first page about poorly built CBs and their whiny agents struck me as odd.

When you implement a code fix do you "release it to the wild" and have us test it for you as the first check to see how well your tweak worked, or do you have a few "test teams" built that you use to see if the game mechanics are working as you intended?

If you use us, that's obviously fine since this is a beta test community. But, I would argue that you'd get much better results from having two teams built that only exist as a test case for your code changes. You could build a prototype player for each position (not one that's a monster, but one that generally fits the way you think an 'average' player would look like at that position) and run a sim game between the two test teams each time you implement a fix.

As an extra layer of transparency you could open the builds of these players and post the game results of your tweaked settings to the change log. This would let you very publicly show what you are doing and why and simultaneously give all the whiny-assed agents out there who are looking for every possible exploit a reason to shut up and build a more balanced player instead of min/maxing everything.

I am sure there are people who will not like this idea because it will be providing a defacto build standard for players...so another way to handle this might be to give all the players the exact same number in every attribute..say 50. That way you could also very clearly see which attributes are too powerful in relation to others.

You've obviously done a great job putting all this game together so far, so maybe I wasted my time putting this recommendation together, but I figure it is worth it on the off chance that some of this is helpful to you.

-- John
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by johnny_bravo
Bort -- hoping you are still watching this thread.

Your comment on the first page about poorly built CBs and their whiny agents struck me as odd.
When you implement a code fix do you "release it to the wild" and have us test it for you as the first check to see how well your tweak worked, or do you have a few "test teams" built that you use to see if the game mechanics are working as you intended?


Bort has an entire Test Server which renders most of your post moot.
 
johnny_bravo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
Originally posted by johnny_bravo

Bort -- hoping you are still watching this thread.

Your comment on the first page about poorly built CBs and their whiny agents struck me as odd.
When you implement a code fix do you "release it to the wild" and have us test it for you as the first check to see how well your tweak worked, or do you have a few "test teams" built that you use to see if the game mechanics are working as you intended?


Bort has an entire Test Server which renders most of your post moot.


I'd say a test server renders about 1/2 of what I said moot. Does anyone except him see the results on what goes on in the test environment? If so, then I agree with you totally.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by johnny_bravo
Originally posted by Knick

Originally posted by johnny_bravo


Bort -- hoping you are still watching this thread.

Your comment on the first page about poorly built CBs and their whiny agents struck me as odd.
When you implement a code fix do you "release it to the wild" and have us test it for you as the first check to see how well your tweak worked, or do you have a few "test teams" built that you use to see if the game mechanics are working as you intended?


Bort has an entire Test Server which renders most of your post moot.


I'd say a test server renders about 1/2 of what I said moot. Does anyone except him see the results on what goes on in the test environment? If so, then I agree with you totally.


His test server is for his eyes alone. Works completely offline and everything.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Right now there are speed rushers on the right DE (weak side) and they are over powered. They blow by the Left OT so fast that he can't get a block on him. This is even happening with OT's with high values in block and "Protect".

Certainly the "protect" SA was ment to stop this, yet even with the boost to the SA it is still a problem.

In real life situations, teams put in [Speed] rushers in on passing downs, and [Strength] DE's on rushing downs.

In GLB there is no benifit(and some detriment) to putting a ST DE in.










 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by johnny_bravo
Bort -- hoping you are still watching this thread.

Your comment on the first page about poorly built CBs and their whiny agents struck me as odd.

When you implement a code fix do you "release it to the wild" and have us test it for you as the first check to see how well your tweak worked, or do you have a few "test teams" built that you use to see if the game mechanics are working as you intended?

-- John


I think the biggest problem is a change that people don't understand.

If for example, Bort were to release "Changes for next season" at the end of this season and it contained something like:

The logic for tackle will now include a greater strength/tackle modifier as well as a greater relative speed modifier. Translated this means you will need higher strength and tackle to ensure tackling for all positions next season. I expect this will directly affect those secondary positions with very low strength/tackle.

Strength/Blocking will now be a larger factor in the escaping and holding of blocks. It will be a greater part of the block mechanism.

Then had a preseason of maybe 4 games so people could actually play with the stuff a bit before the season, it would certainly be much easier to write off complainers as simply complainers. Right now a lot of people complain when surprised by changes that make their "star" players less than useful during the season.

PinTBC

 
Kavadas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I have tried to increase the value of strength and tackling, etc, in the past. All I get in return is 100 bug threads about how players miss too many tackles, because everyone's 20 tackling CB is god's gift to GLB.

Maybe I just need to let those go, but I also don't want to see power backs get 50 ypc all the time.

I'd like to add bump coverage for sure at some point, which would require strength for sure.


See, where you're going wrong is by giving a shit about a bunch of people with retarded builds while neglecting the basic game design itself.

So I guess you have to make the choice of:
a)Making the game less retarded; or
b)Keep yo moniez from people who put the retard in GLB.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

This is why I personally think Bort doesn't do dick or really cares about speed/agility owning this entire game. If he changed the attributes to be less absurd 90% of the builds in this game would be obsolete over night and the forums would erupt in the ultimate QQ fest from 'tards like Flames54 crying about how his all speed WR is getting pancaked at the line every single play. Or all of the morons crying about how power runners are all of the sudden obliterating defenses because they (the defense) lack the strength needed to deal with that type of player. It would take multiple seasons for defensive player builds to adjust to this kind of change; ergo it will never happen. Why do you think power runners were recently nerfed and that ridiculous "line of scrimmage" slowdown was added?

It was a retarded fix that doesn't even begin to address the root of anything.

Bort never gives any change he makes in this game time to correct itself. If he fixes strength to work properly and you get all of the QQ threads about defenses he'll just change it back. What's even more sad is that I'm certain he realizes it could take seasons before attribute balance manifests itself through changes because builds are permanent. If Bort actually cared about BETA TESTING THIS BETA GAME he would just give us the respecs so we could, oh, I don't know, BETA TEST THIS BETA PRODUCT. Instead we pay him for the "privilege" of beta testing and when he actually needs to fix something we paralyze him (and the game).

That's why after 6 six seasons this isn't fixed nor will it ever be fixed. Fixing it would cost Bort $$$.

That's why this game will never work properly.
Last edited Nov 24, 2008 21:02:13
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kavadas
[ Why do you think power runners were recently nerfed and that ridiculous "line of scrimmage" slowdown was added?

It was a retarded fix that doesn't even begin to address the root of anything.


I was actually believing that maybe the slowdown at the line of scrimmage was added because it makes at least some sense?

I won't however disagree with the respect comment being needed to really beta test this and get the game finished. It would certainly be significantly easier to check things out.

PinTBC
 
Kavadas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC

I was actually believing that maybe the slowdown at the line of scrimmage was added because it makes at least some sense?


...but the only time a runner would slow down is if his lane is currently occupied. It's not like a back hits an open crease and then slows down for no reason. Why would he? Sure, if the back is trying to avoid a tackle or makes a little contact it makes sense but the magical "slow down aura" of the defensive line doesn't make any sense unless it has an actual cause.

Originally posted by
I won't however disagree with the respect comment being needed to really beta test this and get the game finished. It would certainly be significantly easier to check things out.


Yeah, it'll never happen though because 99% of the player base is entirely against it (which sets this game back so tremendously IMO). Bort makes a change to something to make the game more sensical and it takes three or four seasons of player building just to confirm or deny a fix actually worked and in the meantime you have thousands of pissed off whiney morons QQing that they're absurdly stupid build which relies entirely on one or two attributes is now useless.

This game will just never work properly IMO. Bort has acquiesced to the whiners quite a few times and with that precedent set he's pretty much crippled any opportunity he's ever had to make this attribute system actually work and make sense.

And then there's the whole situation with leagues, parity, and competition. I've yet to see ideas on how to make that work sans instituting some giant BCS like ranking system which just pairs teams on the fly each "week" based on a number of variables.
Last edited Nov 25, 2008 05:14:53
 
sturge
offline
Link
 
I agree with a post made earlier. Only make major changes in the offseason. I would then allow EVERYONE (since its beta) to completely reassign their skill points to adjust to the changes during the offseason. Once the season starts stats are locked down.

I think it would eliminate a lot of the complaining and allows everyone to see the true effects of the changes right away.
 
Gizizza
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Do away with a lot of the complaints really simply - introduce a mechanism to allow Players to reroll their stats at any time, as long as they are a FA.

Basically, the Agent would roll up a new Player that had the same name, position, and experience as the previous one.. but would lose all of their nightly training, bonus token training.. basically everything else. The drawback would be pretty big, especially for high level Players, but atleast having the option would be a way to quiet the "I built my player under the old rules, you changed the rules" argument.

Another option that I would argue for is to allow Players to be retired with NO LOST FPs while the game remains in Beta.

Either way, your choices are either to do something about complaints, or to do nothing. But I think we all know that an unbalanced game isn't what you want for the end product.


This is really the major issue. The game is evolving more quickly than players can react because building a player takes time (and sometimes money) and the game can be changed instantaneously.

Why not just allow people to retire players and rebuild them at any level, say, up to 80% of the original player's Level?

Or there could just be a permanent number of points on every player that can be reallocated anytime, or in the offseason; a Level 1 could have 1 point like this; a Level 2, 2 points...a Level 30, 30 points. That would allow player flexibility to change with the times and still make the majority of the build permanent.
Last edited Nov 25, 2008 10:25:46
 
jeffhuff
offline
Link
 
Ultimatley if your exploiting known issues expect them to get
nuked.
 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
this is what happens when Seed goes against strength ..heck let everyone build the puny speed CB and safeties and try to blitz them... this team got ran over all game long...yes we were equal in talent

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=223969&pbp_id=5300205

they used speed guys with low strength to tackle our power back. So let guys build their fast CB's and what not...and then they can cry all they want to when this happens

 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
#2 on my list there really frustrates me at this point. There was a
reason to the method, and nobody could see past the end of their own
nose at the time.


I agree. Giving into complaints there was a HUGE mistake.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dianwei32
Originally posted by sully

Originally posted by Bort


I
have tried to increase the value of strength and tackling, etc, in the
past. All I get in return is 100 bug threads about how players miss too
many tackles, because everyone's 20 tackling CB is god's gift to GLB.


Then
maybe they need to work on tackling. I paid attention to tackling early
and my tackling attribute is right around 40. In spite of that, my guy
is still solid in coverage.

If corners don't want to miss
tackles, well, it's pretty easy for them to fix it. Unless of course,
they're truly convinced that Leon can't do everything.



Make
Strength more important like you want to, but couple it with a formal
announcement beforehand that the change will happen and that defenders
will need to work on their strength to keep up.

Once the
change is made, make "Bug" threads about "my CB is missing too many
tackles" from people who still have 20 Tackling/Strength ban-worthy.


Note that when Wrap-Up was nerfed so that at the very least LB's with 20 Tackling became obsolete, Bort changed it between seasons with about a month of warning, and people still screamed bloody murder.

I'd agree that when a change is made to make the game more realistic, Bort should completely tune out the whiners.

I'd also recommend adding to the NGTH list more quickly (for example, if the whining about huge differences in level revenue were occurring today, I'd suggest adding "more equal revenue between divisions" to the NGTH list. Once it's on that list, any thread about it would be locked immediately by the first Mod who saw it, and if the person posted again on the topic or continued to post other NGTH list ideas, then he would get a suspension (what we should call a temporary ban, which my understanding is that most of them are).
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.