Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Knick
Originally posted by TheInfinity
I hate to be against the man on this but I have to be.
First, its looking like you're trying to solve the Defensive End vs. Offensive Tackle problem with this.
If he is then I'll handle the rest of the post. However I think this is just a good idea. Bigger people are slower. More adding an element of realism than trying to "fix" a "problem"
I wasn't actually thinking about DE/OT actually, though I guess it would apply some. I was thinking it would be an interesting way to show the effect of weight and add another customizability option.
Also, how many 250 lb linebackers can run the same 40 as a 170 lb WR?
Very few, but thats not the entire story. That 250lb. Linebacker is 250lb. because he has to be, otherwise he wouldn't be able to do his job due to a lack of strength that comes with that weight. So, in real life the Linebacker has to pump his strength attribute and because of that he doesn't have enough to raise Speed and Agility to huge amounts. Opposite way around for Wide Receivers and Defensive Backs. Extreme examples in Offensive and Defensive Linemen.
Players in football have different sizes in real life because of the different attributes they need to play their positions. Right now in Goalline Blitz Speed and Agility are almost all a player needs at any position.
Originally posted by Knick
Originally posted by TheInfinity
I hate to be against the man on this but I have to be.
First, its looking like you're trying to solve the Defensive End vs. Offensive Tackle problem with this.
If he is then I'll handle the rest of the post. However I think this is just a good idea. Bigger people are slower. More adding an element of realism than trying to "fix" a "problem"
I wasn't actually thinking about DE/OT actually, though I guess it would apply some. I was thinking it would be an interesting way to show the effect of weight and add another customizability option.
Also, how many 250 lb linebackers can run the same 40 as a 170 lb WR?
Very few, but thats not the entire story. That 250lb. Linebacker is 250lb. because he has to be, otherwise he wouldn't be able to do his job due to a lack of strength that comes with that weight. So, in real life the Linebacker has to pump his strength attribute and because of that he doesn't have enough to raise Speed and Agility to huge amounts. Opposite way around for Wide Receivers and Defensive Backs. Extreme examples in Offensive and Defensive Linemen.
Players in football have different sizes in real life because of the different attributes they need to play their positions. Right now in Goalline Blitz Speed and Agility are almost all a player needs at any position.






























