User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Weight Classes
Page:
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Knick

Originally posted by TheInfinity


I hate to be against the man on this but I have to be.

First, its looking like you're trying to solve the Defensive End vs. Offensive Tackle problem with this.


If he is then I'll handle the rest of the post. However I think this is just a good idea. Bigger people are slower. More adding an element of realism than trying to "fix" a "problem"


I wasn't actually thinking about DE/OT actually, though I guess it would apply some. I was thinking it would be an interesting way to show the effect of weight and add another customizability option.

Also, how many 250 lb linebackers can run the same 40 as a 170 lb WR?


Very few, but thats not the entire story. That 250lb. Linebacker is 250lb. because he has to be, otherwise he wouldn't be able to do his job due to a lack of strength that comes with that weight. So, in real life the Linebacker has to pump his strength attribute and because of that he doesn't have enough to raise Speed and Agility to huge amounts. Opposite way around for Wide Receivers and Defensive Backs. Extreme examples in Offensive and Defensive Linemen.

Players in football have different sizes in real life because of the different attributes they need to play their positions. Right now in Goalline Blitz Speed and Agility are almost all a player needs at any position.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
My concern is that there will be no point in being "larger" based on your position. Take CB for example, there won't be any real advantage to being 195 lbs as compared to 170. Just food for thought.

We don't have any sort of bump and run or jamming at the line.


I'm not so sure; there could end up being "power" WR's if they had the opportunity to get +brk tackle bonuses, etc. I think it could actually introduce another metagame.

Also, I'm sure we'd like to see jamming as a tactics option at some point, right?
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Mat McBriar

My concern is that there will be no point in being "larger" based on your position. Take CB for example, there won't be any real advantage to being 195 lbs as compared to 170. Just food for thought.

We don't have any sort of bump and run or jamming at the line.


I'm not so sure; there could end up being "power" WR's if they had the opportunity to get +brk tackle bonuses, etc. I think it could actually introduce another metagame.

Also, I'm sure we'd like to see jamming as a tactics option at some point, right?


85 strength WRs are fail, we've already been through that experiment Bort.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dianwei32
+1 I like the idea, but I think that there could/should also be some way to have the weight (and subsequent speed/agility implications) factor into breaking/avoiding tackles for different style HBs. So if there were 2 Power HBs, and one was in a higher weight class he would break more tackles (more momentum) than the lighter guy, but be slower as a cost.

For Elusive style backs it could work where you are faster and can avoid more tackles, but since you are now a smaller/lighter HB, if the defender even gets a hand on you it's a guaranteed tackle.


Yeah, that's the sort of "customization" type stuff I was talking about.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iruleall15
IMO i think Height and Weight should have an effect. 7 ft guy with 100 speed is slower than a 5ft 8 guy with 100 speed


Not really. Taking out you extreme example...taller sprinters can't accelerate as well but, generally, have longer strides and take less steps in their natural stride pattern. Considering the fact that agility is acceleration...I think that acceleration should be related to height and not speed.

There is actually a statistically insignificant correlation between height and 100-meter dash times. Sprinters come in all shapes and sizes. Trust me.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Players in football have different sizes in real life because of the different attributes they need to play their positions. Right now in Goalline Blitz Speed and Agility are almost all a player needs at any position.


Epic disagree.

Also, YES to jamming!!
 
tordman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Just thought up this random idea while driving in the car, so I thought I'd post it here so as not to forget and see what people thought:

Currently, everybody basically has the same base speed value for what 100 speed will get you. It's modified by height/weight a little, along with acceleration, but not a huge amount.

So here's the idea for a new attribute:

Each player has a "weight class," or whatever we want to call it, defined by how heavy they are and what position they are.

Each "weight class" would have a base max speed and acceleration value that having 100 speed gets you. We could convert this into 40 times or something to make it easy to understand, and base it on top NFL combine scores for various positions.

Each "weight class" would also factor into blocking, breaking blocks, and tackling, as bonuses.

We figure out the base weight classes for each player currently in the game, and put it on their profile page for reference.

For instance, you could have something like:

Class lightweight < 160 lbs : base 3.75s 40, -20% block/break block penalty
Class middleweight 161-190 lbs : base 4.0s 40, -10% block/break block penalty
Class light heavyweight 191-225 lbs : base 4.25s 40, +0% block bonus
Class heavyweight 225-260 lbs : base 4.5s 40, +10% block bonus
Class super heavyweight 261 - 300lbs : base 4.75s 40, +20% block bonus
Class OMGweight 301+lbs : base 5s 40, +30% block bonus

etc. etc.

Here's the part that I think could be kinda interesting: You could adjust your weight class through training or special skills (perhaps veteran abilities?). Maybe you're in the middleweight class but you want to move down to lightweight to be faster, so you choose a skill to do so, etc.

Something like this could make it so we could show calculated 40 times for different players, etc. on their profile. It'd let you know what you're getting for your weight or lack of it, too.


Sorry to be the party pooper, but this is pretty much useless and would've been flamed if posted by anyone besides Bort.

Isn't there more serious issues to focus on, such as offensive and defensive AI's, gutting, realignment, cruise control, I could go on and on.

We're talking about weight here? Come on!
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Dianwei32
+1 I like the idea, but I think that there could/should also be some way to have the weight (and subsequent speed/agility implications) factor into breaking/avoiding tackles for different style HBs. So if there were 2 Power HBs, and one was in a higher weight class he would break more tackles (more momentum) than the lighter guy, but be slower as a cost.

For Elusive style backs it could work where you are faster and can avoid more tackles, but since you are now a smaller/lighter HB, if the defender even gets a hand on you it's a guaranteed tackle.


Should also lead to higher fumble rates as well, that would be a extra deterrent to avoid all speed builds with this idea.

 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Dianwei32

+1 I like the idea, but I think that there could/should also be some way to have the weight (and subsequent speed/agility implications) factor into breaking/avoiding tackles for different style HBs. So if there were 2 Power HBs, and one was in a higher weight class he would break more tackles (more momentum) than the lighter guy, but be slower as a cost.

For Elusive style backs it could work where you are faster and can avoid more tackles, but since you are now a smaller/lighter HB, if the defender even gets a hand on you it's a guaranteed tackle.


Yeah, that's the sort of "customization" type stuff I was talking about.


So whats the difference there between this system and the situation where one guy spends a little more on strength and the other a little more on speed?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by tordman


Sorry to be the party pooper, but this is pretty much useless and would've been flamed if posted by anyone besides Bort.

Isn't there more serious issues to focus on, such as offensive and defensive AI's, gutting, realignment, cruise control, I could go on and on.

We're talking about weight here? Come on!


Truthfully, as many times as this has been suggested in the past, I can't remember one of those threads being flamed.

 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tordman

Sorry to be the party pooper, but this is pretty much useless and would've been flamed if posted by anyone besides Bort.

Isn't there more serious issues to focus on, such as offensive and defensive AI's, gutting, realignment, cruise control, I could go on and on.


1) You're right about the 'anyone besides Bort' part. I've been through a thread similar.

2) Good idea = Good idea
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Originally posted by tordman



Sorry to be the party pooper, but this is pretty much useless and would've been flamed if posted by anyone besides Bort.

Isn't there more serious issues to focus on, such as offensive and defensive AI's, gutting, realignment, cruise control, I could go on and on.

We're talking about weight here? Come on!


Truthfully, as many times as this has been suggested in the past, I can't remember one of those threads being flamed.



Mine was brought down pretty hard tbh.
 
TehRainy
offline
Link
 
Yes to weight classes and yes to jamming, even though I don't have a CB.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tordman


Sorry to be the party pooper, but this is pretty much useless and would've been flamed if posted by anyone besides Bort.

Isn't there more serious issues to focus on, such as offensive and defensive AI's, gutting, realignment, cruise control, I could go on and on.


So we are disallowed to discuss ideas now, if they don't fall into certain categories?

Suggestions forum = suggestions and ideas.
 
Link
 
I don't think I went into yours. I remember seeing a few in season 2 and 3 but I quit going in them after that.

Have to ask Kretch if his got flamed as well. I don't think it did.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.