User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > is anybody suspicious that "go for int only if help over the top" isn't working anymore?
Page:
 
bacardi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
The CB got burned, missed some checks probably due to a problem with his build. So many variables play a part in each play, so trying to break it down to one thing other than being beat is futile unless you see the build of all players in the play, and can identify possible SA's that may have triggered.

why are there still people that come here saying "your cb got burned"

for the 30th time, *I EXPECT CBs TO OCCASIONALLY GET BURNED. IT HAPPENS*

the ACTUAL question is WHY IS THE CB DOING SOMETHING WHEN HIS TACTICS ARE SET NOT TO DO THAT SPECIFIC ACTION?

for the 30th time, if you set a QB to never dump off, HE WILL NEVER DUMP OFF. if he has 100 punting and 10 vision, HE WILL STILL NOT DUMP OFF.

so when a CB is set to not go for an INT without help, WHY IS HE GOING FOR AN INT WITHOUT HELP? every URL i (and others) have linked shows the same thing. a CB staying behind the WR all the way up until the ball is thrown, with no over the top help. then as soon as the ball is released, he charges for the INT. even though his tactics are set explicitly to NOT DO THAT.
 
Peacesells
iBuying
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bacardi
Originally posted by Mightyhalo

The CB got burned, missed some checks probably due to a problem with his build. So many variables play a part in each play, so trying to break it down to one thing other than being beat is futile unless you see the build of all players in the play, and can identify possible SA's that may have triggered.

why are there still people that come here saying "your cb got burned"

for the 30th time, *I EXPECT CBs TO OCCASIONALLY GET BURNED. IT HAPPENS*

the ACTUAL question is WHY IS THE CB DOING SOMETHING WHEN HIS TACTICS ARE SET NOT TO DO THAT SPECIFIC ACTION?

for the 30th time, if you set a QB to never dump off, HE WILL NEVER DUMP OFF. if he has 100 punting and 10 vision, HE WILL STILL NOT DUMP OFF.

so when a CB is set to not go for an INT without help, WHY IS HE GOING FOR AN INT WITHOUT HELP? every URL i (and others) have linked shows the same thing. a CB staying behind the WR all the way up until the ball is thrown, with no over the top help. then as soon as the ball is released, he charges for the INT. even though his tactics are set explicitly to NOT DO THAT.


Thank you!
 
Darkstrand
offline
Link
 
the thing I really hate about this is we will never get a response from Bort on whether or not we're encountering buggy shit or if the CB has a designed chance to think he has help over the top when he doesn't.

I think it's very unlikely that this is an intended feature.
 
MarBro456
Diamond Cutter
offline
Link
 
4 pages and the original question never got answered. Start off asking why your eggs are yellow, and people start arguing whether the bunny is fat or skinny. They completely change what you ask. Happens in almost every thread.
 
Link
 
maybe vision will help him see help over the top
 
lunchbox6186
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by Tobysmith6922

Are your players getting PD's every game???...if they are, then put some skill points into Catching and Jumping and they might get an Int instead of a PD or getting burned when they "miss" the Int attempt....


This is a great idea! Gosh... why didn't we all just come up with that one! We're so dumb... but thanks to your experience with your lv. 22 FS we're enlightened now!



(if one of your guys ever plays in a AAA or pro league, you will understand that your post was funny)

________________________________________________


Now let's get back to topic:

Why don't do CBs just what they're set to? How do you order the CB to play it safe when playing one-on-one while going for the pick when another defender offers help over the top?



Quoted for Elitist 'tude Have a good day!
 
supgreg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NotRippedYet
Originally posted by supgreg

Originally posted by NotRippedYet


Originally posted by supgreg



I fail to see how a CB making a bad play on the ball is a bug. It's a bad read. What is his Vision? Jumping? Swat Ball? 50 Vision isn't that good in the grand scheme of things. If 50 Vision was the standard for a near perfect CB, what is 75 Vision, or 100 going to be like?

Jumping a route and missing, misplaying the ball, not being able to jump higher than the WR are all normal plays in football at all levels.


Except for this completely ignores the tactics the user sets. If I set my CB to play medium and only go after the ball when I have over the top help the CB shouldn't ever attempt to jump the route and get underneath, unless he has over the top help.

Just like if I set my safeties to play a cover 2 shell, they shouldn't be coming in underneath and helping to double or triple team already covered receivers, they should play a zone over the top of the coverage.


I know what you are saying, and I get it. But are you suggesting that our players play everything flawless? Personally, I like that a player can screw up, that way it's not just about my speed vs. your speed. If players always did exactly what they were told, then speed would be the only separation. I can do what you can do only faster.

It sucks when your guy screws up, but haven't you ever seen a real football player go for the big play and screw it up? Players make the wrong zone reads in the NFL all the time, don't you think it's frustrating to NFL and college coaches, too?


I agree there needs to be some margin of error on the players part.

That said, have you ever seen an NFL SS that bites on an inside TE post when the WR on his side streaks nearly every single time the play is run?

I went through ONE of your games. On every one of these plays your safeties are in Cv 2 and AT LEAST one of them has a receiver behind or even with him prior to the release from the QB.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=233016&pbp_id=2566992
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=233016&pbp_id=2567067
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=233016&pbp_id=2568292
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=233016&pbp_id=2568902
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=233016&pbp_id=2569516
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=233016&pbp_id=2569709
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=233016&pbp_id=2569938
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=233016&pbp_id=2569960
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=233016&pbp_id=2570650
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=233016&pbp_id=2570822
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=233016&pbp_id=2571464

That is NOT Cover 2.




That might be correct, but the topic of this thread is a defensive tactic "feeling buggy" not that the cover 2 is incorrectly implemented.
 
Darkstrand
offline
Link
 
I like how supergreg tries to discredit people when they suggest something "feels buggy" by putting it in quotes when his ONLY counter response is "it feels not buggy." The fact is there are more people here who have been having new problems with it than aren't.

there is NOTHING to indicate that deciding if they have help over the top is related to vision/confidence or any other stat. If there isn't then this is definitely a bug. Also, it didn't seem to be happening last season until after the WR glitch was fixed (as far as I can remember). We don't see D-leagues making this mistake in great numbers (if any thing it's happening less in the lower leagues). That to me indicates that it's not a vision issue.

My bet is it is a bug and that bort won't respond to this thread because he can't figure out whats causing it or can't figure out a clean solution to implement.
Last edited Nov 22, 2008 23:51:34
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bacardi
Originally posted by Mightyhalo

The CB got burned, missed some checks probably due to a problem with his build. So many variables play a part in each play, so trying to break it down to one thing other than being beat is futile unless you see the build of all players in the play, and can identify possible SA's that may have triggered.

why are there still people that come here saying "your cb got burned"

for the 30th time, *I EXPECT CBs TO OCCASIONALLY GET BURNED. IT HAPPENS*

the ACTUAL question is WHY IS THE CB DOING SOMETHING WHEN HIS TACTICS ARE SET NOT TO DO THAT SPECIFIC ACTION?

for the 30th time, if you set a QB to never dump off, HE WILL NEVER DUMP OFF. if he has 100 punting and 10 vision, HE WILL STILL NOT DUMP OFF.

so when a CB is set to not go for an INT without help, WHY IS HE GOING FOR AN INT WITHOUT HELP? every URL i (and others) have linked shows the same thing. a CB staying behind the WR all the way up until the ball is thrown, with no over the top help. then as soon as the ball is released, he charges for the INT. even though his tactics are set explicitly to NOT DO THAT.


Well in your links earlier you are assuming he got beat by going for the pick with no help other the top, when in reality he just got burned. I saw nothing out of those replays that showed your guy "going for the pick" I see a a CB going against a WR that has 6 levels on him beating the CB. The CB looks like he is playing close/medium but missed out on some checks to a better player.

 
Draez
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NotRippedYet
Originally posted by sirallan

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=213265&pbp_id=4755410
Perfect example from todays game.
My CB was all over the WR and it was pretty obvious he didn't have help over the top. Yet it appears that he went for the pick by jumping in front of the WR.
I really feel like my only options are to go on loose and always give up the reception or go on aggressive since I will still get beat like that, but every once and a while I'll get a pick.


Perfect example. If you watch the play in slow mo you stay with the receiver the entire time, at the time of release your CB is about a step and a half off the receiver. The second the ball is released he jumps the route and chases after the ball like the fat kid on Maury chasing a cheeseburger.


This is the play you ran.

http://goallineblitz.com/images/plays/156.gif

If you noticed that WR#1 was suppose to do an In route and the CB followed just like it should. The throw wasn't a good throw and the WR adjusted and your CB didn't. If the WR went ahead and completed the route the CB would still be behind the WR.

 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo


Well in your links earlier you are assuming he got beat by going for the pick with no help other the top, when in reality he just got burned. I saw nothing out of those replays that showed your guy "going for the pick" I see a a CB going against a WR that has 6 levels on him beating the CB. The CB looks like he is playing close/medium but missed out on some checks to a better player.



http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=226523&pbp_id=3759418
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=226523&pbp_id=3761101
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=270616&pbp_id=4098542

This is not the CB "Just getting burned". The defender is out in front, and clearly has better position when the ball is thrown. But, on the exact frame that the ball comes out, the CB stops. He doesn't slow down. He comes to a complete stop and waits for the ball to arrive.

I think that possibly a WR 'fake' could be used to attempt to explain it. But it isn't as simple as you like to make it out to be.

Each one has the CB with perfect, over the top, coverage, for the pass that is thrown. But, the CB stops when the ball is thrown.



 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
Originally posted by Mightyhalo



Well in your links earlier you are assuming he got beat by going for the pick with no help other the top, when in reality he just got burned. I saw nothing out of those replays that showed your guy "going for the pick" I see a a CB going against a WR that has 6 levels on him beating the CB. The CB looks like he is playing close/medium but missed out on some checks to a better player.



http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=226523&pbp_id=3759418
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=226523&pbp_id=3761101
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=270616&pbp_id=4098542

This is not the CB "Just getting burned". The defender is out in front, and clearly has better position when the ball is thrown. But, on the exact frame that the ball comes out, the CB stops. He doesn't slow down. He comes to a complete stop and waits for the ball to arrive.

I think that possibly a WR 'fake' could be used to attempt to explain it. But it isn't as simple as you like to make it out to be.

Each one has the CB with perfect, over the top, coverage, for the pass that is thrown. But, the CB stops when the ball is thrown.





Or maybe the ball was thrown high and the CB didn't meet the jump check? There are just so many variables so it's hard to tell until they add every minute detail to the play by play log. It would also help if we could see the builds of the players in these links.



 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Originally posted by chief31

Originally posted by Mightyhalo




Well in your links earlier you are assuming he got beat by going for the pick with no help other the top, when in reality he just got burned. I saw nothing out of those replays that showed your guy "going for the pick" I see a a CB going against a WR that has 6 levels on him beating the CB. The CB looks like he is playing close/medium but missed out on some checks to a better player.



http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=226523&pbp_id=3759418
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=226523&pbp_id=3761101
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=270616&pbp_id=4098542

This is not the CB "Just getting burned". The defender is out in front, and clearly has better position when the ball is thrown. But, on the exact frame that the ball comes out, the CB stops. He doesn't slow down. He comes to a complete stop and waits for the ball to arrive.

I think that possibly a WR 'fake' could be used to attempt to explain it. But it isn't as simple as you like to make it out to be.

Each one has the CB with perfect, over the top, coverage, for the pass that is thrown. But, the CB stops when the ball is thrown.





Or maybe the ball was thrown high and the CB didn't meet the jump check? There are just so many variables so it's hard to tell until they add every minute detail to the play by play log. It would also help if we could see the builds of the players in these links.





That's irrelevant. Why did he stop? He isn't supposed to be going for the INT.

There is a weak-assed argument that that is an attempt to go for the pass deflection. But I would think that his VISION would need to be at -48 to abandon perfect positioning, and letting the WR have it.

And, if that is the case, then it is wrong and should be adjusted. IMO.
 
daman12457
offline
Link
 
Bump.
 
Darkstrand
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
Originally posted by Mightyhalo

Originally posted by chief31


Originally posted by Mightyhalo





Well in your links earlier you are assuming he got beat by going for the pick with no help other the top, when in reality he just got burned. I saw nothing out of those replays that showed your guy "going for the pick" I see a a CB going against a WR that has 6 levels on him beating the CB. The CB looks like he is playing close/medium but missed out on some checks to a better player.



http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=226523&pbp_id=3759418
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=226523&pbp_id=3761101
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=270616&pbp_id=4098542

This is not the CB "Just getting burned". The defender is out in front, and clearly has better position when the ball is thrown. But, on the exact frame that the ball comes out, the CB stops. He doesn't slow down. He comes to a complete stop and waits for the ball to arrive.

I think that possibly a WR 'fake' could be used to attempt to explain it. But it isn't as simple as you like to make it out to be.

Each one has the CB with perfect, over the top, coverage, for the pass that is thrown. But, the CB stops when the ball is thrown.





Or maybe the ball was thrown high and the CB didn't meet the jump check? There are just so many variables so it's hard to tell until they add every minute detail to the play by play log. It would also help if we could see the builds of the players in these links.





That's irrelevant. Why did he stop? He isn't supposed to be going for the INT.

There is a weak-assed argument that that is an attempt to go for the pass deflection. But I would think that his VISION would need to be at -48 to abandon perfect positioning, and letting the WR have it.

And, if that is the case, then it is wrong and should be adjusted. IMO.


this is it exactly. There shouldn't be a jump check. He's been told not to go for the int. He shouldn't be jumping. (PERIOD)
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.