User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Laying in the Team AI (Also Solves League Parity)
Page:
 
GG
offline
Link
 
So it's good to allow all owners from Pro right down to 'B' the full tactical options, allow them to learn, acquire understanding of football itself, and it will help in a team itself, goading agents to interact with each other in team forums and tactics discussions more.

One problem with the market is that players can hold a gun to owners for exaggerated salary demands etc. And there are many "networks" of owners out there who are friends and associates, who feed each other the top players, able to acquire them thru this "buddy system". So what you have is like a mafia of talent control.

There are a lot of leagues out there where half the teams have zero chance of ever being competitive even when they have a team about 5-8 levels lower than those top teams. Where 5-8 levels is coded in the sim to mean a HUGE difference inside the game (resulting in 90-7 scores).

If there was a way to code it that 10 levels of difference was a very small difference then you would see more competitive games, tactics mattering more, and probably a more open player market.
 
Caledric
offline
Link
 
So because I'm in an A league that has been rather competitive since it started you want to take away all of my and my GMs tools? Lets ignore the fact that we have all been around since season 2/3 BEFORE anything other then basic AI was put in. Lets ignore the fact that some of the best minds in GLB own A or even BBB league teams.

Sorry I won't go for this. Its a slap in the face to me and my GMs. We've been working with this stuff since it was implemented, to take it away so some noob stands a fair chance against me is an insult. A noob shouldn't stand a chance against a more experienced player. That is the whole point of experience.
 
Lucius
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Recruiting is the only factor that determines whether you win or lose. Tactics themselves are mostly irrelevant except when you have two identically matched teams. Then it becomes important.


That's absurd. We're playing well above our heads on paper this season and so far have a pretty good record. Tactics make a world of difference.


Originally posted by Caledric
Sorry I won't go for this. Its a slap in the face to me and my GMs. We've been working with this stuff since it was implemented, to take it away so some noob stands a fair chance against me is an insult. A noob shouldn't stand a chance against a more experienced player. That is the whole point of experience.


That mentality is exactly what will prevent the game from growing. You're only interested in your own experience and not the health of the game.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Caledric
Sorry I won't go for this. Its a slap in the face to me and my GMs. We've been working with this stuff since it was implemented, to take it away so some noob stands a fair chance against me is an insult. A noob shouldn't stand a chance against a more experienced player. That is the whole point of experience.


Exactly the point. You've been around to learn the bells and whistles gradually.

New owners just get everything and get overwhelmed.
 
Link
 
I think this should be more choice based than just being done, what if you've been a coordinator for 2-3 seasons and understand how to run the AI, but now you want a team that is a 13 capped team? you have to go back to the basics just because other people in your league don't know what they are doing? not fair to the expierienced players. and if a new player wants the challenge of figuring out the advanced AI they should be allowed
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jared
I think this should be more choice based than just being done, what if you've been a coordinator for 2-3 seasons and understand how to run the AI, but now you want a team that is a 13 capped team? you have to go back to the basics just because other people in your league don't know what they are doing? not fair to the expierienced players. and if a new player wants the challenge of figuring out the advanced AI they should be allowed


Maybe have like vet BBB leagues and n00b BBB leagues?
 
Lucius
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jared
I think this should be more choice based than just being done, what if you've been a coordinator for 2-3 seasons and understand how to run the AI, but now you want a team that is a 13 capped team? you have to go back to the basics just because other people in your league don't know what they are doing? not fair to the expierienced players. and if a new player wants the challenge of figuring out the advanced AI they should be allowed


It has to be the same within a league though, or this doesn't work. It just curses all newbie players to have no chance if a few guys in their league can out gameplan them and they have no alternative.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
Originally posted by jared

I think this should be more choice based than just being done, what if you've been a coordinator for 2-3 seasons and understand how to run the AI, but now you want a team that is a 13 capped team? you have to go back to the basics just because other people in your league don't know what they are doing? not fair to the expierienced players. and if a new player wants the challenge of figuring out the advanced AI they should be allowed


Maybe have like vet BBB leagues and n00b BBB leagues?


would this ^ be a better solution then? I could go for this, since then the competition should be on equal footing from the onset
 
Lucius
offline
Link
 
You just segregate the players from day one, though.

Some of my best friends in the game are rivals from other teams we used to be in leagues with. You don't want to cut new players off from experienced players.

As I've said before. The game is relentlessly shuffling decent teams UP. All new teams by definition are in BBB. So new owners would get this system. Yes, it would also impact some current owners, but frankly, only with rare exception the ones that actually need the help, since they hadn't gotten out of the lower couple leagues on their own.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lucius
Originally posted by Ken1

What if you're a better tactician than anything else, but you can't win through tactics because they're locked out from you?

I'm totally fine with some sort of "basic league" for people who want a league that uses only basic tactics; but not for locking the richness of the game away from people who want it.


It takes more than tactics to succeed. To make pro, you need to be good at everything and that wouldn't change in this system.

It just starts with the logical first step: recruiting. Recruiting leads to friends. Friends leads to more people who know things. That helps you when you reach the more complex things.

Thus, your first step is to make friends. Fact is, no sane human can manage an entire team alone now. It's a full time job. Thus, you need a social safety net for this to be an accessible product. By putting recruiting and thus social networking first, you make sure they have that safety net when things get complex.

If I'm a great tactician and terrible recruiter, then I need to find a recruiter. Maybe, I agree to go GM someone else's team, and they recruit for my lower level team.

It's those bonds that hold the game together, which is why I suggest recruiting be the first step.


Maybe in my case I agree to GM someone else's team (which, if this idea were ever implemented, I'm fortunate was a Pro team), but then he has to sell the team due to personal concerns, transfers it to his head GM (me), but sticks around as a GM to help recruit?

If we were a low-level team, you'd be taking my fun, and heck, my main ability to help the team win, from me-- the tactics.

Let people learn football and learn tactics. Again, I'd be fine with there being a "simple" league that people could voluntarily join if they want the tactics kept simple.

But no one should have their tools stripped from them due to league level.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jared
Originally posted by Knick

Originally posted by jared


I think this should be more choice based than just being done, what if you've been a coordinator for 2-3 seasons and understand how to run the AI, but now you want a team that is a 13 capped team? you have to go back to the basics just because other people in your league don't know what they are doing? not fair to the expierienced players. and if a new player wants the challenge of figuring out the advanced AI they should be allowed


Maybe have like vet BBB leagues and n00b BBB leagues?


would this ^ be a better solution then? I could go for this, since then the competition should be on equal footing from the onset


Yes, much better-- although I wouldn't call them "n00b BBB leagues," due to the stigma. I'd call them "basic leagues" with the others "advanced leagues."

Heck, create a 9th region (which wouldn't compete in anything currently planned down the road for 8 regions) that's a basic tactics region. Some people would prefer teams there. Let people move teams there, with some restrictions so you couldn't move a great team there just to pwn everyone.

Just don't force people into being stuck with basic tactics (the ones that force you to run the FB even if you don't want to, for example) if they don't want to.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jared
Originally posted by Knick

Originally posted by jared


I think this should be more choice based than just being done, what if you've been a coordinator for 2-3 seasons and understand how to run the AI, but now you want a team that is a 13 capped team? you have to go back to the basics just because other people in your league don't know what they are doing? not fair to the expierienced players. and if a new player wants the challenge of figuring out the advanced AI they should be allowed


Maybe have like vet BBB leagues and n00b BBB leagues?


would this ^ be a better solution then? I could go for this, since then the competition should be on equal footing from the onset

that is why I think there should be a choice or something similar to knicks idea that i have quoted
 
Lucius
offline
Link
 
n00b leagues would work, but they wouldn't accomplish the entire point of this thread, which is to retain and train more and better owners.

That is, unless they say sat at the bottom and fed into the regular scheme. IE the winner of the n00b league got promoted to a regular league...

...but you know, that's exactly what I was suggesting
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lucius
n00b leagues would work, but they wouldn't accomplish the entire point of this thread, which is to retain and train more and better owners.

That is, unless they say sat at the bottom and fed into the regular scheme. IE the winner of the n00b league got promoted to a regular league...

...but you know, that's exactly what I was suggesting


You want to retain players by withholding features from them? Not gonna work....
 
Lucius
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Lucius

n00b leagues would work, but they wouldn't accomplish the entire point of this thread, which is to retain and train more and better owners.

That is, unless they say sat at the bottom and fed into the regular scheme. IE the winner of the n00b league got promoted to a regular league...

...but you know, that's exactly what I was suggesting


You want to retain players by withholding features from them? Not gonna work....


Tell that to World of Warcraft and... umm.. every progression based game in the history of time
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.