User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Fumbles still a problem (jumping on it early this season)
Page:
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by MrMoose

1) RBs get tired and fumble near the end of a drive -- but if the RBs are tired, shouldn't the defense also be somewhat tired and no more likely to cause a fumble?


I think this is a common syndrome.

Perhaps velocity just needs to be less of a factor in fumble forcing?

Two really fast guys smashing into each other can generate a decent amount of fumble causing power, on top of any bonuses from big hits, etc.


Thanks for jumping in Bort.

I can see the stamina issue being a factor for sure. However, in the instances I referenced at least my RB had 23 carries, 39 total plays and fumbled 4 total times, twice in the red zone.

Anyway, there are so many factors you would have to evaluate on that and you and many others are better equipped to address that then I am. I am just happy you are looking into it.

The velocity part of the equation is the one that I think certainly needs to be toned down. Although it clearly plays a major role in the real world, I think it makes for some very unrealistic sims, particularly with the special teams fumbles.
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by MrMoose

1) RBs get tired and fumble near the end of a drive -- but if the RBs are tired, shouldn't the defense also be somewhat tired and no more likely to cause a fumble?


I think this is a common syndrome.

Perhaps velocity just needs to be less of a factor in fumble forcing?

Two really fast guys smashing into each other can generate a decent amount of fumble causing power, on top of any bonuses from big hits, etc.


I think what I'm also concerned with -- there are tons of ways for defenders to light up a ball carrier with some defenders having multiple SAs that can cause fumbles, or cause morale drop. Does the cover up SA account for this, or is a defense having 6 or 7 guys specialized in fumble causing going to wreck an HB enough that nothing can save him? Also, does someone with a high monster hit SA missing a tackle still affect an RBs morale? Or does it only take effect if that person makes a tackle?

Something I've talked about with others that also seems to be a problem is that defenders all have an opportunity to attempt to force fumbles or make wrap-up tackles. They can do their best to have a better chance at making a tackle and possibly counter a powerback. However, powerbacks don't have the opportunity to try to break less tackles while focusing on protecting the ball. If I know I'm going up against an offense that has a focus on forcing fumbles, I know that I would emphasize less of a "knock those guys over" mentality in practice and more of a "hold onto the dang ball" type of philosophy.

I'm all for speed affecting fumbles, though -- I mean, it should. However, a defender hauling off trying to hit my guy should also have a larger chance of bouncing off of me. I mean, imagine a cornerback trying to run full tilt at Brandon Jacobs or some such. He'll just let the corner bounce off him. The corner isn't going to have much of a chance if he does what he needs to to make the tackle -- go for the legs.

Fumbles should also be happening a bit more when running through a massive pile of defenders. As it is, they rarely happen when you have 6 guys all trying to make tackles, yet this is where I see many fumbles happen in real life. Defenders stand someone up who fights still to make progress and they're all reaching in to try to force a fumble.

So, yeah, I rambled. Here's the tl;dr version:

1) Fumbles should be less likely from a high speed collision, OR broken tackles should be much more likely in a one-on-one situation involving a power back and a speedy defensive back.

2) Anyone that carries the ball should get an option that lets them focus on holding onto the ball, on breaking tackles or neutral. This option would be the offensive opposite of the defenders ability to try to cause fumbles or wrap up a tackle.

3) While we have you here -- is it possible to also implement a sort of ball rolling mechanism to a fumble? Someone causing a fumble from behind may cause the ball to roll forward and out of an end zone, for example, as opposed to just falling down and not moving at all.
Last edited Dec 2, 2008 16:23:15
 
Aaddron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose

2) Anyone that carries the ball should get an option that lets them focus on holding onto the ball, on breaking tackles or neutral. This option would be the offensive opposite of the defenders ability to try to cause fumbles or wrap up a tackle


I like that idea.
Last edited Dec 2, 2008 16:26:03
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Aaddron
Originally posted by MrMoose


2) Anyone that carries the ball should get an option that lets them focus on holding onto the ball, on breaking tackles or neutral. This option would be the offensive opposite of the defenders ability to try to cause fumbles or wrap up a tackle


I think that idea.


That is a great idea imo.

I do get the velocity causing fumbles part of it and I am fine with it, except it is totally out of whack on KR/PR. That may be something that just needs to be addressed with a BIG overhall in the KR/PR side of things though, because there are also the vision problems, as mentioned in a thread above, the blocking problems, the kick return SA being totally broken imo and then this funble issue.

Sorry I got off track as well, tl;dr version:

Moose has a great idea, don't forget about the KR/PR fumbles problem.
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sxewesley
Moose has a great idea, don't forget about the KR/PR fumbles problem.[/QUOTE



It seems that it is possible to adjust stuff for different phases of the game -- I wonder how possible it is to drastically lower the chance to cause a fumble on returns. For example, WRs seem to be able to hold onto blocks pretty well despite low tackling, HBs seem to catch even bad passes effectively with low catching, etc.

That may be one bandaid fix for this problem.
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose
For example, WRs seem to be able to hold onto blocks pretty well despite low tackling, HBs seem to catch even bad passes effectively with low catching, etc.


Maybe I'm just a n00b....but what does the tackling skill have to do with holding onto a block?

As for the HBs making catches with low catching, my guess would be the QBs have high Tight Spiral SA along with high Dump Pass SA.
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
This is my problem with the special teams fumbles. That is our power back I described earlier, who was put in there specifically to avoid fumbles and there he is fumbling again, who causes it? A DT? A LB? A DE? No, a CB. On top of which and one of the reasons I posted this one, is that the very last time he touched the ball he took one to the house.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=214479&pbp_id=8091323

The only stat anyone could possibly say is low on that back is confidence. Why would his confidence be low after he just took one back for a TD?
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by deez11010
Originally posted by MrMoose

For example, WRs seem to be able to hold onto blocks pretty well despite low tackling, HBs seem to catch even bad passes effectively with low catching, etc.


Maybe I'm just a n00b....but what does the tackling skill have to do with holding onto a block?

As for the HBs making catches with low catching, my guess would be the QBs have high Tight Spiral SA along with high Dump Pass SA.


I meant to say blocking. I was rushing through typing.
 
bigpimpin123
offline
Link
 
I agree, I am on a team that fumbles a lot too even though builds are good.
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose
Originally posted by deez11010

Originally posted by MrMoose


For example, WRs seem to be able to hold onto blocks pretty well despite low tackling, HBs seem to catch even bad passes effectively with low catching, etc.


Maybe I'm just a n00b....but what does the tackling skill have to do with holding onto a block?

As for the HBs making catches with low catching, my guess would be the QBs have high Tight Spiral SA along with high Dump Pass SA.


I meant to say blocking. I was rushing through typing.


Ok, you had me all confused for a min there.
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
i think everything needs to be left alone.. I raised my LBers vision and he was a forced fumble machine last season.. Fumbles happen. People come on here and want things changed to help THEMSELVES..and it's making Defenses get weaker.. Too many INTs last season..."needed changed".. So now any team can pass all day on any Defense because Passing is far stronger now.
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose
Originally posted by sxewesley
Moose has a great idea, don't forget about the KR/PR fumbles problem.[/QUOTE



It seems that it is possible to adjust stuff for different phases of the game -- I wonder how possible it is to drastically lower the chance to cause a fumble on returns. For example, WRs seem to be able to hold onto blocks pretty well despite low tackling, HBs seem to catch even bad passes effectively with low catching, etc.

That may be one bandaid fix for this problem.

Uhh..fumbles happen on Kick offs.. No need to drastically lower anything.. Things have been changed bad enough.. Some things over power other things IE: Past few season there was a heavy INT rate.. Somehting was changed and now an offense can pass all day on even the best defense. Power runners were too powerful last season... Now that slow down at the line thing was added and now power runners arent as good.

Basically..stop complaing about little things that you just dont like. Fumbles happen... Fast runners have a huge hit on impact..and that causes fumbles.. Good vision will allow the tackler to see the ball placement and cause a fumble.. Leave it alone already.. Things get over powered as it is already
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by MrMoose

1) RBs get tired and fumble near the end of a drive -- but if the RBs are tired, shouldn't the defense also be somewhat tired and no more likely to cause a fumble?


I think this is a common syndrome.

Perhaps velocity just needs to be less of a factor in fumble forcing?

Two really fast guys smashing into each other can generate a decent amount of fumble causing power, on top of any bonuses from big hits, etc.



velocity and 'big hits" go hand in hand. Both are major factors in forcing a fumble and should be in this game as well
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jason Cash
Originally posted by MrMoose

Originally posted by sxewesley
Moose has a great idea, don't forget about the KR/PR fumbles problem.[/QUOTE



It seems that it is possible to adjust stuff for different phases of the game -- I wonder how possible it is to drastically lower the chance to cause a fumble on returns. For example, WRs seem to be able to hold onto blocks pretty well despite low tackling, HBs seem to catch even bad passes effectively with low catching, etc.

That may be one bandaid fix for this problem.

Uhh..fumbles happen on Kick offs.. No need to drastically lower anything.. Things have been changed bad enough.. Some things over power other things IE: Past few season there was a heavy INT rate.. Somehting was changed and now an offense can pass all day on even the best defense. Power runners were too powerful last season... Now that slow down at the line thing was added and now power runners arent as good.

Basically..stop complaing about little things that you just dont like. Fumbles happen... Fast runners have a huge hit on impact..and that causes fumbles.. Good vision will allow the tackler to see the ball placement and cause a fumble.. Leave it alone already.. Things get over powered as it is already


90% of my players are defensive guys and I am the DC for 5 teams, more fumbles is good for me personally. I am complaining about something that is completely unrealistic and needs to be fixed imo.
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
cornerbacks don't fumble in any form of football on returns as often as they do in GLB. And they're still able to be decent cornerbacks too -- they don't have to sacrifice everything for carrying ability.

Less fumbles would hurt me in one areas as much as it would help me in another. But an RB fumbling 10+ times in a season is just ridiculous. Should they still happen? Yes. They happen too often as it is, though. A running back with high carrying and strength should not fumble as often as they do now. There doesn't seem to be anything people can do to prevent them -- high cover up and carrying and strength doesn't seem to be mattering at all -- fumbles are way too random.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.