User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Madcow8me
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by catspaw27


Bort, wake up on this. I always hear comparisons to real football in discussions that"it's like a Pro going up against a High School player" but no one can get to a QB that quick.

No one. Ever. Even if the OT is a pylon you still have to get around him.

It's a flaw, a bug, incorrect coding whatever. It needs to be fixed bottom line.



Except it doesn't happen to OT's who are built well.

What the hell do you need 80 strength for when the DE you are blocking is 30-40 strength??

It is 80 blocking jackass, not 80 strength...... From what everyone says, Blocking comes into play with blocking angles shit...



well "everyone" is telling you to stop being an idiot and put points into speed, yet you refuse. Take what you get then and stop crying about it if you don't want to listen.
 
MadCow420
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Madcow8me

Just because my LT dominated last year, You are just a bitter socialist....



Did he dominate in a D-league or was it a league of slow-build teams? Cuz he didn't play any good pass rushing DE's, that's for sure...


Last season, he wents vs LTs 5+ levels last year, in a very good conference. Only giving up 1 sack... and for him to give up 5 sacks in the first game, it is fishy, dick breath
 
Jah King
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Madcow8me
so apparently 80 Blocking and 50 agility doesnt mean much anymore.. so i need a speed LT...... are you fucking kidding me, a speed LT.


Thats how I'm building my LT by working on soft capping speed and agility first and if you think about it most DE's especially RDE's go by similar speed builds so why not build a LT similar? If you and a DE have similar speed and agility in this game you would still be 25+ pounds heavier.

 
Footballmike
offline
Link
 
DE's with better builds than OTs are going to win....nuff said....
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Jah King
Originally posted by Madcow8me

so apparently 80 Blocking and 50 agility doesnt mean much anymore.. so i need a speed LT...... are you fucking kidding me, a speed LT.


Thats how I'm building my LT by working on soft capping speed and agility first and if you think about it most DE's especially RDE's go by similar speed builds so why not build a LT similar? If you and a DE have similar speed and agility in this game you would still be 25+ pounds heavier.




That is using logic that the OP certainly doesn't have. Your OT will be a great pass blocker.
 
CoachBradley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Except it doesn't happen to OT's who are built well.

What the hell do you need 80 strength for when the DE you are blocking is 30-40 strength??


The next team he plays might have DE's who have 65-70 strength.

IRL, offensive tackles have to play both bull rushers and speed rushers, sometimes on adjacent downs, much less adjacent games. Some tackles do better against one or the other, but other tackles do just fine against both. Taking the NFL as an example, I would bet there are very few OT's who can run as fast as DE's. But by the same token, very few DE's are as big as their OT counterparts...for a DE to speed rush completely around a mountain of an OT, you have to catch the OT in a false step, catch him off guard, or completely jump the snap count, and that isn't going to happen 15 times in a game. It's not realistic in any way, shape, or form.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by CoachBradley
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Except it doesn't happen to OT's who are built well.

What the hell do you need 80 strength for when the DE you are blocking is 30-40 strength??


The next team he plays might have DE's who have 65-70 strength.

IRL, offensive tackles have to play both bull rushers and speed rushers, sometimes on adjacent downs, much less adjacent games. Some tackles do better against one or the other, but other tackles do just fine against both. Taking the NFL as an example, I would bet there are very few OT's who can run as fast as DE's. But by the same token, very few DE's are as big as their OT counterparts...for a DE to speed rush completely around a mountain of an OT, you have to catch the OT in a false step, catch him off guard, or completely jump the snap count, and that isn't going to happen 15 times in a game. It's not realistic in any way, shape, or form.



You guys are all viewing speed wrong. OT's shouldn't have to be FASTER than DE's, but they have to be semi-close.

50 speed OT should be able to handle 60 speed DE, but for someone to think that a 35 speed OT should be able to handle ANY speed DE, then they are seriously missing a few marbles.

Especially if you consider that a 35 speed OT might not be able to go backwards at 35 speed.....that the 35 might be the forward speed.

Last edited Nov 11, 2008 09:38:38
 
Link
 
50 agility is not even close to enough. How do you know the end who burned you doesn't have 90 agility? In which case it's pretty reasonable for you to get burned.
 
CoachBradley
offline
Link
 
Do you look at speed as a percentile of 100? For example, DE's who have 70 speed are in the 70th percentile? Or are you using a zero base? What does this game use?

And for pass-setting, that's more agility/footwork than it is speed. Speed really has nothing to do with the pass-set at all.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by CoachBradley
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Except it doesn't happen to OT's who are built well.

What the hell do you need 80 strength for when the DE you are blocking is 30-40 strength??


The next team he plays might have DE's who have 65-70 strength.



And what happens if he is going to face a 90 strength DE? What is that DE going to do to him? Have you ever seen an OT get pancaked by a DE on the way to a quick sack? I've seen alot of games and I've never seen one. A 50 strength OT can handle a 80 strength DE just fine in pass blocking.

If you want to complain about something, complain about that. Complain that high strength DE's are good for nothing. I'll back you on that. They should pummel low strength OT's and drive them back on running plays and back into the QB on passing plays. But it doesn't happen.

Don't punish the speed DE's because the strength DE build isn't working. If the speed DE's can't get sacks using their speed, then how the hell are they going to get a sack?

In RL, teams often have to keep a RB or TE in all game to help double a fast DE. Bort just implemented that now, so that should help also.
Last edited Nov 11, 2008 09:43:53
 
Faux Bear
offline
Link
 
Speed should have absolutely nothing to do with the blocking equation.

Successful OT's are described as having great footwork, which should be about agility and nothing at all to do with speed.

Now I have no idea how the sim is coded, but if anything, the OT SHOULD need more agility (yes, more than the soft cap), but speed should bare absolutely no consequence to the sucecss of an OT.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
the funny thing is, most of the threads this season have been about DE's that aren't getting the QB. OT's received better blocking pathing and the ability to use their strength to push around a lower strength DE, if they locked up. I've seen it a lot in the games I've reviewed.

From the looks of the replays, you are going up against a DE with...80+ speed...maybe 90+? Probably all speed & agility...some strength. 80+ speed will own 35 speed any day of the week on a lot of plays -- if you want comparisons, watch some of the hybrid DE's in the NFL, ala James Harrison, for example, and how fast they can bypass a bad OT.
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
The entire concept of "speed" needs a serious reevaluation if an offensive linemen needs DE-like speed just to get set in pass protection. They're not running. They're not chasing. They're taking a couple steps back and engaging. Foot speed should have very little at all to do with it.

Or did we decide that achieving some semblance of realism was no longer a goal here?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Faux Bear
Speed should have absolutely nothing to do with the blocking equation.

Successful OT's are described as having great footwork, which should be about agility and nothing at all to do with speed.

Now I have no idea how the sim is coded, but if anything, the OT SHOULD need more agility (yes, more than the soft cap), but speed should bare absolutely no consequence to the sucecss of an OT.



agility in GLB = not agility in RL

I say that every day.


Think of agility of how quickly a guy can turn.

If he had 100 agility and 0 speed, he would just spin around in a circle and not move position at all.

If he had 0 agility and 100 speed, then he could move extremely fast, but only in 1 direction.

So to say that a OT only needs agility, I would tell you that is wrong. High agility (in GLB) just means that he would be able turn very quickly and watch the DE run past him.


Speed + agility = quickness is the GLB equation.

In real life quickness = agility, but that is not how Bort defined the attributes.
Last edited Nov 11, 2008 09:47:36
 
cwrujosh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Faux Bear

Speed should have absolutely nothing to do with the blocking equation.

Successful OT's are described as having great footwork, which should be about agility and nothing at all to do with speed.

Now I have no idea how the sim is coded, but if anything, the OT SHOULD need more agility (yes, more than the soft cap), but speed should bare absolutely no consequence to the sucecss of an OT.



agility in GLB = not agility in RL



Why is this so hard for people to grasp? While this is a football SIM, you need to understand the SIM better than the game itself.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.