good idea. been said before, but i liked it back then too.
Forum > Suggestions > Has there been any discussion of instituting NCAA overtime rules?
SwagOnLock
offline
offline
Originally posted by Darren Sanders
good idea. been said before, but i liked it back then too.
Good to know. Was it ever addressed by Bort and Co.?
good idea. been said before, but i liked it back then too.
Good to know. Was it ever addressed by Bort and Co.?
uncle_wilf
offline
offline
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
Anybody care to play devil's advocate? Any reason Bort might have for not wanting to implement this?
OK. I haven't got a clue what the NCAA rule is. Those 15%* or so of GLBers outside North America probably don't ever get to see the College game. I know I don't. Everyone who plays this game is familiar with the NFL rule.
That's the only reason I have.
(* 15% is an approximation. Or in other words, a guess)
Anybody care to play devil's advocate? Any reason Bort might have for not wanting to implement this?
OK. I haven't got a clue what the NCAA rule is. Those 15%* or so of GLBers outside North America probably don't ever get to see the College game. I know I don't. Everyone who plays this game is familiar with the NFL rule.
That's the only reason I have.
(* 15% is an approximation. Or in other words, a guess)
SwagOnLock
offline
offline
Originally posted by uncle_wilf
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
Anybody care to play devil's advocate? Any reason Bort might have for not wanting to implement this?
OK. I haven't got a clue what the NCAA rule is. Those 15%* or so of GLBers outside North America probably don't ever get to see the College game. I know I don't. Everyone who plays this game is familiar with the NFL rule.
That's the only reason I have.
(* 15% is an approximation. Or in other words, a guess)
Ah thanks for speaking up. The NCAA rule is great:
# A coin toss determines which side shall attempt to score first, and at which end zone the scores shall be attempted.
# Each team in turn will receive one possession, starting with first-and-10 from a fixed point on the opponent's side of the field:
* In college football, the possession begins at the opponent's 25-yard line
# The game clock does not run during overtime; the play clock, however, is enforced.
# A team's possession ends when it scores (touchdown or field goal), misses a field goal, fails to gain a first down on the final down, or loses the ball by turnover. As usual, a touchdown by the offense is followed by a try for one or two points. (In NCAA Football, teams must attempt a two-point conversion after a touchdown starting in the third overtime.)
If the score remains tied at the end of the overtime procedure, an additional overtime procedure is played. The team with the second possession in one overtime procedure will have the first possession in the next overtime procedure.
In other words, you have to stop the opposing offense on their possession, and then score on them in your possession, in order to win the game. No more lucking out with the coin toss, kicking a FG, and winning.
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
Anybody care to play devil's advocate? Any reason Bort might have for not wanting to implement this?
OK. I haven't got a clue what the NCAA rule is. Those 15%* or so of GLBers outside North America probably don't ever get to see the College game. I know I don't. Everyone who plays this game is familiar with the NFL rule.
That's the only reason I have.
(* 15% is an approximation. Or in other words, a guess)
Ah thanks for speaking up. The NCAA rule is great:
# A coin toss determines which side shall attempt to score first, and at which end zone the scores shall be attempted.
# Each team in turn will receive one possession, starting with first-and-10 from a fixed point on the opponent's side of the field:
* In college football, the possession begins at the opponent's 25-yard line
# The game clock does not run during overtime; the play clock, however, is enforced.
# A team's possession ends when it scores (touchdown or field goal), misses a field goal, fails to gain a first down on the final down, or loses the ball by turnover. As usual, a touchdown by the offense is followed by a try for one or two points. (In NCAA Football, teams must attempt a two-point conversion after a touchdown starting in the third overtime.)
If the score remains tied at the end of the overtime procedure, an additional overtime procedure is played. The team with the second possession in one overtime procedure will have the first possession in the next overtime procedure.
In other words, you have to stop the opposing offense on their possession, and then score on them in your possession, in order to win the game. No more lucking out with the coin toss, kicking a FG, and winning.
cameron5dollars
offline
offline
I like College OT, just move it back so you have to at least make ONE first down before you can score, like the 45.
Last edited Nov 8, 2008 19:00:12
Adderfist
offline
offline
Originally posted by cameron5dollars
I like College OT, just move it back so you have to at least make ONE first down before you can score, like the 45.
I like College OT, just move it back so you have to at least make ONE first down before you can score, like the 45.
Homsar16
offline
offline
Originally posted by uncle_wilf
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
Anybody care to play devil's advocate? Any reason Bort might have for not wanting to implement this?
OK. I haven't got a clue what the NCAA rule is. Those 15%* or so of GLBers outside North America probably don't ever get to see the College game. I know I don't. Everyone who plays this game is familiar with the NFL rule.
That's the only reason I have.
(* 15% is an approximation. Or in other words, a guess)
The guys outside of America often don't see the pro game either. I've played with guys that have never even seen American football on TV before.
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
Anybody care to play devil's advocate? Any reason Bort might have for not wanting to implement this?
OK. I haven't got a clue what the NCAA rule is. Those 15%* or so of GLBers outside North America probably don't ever get to see the College game. I know I don't. Everyone who plays this game is familiar with the NFL rule.
That's the only reason I have.
(* 15% is an approximation. Or in other words, a guess)
The guys outside of America often don't see the pro game either. I've played with guys that have never even seen American football on TV before.
happylittletrees
offline
offline
Originally posted by Adderfist
Originally posted by cameron5dollars
I like College OT, just move it back so you have to at least make ONE first down before you can score, like the 45.
I don't think it's needed, some teams have problems with this look what happen to lsu in OT against alabama
Originally posted by cameron5dollars
I like College OT, just move it back so you have to at least make ONE first down before you can score, like the 45.
I don't think it's needed, some teams have problems with this look what happen to lsu in OT against alabama
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























