User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Oceania A Leagues > Oceania A #2 > Why the NHL is better then the NFL
Page:
 
Cowpoker
offline
Link
 
Hey easy, I used to lead with my helmet, maybe that explains ALOT
 
ttipp
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by easycheez
As a coach I can assure you that "no helmet to helmet" has nothing to do with trying to make the game less vicious, it's intended to reduce the number of vegetables and corpses among former players.

I love hockey, but let's face it - In the NFL these guys are 6'5", 270lbs, and they run a 4.4 40. These guys are unbelievable athletic machines - They're big, they're fast, they're ripped. Rules are in place to make sure that one of these guys doesn't hit someone to the point that the recipient spends the rest of his life shitting into a leg bag.

I was following your argument and I do love hockey but comparing fighting and vicious hits to the moves that the NFL has made to reduce in-game fatalities really just single-handedly ruined your argument imo. You went from debater to zealot with that argument.

I love sports, I love vicious sports, and i love to see people get their clocks cleaned. I do not, however, want to see someone's life ruined because of a nasty hit. I don't care how cool the replay looks, if it causes a human being to require a machine to breath I'm generally going to be against it.

I've had far too many football players carted off the field on a backboard to argue that protective rules are "un-manly" in any way.

Agreed. I love football and a lot of people dont realize that most of the players have serious health issues after they retire. Some are so F'd up phiscally that they cant walk
 
Cowpoker
offline
Link
 
Don't play then
 
easycheez
offline
Link
 
I played hockey, too, so I do love both sports. Ever since I started coaching football my love for the game has really grown. From a coaching stand-point the game is basically a huge chess match. You're trying to guess what the other team is going to do, you track their tendencies, look for tells... You spend more of the game inside of your opponents' head then you do coaching your own team, typically.

From a player stand-point, yes, hockey is fast, it's skill-intensive, and it's fun as hell. I just think football has more meat to it.
 
Cowpoker
offline
Link
 
You think wrong
 
ttipp
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cowpoker
Don't play then


Football is by far my favorite sport to play. IS it dangerous yes, but the fun out weighs the risks.
 
Cowpoker
offline
Link
 
There are more serious injuries in High School cheerleading then there are in High School football. That might not have anything to do with the topic but it is interesting none the less.
 
tsailin
offline
Link
 
At least one sport isn't going bankrupt.

On the other hand, Hockey is more fun to play though, IMO.
 
sjbtwitch
offline
Link
 
hockey sucks
 
ttipp
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cowpoker
There are more serious injuries in High School cheerleading then there are in High School football. That might not have anything to do with the topic but it is interesting none the less.


What are you talking about!?!?!
 
Cowpoker
offline
Link
 
Its a fact
 
ttipp
offline
Link
 
No its not you just made that up.. There are a ton of injuries in HS Football....
 
RaginAsian23
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ttipp
No its not you just made that up.. There are a ton of injuries in HS Football....


+1
 
Roctronic
offline
Link
 
Agreed, Hockey is sick.

However the NFL and the NHL are too different to compare.

Solid points though.
 
masterrdogg
offline
Link
 
I have to say cowpoker is right about the cheerleading I saw the same report.

but I also have played and coached football
been around the game 39 yrs
I love football
I have a replaced knee titanium would i do it all over again in a heart beat.
to another area
last weeks varsity Game
we were down at halftime 33-6
came back to 33-26
driving for a score as time was ticking off the clock
our star HB breaks loose and gets tackled at the 5 and fumble pitches the ball forward our OT picks it up and bulls forward being tackled down at the foot mark and the clock ticks off the final seconds
thats what is so awesome about football
comebacks courage heart physical contact
and drama
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.