User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Africa A League > Africa A #2 > Africa 2 Power Rankings
Page:
 
froman77
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Verde Verde Verde
How are we behind the Zulu Death Warriors when we just beat them?


you guys are pretty close. and dont ask me. ask the program i stole from the fat kid in my dorm.
 
odt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Verde Verde Verde
How are we behind the Zulu Death Warriors when we just beat them?


Should Oregon State jump over USC after they beat them?
 
swimmaboy69
offline
Link
 
Froman thank you for the bulletin board material...
 
odt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by swimmaboy69
Froman thank you for the bulletin board material...


I don't see how the dragons aren't the top team in your rankings, they have the 3rd jump from the team below them and they only have 1 bottom feeder left to play, so they may increase their lead even more after they run the table (jinx).
 
froman77
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by odt
Originally posted by swimmaboy69

Froman thank you for the bulletin board material...


I don't see how the dragons aren't the top team in your rankings, they have the 3rd jump from the team below them and they only have 1 bottom feeder left to play, so they may increase their lead even more after they run the table (jinx).


it is what it is. im surprised too, but this is what the computer spits out at me.
 
swimmaboy69
offline
Link
 
Like Head1 and I said we don't expect to be unbeaten there are some great teams in our conference. We look forward to this part of the season it will bring some more excitement (not that this season hasn't been exciting enough already....)
 
head1
offline
Link
 
I think your formula needs to be adjusted to take into account losses a bit more. Cairo imo is the team to beat, but if you are going by numbers losses etc their would be no doubt in our conference who the top 2 should be, based on numbers. Now putting in a biased vote would possibly move Cairo up.

But the funny thing is thats not even the most jacked up part....Lion has a 2 loss team as the #1..?

dont know how you came to make your calculations work, they are fun to read but this one is a little more un realistic than most with no thought given to wins and losses. to me it looks like you just took scores and used that and left out wins/losses.

 
roake0331
offline
Link
 
after the dragon/cairo game I am sure the computer rank system will make more sense to you head1.

can't wait!
 
head1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by roake0331
after the dragon/cairo game I am sure the computer rank system will make more sense to you head1.

can't wait!


Cairo doesn't need a fubar computer ranking to get respect from me or my GMs. I have said many times I think Cairo is the team to beat, but the way this ranking is made is not accurate on paper. If I came to this league and looked at the teams, and scored and W/L it would be pretty obvious how it would go.

I do agree its going to be a good game, a tough game at that.
 
odt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by head1
But the funny thing is thats not even the most jacked up part....Lion has a 2 loss team as the #1..?


Lion has only 1 one loss team and 3 two loss teams, so thats not so hard to believe. The funny part is how far ahead of KC both freetown and the warriors are.
 
froman77
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by head1
I think your formula needs to be adjusted to take into account losses a bit more. Cairo imo is the team to beat, but if you are going by numbers losses etc their would be no doubt in our conference who the top 2 should be, based on numbers. Now putting in a biased vote would possibly move Cairo up.

But the funny thing is thats not even the most jacked up part....Lion has a 2 loss team as the #1..?

dont know how you came to make your calculations work, they are fun to read but this one is a little more un realistic than most with no thought given to wins and losses. to me it looks like you just took scores and used that and left out wins/losses.



its true. don't really take into account wins and losses that strongly. if you win you will get +(margin of victory)*(some #) where the # is a pretty solid indicator of how good the opposing team is. if you lose you get -(margin of victory)*(some #) where the # is the same indicator but saying how bad the team is. the further the games go into the season, the more heavily they are weighted too.

who knows, maybe i just entered the results of the last games wrong.

im thinking of probably increasing the weight given to when you beat good teams. with these rankings, you get a significant amount of more points by destroying a weak team, than you would narrowly beating a good team.
 
froman77
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by odt
Originally posted by head1

But the funny thing is thats not even the most jacked up part....Lion has a 2 loss team as the #1..?


Lion has only 1 one loss team and 3 two loss teams, so thats not so hard to believe. The funny part is how far ahead of KC both freetown and the warriors are.


KC has won some games by very narrow margins. when you're winning by 1 or 2 points, that's only one significant play or two difference between the two teams. its my opinion that teams shouldn't be too heavily rewarded for barely beating another team.
 
mmuhr
offline
Link
 
When you look at Anubis they lost to KC by 1 pt and Killamanjaro by 3pts. And then you look at how badly we dominated everyone else....Sure a win is a win but if the best team doesnt always win.
 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by froman77


im thinking of probably increasing the weight given to when you beat good teams. with these rankings, you get a significant amount of more points by destroying a weak team, than you would narrowly beating a good team.


One of the fundamentals of mathematical modeling - any time two numbers are multiplied together, it's better to have both parts medium than one high and one low.

Example - two numbers which add up to 21:

1 x 20 = 20
2 x 19 = 38
5 x 16 = 90
9 x 12 = 108
10 x 11 = 110


 
froman77
offline
Link
 
updated through week 10
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.