User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Defense AI occasionally not followed
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

...

1.) I don't know about your problem. I was talking about the others. You need to provide a link to the play you are talking about and the EXACT code you have (down, distance, field postition, etc, along with the defensive AI and we can go from there. Maybe you provided it before, but can you copy it again? Yours is probably a mistake you will realize just from posting it.

2.) They are talking about something completely different. They are talking about calling plays on offense (mostly), but also occasionally on defense that they didn't call and aren't in their playbook at all.


P.S. My solution is not a workaround. I just found the error is MY program. That is basically what we are doing, making a program. Many of US have made errors in our programs and come here looking for Bort to look through all our code and fix your mistakes. He has better things to do.


Look... you kind of pretend to know that's an error in the AI. I've been helping people to fix those kind of self-made bugs for quite a while. I'm not dumb, but just reporting a BUG.

The BUG is that plays are called that are NOT supposed to be called while the defensive AI is PROPERLY set up. How hard is that to understand?



Originally posted by RAPB

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=146243&pbp_id=6071961

This is the single back big. We play one of our single back plays (3-3-5 and MLB + ROLB blitzing) - instead of the single back big plays (3-4 and 4-3 + no blitzers).

The single back big - input is above the single back inputs, so it should have triggered. But it has not!


Here's the play.

Here's the defense AI test:

Quarter: 4
Time Remaining: 673 seconds
Ball Spot: opp 20 yd line
Down: 1
Yards to go: 10 yards
Score: I'm leading by 1 points
Opponent Formation: Single Back Big
Number of Wide Receivers: 2


Matching Input
Input Named: Single Back Big

Possible Outputs
5% 3-4 - "(deleted by myself)" (3-4 Cover 1 man)
25% 3-4 - "(deleted by myself)" (3-4 Cover 2 man)
70% 4-3 - "(deleted by myself)" (4-3 Cover 2 man)

(ALL of these outputs don't have blitzers; we don't blitz on this shorter pass play - and the play in question is a 3-3-5.)


Got it?

Just a bug. Plain and simple.

Now - just for a second - assume that some of the guys posting here haven't done something wrong too. They just keep on reporting a BUG.

Got it?

Just a bug. Plain and simple.

No Painmaker, no SteelersInsider, no secret alliance will take that away - for the AI is set up properly.

Just a bug. Plain and simple.



(while I do agree that 99% of all "AI not followed" posts are just user errors, you should take some people serious once in a while)




I need more info than that.

What do you have in for 4th quarter AI?

And that blitz that is called - it is a very popular weakside shift, MLB and ROLB blitz. Where do you have that blitz in your AI? The computer didn't randomly just pick that one.

Send me a GM and I'll take a look?

Did you change stuff since the game?
 
Link
 
want to bet it isn't a bug?

They should have people put up 1,000 FP's before posting a bug. Then if it isn't a bug, then they lose the 1,000 FP.

how about that? If I find your bug, you owe me $5? I could sit in the bug forum and make $100/day finding "bugs". lol
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
...

I need more info than that.

What do you have in for 4th quarter AI?

And that blitz that is called - it is a very popular weakside shift, MLB and ROLB blitz. Where do you have that blitz in your AI? The computer didn't randomly just pick that one.

Send me a GM and I'll take a look?

Did you change stuff since the game?


You still don't get it. THE AI IS PROPERLY SET UP!!!

(I know, naturally you'd like to distrust guys you don't know. You might think about that attitude anyway - but since I'm the same, I can understand.)

As I stated already (see above), we play the defense called as one of our plays vs. single back and 3 WR shotgun. And as I stated already (see above), the input for single back is BELOW the input for single back big in the AI.

Yes, we got 4th quarter specifics. A lot. For about every formation. And depending on leading or trailing. But none for the single back big (the "normal" plays just work fine and no need to gamble on this one).

At the same time, ALL inputs are set up by formation. So there's no "catch all" input anywhere. We got a 4th quarter single back input - including that 3-3-5 MLB+ROLB blitz... but set to less than 360 seconds and Score Difference between -100 and -3. So even if the AI triggers a single back big formation as part of the single back [like strong I and weak I to I (any variation)] - that one shouldn't have triggered.

And as the defense AI tester shows, there actually is no input interfering.

Now you can keep thinking, there's still a error in the AI setup and you'd find it for sure.

(Sometimes I keep doing that myself in similar situations. I always feel bad afterwards if "Mr. Superbrain" fails once again because the other guy was just right and actually thought about it just as well.)

But I tell you: it's not. It's a bug and I reported it to show Bort this is not just crap and stupid. There's a problem the better DCs recognize when it happens. It's VERY RARE. The whole game it called the plays we set up - but then one play...

... just not.
 
Morphius
offline
Link
 
I agree with thehazyone. I just discovered this today. I would have discovered it sooner but I havn't gone through our replays play by play in a while cause we've had a string of easy teams the last few games.

I too go through all my replays to see whats working on defense and whats not. As of late I've noticed some of my AI settings being ignored. My Big I 2WR calls in particular. Every time the offense lines up in the Big I 2WR, it calls the base 4-3 defense. Whereas I have an input with about 5 different outputs at 20% each it has the potential to call. Yet, all of them get ingored.

When I first noticed this I too went to the Test AI page and entered the exact details for about 5 different plays, to make sure it wasn't just overriding it with another input or that I didn't have a typo somewhere. Sure enough, it pops up with my Big I 2WR input like it was calling it all day long.

The only time I found a game where it actually called the plays I wanted for the Big I 2WR formation, was the game where I had its input at the top of the AI. On the other AIs where it was messing up, it was the 3rd input down, and again, there was nothing to override it.

This is most definately a bug and needs to be dealt with.
Last edited Oct 10, 2008 11:53:37
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Morphius
I agree with thehazyone. I just discovered this today. I would have discovered it sooner but I havn't gone through our replays play by play in a while cause we've had a string of easy teams the last few games.

I too go through all my replays to see whats working on defense and whats not. As of late I've noticed some of my AI settings being ignored. My Big I 2WR calls in particular. Every time the offense lines up in the Big I 2WR, it calls the base 4-3 defense. Whereas I have an input with about 5 different outputs at 20% each it has the potential to call. Yet, all of them get ingored.

When I first noticed this I too went to the Test AI page and entered the exact details for about 5 different plays, to make sure it wasn't just overriding it with another input or that I didn't have a typo somewhere. Sure enough, it pops up with my Big I 2WR input like it was calling it all day long.

The only time I found a game where it actually called the plays I wanted for the Big I 2WR formation, was the game where I had its input at the top of the AI. On the other AIs where it was messing up, it was the 3rd input down, and again, there was nothing to override it.

This is most definately a bug and needs to be dealt with.


Sorry, but fail. There's no big I plays as of today.

If you think the I formation with the HB a little further backwards is the big I... no. It's just I (any formation) + 2 WR.

No big I plays in the SIM.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Come up so many times, so
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1206193
 
Morphius
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Come up so many times, so
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1206193


Ah. Thank you for clarifying. I retract my previous statement.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by Morphius

I agree with thehazyone. I just discovered this today. I would have discovered it sooner but I havn't gone through our replays play by play in a while cause we've had a string of easy teams the last few games.

I too go through all my replays to see whats working on defense and whats not. As of late I've noticed some of my AI settings being ignored. My Big I 2WR calls in particular. Every time the offense lines up in the Big I 2WR, it calls the base 4-3 defense. Whereas I have an input with about 5 different outputs at 20% each it has the potential to call. Yet, all of them get ingored.

When I first noticed this I too went to the Test AI page and entered the exact details for about 5 different plays, to make sure it wasn't just overriding it with another input or that I didn't have a typo somewhere. Sure enough, it pops up with my Big I 2WR input like it was calling it all day long.

The only time I found a game where it actually called the plays I wanted for the Big I 2WR formation, was the game where I had its input at the top of the AI. On the other AIs where it was messing up, it was the 3rd input down, and again, there was nothing to override it.

This is most definately a bug and needs to be dealt with.


Sorry, but fail. There's no big I plays as of today.

If you think the I formation with the HB a little further backwards is the big I... no. It's just I (any formation) + 2 WR.

No big I plays in the SIM.



there goes 2 of your 4 supporters (I proved Islanders was wrong also).

 
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

...

I need more info than that.

What do you have in for 4th quarter AI?

And that blitz that is called - it is a very popular weakside shift, MLB and ROLB blitz. Where do you have that blitz in your AI? The computer didn't randomly just pick that one.

Send me a GM and I'll take a look?

Did you change stuff since the game?


You still don't get it. THE AI IS PROPERLY SET UP!!!

(I know, naturally you'd like to distrust guys you don't know. You might think about that attitude anyway - but since I'm the same, I can understand.)

As I stated already (see above), we play the defense called as one of our plays vs. single back and 3 WR shotgun. And as I stated already (see above), the input for single back is BELOW the input for single back big in the AI.

Yes, we got 4th quarter specifics. A lot. For about every formation. And depending on leading or trailing. But none for the single back big (the "normal" plays just work fine and no need to gamble on this one).

At the same time, ALL inputs are set up by formation. So there's no "catch all" input anywhere. We got a 4th quarter single back input - including that 3-3-5 MLB+ROLB blitz... but set to less than 360 seconds and Score Difference between -100 and -3. So even if the AI triggers a single back big formation as part of the single back [like strong I and weak I to I (any variation)] - that one shouldn't have triggered.

And as the defense AI tester shows, there actually is no input interfering.

Now you can keep thinking, there's still a error in the AI setup and you'd find it for sure.

(Sometimes I keep doing that myself in similar situations. I always feel bad afterwards if "Mr. Superbrain" fails once again because the other guy was just right and actually thought about it just as well.)

But I tell you: it's not. It's a bug and I reported it to show Bort this is not just crap and stupid. There's a problem the better DCs recognize when it happens. It's VERY RARE. The whole game it called the plays we set up - but then one play...

... just not.



It isn't about "trusting" you. The fact is that you are human and humans make mistakes.

I've looked over the same piece of computer code for 1 week straight and was sure everything was perfect but still getting an error. Another person took a look in 5 minutes saw the missing ";" and it worked fine.

Want to bet that I can find the error?

What do you want to bet?
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
I wish SI wouldn't derail this thread. This is a legitimate bug, I have no doubt about this. I know how to input the AI's and don't make mistakes doing so. I'd still like Bort to look into this.

This also has nothing to do with the offensive AI. I haven't had any issues with that. It is solely on the defensive side of the ball where I have a 100% formation play call and that play is not getting called under that particular formation (which is why I know it is not a user error, it's simply not possible) on random occurrences... not all occurrences, most of the time the correct play is called, but occasionally, say one out of ten times, it will go to my bug defense which is the last input I have in my playbook and should never get called since I have formation specific defenses for every formation. This is why I know when something wrong happened. I see the "bug" defense on the field and I know that for some reason the right formation play was not called out.
 
Link
 
I saw the same problem once in a while, it doesn't show up very frequently though.

A simple question to people who don't believe this is a bug: In OP's case, the defense AI tester says it is 100% "3-4 Cover 0 man". Why wasn't "3-4 Cover 0 man" used in the link OP provided? If it was a human mistake in defense AI, defense AI tester wouldn't have showed 100% "3-4 Cover 0 man" and should show a play matched what was actually used in the game. Shouldn't it?

Last edited Oct 11, 2008 12:44:34
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Bump
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Not denying your reality, but I also watch every single play of every game for the team I own, and for one of the teams I GM as well (though only on offense for them).

I have many times seen a defense that didn't look right...and every time I eventually tracked down the error...which was mine.

I am fairly fastidious, and have a background writing code, so I am no prone to these mistakes...yet they do seem to happen to me at least.

A few questions, meant to be helpful...

Do these unexpected formations always occur in the same quarter? Do they ever occur at the beginning of a game, or only towards the end? If you see the wrong coverage called, will it ever return tp the correct coverage later in the game?

 
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone
Bump



did it happen again in your last game?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Not denying your reality, but I also watch every single play of every game for the team I own, and for one of the teams I GM as well (though only on offense for them).

I have many times seen a defense that didn't look right...and every time I eventually tracked down the error...which was mine.

I am fairly fastidious, and have a background writing code, so I am no prone to these mistakes...yet they do seem to happen to me at least.

A few questions, meant to be helpful...

Do these unexpected formations always occur in the same quarter? Do they ever occur at the beginning of a game, or only towards the end? If you see the wrong coverage called, will it ever return tp the correct coverage later in the game?



I agree with everything you said and how to start de-bugging it.

I pull plays that didn't seem right and every time I go back, *I* was the one who made the error. Even though I spent tons of time fixing it.

If the OP had a couple people (or at least 1 other person) take a look we could easily get this thing solved or pass it along for Bort to see.

It seems at this point that the OP is the only owner (out of all 2,000 teams or however many there are) that is experiencing this problem.

Maybe the OP should try the exact same defense on another team you play/GM for and see if it does the same thing (maybe in a game vs weak opponent).

If it is happening to many teams, then it is a bug. If it is only your team, then 99.99% chance it is user error.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.