User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > IS STRONGBASE BROKEN? (by WiSeIVIaN, the guy who posts threads that never really go anywhere)
Page:
 
California
knows how to party
offline
Link
 
The larger point is this:

DTs were the original nerf. How many DTs do you think have had more than 80 tackles in a season?
 
Randy03Texags
offline
Link
 
DTs are like FBs, if they are doing their job, you dont notice it, if they arent, you notice it.

Also DTs that are really in one direction or the other (just like all GLB builds) do their job, high strength and shed block DTs disrupt running plays well, high speed and agility DTs get around guards well and rush the passer, we scrimmaged a team just recently that I know the DTs were built more like LBs and they were really fast (70 speed and agility), it worked somewhat.

Strong base is used so that you dont get pushed out of the way by guards, it is the anti-SA of Get Low and Strong Arm. You need it to hold your ground, not to blow past guards. To blow past guards you need Shed Block and/or lots of speed/agility.

Its not the SA that is broken, it is the people who dont understand their point.
Last edited Oct 1, 2008 03:09:15
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
Originally posted by Havoc
...You seem to be arguing that agility/speed are the only way to produce pressure, which would imply strong base is useless.


Which would be the point of my thread, that strongbase is useless. The point of my thread isn't "i want my player to get sacks"....


I guess, you imagine SA Strong Base as kind of SA Pancake for DTs. Set the LG or Center on his back and procede to the QB. If so, SA Strong Base is a "stand alone" and should work no matter what your side skills are.

I see it rather like a it helps to push free you way to the QB. Now vision makes you choose a good way and react quicker to what the lineman does - he's stepping aside to give a LB a Strong Arm? Your guy realizes faster, takes a step to the opposite side and pushes all he can. I'm not saying to softcap vision - but get it somewhat up to like 35+.

After looking at the SA Absorb Pain of offense lineman and watching lineman all the time, I see in-game morale and the effect of confidence not only as "drop if fail". It's more like a constant going down when doing hard work (getting blocked / blocking strong guys), getting scored upon, getting to trail... and of course if you fail. Confidence makes that drop down slower and cheers you up once you do something great. Again, I'm not talking about softcapping confidence, but 30 I consider a minimum (that's twice as much as you got!).

So the intense training combination vision+confidence sure looks good for your guy. With that strength and the SA, YOUR guy should be the one that lowers the opponents in-game morale by making them suffer. And if you do this fast enough, you'd see false starts and good QB pressure as the game goes on.

b.t.w.: the description of SA Strong Base mentiones a "chance of the skill working". So you don't see it every play - just sometimes. Now if your guy is in the NT position as it fires and is double teamed by C/RG - you sure see less effect. And if it fires during run plays, you won't see much more than your guy not beeing moved at all and the FB helping out and/or the HB avoiding your guy.
Combine that with the effect of low in-game morale and the fact, that offensive lineman have the SA Foundation up somewhat. If the other players of your team don't have much points into SAs D-Line-General and Defense General, the opponents might even get a edge on your team as the game goes on.

 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
I think people expect to see a little bit of push like this at least once in a while if they use Strong Base:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=88491&pbp_id=910771
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=88491&pbp_id=910050
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=88491&pbp_id=911401

I haven't really seen this happen other than the 1st game(s) of Season 4 right after bull rush was 1st introduced.

It could be a number of things:

- Knock-on of run blocking improvements in S4 (holding blocks longer once in contact)
- Double teams essentially defeat the skill (the G in my example doesn't really do anything)
- Guards have an aversion to double-teaming DEs (now see previous point)
- Inability to keep STR ahead of the OL STRncurve (once you approach the high 90's in STR you are dealing with 1 point for 4 and 5 SP). Also 75-80 STR C or G seem to hold their own vs. a 90-95 STR DT (assuming somewhat decent build).


Also about BigCali's point...my NT did manage 80 tackles in Season 3, but it was in USA BBB and he played every down of every game. I have one guy on pace for 80 this year, but figure he will return to his 1 or 2 tackle ways soon.
Last edited Oct 1, 2008 06:32:14
 
crazy454
what
offline
Link
 
My DT

75-50-72 St, Sp, Ag, 5 shed 6 strong

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=171555

Most of my sacks come from running right through the player
Last edited Oct 1, 2008 06:39:24
 
NotRippedYet
offline
Link
 
In my opinion Strong base works, but in the wrong way. From what I've seen (and again, it's difficult to judge when the SA is working) when strong base activates the DT will simply push the guard straight back, causing him to act like a sled rather than shoving him to a side to get around him. If you SERIOUSLY overpower the guard this may pancake him and allow your DT around, however, since most guards have tons of strength it usually just causes the guard to go sliding back towards the QB while still somewhat holding the block and you get no hurry or sack.
 
crazy454
what
offline
Link
 
Using Strong Base and SHED block is what gets sacks, push him back shed the block speed to hit the QB
 
Madd_Maxx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Strong base works just fine, in my experience.


You have like 10+ DT's and not a single sack from any of them this season.
 
Madd_Maxx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter


A lot of ya'll are under estimating vision and confidence. Vision is a must have for all positions. If you can't see or know where to go/put your hands yadda yadda yadda then your guy won't do much.
If your guy is getting pushed around a little by a G then your in game morale will drop as well, especially if you get pancaked, even if you are winning.


Wrong, my DT has 25 vision and has 10 sacks and a lot of hurries, tackles this season including scrimmages.
 
Madd_Maxx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thebigcali
The larger point is this:

DTs were the original nerf. How many DTs do you think have had more than 80 tackles in a season?


My DT had 72 last year and has 33 already after 5 games.
 
Madd_Maxx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Randy03Texags
DTs are like FBs, if they are doing their job, you dont notice it, if they arent, you notice it.

Also DTs that are really in one direction or the other (just like all GLB builds) do their job, high strength and shed block DTs disrupt running plays well, high speed and agility DTs get around guards well and rush the passer, we scrimmaged a team just recently that I know the DTs were built more like LBs and they were really fast (70 speed and agility), it worked somewhat.

Strong base is used so that you dont get pushed out of the way by guards, it is the anti-SA of Get Low and Strong Arm. You need it to hold your ground, not to blow past guards. To blow past guards you need Shed Block and/or lots of speed/agility.

Its not the SA that is broken, it is the people who dont understand their point.


My DT does both well, run and pass rushing, and doesnt have SA's.
 
Motiak
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I think for the most part DT SAs just aren't effective. People who try to blame this on confidence/vision just haven't been in the DT community long enough to realize that pretty much no one with a strong base build gets anywhere against OLines.

edit: I don't use strong base on my DT.
Last edited Oct 1, 2008 08:23:31
 
NotRippedYet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Madd_Maxx
Originally posted by thebigcali

The larger point is this:

DTs were the original nerf. How many DTs do you think have had more than 80 tackles in a season?


My DT had 72 last year and has 33 already after 5 games.


Your DT is a level 25 in a second season league. You can't base anything off of him.
 
Madd_Maxx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by notrippedyet

Your DT is a level 25 in a second season league. You can't base anything off of him.


Sure I can...he is going up against good, similar level Guards, against some very good teams and dominating all of them.
Last edited Oct 1, 2008 09:51:44
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
I would absolutely love to see a DT with high vision/confidence who has had production rushing the passer. You don't have to open the build, but I'd love to see one buddy and would fully concede to your point.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=356507

45+ Vision, 30+ Confidence.

3 Hurries, 1 Sack and 7 TFL in 5 games this year. We've only played one weak team, although they weren't gutted, just not up to the level of the league.

He's had highs and lows, for sure. Last year was not a very productive year. I think his build is finally getting to the point of solid, steady production. In fact, I predict him to be a true force by the end of the season.

Of course, it's pretty tough to get a hurry or sack when the DEs he plays with are in the backfield on every play...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.