User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Petition to Fix XPs
Page:
 
saintedix
offline
Link
 
EVERYONE: Your K's aren't NFL kickers. Get over it.

Once we see kickers who are level 50+ missing XPs regularly, then come back and post this.
 
saintedix
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho
Originally posted by sickie8305

I see the point, I average about 1 miss every 2-3 games...It could be better


I know this game isn't trying to emulate any sort of professional football league, but if you look at the stats of just about any organized football (including college, arena, even high school), you'll see that they miss significantly less XPs than we do here. It just isn't realistic.

And even if you don't consider the real life stats, using basic logic would tell you that someone who is built to kick the ball up to 50 or 60 yards should be able to consistently kick it accurately 10 yards.


By the way, XP is 19 yards
 
conmack49
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by saintedix
Originally posted by Anarcho

Originally posted by sickie8305


I see the point, I average about 1 miss every 2-3 games...It could be better


I know this game isn't trying to emulate any sort of professional football league, but if you look at the stats of just about any organized football (including college, arena, even high school), you'll see that they miss significantly less XPs than we do here. It just isn't realistic.

And even if you don't consider the real life stats, using basic logic would tell you that someone who is built to kick the ball up to 50 or 60 yards should be able to consistently kick it accurately 10 yards.


By the way, XP is 19 yards


The PAT is placed at the three yard line. The uprights are set 10 yards deep. Typical holder placement is 7 yards deep. 3 + 10 + 7 = 20. Unless the holder is set differently, an extra point is 20 yards.
Last edited Sep 29, 2008 02:01:12
 
dablackhole
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by conmack49
Originally posted by saintedix

Originally posted by Anarcho


Originally posted by sickie8305



I see the point, I average about 1 miss every 2-3 games...It could be better


I know this game isn't trying to emulate any sort of professional football league, but if you look at the stats of just about any organized football (including college, arena, even high school), you'll see that they miss significantly less XPs than we do here. It just isn't realistic.

And even if you don't consider the real life stats, using basic logic would tell you that someone who is built to kick the ball up to 50 or 60 yards should be able to consistently kick it accurately 10 yards.


By the way, XP is 19 yards


The PAT is placed at the three yard line. The uprights are set 10 yards deep. Typical holder placement is 7 yards deep. 3 + 10 + 7 = 20. Unless the holder is set differently, an extra point is 20 yards.


I thought the PAT is placed on the 2 yard line.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by dablackhole
Originally posted by conmack49

Originally posted by saintedix


Originally posted by Anarcho



Originally posted by sickie8305




I see the point, I average about 1 miss every 2-3 games...It could be better


I know this game isn't trying to emulate any sort of professional football league, but if you look at the stats of just about any organized football (including college, arena, even high school), you'll see that they miss significantly less XPs than we do here. It just isn't realistic.

And even if you don't consider the real life stats, using basic logic would tell you that someone who is built to kick the ball up to 50 or 60 yards should be able to consistently kick it accurately 10 yards.


By the way, XP is 19 yards


The PAT is placed at the three yard line. The uprights are set 10 yards deep. Typical holder placement is 7 yards deep. 3 + 10 + 7 = 20. Unless the holder is set differently, an extra point is 20 yards.


I thought the PAT is placed on the 2 yard line.


And aren't the uprights only 8 yards back?
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
I was always under the impression that any kick is 18 yards + the spot of the ball.
 
Firenze
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by saintedix
EVERYONE: Your K's aren't NFL kickers. Get over it.

Once we see kickers who are level 50+ missing XPs regularly, then come back and post this.


We're not saying we should be NFL kickers. We're saying our XP % is worse than a college kicker, which makes no sense.

Players shouldn't have to be level 50+ to become effective at their jobs.

Last edited Sep 29, 2008 12:12:40
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
I think the logic behind the "you're not NFL kickers" argument is highly flawed.

I think everyone can agree that kicking becomes significantly more difficult the farther away from the uprights the kicker is.

Regardless of where GLB kickers range in terms of professional equivalence, there is no logical reason why a kicker would have less difficulty making kicks that by logic are more difficult.

What I'm saying is that something is wrong with kickers, regardless of where they are in terms of NFL talent.

No kicker can have more problems kicking 20 yards than they do kicking 30+. And that is what we are seeing here.

Last season the kicker on my team missed 8 FGs from 30-50+ yards. He also missed 8 XPs. This season he's missed 3 FGs, but 4 XPs. Doesn't make any sense. It doesn't matter if he only has one leg or if he is an NFL hall of famer.

Either all kickers should be terrible at all kicks, or all kickers should be adjusted to be able to make XPs at a higher percentage.
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Our kicker missed another XP today.

He's now officially missed more XPs than FGs this season.

Someone please explain how any logic could explain that?

You can't make long kicks without being able to make short ones first.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho

Either all kickers should be terrible at all kicks, or all kickers should be adjusted to be able to make XPs at a higher percentage.


Are you trying to say Bort has specifically targeted certain Kickers in the game to put a code in that makes them suck, and others not?

Please...
 
PjSanford
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho
Every area that has been addressed as a possible issue for kickers missing XPs (including stamina) has been met by a player who has no deficiencies in those areas who is still missing extra points.


Not being an arsehole, but that doesn't hold water.

Person A misses a kick, people say: "It might be stamina related."
Person B misses a kick, he says: "My stamina is fine."

That doesn't explain why Person A couldn't miss. Just because, B, C, D, E, etcetera are fine in areas 1, 2, 3, 4, etcetera, doesn't mean that they will also be fine in EVERY area.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
I'm still convinced it's a vision fuckup. If a failed vision check can make a HB run towards the defense instead of the end zone, who's to say a similarly failed vision check can't lead to a shanked XP?
 
PjSanford
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho
Our kicker missed another XP today.

He's now officially missed more XPs than FGs this season.

Someone please explain how any logic could explain that?

You can't make long kicks without being able to make short ones first.


I used to play football (Soccer) in the UK, in goal. I can put a ball nearer a traget if I am 60 yards away than if I am 20.
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnerhero
Originally posted by Anarcho


Either all kickers should be terrible at all kicks, or all kickers should be adjusted to be able to make XPs at a higher percentage.


Are you trying to say Bort has specifically targeted certain Kickers in the game to put a code in that makes them suck, and others not?

Please...


No I'm not trying to say that... otherwise I would have just said that.

I think you focused too much on the "Either all kickers" part. I'm saying that all the kickers in this game should be adjusted to be able to make XPs. OR, if we are going to go by the horrible logic that it's just part of the game and no one is an NFL kicker, than kickers in general should have a more significant problem making longer kicks.

Originally posted by PjSanford
Not being an arsehole, but that doesn't hold water.

Person A misses a kick, people say: "It might be stamina related."
Person B misses a kick, he says: "My stamina is fine."

That doesn't explain why Person A couldn't miss. Just because, B, C, D, E, etcetera are fine in areas 1, 2, 3, 4, etcetera, doesn't mean that they will also be fine in EVERY area.


It isn't exactly that simple. This issue has been exhausted in multiple threads by multiple kickers who have opened their builds and compared to other players. It isn't as simple as hearsay. It's a matter of the "experts" pointing out flaws in builds and then other kickers coming in with open builds who have no deficiencies that are still missing kicks.

Originally posted by PjSanford
I used to play football (Soccer) in the UK, in goal. I can put a ball nearer a traget if I am 60 yards away than if I am 20.


I imagine kicking a soccer ball is at least slightly different than kicking an American football. Also, since everyone on this site seems to get their panties in a bunch whenever someone mentions real life, your example is void.

American Football kickers typically have less problems kicking short than they do long. Something that is completely backwards on this game.

I'm not sure why there is so much resistance to this obvious problem. I don't think anyone can argue that any kicker (professional or otherwise) should be able to nail 40 yard kicks and not consistently make XPs. It's just silly.

Also, I wish people would actually stop and think about what it is that we are talking about. People are having problems consistently kicking XPs. How complex of a build does a kicker need to have to do something that simple? If you think about it, all this "your kicker needs more _____" talk is ridiculous. How much more of anything does a player need to do the simplest thing in the entire sport?
Last edited Sep 29, 2008 20:37:11
 
conmack49
offline
Link
 
Bump, because it'd be nice to see someone get a solution to this at some point.

Ooooh, wait, is that a shiny new field graphic?!

I completely forgot what we were talking about...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.