User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Why doesn't Bort address absurd sack totals?
Page:
 
mpowell
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by nightmaresabin

Good luck changing the game somehow to only allow 14 sacks a season when you play gutted teams that have level 4 cpu players. Blowouts are going to happen, and absurd stats are going to happen. And those guys with 50+ sacks a season, a good portion of those are on cupcake teams. It would be the equivalent of the New York Giants playing your local Junior High team. You would see guys with 80 sacks a season. Nothing you can do about that. Why does it bother you so much though?


You realize there are DEs in leagues with no gutted teams at all that got over 80 sacks last season, right?

So PLEASE stop trying to pidgeon hole my argument into the worn-out team gutting debacle. I'm NOT referring to that at all. I'm referring to absurd sack statistics across the board.

If you want to debate gutting problems go start your own thread.


The reason people keep hammering this point is because you continue to fail to understand it. You don't need to face a gutted team to run up stats. You just need 3 or 4 games against a team with a crappy OT. Maybe he's 5 levels lower, maybe he's a crappy build. Doesn't matter the reason why, but the guy earlier said it right. Quality control is missing among these teams. Even the top DEs get fairly reasonable numbers in their matchups against the very best teams.
 
Link
 
And it's absolutely unrealistic to get absurd sack totals even against inferior OTs.

In the NFL, even if the starting OT is hurt and he has a crumby backup, no DE is ever going to get even four sacks in one game. Even three-sack games pretty much only happen on *RARE* occasions to only the elite DEs of the league.

Uneven match-ups in real football = DE gets 1-3 sacks and hurries

Uneven match-ups in GLB = DE gets ten sacks

The result is a failed football simulation.

Last edited Sep 27, 2008 06:39:23
 
otto_g_2k8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Addle
I have to go with the OT builds sucking. Like I said my tackles never have any trouble stopping DEs and they're built to be able to move around. If you get your speed and agi up on your OTs you'll find it a lot easier to stop them.


THIS!!!
 
william78
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
And it's absolutely unrealistic to get absurd sack totals even against inferior OTs.

In the NFL, even if the starting OT is hurt and he has a crumby backup, no DE is ever going to get even four sacks in one game. Even three-sack games pretty much only happen on *RARE* occasions to only the elite DEs of the league.

Uneven match-ups in real football = DE gets 1-3 sacks and hurries

Uneven match-ups in GLB = DE gets ten sacks

The result is a failed football simulation.



Considering the NFL record is 7 in a game kinda belays your argument. Plus when you consider level disparity imagine putting the best pass rushing DE in the NFL against a high school or poor college players - 10 sacks might come easy.

 
hemprobot
offline
Link
 
William78 is right, it largely comes down to quality control. Even the absolute worst backup OT in the NFL is still one of the top players in his position in the entire country (if you consider the total pool of football players) or he wouldn't be on the squad at all.

Mismatches in GLB have the potential to be far, far greater than any mismatch you will ever see in the NFL. The reality is that in GLB right now any OT that has poor speed and agility is going to have his ass handed to him by some of the 80+ speed and agility DE's that exist out there and you can scale this down to be relevant at all levels.
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
GLB doesn't have QBs that know when to throw a ball away, in the NFL if you credited a sack for every throw away a QB had, they would be closer to our numbers.
 
hemprobot
offline
Link
 
Also an excellent point.
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
WAAAAAAHHHHHHH!......

Just because your team isn't benefiting from good builds, you want something "fixed". Fix yourself.

Most OT's on this game DO suck. Know how impossible it is to find a good OT in free agency? Even more difficult than it is to find a good CB.

Here's the prototypical OT on this game.

Strength: 80-100
Blocking: 60's
Speed: mid 30's
Agility: high 30's
Stamina: 40-45
Vision: 30
Confidence: 30

Protect: 2-4 (even on RT's)
Pancake: 6-8



Any guesses as to why some teams with unbalanced OT's are having struggles against unbalanced DE's? Every offensive lineman that went through seasons 2-4 trying to build up huge pancake whoring OT's, and didn't have the vision to anticipate needing to handle speed rushers, well, this is what you, and your irresponsible team owners get.
 
lump7502
offline
Link
 
and no one thinks it because the defensive end are over powered on this game from a building stand point

the tackles have 0 chance to keep up with the ends in speed

with 0 natural progression in that skill vs the position on the field with the highest progression
 
lump7502
offline
Link
 
a simple solution would be to remove tackling from the oline progression and replace it with speed
 
shull
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lump7502
a simple solution would be to remove tackling from the oline progression and replace it with speed


This is actually a good idea.

I'm a believer that DE's aren't broken, it's simply that people built their OT's like jktooley described.
 
Sao
offline
Link
 
How about some agility for these big dumb oaf OT's? Instead of everyone going for 90 STR and 80 BL, build some movement. I'll take 0 pancakes if I allow 0 sacks any given Sunday.
 
Donnie Brasco
offline
Link
 
I support this!
Having O-Linemen that worry more about how many pancakes they have instead of how well protected their QB is, or how well blocks for the RBs are executed is just a painn in everyones behind.
Unfortunatly not too uncommon...
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
A large number of DEs racked up 60 sacks in leagues where gutting wasn't even a factor. Some DEs racked up over 80.

Since this is horribly lame and unrealistic (whole NFL teams only average about 35/yr), why doesn't Bort address it? This stuff has been going on for waaaay too long.

Bort please fix.


When a player develops a superior guy he should be able to use that guy. It is not fair that people try to figure out how to build a guy and then when they do, they are penalized. You have the same opportunity to build a stronger player, but you just haven't figure out the formula.
 
Roctronic
offline
Link
 
I support this as well!

Sacks should be based on how the DE can get around the Tackles and Blockers.

My DE has 65 Agility and 35 Speed, Not 1 Sack in 2 seasons! Come on!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.