User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Wide Open Incompletion Case Study - Intended to answer Borts questions about the frequency of this error
Page:
 
BigDaddyTim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by BigDaddyTim

So are you going to work on getting the text to tell us if the pass is short, or long?


I'm really not sure how to go about doing that actually...The receiver's catching code doesn't know if the ball is short or long; just if it's in range to catch. Then the sim sees that the ball's on the ground and it's play over.


i understand. just checking. it would be nice to know.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BigDaddyTim
Originally posted by hud

Originally posted by Bort


Honestly, folks, if there is a problem it's not intentional. I haven't made an updates to the passing/receiving portion of things for some time now, and I haven't seen this come up in any tests. I'm guessing that it's a particular combination of things coming together to give certain QB/WR pairs trouble (which would also explain why some people have absolutely no troubles at all), or it could just be that the replay isn't accurate enough to really show what's going on.

To me, it looks like the passes are all coming up short. The replay would end on the last play like that if the ball had hit the ground.


Could it be the that QB's strength can no longer match the receiver's speed and the ball is falling at the feet of the receiver?


the argument to this is if it clears the CB how does it hit the WR's feet. this has not been explained so no one buys this idea.


If the CB doesn't make his vision/agility checks to get to the ball, he's not going to affect it's path at all, no matter what its height is.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by rj414

Originally posted by Bort


Honestly, folks, if there is a problem it's not intentional. I haven't made an updates to the passing/receiving portion of things for some time now, and I haven't seen this come up in any tests. I'm guessing that it's a particular combination of things coming together to give certain QB/WR pairs trouble (which would also explain why some people have absolutely no troubles at all), or it could just be that the replay isn't accurate enough to really show what's going on.

To me, it looks like the passes are all coming up short. The replay would end on the last play like that if the ball had hit the ground.


Is there anyway you can go in and run the math on one of the plays that has been shown here and determine this for certain?


Once the particular play is done and saved, it's done. I only have the data that's saved, which is the replay data and the particular play calls. A full memory dump or something would mean terabytes and terabytes of storage that we don't have. Best I can do is export the players and their tactics, etc, and run some test sims to see if it comes up.


Hugh and his recieving corps will happily volunteer for this if you would like to test them.
 
BigDaddyTim
offline
Link
 
Even on the plays that the ball goes threw the CB's dot? so could the passes that are not being caught be a vision catch check that the WR's are not making?
 
BigDaddyTim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by rj414


Originally posted by Bort



Honestly, folks, if there is a problem it's not intentional. I haven't made an updates to the passing/receiving portion of things for some time now, and I haven't seen this come up in any tests. I'm guessing that it's a particular combination of things coming together to give certain QB/WR pairs trouble (which would also explain why some people have absolutely no troubles at all), or it could just be that the replay isn't accurate enough to really show what's going on.

To me, it looks like the passes are all coming up short. The replay would end on the last play like that if the ball had hit the ground.


Is there anyway you can go in and run the math on one of the plays that has been shown here and determine this for certain?


Once the particular play is done and saved, it's done. I only have the data that's saved, which is the replay data and the particular play calls. A full memory dump or something would mean terabytes and terabytes of storage that we don't have. Best I can do is export the players and their tactics, etc, and run some test sims to see if it comes up.


Hugh and his recieving corps will happily volunteer for this if you would like to test them.


and the Vets will happily volunteer to help as well offense of defense.
 
aspenwolf
offline
Link
 
the only thing i would add though, is that if it was a QB setting issue, then wouldn't there be problems with -all- of the wrs on the team?
it seems to affect certain wrs more than others

here are a few of my players routes over the past 3 games
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=140266&pbp_id=1144974
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=140266&pbp_id=1145938

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=140242&pbp_id=1722250

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=140305&pbp_id=2318176
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=140305&pbp_id=2319471
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=140305&pbp_id=2319859

 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BigDaddyTim
Even on the plays that the ball goes threw the CB's dot? so could the passes that are not being caught be a vision catch check that the WR's are not making?


No, WR's don't have to make that same check to see if they "see" the ball to react to it in time. They just have to make a "can I catch it" check, since they know it's coming.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aspenwolf
the only thing i would add though, is that if it was a QB setting issue, then wouldn't there be problems with -all- of the wrs on the team?
it seems to affect certain wrs more than others

here are a few of my players routes over the past 3 games
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=140266&pbp_id=1144974
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=140266&pbp_id=1145938

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=140242&pbp_id=1722250

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=140305&pbp_id=2318176
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=140305&pbp_id=2319471
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=140305&pbp_id=2319859



This may be true - our wrs are all built very similarly so we see it spread around quite a bit, but I've heard of it only affecting the QBs throwing to the faster ones.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by BigDaddyTim

Even on the plays that the ball goes threw the CB's dot? so could the passes that are not being caught be a vision catch check that the WR's are not making?


No, WR's don't have to make that same check to see if they "see" the ball to react to it in time. They just have to make a "can I catch it" check, since they know it's coming.


You said if they don't read as drops, then the WR isn't making this check on the play. What could cause the WR to simply not make the check on a play where the ball touches 'the dot' (I know the dot's aren't exact, but is the radius small enough that the icons could touch and still not trigger the check?)
 
aspenwolf
offline
Link
 
i have two wrs, on two different teams
one wr (the speed one) is having these probs

the other wr, with the SA's in the possession tree, is doing just fine, no issues at all

and his base speed is -faster- than the speed wr, the speed wr has more equip on and it makes him faster

confusing i know:
the speed wr has speed SA's, and he's getting the incompletions
the possession wr has possession SA's, and he's catching passes and doing fine
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aspenwolf
i have two wrs, on two different teams
one wr (the speed one) is having these probs

the other wr, with the SA's in the possession tree, is doing just fine, no issues at all

and his base speed is -faster- than the speed wr, the speed wr has more equip on and it makes him faster

confusing i know:
the speed wr has speed SA's, and he's getting the incompletions
the possession wr has possession SA's, and he's catching passes and doing fine


All of our wrs have at least 4 in first step and quick cut (the first 2 specials on the speed tree) Could either special be causing this?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by BigDaddyTim


Even on the plays that the ball goes threw the CB's dot? so could the passes that are not being caught be a vision catch check that the WR's are not making?


No, WR's don't have to make that same check to see if they "see" the ball to react to it in time. They just have to make a "can I catch it" check, since they know it's coming.


You said if they don't read as drops, then the WR isn't making this check on the play. What could cause the WR to simply not make the check on a play where the ball touches 'the dot' (I know the dot's aren't exact, but is the radius small enough that the icons could touch and still not trigger the check?)


If he doesn't think it's in his radius, or it's too low to catch (touching the ground), or too high (over his head) he doesn't get a chance to try and catch it.
Last edited Sep 26, 2008 00:37:40
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by aspenwolf

i have two wrs, on two different teams
one wr (the speed one) is having these probs

the other wr, with the SA's in the possession tree, is doing just fine, no issues at all

and his base speed is -faster- than the speed wr, the speed wr has more equip on and it makes him faster

confusing i know:
the speed wr has speed SA's, and he's getting the incompletions
the possession wr has possession SA's, and he's catching passes and doing fine


All of our wrs have at least 4 in first step and quick cut (the first 2 specials on the speed tree) Could either special be causing this?


No, they shouldn't have any effect. They are only taken into account when calculating player movement.
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
How is the "spot" the QB throws the ball calculated? Could there be a problem where the quicker, faster WRs are moving past that "spot?"
Last edited Sep 26, 2008 00:40:17
 
BigDaddyTim
offline
Link
 
So you think diving catch would widen the radius to to get the "can i catch it" check to fire? This may be giving out to much info and if so feel free to pretend i did not ask.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.