User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > 4 out of 29 Completion ratio to open WR…incomplete. Plays showing all of them.
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone
What do people want? 90% completion rate with 500 yards passing a game?


Yes!
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by thehazyone

What do people want? 90% completion rate with 500 yards passing a game?


Yes!


No, just wide open players to catch the ball if it is close to them most of the time not rarely.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
I just want my players to execute the play! If he's my intended receiver, and I got him wide open on the play, should I not be rewarded with the catch every once in awhile?
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Bort are you saying that what is happening is suppose to happen? Are you saying that the animation is way off?

To me it looks like the ball is in a catching radius. I realize the animation isn't perfect.

Also, is there away to move the players forward about 2 yards down the field. All the replays seem to be 1.5 yards to 2 yards off?

If I'm just griping, let me know. I'll quiet down, but I do think this is an issue to look at. The replays really show that ball right on top of receivers all day and register neither a drop or deflection or catch.
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
What you should do is adjust the catching radius so wide open players catch the ball or attempt to catch it more often and increase the chance of balls being deflected/dropped to make up for it when defenders are around. That or make defenders a bit better at covering WR's. You don't want passing to get to out of hand.

Thoughts?
 
tonylieu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by robelder
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by thehazyone


What do people want? 90% completion rate with 500 yards passing a game?


Yes!


No, just wide open players to catch the ball if it is close to them most of the time not rarely.


I heard that if you look at those replay frame by frame, you can see distance accurate to 1/1000 of an inch, and if you squint your eyes a little, you can actually see them in 3D.


 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tonylieu
Originally posted by robelder

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by thehazyone



What do people want? 90% completion rate with 500 yards passing a game?


Yes!


No, just wide open players to catch the ball if it is close to them most of the time not rarely.


I heard that if you look at those replay frame by frame, you can see distance accurate to 1/1000 of an inch, and if you squint your eyes a little, you can actually see them in 3D.




1: you think you're so funny, LOL whatever
2: if you were watching our games and saw this happen about 10 times a game when the ball is on top of your receiver square and it doesn't register as a drop, you would wonder why it is so far off

Come on add something smart, you've got some intelligence I'm sure. Well maybe not.
 
tonylieu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by couchpotatoe

Too much speed is stupid. So lets say we stop with the speed, then nobody gets open. Maybe the corners should get more speed. No instead we choose to let the Qb miss wideopen recievers for no appearent reason. This is stupid. I understand this if the are decently covered, but I was wideopen for a TD in my first game six times. The result? Six wideopen incompletes.


If it's the case, it's not intentional. It's just a theory on maybe why it's showing up now, when catching mechanics haven't changed in a long time, but the QB throwing options increased last season.

If the text says (incomplete) but not dropped, it means it was outside of the receiver's catching radius. Dropped means that he tried to catch it but failed.

Dunno, maybe the allowable radius need a bump up or something, but I haven't seen any problems with test sims I've ran, using a bunch of different teams and players.


As thehazyone mentioned, the passing game is far from broken. My QBs completion rates for the last two games were in excess of 75 percent, playing against DBs average 2/3 levels above them. Please ignore the whiners.
 
couchpotatoe
offline
Link
 
It isn't the QB's that are sufering, but the Wideouts. Who cares if we screw the WR's tho right? When we are that open we should catch it. Maybe make it harder when we are actually covered.
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tonylieu
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by couchpotatoe


Too much speed is stupid. So lets say we stop with the speed, then nobody gets open. Maybe the corners should get more speed. No instead we choose to let the Qb miss wideopen recievers for no appearent reason. This is stupid. I understand this if the are decently covered, but I was wideopen for a TD in my first game six times. The result? Six wideopen incompletes.


If it's the case, it's not intentional. It's just a theory on maybe why it's showing up now, when catching mechanics haven't changed in a long time, but the QB throwing options increased last season.

If the text says (incomplete) but not dropped, it means it was outside of the receiver's catching radius. Dropped means that he tried to catch it but failed.

Dunno, maybe the allowable radius need a bump up or something, but I haven't seen any problems with test sims I've ran, using a bunch of different teams and players.


As thehazyone mentioned, the passing game is far from broken. My QBs completion rates for the last two games were in excess of 75 percent, playing against DBs average 2/3 levels above them. Please ignore the whiners.


Oh so you don't have the issue that lots of others have. Makes sense your words mean nothing. Ignore the arrogant!
 
winchester
offline
Link
 
I am the one that started this and my teams qb ratings are not that high. The whole point is being missed. Open guys incomplete.... Triple covered catch. There would not be 20 different guys saying the same thing over and over with a ton of examples to show proof over and over again. A lot of the passes I showed were 10-15 yard passes. People in here talking crap about plays put in there face need to watch them then talk not come here on someone's dick trying to get free flex points or something.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tonylieu
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by couchpotatoe


Too much speed is stupid. So lets say we stop with the speed, then nobody gets open. Maybe the corners should get more speed. No instead we choose to let the Qb miss wideopen recievers for no appearent reason. This is stupid. I understand this if the are decently covered, but I was wideopen for a TD in my first game six times. The result? Six wideopen incompletes.


If it's the case, it's not intentional. It's just a theory on maybe why it's showing up now, when catching mechanics haven't changed in a long time, but the QB throwing options increased last season.

If the text says (incomplete) but not dropped, it means it was outside of the receiver's catching radius. Dropped means that he tried to catch it but failed.

Dunno, maybe the allowable radius need a bump up or something, but I haven't seen any problems with test sims I've ran, using a bunch of different teams and players.


As thehazyone mentioned, the passing game is far from broken. My QBs completion rates for the last two games were in excess of 75 percent, playing against DBs average 2/3 levels above them. Please ignore the whiners.


My QB has completed 56% of his passes. The lowest in his career...and one of our games was against a gutted team. Last season my completion % was 66.

Just because it's not happening to you, doesn't mean the rest of us are "whiners" and should be ignored. I just want to know what's wrong with my QB/WR, because something is definitely up.
 
tonylieu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Originally posted by tonylieu

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by couchpotatoe



Too much speed is stupid. So lets say we stop with the speed, then nobody gets open. Maybe the corners should get more speed. No instead we choose to let the Qb miss wideopen recievers for no appearent reason. This is stupid. I understand this if the are decently covered, but I was wideopen for a TD in my first game six times. The result? Six wideopen incompletes.


If it's the case, it's not intentional. It's just a theory on maybe why it's showing up now, when catching mechanics haven't changed in a long time, but the QB throwing options increased last season.

If the text says (incomplete) but not dropped, it means it was outside of the receiver's catching radius. Dropped means that he tried to catch it but failed.

Dunno, maybe the allowable radius need a bump up or something, but I haven't seen any problems with test sims I've ran, using a bunch of different teams and players.


As thehazyone mentioned, the passing game is far from broken. My QBs completion rates for the last two games were in excess of 75 percent, playing against DBs average 2/3 levels above them. Please ignore the whiners.


My QB has completed 56% of his passes. The lowest in his career...and one of our games was against a gutted team. Last season my completion % was 66.

Just because it's not happening to you, doesn't mean the rest of us are "whiners" and should be ignored. I just want to know what's wrong with my QB/WR, because something is definitely up.


If it's truly a bug, it will happen to all QBs not just a handful out of thousands. Don't forget in the end, this is a game of statistics, there will be variations and sometimes there will be extreme variations to a few, but the overall average will be and should be as intended by game designer. And as Bort has already said, he ran tests and he did not see any anomaly. It's unfortunately that you and a select few got the bad end of the stick, but in the long run you will get your share of completed passes, and my QBs will get their share of incomplete passes.

With all due respect, calling something a bug and demanding fixes without fully understanding the mechanics of the game are whiners in my book.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
It might be worthwhile to go through and check on the QBs and teams who are not having trouble, and try to figure out what they are doing that you are not.

There are a great many QBs in leagues from A to Pro with completion rates well over 70%.
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tonylieu
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

Originally posted by tonylieu


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by couchpotatoe




Too much speed is stupid. So lets say we stop with the speed, then nobody gets open. Maybe the corners should get more speed. No instead we choose to let the Qb miss wideopen recievers for no appearent reason. This is stupid. I understand this if the are decently covered, but I was wideopen for a TD in my first game six times. The result? Six wideopen incompletes.


If it's the case, it's not intentional. It's just a theory on maybe why it's showing up now, when catching mechanics haven't changed in a long time, but the QB throwing options increased last season.

If the text says (incomplete) but not dropped, it means it was outside of the receiver's catching radius. Dropped means that he tried to catch it but failed.

Dunno, maybe the allowable radius need a bump up or something, but I haven't seen any problems with test sims I've ran, using a bunch of different teams and players.


As thehazyone mentioned, the passing game is far from broken. My QBs completion rates for the last two games were in excess of 75 percent, playing against DBs average 2/3 levels above them. Please ignore the whiners.


My QB has completed 56% of his passes. The lowest in his career...and one of our games was against a gutted team. Last season my completion % was 66.

Just because it's not happening to you, doesn't mean the rest of us are "whiners" and should be ignored. I just want to know what's wrong with my QB/WR, because something is definitely up.


If it's truly a bug, it will happen to all QBs not just a handful out of thousands. Don't forget in the end, this is a game of statistics, there will be variations and sometimes there will be extreme variations to a few, but the overall average will be and should be as intended by game designer. And as Bort has already said, he ran tests and he did not see any anomaly. It's unfortunately that you and a select few got the bad end of the stick, but in the long run you will get your share of completed passes, and my QBs will get their share of incomplete passes.

With all due respect, calling something a bug and demanding fixes without fully understanding the mechanics of the game are whiners in my book.


Maybe only a handful post in the forum but many have the problem. I have talked to several not in these threads that see the same thing. You're generalizing too much. If it happens to us it is happening a lot of places. Someone has to bring it up and get it started as a conversation piece. It may even happen in your games. Maybe I'll check it out this weekend when I have more time.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.