User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Well Thought-Out Solution to Gutting
Page:
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
Solution to Gutted teams:
Increase promotion/relegation. More gutted teams = more teams relegated. You will have to deal with the mid-season guts.
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ubasstards
Solution to Gutted teams:
Increase promotion/relegation. More gutted teams = more teams relegated. You will have to deal with the mid-season guts.

My proposal deals with all of this.
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
Originally posted by w_alloy

Originally posted by greengoose



If you are gonna reward every team that slowbuilds - pretty soon EVERYBODY will slowbuild because they know it's the "TICKET" to get down to the lowest leagues.

Slow built teams aren't gutted teams - they aren't sold back. Your proposal only addressed sold back teams unless I misunderstood it.

Personally, I don't think "slow build" teams should be rewarded at all.


My system doesn't reward slowbuilding. The "TICKET" to getting to the bottom tier leagues is losing a lot or getting a new team. Most slowbuilt teams are made from new teams. Teams shouldn't want to be at the bottom and so this isn't rewarding them.

Quit trying to hijack my thread, and if you are going to, at least try to make sense.



You never addressed what I said before though. I agree gutted teams should be moved down before a new owner takes over. The problem is the landscape of competitive balance won't change much as you still have teams that are just poorly run and also teams that purposely choose to blow their teams up and start from scratch.

Your proposal addresses just one of a multitude of issues that create competitive imbalance and 144-0 games.


Actually, I did address all of what you said before. I mentioned that the problems you are talking about are outside the scope of my suggested changes and are a problem with the current system. Further, nobody has solutions to these problems, so harassing me for not addressing them more fully in my system is naive.

If you have solutions to the problems you are referring, I would welcome suggestions on how to deal with them. I believe my solution is the best currently put forward, and that the criticisms you are throwing at me apply to any suggestion currently in this whole forum. And I also think you are underestimating the effect of my suggested changes.
Last edited Sep 27, 2008 04:38:09
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Bump for the night crew.
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
http://www.gospelcommunications.org/communique/wp-content/uploads/2006/05/514_Bump.jpg
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
w_alloy- any suggestion that is well thought out and will actually will benefit the game doesn't get much traffic. Any suggestion that is completely horrible and has tons of negative unaccounted for side effects will push it ahead in no time.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tomcollins
w_alloy- any suggestion that is well thought out and will actually will benefit the game doesn't get much traffic. Any suggestion that is completely horrible and has tons of negative unaccounted for side effects will push it ahead in no time.


this
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Thanks for the support.
 
Whatsdafus
offline
Link
 
I like the OP's views and suggestions to stopping mid season guts.

Also add this to help stop gutting.

- 0 FP return when selling a team.

- Or set up an advance selling feature that allows owners to only sell teams in the offseason. Once activated, it mails all team members that the owner has elected to do this, gives a 5 day period for a GM to buy the team. If a gm buys the team he will take over on day 1 of the offseason (day 41). Once a GM buys the team, another email is sent to the team with a poll, stating if they would like to stay or go once the season ends since the new owner is so and so. If more then 50% say they want to leave, they become flagged for regulation under the OP's system. if 51% say they wanna stay, they arent regulated and the players are binded to their contracts. thus he can begin to trade or build the team as he feels fit to. With this option a owner is allowed to recieve his % of fp's back with a stipulation... that he doesnt go inactive during that season from the moment he activated that selling feature.

 
shadowmane
offline
Link
 
I've been thinking about this, and I think there ought to be a choice. If a prospective new owner wants to start a slow build team (or a present owner's team gets gutted and he is forced to go slow build), then they should be put in a lvl 4 capped league together.

If an owner sees that his team is going to get gutted before the off-season, and sticks it out, he should be given the choice to be able to self-relegate, but only after his team is surveyed by a moderator.

On that note, I think each league should have a moderator/commissioner who deals with the problems of just that league. If he sees a team struggling, he checks into it and sees why. If its just sucky builds, then he leaves it alone to be relegated at the end of the season. If the owner is inactive, then he takes steps to make sure the team and the players are looked out after (even if he has to step in for a game to set basic tactics until he can deal with the situation). At the end of the season, the team is surveyed to see if it is in danger of being gutted. If so, it is relegated, the contracts are released, and the team is sold (this is only if the owner has packed up shop and left the game).

There should also be some way of disciplining owners who show up only every week or so to keep his team. That's not fair to the players on the team, who want to see it succeed. I think adding League Commissioners/Moderators would go a long way toward dealing with the gutted team problem, if only to act as an early detection device.
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Thanks for the suggestions, although I still like my idea as proposed.
 
Whatsdafus
offline
Link
 
Also maybe... just maybe its time to make players accept and live up to the contracts they sign and not allow owners to cut everyone when they know they are gonna sell the team.

I remember battles about how its not fair to players to make them go thru their contracts on a team with an owner they dont know....

What i think isnt fair is all these teams that are gutted and we have to deal with them in our leagues.

- NO MORE NEW TEAMS. do that for a season or two and lets get the teams that are currently out there now in the hands of good owners and fully staff.

- Dont allow owners to cut 100 players a day. Give him only the rights to make cuts in the offseason. Players cant be cut after day 1 of the season. If you want to move a player during the season.... trade him. That will stop guts during the season.
Last edited Sep 28, 2008 16:34:12
 
Whatsdafus
offline
Link
 
also that 10 day rule with owners being inactive... shouldnt make players free to go right then and there. What should happen is the players can then click yes or no to an option where they become free agents on day 41, or the first day of the off season.

That 10 day rule is a built in gutting rule and it sucks balls
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Bort, please post in this thread so I can stop bumping it.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by w_alloy
Bort, please post in this thread so I can stop bumping it.


Bort's presence is requested FAR more in the other DOZEN threads which have been bumped (some since May) far too many times.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.