Originally posted by greengoose
Originally posted by w_alloy
Originally posted by greengoose
If you are gonna reward every team that slowbuilds - pretty soon EVERYBODY will slowbuild because they know it's the "TICKET" to get down to the lowest leagues.
Slow built teams aren't gutted teams - they aren't sold back. Your proposal only addressed sold back teams unless I misunderstood it.
Personally, I don't think "slow build" teams should be rewarded at all.
My system doesn't reward slowbuilding. The "TICKET" to getting to the bottom tier leagues is losing a lot or getting a new team. Most slowbuilt teams are made from new teams. Teams shouldn't want to be at the bottom and so this isn't rewarding them.
Quit trying to hijack my thread, and if you are going to, at least try to make sense.
You never addressed what I said before though. I agree gutted teams should be moved down before a new owner takes over. The problem is the landscape of competitive balance won't change much as you still have teams that are just poorly run and also teams that purposely choose to blow their teams up and start from scratch.
Your proposal addresses just one of a multitude of issues that create competitive imbalance and 144-0 games.
Actually, I did address all of what you said before. I mentioned that the problems you are talking about are outside the scope of my suggested changes and are a problem with the current system. Further, nobody has solutions to these problems, so harassing me for not addressing them more fully in my system is naive.
If you have solutions to the problems you are referring, I would welcome suggestions on how to deal with them. I believe my solution is the best currently put forward, and that the criticisms you are throwing at me apply to any suggestion currently in this whole forum. And I also think you are underestimating the effect of my suggested changes.
Last edited Sep 27, 2008 04:38:09